What's new

NA set to amend rules to introduce PM’s Question Hour

hussain.r97

ODI Debutant
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Runs
11,153
ISLAMABAD: The National Assembly is set to take up on Monday (today) an amendment to its rules making it mandatory for the prime minister to respond to questions of the members about government affairs on the floor of the house.

Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Ali Mohammad Khan will move an amendment to Rule 69 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business 2007 in the assembly, which suggests insertion of a sub-rule introducing “Prime Minister’s Question Hour”, according to an 11-point agenda issued by the NA Secretariat for Monday’s sitting.

Soon after winning the election of prime minister, Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf Chairman Imran Khan had announced that he would make himself available on a fortnightly basis to the members of parliament to reply to their questions relating different matters on the floor of the house on the pattern of the British parliament.

However, the new rule suggests that the prime minster will be bound to reply to questions only on the first Wednesday of each session and subject to his availability.

“Notwithstanding anything contained in this Chapter, subject to availability of the prime minister, there shall be ‘Prime Minister’s Question Hour’ on the first Wednesday once in each session for answering questions on the matters relating to the overall substantive policy or the performance of government,” reads the new sub-rule (2) to be inserted in Rule 69 of the assembly rules.

Though the prime minister has a privilege of getting the floor of the National Assembly any time he wants to speak on any matter, Imran Khan wants to see the rules amended with a view to make it mandatory for future prime ministers as well to respond to the questions of MNAs.

Syed Yousuf Raza Gilani of the Pakistan Peoples Party was the only prime minister who was found to be present in the assembly during the question hour most of the time and even used to give replies to questions of the members, despite the fact that it was not mandatory for him. In 2012, the rules of the Senate were amended under which one hour was allocated for the prime minister to give reply to questions.

Rule 61 of the Senate says: “The prime minister shall whenever possible personally respond to points raised by members whenever he is present in the house. However, the prime minister shall attend the Prime Minister’s Zero Hour at least once in each week when the Senate is in session.”

However, this rule was never implemented as former prime minister Nawaz Sharif attended the Senate sessions only three to four times throughout his more than four-year rule.

Even former Senate chairman Raza Rabbani, who was otherwise known for strictly running the house under rules, never raised the issue of non-implementation of the rule. Similarly, though the senators usually complained about the absence of the prime minister and ministers from the house, they never called for implementation of the rule.

Debate on mini-budget

Besides taking up the proposed amendment, the members of the assembly are also expected to take part in a general debate on the mini-budget presented by Finance Minister Asad Umar last week.

Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry will lay the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Amendment) Ordinance 2018 (No IX of 2018) and the minister of state for parliamentary affairs will present the Elections (Amendment) Ordinance 2018 (No XIII of 2018) in the assembly, which will be meeting after a five-day recess.

Published in Dawn, September 24th, 2018

https://www.dawn.com/news/1434659/na-set-to-amend-rules-to-introduce-pms-question-hour
 
In theory PM question hour is a wonderful idea.

But it's going to turn into utter chaos thanks to the Jaahil Noon league animals in opposition.

They will make the question hour very difficult for Imran and they will criticize him left right and centre.

They will rant, rave and bark throughout the question hour
 
In theory PM question hour is a wonderful idea.

But it's going to turn into utter chaos thanks to the Jaahil Noon league animals in opposition.

They will make the question hour very difficult for Imran and they will criticize him left right and centre.

They will rant, rave and bark throughout the question hour

Not just them, all the other parties will do so and all those that have an agenda.
 
In theory PM question hour is a wonderful idea.

But it's going to turn into utter chaos thanks to the Jaahil Noon league animals in opposition.

They will make the question hour very difficult for Imran and they will criticize him left right and centre.

They will rant, rave and bark throughout the question hour

Lets see but he is trying to change a culture to bring more acountability, which is the last thing these crooks want.
 
Good intention but this wont work in Pak, some of them would be licking their lips if this happens. Our politician act like jaahils and will stoop to levels that one cant even imagine.

I expect fazlu and his gang to question IK religion, PMLN to start targeting his personal life directly. PPP to initiate a smear campaign and the rest of the gang to join in whenever possible.

Imran needs to realize that these guys don't give two hoots about Pakistan and he should focus his energies elsewhere rather then waste his time with these fools.
 
We have Prime Minister's Questions here in the UK and it's a waste of time.

Nothing productive ever comes out of it with the leaders recycling the same talking points and launching attacks against each other all the while the backbenchers are barking like ravenous hounds.
 
this is a superb move in a civilized and corruption free country... here they (opp.) will use it in the wrong context and waste time and create headaches... and God forbid if NS ever comes back in power this amendment will be taken out first thing....
 
Sets a good precedent but this will be a waste of time.

Why? why will it be a waste of time? Its attitudes like this that keep our community behind all the time. In that hour, only certain MP's will get a chance to ask questions just like in PM's question time in the uk. The leader of the opposition gets a chance to ask his /her questions and the PM will answer back.

If that crook and pindoo NS gets in power again you may aswell say good bye to whats left of the nation..
 
Why? why will it be a waste of time? Its attitudes like this that keep our community behind all the time. In that hour, only certain MP's will get a chance to ask questions just like in PM's question time in the uk. The leader of the opposition gets a chance to ask his /her questions and the PM will answer back.

If that crook and pindoo NS gets in power again you may aswell say good bye to whats left of the nation..

I think it might be a waste of time due to the actions and antics of the opposition. In more civilised environments this would be great.

Actually I am more open to this idea now. It's just that at the time of the original post I was in an especially pessimistic mood.
 
Back
Top