What's new

Pakistan left with more questions than answers after ODI series win against Sri Lanka

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
Pakistan's ODI series against Sri Lanka marked two important events for Pakistan cricket: ODI cricket returning to Karachi after a 10-year hiatus and the commencement of the Misbah-ul-Haq era (again, but as a Head Coach-cum-Chief Selector this time). Yet, in typical Misbah fashion, Pakistan opted for a full strength side against a weakened Sri Lankan team and finished the series with two comfortable wins under their belts.


<img src="http://p.imgci.com/db/PICTURES/CMS/295300/295347.jpg" width="700">​


With the first ODI washed out due to thunderstorms, the ODI series got underway with the 2nd match at the National Stadium on the 30th, a Monday. As the time neared for the toss, there were sparse crowds in attendance - somewhat of a surprise, despite it being a working day. Perhaps the recent bad weather also played a part, with Karachi's poor infrastructure disrupting everyday lives on a constant basis.

Pakistan won the toss and opted to bat. They proceeded to compile a solid total 305/7 with the ever-impressive Babar Azam hitting a superb 115. Fakhar Zaman and Haris Sohail made useful contributions while Iftikhar Ahmed contributed some lusty blows in his 20-ball 32* at the back-end of the innings.

Sri Lanka's chase practically ended before it began, with Usman Khan Shinwari running through the top-order with his opening spell. A big partnership between Jayasuriya (96) and Shanaka (68) ensued, but the hosts were always in control of the game. Shinwari returned to break the partnership and finished with 5 wickets as the tourists suffered a 67-run loss in ODI cricket's return to Karachi.

It was the visitors who won the toss in the 3rd and final ODI, and they also opted to bat. Despite regular breakthroughs by the Pakistani bowlers, Gunathilaka held the innings together with a fantastic 133 before Shanaka once again came to the fore with a stroke-filled 43 to take SL close to the 300-run mark. Pakistan's performance in the field was desperately poor, with overthrows, dropped catches and poor ground-fielding witnessed on multiple occasions.

Abid Ali in the absence of the injured Imam-ul-Haq led the way for the hosts in the chase, with a magnificent 74 off just 67 balls. Fakhar began slowly, but he too compiled a good innings of 76. Haris Sohail anchored the innings towards the back-end, also hitting an impressive fifty while Iftikhar Ahmed finished off the chase.

Pakistan won their first ODI series in more than a year, with the previous one being another practical walkover against struggling Zimbabwe. What was notable about this series against Sri Lanka, was that Pakistan didn't come out of it any wiser than before. Babar Azam and Haris Sohail continued their excellent performances. Fakhar Zaman once again delivered, but was unconvincing. Usman Shinwari demolished the Islanders, but not for the first time. The team management opted to bench the likes of Mohammad Hasnain, with a struggling Wahab Riaz preferred, despite the fact that he is 34 years old and is unlikely to feature in the 50-over format for much longer. Sarfaraz Ahmed's attempt at regaining some semblance of form failed, and his spot in the team remains under question, with Mohammad Rizwan scoring heavily in all forms of cricket. Shadab Khan continued to struggle, and Pakistan opted to not select a specialist spinner once again, a hallmark of the Mickey Arthur era.

Pakistan's next ODI series is scheduled to be held after approximately 9 months: A 3-match series against Netherlands. With relatively few ODIs scheduled for the next couple of years, due to back to back T20 World Cups, Pakistan won't get a lot of opportunities to fix the weaknesses in the 50-over format. However, persisting with over the hill players and neglecting to plug the gaps in the side can once again put Pakistan in an uncomfortable position in future, where they will have to chop and change a lot in order to figure out a strong squad for future assignments.

Amongst the biggest problems Misbah faces is the future of Sarfaraz. By neglecting to announce the wicket-keeper batsman as the captain for a period of time, and limiting it to the series against Sri Lanka, the Head Coach has kept his options open. The lower-order batting remains a concern, with Iftikhar Ahmed showing glimpses that he may be the solution, but is yet to totally convince. The bowling options remain a worry with Mohammad Amir the only Pakistani bowler in the top 20 of the ODI bowling rankings. Another worry, albeit in a more positive sense, is how to fit Imam-ul-Haq, Abid Ali and Fakhar Zaman in the opening slots - a good competition to have within the team.

On to the T20Is in Lahore, where Ahmed Shehzad and Umar Akmal return to the squad... Misbah has certainly made his mark on the team! The planning for the T20 World Cup next year must start sooner rather than later.
 
I find it really surprising that more of the fringe players were not tried in this series.

Instead the likes of Wahab and others were played.
 
I find it really surprising that more of the fringe players were not tried in this series.

Instead the likes of Wahab and others were played.

I agree. Maybe its the case of new management wanting to ensure good start to their tenure as any upset wouldnt have been taken lightly especially when so many changes have been made in Pak cricket in recent times and many people have acted as resistance to change.
 
I find it really surprising that more of the fringe players were not tried in this series.

Instead the likes of Wahab and others were played.

Are you really surprised? I'm sure you've followed PCT under Misbah. With him now as the commander in chief, why do you expect things to be any different?

God bless Mickey for introducing youngsters like Shaheen, Hassan, Shadab et Al, otherwise we'd still be playing TTF XI!

You've already seen where our T20 squad is headed with the return of prodigal sons.

I'll just sit here quietly and watch this shitshow unfold!
 
Are you really surprised? I'm sure you've followed PCT under Misbah. With him now as the commander in chief, why do you expect things to be any different?

God bless Mickey for introducing youngsters like Shaheen, Hassan, Shadab et Al, otherwise we'd still be playing TTF XI!

You've already seen where our T20 squad is headed with the return of prodigal sons.

I'll just sit here quietly and watch this shitshow unfold!

Full credit to Mickey for these youngsters is bit too much as they would never have played for Pakistan this early if they wouldnt have played in PSL which started in 2016 giving much needed help or shortcut to Mickey and Co which allowed Mickey and Inzi to see them. Do you really believe if they wouldnt have featured in PSL Mickey would have unearthed them? I dont think so as he didnt unearth or handpicked anybody. Though he transitioned them well into international cricket.
 
No new players are going to be trieed out under misbah, it will be a safety 1st policy all the time same TTFs will be littered in test squad aswell.
 
Full credit to Mickey for these youngsters is bit too much as they would never have played for Pakistan this early if they wouldnt have played in PSL which started in 2016 giving much needed help or shortcut to Mickey and Co which allowed Mickey and Inzi to see them. Do you really believe if they wouldnt have featured in PSL Mickey would have unearthed them? I dont think so as he didnt unearth or handpicked anybody. Though he transitioned them well into international cricket.

Lets see how many Misbah unearthes from PSL.
 
Are you really surprised? I'm sure you've followed PCT under Misbah. With him now as the commander in chief, why do you expect things to be any different?

God bless Mickey for introducing youngsters like Shaheen, Hassan, Shadab et Al, otherwise we'd still be playing TTF XI!

You've already seen where our T20 squad is headed with the return of prodigal sons.

I'll just sit here quietly and watch this shitshow unfold!

Well I had thought and hoped, new regime, new energy, new ideas. And not the same tried and tested failures.
 
Are you really surprised? I'm sure you've followed PCT under Misbah. With him now as the commander in chief, why do you expect things to be any different?

God bless Mickey for introducing youngsters like Shaheen, Hassan, Shadab et Al, otherwise we'd still be playing TTF XI!

You've already seen where our T20 squad is headed with the return of prodigal sons.

I'll just sit here quietly and watch this shitshow unfold!

Good post couldn’t agree more.
 
Well I had thought and hoped, new regime, new energy, new ideas. And not the same tried and tested failures.

Unfortunately, this regime is just a one-man show. A man who is not known for his energy or creativity (lol!)

This is why I was a big on Mickey. He might not be the best tactician, neither is Misbah by any means, but he at least got this unit on the right track in terms of introducing players who have immense potential to improve. Mickey was in this for the long-haul and had the bigger picture in mind, unlike others before and after him who are just focused on short-term results to save their seat.

I won't be surprised if we see Kamran Akmal make a comeback soon
 
For me the crux:

Amongst the biggest problems Misbah faces is the future of Sarfaraz. By neglecting to announce the wicket-keeper batsman as the captain for a period of time, and limiting it to the series against Sri Lanka, the Head Coach has kept his options open.


===

This is a serious issue which needs to be addressed sooner than later.

Excellent writeup.
 
I find it really surprising that more of the fringe players were not tried in this series.

Instead the likes of Wahab and others were played.

I'm guessing they would have in the 3rd ODI if the first two games were won.

I'm only disappointed we didn't get to see Hasnain instead of Wahab. I don't really need to Asif Ali because he is just not ODI material. Iftikhar was a pleasant surprise and possibly a decent replacement for Malik.
 
For me the crux:

Amongst the biggest problems Misbah faces is the future of Sarfaraz. By neglecting to announce the wicket-keeper batsman as the captain for a period of time, and limiting it to the series against Sri Lanka, the Head Coach has kept his options open.


===

This is a serious issue which needs to be addressed sooner than later.

Excellent writeup.

Misbah recomended azhar ali as captain after 2015 world cup shambles. That was a pointless and stupid move which was realized after 2 years. Now we persist with sarfaraz, PCB never learns.
 
Not quite sure which over the hill players are being talked about in this series ? Riaz has had a brief rebirth following the world cup and sarfraz is still captain, although he shouldn't be in the side anyway. Other than that, who is over the hill ??

I also do not see the negative in Pakistan playing the best available players they have, considering odi cricket will be invisible for these cricketers for months now. Were they supposed to leave babar, fakhar, amir, shadab etc without international cricket in the build up to a test series ?

Come on now.
 
I think too many posters are looking at this whole episode in a very short sighted way. You need a squad of at least 20-30 players and choose your LO and test specialists within that. T20 is the format to take the most risks and odi less so. You have to slowly build up experience of the new or returning players. Apart from babar, Haris and amir I don’t think any player can walk into this side. Even players like wahab and shadab have question marks over them.

So this is not a full strength team we don’t even know what our full strength team looks like. Even the experienced players need to up their performances and need exposure. We are playing cricket after a long lay off it should have been obvious to go with the more experienced 11’s in odi and t20’s
 
Back
Top