Only ones who dont deserve to be in the squad is proberly wahab and sohail khan,imran Khan
Didn’t notice, you responded me
For a squad of 15-16, often 80% (12-13) players almost picks themselves - it’s the rest 2-4 players where you need selectors, who should be smart enough about conditions, combinations & future prospects. When it comes to 29 players, then it becomes tough; because after top 15-16 players, there are so, so many options available - it’s same in every aspect of life, the lower you go down the pyramid, base gets wider. If one asks to pick 2 players from PAK for a World squad, my 6 years old nephew can do the job (& he will get it correct) because he started watching cricket from last WC.
Coming to this squad - CV19 gave Misbah the honourable CS of PCB a wonderful chance to pick at least 10-12 new faces and give promising young players the exposure. Eventually, for a mini series with 3+3 games only, maximum 15-16 players will get games - that’s even considering that two confirmed starters for either format opted out of the tour. This means, last 10-12 players are there just as back up and giving regular players net practice - may be through that someone can outshine some preferred player and force his way in the playing XI.
In that regard, I would have picked only these known faces
Openers: Abid, Shan, Imam, FZ
Middle Order: Asad, Azhar, Babar, Khusdil
WK: Rizwan, Sarfraz
Spinner: Yasir
All-rounder: Faheem, Shadab
Pacer: Shaheen, Naseem, Abbas, Rauf, Hasnain
That’s 18 names, and I am sure everyone here will pick these 18 out of 29 (May be [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] won’t pick Yasir, despite averaging 48+ in last Australian tour, with bat ....) - you don’t need a high profile CS for this one.
You can tactfully add four “ancient” names here in excuse of upcoming T20 WC (which I am not sure is going to take place, come October) - MoHa, Malik, Wahab, Iftekhar - that’s 22 names in total. I won’t have picked MoHa, Malik, Iftekhar even if there was no CV situation (& WC confirmed), because these three are not going to offer much in a WC in Australia (I know about Ifti’s heroics there), but that little we have to give it to Misbah, for the sake of his man crash for male over 40. Even then, among oldies, I would have picked Rahat over IK Sr. (Not the PM, he is a bit too old, even for Misbah), any day.
Still, still 7 slots were available and these 7 have very little chances to get a game - their only chance is either 2/3 players get injured or sick (hope not) or someone really sparkles during practice games. These 7 should have gone to players with promise, players who had a chance to serve PCT for a decade. In any of the situations, those obsolete oldies that are picked here as backup have absolutely nothing to offer - they have their celling measured and it wasn’t enough in past. This was the time to pick potential players - if just two of those could have made a mark, it would have been a gain.
Keeping those 22 intact, these are the next 7 that I would have picked
Batsman: Haider
WK: One of Ruhail or Umair
Spinner: Gohar, Sajid - finger spinners are not suggested to play in UK as the only spinner (and no way one should pick 2 spinners), but ENG will play one finger spinner - either an office or SLAO; therefore it was a must that PAK should pick two finger spinners (one each from either variety) for the squad
All-rounder: One of Saud (as batting all-rounder) or Amad as bowling alley-rounder
Pacer: Sameen, Ehsan Adil
If I were in charge, I would have kicked MoHa, Malik, Ifti out as well (but keep Wahab - in absence of Amir, he is the only experienced pacer and PAK will need to practice against someone express - Poms will field Jofra & Wood) and add Sami, Zeeshan (not sure about Sharjeel’s fitness, Zeeshan comes as T20 specialist) & one more new batting face - may be Babar or one of two Imrans (Butt, Rafique) or Badar and another pace bowling all-rounder - may be Yamin.
Still to ranking from me - it’s not even worthy of a fail mark.