What's new

Pakistan's first moon sighting website launched, Eid on June 5

WebGuru

Senior ODI Player
Joined
Mar 4, 2013
Runs
21,339
Post of the Week
3
Federal Minister for Science and Technology Fawad Chaudhry has launched Pakistan’s first moon sighting website and according to the newly-formulated five-year lunar calendar, Eidul Fitr will fall on June 5 this year.

Addressing the launching ceremony in Lahore on Sunday, Chaudhry said in his opinion Pakistan can do away with the traditional moon sighting methods used by the Ruet-e-Hilal Committee to end the moon sighting controversy on all important Islamic festivals, Express News reported.

“We have launched pakmoonsighting.pk website and Eidul Fitr will fall on June 5 this year … we have formulated the lunar calendar for five years which will be presented before the federal cabinet on Tuesday for final approval,” said the minister.

He also took to Twitter to announce the launch.

Since assuming office as the minister for science and technology, Fawad has been pushing for using science for the Islamic calendar .

Recently, the National Assembly was informed that an amount of Rs3.06 million was spent on the sighting of the moon for Muharram, Ramazan, Eidul Fitr and Eidul Azha in 2018.

Earlier this month, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) minister formed a five-member committee comprising officials from the ministry, Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission (Suparco) and Pakistan Meteorological Department to formulate the Hijri calendar.

The committee was tasked to prepare a lunar calendar and publish it by the 15th of Ramazan. Speaking at an event at Karachi University, he said the ministry was also working on a mobile phone app that will enable people to sight the moon on their devices.

Fawad also invited renowned clerics Mufti Muneebur Rehman and Shahabuddin Popalzai to see “how the moon cycle works”.

“We are inviting Maulana Muneebur Rehman and Shahabuddin Popalzai to come and witness how the moon cycle works,” wrote Fawad. “And see for themselves how easy science has made it to predict the lunar calendar. There is no need for an arduous task.”


Source: https://tribune.com.pk/story/1980682/1-fawad-launch-islamic-hijri-calendar-today/
 
Fawad in trouble once again this time Maulvis are after him and liberals are standing with him. He is a football between liberals and maulvis thanks to his brilliant ways of inviting the trouble :)) aa bael muje maar
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">In a rare act of modernisation, Pakistan's Ministry of Science & Technology announces the moon dates for next 5 years identifying exact dates of Eids. Great job <a href="https://twitter.com/fawadchaudhry?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@fawadchaudhry</a>, you've accomplished something no one dared in past. It will infuriate mullahs, but stay strong. Cheers!</p>— Marvi Sirmed (@marvisirmed) <a href="https://twitter.com/marvisirmed/status/1132592089534013445?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">May 26, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
This is a great move imo.

There are some who believe in literalism so want the moon to be sighted by the naked eye. However most understand the moon can now be easily calculated so Eid can be announced early allowing people to prepare.
 
Good job by Fawad. The mullahs don't do the moon sighting for free. So besides from having a more accurate date, the government will also save some money.
 
This goes completely against shariah. Moon should be sighted with the naked eye. It is not about convenience, it is about the teaching of the prophet pbuh
 
This goes completely against shariah. Moon should be sighted with the naked eye. It is not about convenience, it is about the teaching of the prophet pbuh

You sure about the naked eye part?


210662_5690274_updates.jpg



So using technology like spectacles and telescope is halal and jaiz but using math to accurately calculate the trajectory of the moon is blasphemy.


Who determines what level of technology is acceptable? Pretty sure during the Prophet's (PBUH) era there were no durbeen or chashmay.


No wonder the west has left us FAR behind in science when the Muslim world is still stuck in 600AD.
 
You sure about the naked eye part?


210662_5690274_updates.jpg



So using technology like spectacles and telescope is halal and jaiz but using math to accurately calculate the trajectory of the moon is blasphemy.


Who determines what level of technology is acceptable? Pretty sure during the Prophet's (PBUH) era there were no durbeen or chashmay.


No wonder the west has left us FAR behind in science when the Muslim world is still stuck in 600AD.

Exactly.

Don't forget about the prayer time tables or azaan apps. No one goes outside to look at if the sun is setting, etc... instead they wait for an app to tell them it's time to pray.
 
Some fiqh allow visual aids such as telescopes and others say it has to be with naked eye. Those are still better than not looking for the moon at all which is what was prescribed by our prophet pbuh. Islam has been completed, we can't update it and any modernisation is just an excuse to look 'western'.
 
Some fiqh allow visual aids such as telescopes and others say it has to be with naked eye. Those are still better than not looking for the moon at all which is what was prescribed by our prophet pbuh. Islam has been completed, we can't update it and any modernisation is just an excuse to look 'western'.

I see. Let me guess you go outside to check if the sun is setting before you break your fast...
 
So 29 fasting days in Pakistan this year.

Pakistan and Norway will have Eid on same day.

Even if they have decided that, people should go out and try to sight the moon so they also can benefit from the blessings of Sunnah.
 
Some fiqh allow visual aids such as telescopes and others say it has to be with naked eye. Those are still better than not looking for the moon at all which is what was prescribed by our prophet pbuh. Islam has been completed, we can't update it and any modernisation is just an excuse to look 'western'.

My understanding is that in Islam, Social Harmony takes preference in controversial circumstances.

Moon sighting in Pakistan is amongst controversial circumstances. It's responsibility of govt to establish social harmony.

Still I think a better option is to follow moon sighting committee that should be chaired turn-wise by Mufti Popalzai for 2 years and by Mufti Munib for next two years.
 
Fiqh Council of North America already announced Eid for Jun-4, as per astronomical calculations, the moon would be sighted in Miami.
 
Back
Top