England have picked up a lot of soft wins since Stokes took over and they have had favorable circumstances too.
1. Rohit unavailable for the fifth Test. India clearly suffered without his batting and captaincy.
2. Lyon getting injured and missing the last three Tests of the Ashes. Australia were 2-0 up when he played and he bowled really well, taking 8 wickets in the first Test.
Funny how cheerleaders of Stokes captaincy conveniently ignore this
@Forum363
3. Kohli not playing in this Test was obviously a big factor that greatly weakened India’s middle-order. Pant’s absence cannot be discounted either.
You are right that I hate Stokes but I loved him until 2021. He is the most selfish cricketer I have ever seen. The way he sat out of the 2021 series vs India and the WT20 was shameful.
In addition, he retired from ODIs in 2022 and gave a phony excuse that he wanted to manage his workload even though between his retirement and the 2023 World Cup, England were only playing 7 ODIs. He wouldn’t have died had he played those 7 matches.
Right before the World Cup, he decided to make himself unavailable and selfishly hogged the spot of another player. What was the point of his retirement? It completely disrupted England’s preparation for the World Cup.
The way he has humiliated by Shami in the World Cup gave me a lot of sadistic pleasure.
Stokes did an AB de Villiers in 2019 but unlike CSA, ECB didn’t have the balls to say no him. Initially, they made Brook the sacrificial lamb before deciding to switch to Roy.
Both Roy and Brook deserved to play in the World Cup ahead of Stokes who shouldn’t have retired before the World Cup in the first place but once it was done, he should have had the dignity to stay retired.
Stokes’ selfishness in 2021 was rewarded with a leadership position but a man who has a documented history of putting himself above the team should never be rewarded with captaincy because he always leave the team high and dry.
Joe Root is always available for England. These are the type of men that you want to captain your team.