What's new

PM Modi’s clean India claim 'pooh-poohed'

Cpt. Rishwat

T20I Captain
Joined
May 8, 2010
Runs
44,558
Modi’s clean India claim pooh-poohed

India’s prime minister has insisted that his government has built enough lavatories to eradicate the need for Indians to defecate outside but campaigners say that up to 300 million people still lack basic sanitary facilities.

Narendra Modi said that his administration had delivered Mahatma Gandhi’s dream of a “clean India” — yesterday was the 150th anniversary of the independence campaigner’s birth. Organisers at events in Gujarat on the western coast marked the occasion by handing out 10,000 jars of treated human faeces.

After presiding over the building of millions of lavatories since coming to power in 2014, Mr Modi said the nation was “open-defecation free”. “Today the whole world is amazed by this,” he said. “The women of our country no longer have to wait for darkness. Innocent lives of young children are being saved.”

On taking office Mr Modi vowed to stamp out public defecation, installing a lavatory in each of India’s 650,000 villages. At the time, more than half of India’s 1.3 billion people did not have access to a lavatory, a fact that jarred with the country’s image as an emerging superpower.

Mr Modi vowed to end the need for men and women to squat by roadsides, fields, rivers and railways lines, yet it remains a common sight. Many of the new facilities have no water supply; caste and cultural barriers also deter many Indians from using them.

The government claimed in March that fewer than 50 million people relieved themselves outside, down from 550 million in 2014. “There is no way this claim is true,” Aashish Gupta, of the Research Institute for Compassionate Economics, said after studying the use of lavatories across four states last year. “A substantial proportion of the population still does not have access to a toilet. Even if they do, many don’t use them. Toilets still carry a caste stigma.”

The jars of treated faeces handed out in Ahmedabad contained waste that had been dried, sieved and packed with seeds that would sprout upon watering.

Earlier Mr Modi paid his respects to Gandhi. “Take any problem the world faces, the teachings of Mahatma Gandhi offer solutions to those challenges,” Mr Modi said in Delhi.

Opposition supporters took to social media to say that Gandhi was assassinated in 1948 by a member of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the Hindu militia that was a forerunner of Mr Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party. Sonia Gandhi, the Congress party chairwoman, suggested that Gandhi’s soul “would have been pained by what’s been happening in India in the past few years”.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/world/modis-clean-india-claim-pooh-poohed-7ptkfk7cc


I think Modi's intentions were good, public lavatories are a step in the right direction, but you need the infrastructure to support them such as water supply to truly make them effective.

I suppose critics might suggest these are cosmetic changes for publicity rather than dealing with the underlying issues such as infrastructure and caste mentality.
 
This is a good initiative and we can make fun of it, but its important for India.
 
I think India has this problem worse than Pakistan and Bangladesh.

India spends so much money on so many things but they can't resolve this toilet issue somehow.
 
With an out of control population it will take hundreds of years for India to sort out such problems if it were to remain one country. The world does not have time to wait for India resolving such problems.
 

Why POOPING on Streets Will Keep India POOR Forever​






@Rajdeep @cricketjoshila @Champ_Pal @JaDed @Devadwal @uppercut @Theanonymousone @straighttalk @Vikram1989 @Varun @Romali_rotti @Bhaijaan @Cover Drive Six @rickroll @rpant_gabba, @Romali_rotti @kron @globetrotter @Hitman @jnaveen1980


#FreeMinoritiesOfIndiaFromHindus

#SaveAllIndianMinorities

#FreeIndiaFromHinduExtremism

#SanctionIndia

I know India lie about their GDP and many other things.

But, surely, they can resolve this toilet shortage problem? Why do so many Indians defecate openly? :inti
 

Why India is still struggling to provide access to toilets​




November 19 is World Toilet Day, a crucial health issue in India. According to the World Bank, nearly 15 percent of the country's population does not have access to a toilet and the consequences are severe: water pollution, waterborne diseases and sexual violence. In 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi promised that open defecation would be eradicated in India. Eight years after the government's promise, India still lacks toilets and the country's sanitary problems are not getting any better. Our correspondents report.

 
I know India lie about their GDP and many other things.

But, surely, they can resolve this toilet shortage problem? Why do so many Indians defecate openly? :inti
Indias gdp numbers are false?

Joits not Bangladesh where you lie about gdp numbers and go to imf to get bailouts
 
@cricketjoshila Why did Modi lie ? Over a decade later over 300 million still don’t have a toilet ?

Modi is one of the most dishonest pathological liars in the last 100 years.

People who support him are clearly low-IQ. The fact he gets away with so many broken promises and lies shows his supporters are braindead zombies; incapable of critical thinking. :inti
 
Because I’m thinking of going into the toilet manufacturing business. Is there a market for toilets in India or is Modi being honest ? I can export direct to Calcutta .
Pakistanis wont get export permission so u can export to Pakistan as Pakistan needs them, but payment be irregular
 
Modi is one of the most dishonest pathological liars in the last 100 years.

People who support him are clearly low-IQ. The fact he gets away with so many broken promises and lies shows his supporters are braindead zombies; incapable of critical thinking. :inti
Pakistanis hate modi, modi must be doing something good
 
Pakistanis wont get export permission so u can export to Pakistan as Pakistan needs them, but payment be irregular

That’s fine I’ll use an Indian citizen , plenty of them here now .

Modi claimed only 50 million Indians defecate on roads , fields etc but still over 300m have no access . Are they willing to pay well for a toilet ? I can change the name to Amarbith Shanks ?
 

Source: https://healthissuesindia.com/india...sis-a-public-health-emergency-in-slow-motion/.​

India’s water and sanitation crisis: A public health emergency in slow motion​


In 2025, it should not be news that millions of people still live without clean drinking water or a working toilet. But in India, that’s the reality. Every day, contaminated water quietly sickens families. Flooded drains spill sewage into homes. Schoolgirls have to skip class because there’s no bathroom. And in hospitals, children die from diarrhoea, something easily preventable with safe water and basic hygiene.

However, it is not for lack of effort. India has spent billions on water pipelines and toilet construction. Government missions have reached nearly every rural village but somewhere between the grand schemes and the daily grind, the system breaks.

The human cost of contaminated water

Diarrhoeal diseases remain a leading killer in India, especially among children. According to UNICEF, around 100,000 children under the age of five die annually due to poor water, sanitation, and hygiene1. The World Health Organization estimates that over 395,000 deaths globally could be prevented with basic water and sanitation improvements2. In cities like Ahmedabad, 897 deaths from water- and mosquito-borne diseases were recorded in public hospitals from 2015 to 20253.

Beyond mortality, the economic cost is staggering. India loses an estimated $600 million annually to waterborne diseases, not to mention the lost productivity and educational setbacks, particularly for women and children who bear the brunt of inadequate WASH (Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene) services4.

India has made impressive progress in expanding access to drinking water. As of February 2025, the Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM) had brought tap water to nearly 80% of rural households5. But quantity doesn’t guarantee quality. A significant share of India’s water, especially in rural areas, comes from untreated groundwater sources, many of which are contaminated. Arsenic, fluoride, and heavy metals plague districts across Maharashtra, Bihar, West Bengal, and Punjab.

Sanitation infrastructure

India’s flagship Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM) dramatically increased toilet coverage. Yet building toilets is only half the battle. By October 2019, all villages in India were declared Open Defecation Free (ODF) under the Swachh Bharat Mission-Gramin (SBM-G). This marked a jump from just 38.7% of rural households with access to toilets in 2014 to nearly 100% coverage in 20197. Yet, a UNICEF report showed that one-sixth of rural India still defecates openly7.

This is because many such facilities, in both rural and urban areas, are unusable due to poor maintenance, lack of water, or absence of separate provisions for women. Women are particularly affected and the problem even extends to schools, especially those without functioning toilets, contributing to absenteeism among girls8.

Untreated waste and polluted rivers

Sewage treatment remains India’s Achilles’ heel. Of the 38,354 million liters per day (MLD) of sewage generated, only about 11,786 MLD is treated. The rest flows into rivers, lakes, and groundwater which further pollute drinking water sources and spreading disease9.>

In Maharashtra, 89 new sewage treatment plants (STPs) are in development, yet half of the state’s 9,190 MLD sewage output is still dumped untreated10. In Punjab, while STPs exist, only 87% of the installed capacity is used, leaving 268 MLD untreated11. Meanwhile, unregulated RO plants continue to sell contaminated water in cities like Nagpur.

Climate and urban pressures

Climate change is amplifying the crisis. Erratic rainfall, heatwaves, and urban flooding are overwhelming outdated infrastructure. The monsoon brings not just relief but risk with flooding drains, overflows septic tanks, and spreads waterborne diseases like cholera, jaundice, and typhoid. Urban sprawl is making things worse. As cities expand, wetlands disappear, sewage networks collapse under pressure, and groundwater sources become more polluted and overdrawn.

What is being done?

India’s response has been multi-pronged. The Jal Jeevan Mission has extended to 2028, with ₹67,000 crore allocated in the 2025 Union Budget12. In urban areas, AMRUT 2.0 aims to create 24×7 water supply and upgrade sewerage systems13. SBM Phase II is focusing on waste management and behavior change.

Community efforts and public-private partnerships offer hope. In Maharashtra, a Tata Motors initiative revived 356 water bodies, benefiting 350,000 people14. Yet challenges persist as infrastructure is underused or poorly maintained. Behavior change remains slow and water pollution laws go unenforced, with climate adaptation lagging. Without regular monitoring, sustainable financing, and community engagement, the gains could unravel. To turn the tide, India must shift from infrastructure expansion to sustainability and governance:

  • Monitor in real time: Use sensors to track water quality and enforce pollution controls.
  • Charge for sustainability: Introduce water and sanitation tariffs to fund maintenance, not just construction.
  • Engage communities: Scale successful PPPs and community-led models like Gram Vikas.
  • Prioritize equity: Design facilities that work for women, slum dwellers, and schools.
  • Focus on quality: Test and treat water at the source; regulate RO units and groundwater use.
India’s battle for clean water and sanitation is far from over. Progress has been made but it’s fragile. Public health depends not just on new pipes and toilets, but on the systems, behaviors, and enforcement that keep them working. Without that, the same cycle will continue: build, break, neglect, rebuild and lives lost in the gap. Water is life and sanitation is dignity. For India to truly thrive, both must be safe, reliable, and universal.
 
That’s fine I’ll use an Indian citizen , plenty of them here now .

Modi claimed only 50 million Indians defecate on roads , fields etc but still over 300m have no access . Are they willing to pay well for a toilet ? I can change the name to Amarbith Shanks ?
If caught your payment may be with held
 
Back
Top