Rate these wicket-keeper batsmen in Tests

[Ab Fan]

I want you to rate the following wkt-keeper batsmen on 10 in test cricket:-

Adam Gilchrist
Mark Boucher
Johnny Bairstow
MS Dhoni
Quinton de Kock
BJ Watling
Sarfaraz Ahmed

Discuss!

 

[the_outsider]

Gilchrist 10/10 - he sets the benchmark
Boucher - 8/10 - not a great bat but the best wk in this list
Bairstow - 5.5/10
Dhoni - 10/10 - bonus point for captaincy
De Kock - 6.5/10
Watling - 5.5/10
Sarfraz - 6/10 - bonus point for captaincy

Edit: Sorry I rated overall, not just tests. Missed that detail.

 

[shaaik]

There can never be another Gilchrist. No way Australia would hv been the same dominant force with out Gilly. He was once in a century player...

 

[Robert]

Adam Gilchrist 10
Mark Boucher 7
Johnny Bairstow 5
MS Dhoni 6
Quinton de Kock dunno
BJ Watling dunno
Sarfaraz Ahmed 6

 

[Ab Fan]

Adam Gilchrist 10
Mark Boucher 7
Johnny Bairstow 5
MS Dhoni 6
Quinton de Kock dunno
BJ Watling dunno
Sarfaraz Ahmed 6

Sarfaraz better than Bairstow??

 

[saeed5646]

Sarfaraz better than Bairstow??

both average 37 with the bat in test so i think both are equal at the moment but bairstow have potential

to be number 1 keeper in the world

 

[Reverse Sweep]

Gilchrist 10
Watling 8
QDK 7.5
Sarfraz 7
Dhoni 7
Bairstow 7

 

[Stalin]

Gilchrist - 10/10 (G.O.A.T in wk )
Boucher - 8/10 ( Great wk but not that good a Bat)
Bairstow - 7 /10 ( on the fall in recent Times)
Ms Dhoni - 7.5/10
De Kock - 7/10
BJ Watling - 7/10
Sarfraz - 6/10

 

[Itachi]

Gilchrist - 10/10 (G.O.A.T in wk )
Boucher - 8/10 ( Great wk but not that good a Bat)
Bairstow - 7 /10 ( on the fall in recent Times)
Ms Dhoni - 7.5/10
De Kock - 7/10
BJ Watling - 7/10
Sarfraz - 6/10

Seems pretty much realistic.

 

[Hasan123]

Gilchrist-10
Boucher-8
Bairstow-6.5
MSD-7
De Kock-6.5
Watling -6
Sarfraz-6

 

[introvert]

Gilchrist - 9
Boucher - 6
Bairstow - 7
MSD - 7
De Kock - 7
Watling. - 7
Sarfaraz - 7