Should the whole Mohsin Naqvi administration be sacked for their Asia Cup's 2025 boycott fiasco?

[Devadwal]

Based on posts in this forum, this dude holds 2-3 other posts in governement. How is it allowed? Doing one job should be hard enough for a large country like Pakistan.

He is home minister of Pakistan yet holding a position of PCB chairman and ACC chairman as well. But sir don't mix the poltics with sport's

 

[ads101]

He is home minister of Pakistan yet holding a position of PCB chairman and ACC chairman as well. But sir don't mix the poltics with sport's

Yeah the irony is not lost on me. And then flanked by former chairmen who were both installed there due to politics and also removed due to politics .

 

[Devadwal]

Yeah the irony is not lost on me. And then flanked by former chairmen who were both installed there due to politics and also removed due to politics .

ICC is spineless otherwise they should have banned PCB long long ago. PCB is last board to even talk about mixing poltics with sport's.

 

[ads101]

ICC is spineless otherwise they should have banned PCB long long ago. PCB is last board to even talk about mixing poltics with sport's.

Internally PCB are guilty of this. There is so much politics when it comes to appointing positions. But externally generally between nations they are fine. And most nations it usually takes something insane for nations to ban them from sport. Even Russia, they still let them participate except under a different flag.

I do get the Indian people’s grievances about Pakistan. And do realise some things are bigger than cricket.

But still when it comes to sport it’s about peace and coming together despite differences. Even it was my worst enemy or even if our countries were at full on war, I’d probably still shake their hand after I played sport with them. It’s just general etiquette when it comes to sport. Maybe you could argue it’s just tradition but that’s how it’s been. Can’t speak for Pakistan as I don’t live there but I was born in Uk and raised there and that’s generally how most people in UK feel.

 

[Devadwal]

Internally PCB are guilty of this. There is so much politics when it comes to appointing positions. But externally generally between nations they are fine. And most nations it usually takes something insane for nations to ban them from sport. Even Russia, they still let them participate except under a different flag.

I do get the Indian people’s grievances about Pakistan. And do realise some things are bigger than cricket.

But still when it comes to sport it’s about peace and coming together despite differences. Even it was my worst enemy or even if our countries were at full on war, I’d probably still shake their hand after I played sport with them. It’s just general etiquette when it comes to sport. Maybe you could argue it’s just tradition but that’s how it’s been. Can’t speak for Pakistan as I don’t live there but I was born in Uk and raised there and that’s generally how most people in UK feel.

In Ideal case scenario you're right but when comes to india - Pakistan there are much more things that matter above cricket and sportsmanship .

 

[Caved12]

False pride and ego is causing most of the problems for Pakistan cricket.

Indian players should have shook hands imo but Naqvi's reaction is even weirder.

Spot on! Instead of focusing on cricket itself, improving our domestic structure and bringing some stability, Naqvi has chosen the route of endless chopping and changing, chasing cheap points with theatrics. Since the day he came in, he has been playing musical chairs with captains, coaches, and everything else related to Pakistan cricket.

Some fans here defend it under the name of “merit,” but deep down they know the reality: Gillespie and Gary were forced to resign within months, Shaheen was wrongly removed from T20I captaincy, and Babar should never have been reinstated in that manner. On top of that, players who openly took cheap shots at Babar and ruined the dressing room environment were brought back. He even supported a fixer like Amir, revived failed and recycled players, and talked about a “surgery” that till today makes no sense.

Meanwhile, our two best players were punished and replaced with failures, guys who haven’t proved themselves at either domestic or international level. Add to that the unnecessary posturing and silly fights with India, only to lose to them again and again. And yet, unbelievably, there are still people here blindly supporting Naqvi as if he’s some savior, when in reality he has been the worst of them all.

The one person he hasn’t touched is Aaqib Javed, who has failed as a coach, failed as a selector, failed in every role he’s taken in the PCB setup, yet keeps conveniently shifting from one position to another. That alone shows what a complete joke this management is and an even bigger joke are those who can’t see it and keep blindly cheering for every wrong decision being made.

 

[BouncerGuy]

Naqvi sahab is untouchable. forget about sacking him