Sikh organization files $2.5M defamation lawsuit against India following Sikhs For Justice ban

RameezRambo_Fan

Tape Ball Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2019
Runs
338
Canadian Sikh organization files $2.5M defamation lawsuit against India
Mia Rabson, The Canadian Press
Published Wednesday, July 10, 2019 10:56AM EDT
Last Updated Thursday, July 11, 2019 6:30AM EDT
https://www.ctvnews.ca/mobile/canad...5m-defamation-lawsuit-against-india-1.4502024

OTTAWA -- Canadian Sikh organizations fear the Indian government is trying to interfere in the upcoming federal election after a flurry of Indian media articles accusing Canadian Sikhs of inciting violence and militancy in Punjab and the Canadian government of supporting them.

Balpreet Singh, the lawyer for the World Sikh Organization in Canada, said a number of stories in Indian media in June and July have cited Indian government sources that Canadian Sikhs are behind terrorist activities targeting India. He believes the looming federal election is driving the stories because the Indian government wants to quiet the politically influential Sikh community in Canada.

"There are going to be a lot of Sikhs running for political office and it's to ensure the Sikh community is seen through a paradigm of extremism, of suspicion, essentially to marginalize Sikhs in Canada," he said.

There were 19 Sikh MPs elected in 2015, most of whom are seeking re-election. Singh said these articles undermine Sikhs within Canada. Singh said there is simply no evidence of any extremism or terrorist elements in Canada's Sikh community.

A government report last fall listed Sikh extremism as one of five major terrorist threats to Canada, though it acknowledged the number of actual incidents in Canada associated with it is extremely limited. After an outcry from groups that included the World Sikh Organization, Public Safety Canada revised the report to talk about extremists who support violent means to establish an independent state within India, instead of naming Sikhs as a community.

Many of the recent articles cite unnamed Indian government sources but some also directly quote Amarinder Singh, the chief minister of Punjab state, who has accused members of the Canadian cabinet of being Khalistani sympathizers.

In late June, Amarinder Singh accused the Canadian government of "overt and covert support" of the Khalistani movement, citing a 2010 Canadian report on the 1985 Air India bombing. Singh alleges that report proves Canada was complicit in not preventing the attack and suggested there should be United Nations sanctions against Canada to pressure the government here "to put an end to the use of its soil to unleash terror against India."

In 2018, Singh met with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau during his troubled state visit to India and gave Trudeau a list of alleged terror suspects in Canada to investigate. Singh said the fact nothing has happened to the people on the list is proof of Canada's complicity in pro-Khalistan activities.

Another article in the Hindustan Times, on July 6, suggests Canada's relationship with India will remain icy unless the Canadian government condemns any pro-Khalistan movements entirely. That article cites unnamed sources saying India's new foreign minister, Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, issued that warning both to Canada's high commissioner in India on June 19 and again to Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland when the two met on the sidelines of the G20 leaders' summit in Japan on June 28.

Canadian officials describe the meeting only as an introduction between Freeland and Jaishankar, who was only appointed to the post in May. Freeland's tweet about that meeting said "Canada and India are close partners with deep historical and people-to-people ties" and that it was "wonderful" to meet Jaishankar.

One Canadian organization is trying to fight back against the allegations in court. Sikhs for Justice, a Toronto-based human rights organization promoting the right of Sikhs to have their own independent state, filed a defamation suit in Ontario Superior Court July 8 alleging the Indian government was the source of at least three stories that falsely accuse Sikhs for Justice of colluding with the Pakistani intelligence agency to target Indian police officers and military personnel.

The Indian government has not yet responded to the $2.5-million libel suit, nor did a spokesman from the Indian High Commission respond to a request for comment from The Canadian Press.

"We want to show to the Canadian community that these are lies," said Jatinder Singh Grewal, the international policy director for Sikhs for Justice.


In March 2018, Canada's deputy ministers were warned about the risks the large Chinese and Indian communities in Canada are "vulnerable to foreign state-led campaigns that directly or indirectly work to influence diaspora communities across the country."

The warning, in a report prepared for deputy ministers attending a retreat on national security, was obtained under the Access to Information Act.

"While the increasing political participation of these communities at all levels of government is both laudable and reflective of the increasing diversity of the Canadian political system, the risk of these communities being influenced, overtly or covertly, by foreign governments with their own agendas cannot be overlooked," the report reads.
 
They can do whatever they want in Canada or US or UK. They can have their referendum there. Means jack **** in India. The whatever court in Canada, has no jurisdiction in India.

Any organisation talking about secession in India, be it based anywhere will be banned in India. There is nothing foreigners can do about it.
 
They can do whatever they want in Canada or US or UK. They can have their referendum there. Means jack **** in India. The whatever court in Canada, has no jurisdiction in India.

Proving that India's High Commission in Canada is pushing out fake stories into the Canadian media is an issue that the Canadian courts will look into. If proven, it will not be a good look for India and just bodes better for the Punjab secessionist movement.

Any organisation talking about secession in India, be it based anywhere will be banned in India. There is nothing foreigners can do about it.

By banning them, you're just legitimizing them. Congratulations.

PS: Are these foreigners?
 
Proving that India's High Commission in Canada is pushing out fake stories into the Canadian media is an issue that the Canadian courts will look into. If proven, it will not be a good look for India and just bodes better for the Punjab secessionist movement.

'If proven it will not be a good look for India' :))), yeah I am sure Indians will be losing sleep over a minuscule Sikh population in Canada. lol Indian government is not going to care nor will it affect India, Canada relations if proven Indians had something to do with this..

By banning them, you're just legitimizing them. Congratulations.

They will never get Khalistan, neither will Pakistanis get Indian side of Kashmir, neither will Palestinians throw Jews from Israel, its life, stop wasting it on causes that will never happen. Ofcourse if you want to stick with: ' Oh one day it will change' then so be it, whatever makes you happy,..

bold...
 
Not sure what the Khalistanis are fighting about. They already have their land. We can double or triple what they have if that makes them happy about it.
 
'If proven it will not be a good look for India' , yeah I am sure Indians will be losing sleep over a minuscule Sikh population in Canada. lol Indian government is not going to care nor will it affect India, Canada relations if proven Indians had something to do with this..

By all means, continue what you're doing. Everyday you just inflame the situation further and further, it's like watching a kid scratch a mosquito bite. This is why I supported Narinder Modi being elected in India again. He's the best ISI agent anybody could ask for.

Secondly, I couldn't personally careless what Indians think. I'm just interested in seeing Punjabi nationalism rise in India. Bodes well for Pakistan in the long run.

They will never get Khalistan, neither will Pakistanis get Indian side of Kashmir

Pakistan doesn't claim Kashmir, it only regards it as disputed territory. An independent Kashmir also works in Pakistan's favour.

Also, by that logic India will never get Azad Jammu & Kashmir or Gilgit-Baltistan right?

neither will Palestinians throw Jews from Israel

Also, neither will Israel destroy the West Bank and Gaza right and force the Palestinians into refugee camps right?

its life, stop wasting it on causes that will never happen. Ofcourse if you want to stick with: ' Oh one day it will change' then so be it, whatever makes you happy,..

It's life, when Punjab is being converted into a desert when its rivers are all being diverted away to Delhi and the Bhaiya Tract. You think this is a dead issue? Wait until Indian Punjabis have to start rationing water. :lol:

 
Is this Sikh 2020 referendum gonna be in Europe, UK, Canada, USA or India? Surely it has to be in India as no one else cares.
 
By all means, continue what you're doing. Everyday you just inflame the situation further and further, it's like watching a kid scratch a mosquito bite. This is why I supported Narinder Modi being elected in India again. He's the best ISI agent anybody could ask for.

Secondly, I couldn't personally careless what Indians think. I'm just interested in seeing Punjabi nationalism rise in India. Bodes well for Pakistan in the long run.



Pakistan doesn't claim Kashmir, it only regards it as disputed territory. An independent Kashmir also works in Pakistan's favour.

Also, by that logic India will never get Azad Jammu & Kashmir or Gilgit-Baltistan right?



Also, neither will Israel destroy the West Bank and Gaza right and force the Palestinians into refugee camps right?



It's life, when Punjab is being converted into a desert when its rivers are all being diverted away to Delhi and the Bhaiya Tract. You think this is a dead issue? Wait until Indian Punjabis have to start rationing water. :lol:


Perfectly put, wonderful post.. Its quite easy to see why Pakistan is currently in the state it is in... The word 'Delusion' has a strong connection with a lot of Pakistanis,...
 
Perfectly put, wonderful post.. Its quite easy to see why Pakistan is currently in the state it is in... The word 'Delusion' has a strong connection with a lot of Pakistanis,...

What does Pakistan have anything to do with the video I posted whereby it describes the Sikh genocide of 1984, and how India is diverting all of Punjab's river water away to Delhi and the Hindi belt? Nice deflection.

Meanwhile in the land of delusion.

Indian Science Congress Speakers Say Newton Was Wrong, Ancient Demon-King Had Planes
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsa...-say-newton-was-wrong-ancient-demon-had-airpl

India had planes and test tube babies thousands of years ago, science conference told
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/20...ondemn-irrational-claims-hindu-epics-contain/

Indians invented planes 7000 years ago — and other startling claims
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...-the-science-congress/?utm_term=.e7393e246ee7
 
What does Pakistan have anything to do with the video I posted whereby it describes the Sikh genocide of 1984, and how India is diverting all of Punjab's river water away to Delhi and the Hindi belt? Nice deflection.

Meanwhile in the land of delusion.

Indian Science Congress Speakers Say Newton Was Wrong, Ancient Demon-King Had Planes
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsa...-say-newton-was-wrong-ancient-demon-had-airpl

India had planes and test tube babies thousands of years ago, science conference told
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/20...ondemn-irrational-claims-hindu-epics-contain/

Indians invented planes 7000 years ago — and other startling claims
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...-the-science-congress/?utm_term=.e7393e246ee7

Lad, your country is broke, it is plunging into bigger debt by the day the future is grim... Too bad there is not enough Mamoons around, but hey what the hell, if it makes you happy, stay put and stay the way you are, keep up the good progress.. :wa
 
By all means, continue what you're doing. Everyday you just inflame the situation further and further, it's like watching a kid scratch a mosquito bite. This is why I supported Narinder Modi being elected in India again. He's the best ISI agent anybody could ask for.

Secondly, I couldn't personally careless what Indians think. I'm just interested in seeing Punjabi nationalism rise in India. Bodes well for Pakistan in the long run.

[lol...First time hearing about 'Punjabi Nationalism' rising in India. Which planet do you live in? 'Sikh Nationalism' or 'Khalistan liberation' died in the eighties. Now you are fantasizing about not just Sikh nationalism but entire 'Punjabi Nationalism'.
Question for you: So is this 'Punjabi Nationalism' about the Punjab of India and the Punjab of Pakistan both seceding from India and Pakistan respectively and forming a whole new nation of 'Punjab', with all Punjabi Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs living together as its citizens?]


Pakistan doesn't claim Kashmir, it only regards it as disputed territory. An independent Kashmir also works in Pakistan's favour.

Also, by that logic India will never get Azad Jammu & Kashmir or Gilgit-Baltistan right?

[Welcome to the world of reality. IOK, POK shall remain the way they are. The earlier everyone accepts this, the better for their own sanity. No amount of terrorism in Indian Kashmir shall cause it to secede. No amount of Indian attempts to liberate or occupy POK will work. Don't see a way that both Kashmirs can unite into one independent nation. Neither India nor Pakistan shall stand for that. So what are we even discussing here?]

Also, neither will Israel destroy the West Bank and Gaza right and force the Palestinians into refugee camps right?

[Don't even know what Israel and Palestine has to do with IOK/POK. Kashmir and Palestine are not co-related].

It's life, when Punjab is being converted into a desert when its rivers are all being diverted away to Delhi and the Bhaiya Tract. You think this is a dead issue? Wait until Indian Punjabis have to start rationing water. :lol:

[Diverting rivers is not like bending a pipe of water and pointing it into the neighbors house. Also water shortage is a big issue of most of Pakistan and India and the rest of the world.

If Punjab is the bread basket of India, do you think any government would want to starve Punjab of its water? India has not even diverted water flowing into Pakistan, why do you think Indian govt will divert water flowing into Indian Punjab?]



My responses in blue above.
 
No Sikh in India wants a separate khalistan. I have lived in Punjab for more than 3 years and no one wants to separate from India. Pakistanis should worry more about their government going bankrupt.
 
Back
Top