What's new

South Africa v Pakistan | 1st ODI | Centurion | 2nd April, 2021 | Pre-Match Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rayyman

Test Debutant
Joined
May 5, 2014
Runs
15,182
Excited for this match!

Pakistan's ODI team is strong. Even though they are missing their top ranked bowler and all-rounder (Amir and Imad), it is gonna be fun to see the prolific Pakistani Top 3 back at it. Our fast bowlers should enjoy the pace of the African pitches. And let's see if Mohammad Rizwan can cement his spot in the playing XI.
 
Should be an exciting series..Even SA isn't loaded with too many great players and Pakistani pace bowlers should get a lot of assistance from the pitches.
 
I reckon Pakistan can win this provided they win either the first or second game. They should win the last game for sure i feel as neither Ngidi, Nortje, Rabada or QDK will be playing as they all set sail for India after the 2nd odi.
 
Let's see if we've learned our lesson from the last tour when we couldn't handle the short pitched bowling.
 
Pakistan head coach Misbah-ul-Haq said on Monday he believed the venues for two white-ball series in South Africa would suit his team, as they stepped up preparations after arriving in the country.

Misbah, speaking for the first time since Pakistan arrived in South Africa, said he looked forward to three one-day internationals and four Twenty20 internationals, which will be shared between the Wanderers Stadium in Johannesburg and SuperSport Park in Centurion in order to adhere to Covid-19 protocols.

The series starts with a one-day international is in Centurion on Friday.

"If I look back, when we used to come here and play, these two wickets, Centurion and Wanderers, we always enjoyed these pitches,” said Misbah, who captained Pakistan on a 2012/13 tour of South Africa.

"The bounce and pace is very true and as a batsman you enjoy that," he said. "You get full value for your shots. Some of the players in this team have already played here and performed very well.

"Those previous performances and experiences definitely help you. Pakistan always have the luxury of good fast bowlers and I think that is the reason why we do well here."

South Africa played a Test series and a T20 series in Pakistan recently and Misbah said the reciprocal series was important in times made difficult because of the Covid-19 pandemic when the calendar had been impacted by the crisis.

"It is our duty as different nations to keep going, keep helping each other and keep this game alive."

New South African white-ball captain Temba Bavuma confirmed earlier that South Africa would only be able to use their Indian Premier League players for the first two one-day internationals.

Bavuma said he respected the relationship between the South African and Indian boards that enabled star players to fulfil their IPL contracts.

Quinton de Kock, Kagiso Rabada, Lungi Ngidi, David Miller and Anrich Nortje will miss the third one-day international and all four Twenty20 internationals because of their IPL commitments.

"For the first two games we have got all our best players so it is important to get positive results in those first two games," said Bavuma.

"But that is not to say we are conceding the third game. We believe we have the replacements with guys coming in to fill those boots."

Bavuma said that the tour provided an opportunity for players to stake a claim for two World T20 tournaments in the next two years as well as the 2023 Cricket World Cup.

"We’ve got 22 players, which is a big squad," he said. "The message to the players is that 90 percent of the World Cup squads will come from this group. It is important that the guys understand there is an opportunity and also that they know where they stand."

https://www.barrons.com/news/s-afri...-says-coach-misbah-ul-haq-01617028505?tesla=y


==


"I think especially with white-ball cricket, the pitches are very good, they're true pitches, with good bounce and pace and for batters"

"In white-ball cricket, it is easier to adjust to these conditions and you get good value for shots. Obviously Pakistan has also always had the luxury of good fast bowlers. That is the reason Pakistan has done well here."

"In 2013-14, when we were here, we had Junaid [Khan], [Mohammad] Irfan, then we had youngsters like Bilawal Bhatti and a couple of others. That is the reason why Pakistan like playing here. No doubt South Africa are very good, they know their conditions well. But I think these conditions help Pakistan as a whole, the batsmen especially. And obviously, there's something psychological as well, when a team has done well here before, it helps moving forward as well to perform."

'If I look back when I used to play, these two wickets at Centurion and Wanderers, I really enjoyed batting on them, the bounce and the pace is very true,' he said.

"No doubt South Africa are very good, they know their conditions well. But I think these conditions help Pakistan as a whole, the batsmen especially."

"As a batsman you enjoy that, you get full value for your shots. Previously, in this team, some of the players have played here and performed - Imam [ul-Haq], Babar [Azam], Fakhar [Zaman] was here. These players love that pace and bounce, now [Mohammad] Rizwan is in form, a very good backfoot player. Those previous series and experiences definitely count, they play a role in your confidence as a player and team. When I was playing, suddenly, you just went to a ground where you've performed and your confidence level was always different."

Pakistan have already had a couple of days of training, a bonus given how difficult it had been when they toured New Zealand and had to be in strict isolation with no training for 14 days. South Africa had their own issues this season with the mid-tour cancellation of England's series earlier, and then Australia pulling out of a visit because of concerns over the pandemic in the country. Misbah was confident, however, of no mishaps this time.

"Both the boards are working very hard especially to keep this series going"

"Players and all coaching staff are keen to just play and move forward. Obviously some measures been taken keeping in view previous series but we are hopeful that if we just look after protocols, especially the players while practising, and take responsibility, I'm pretty sure series will go on. Already we've been to England and New Zealand, completed series there and obviously we'd like to do the same here. We'll do our best to complete this series."
 
Last edited:
Pakistan has no business losing both the ODI and T20 series. But just when they are considered favorites, they tend to bottle it.
 
Can anybody explain how pak are favourites for one days when saffers are at full strength especially when they playing in south africa where they have an awful record
 
Should be pretty fun, but I doubt our guys will handle the swing and bounce well.

When should Pak stop playing ODIs and only focus on T20s for the WC? A 5 match ODI series in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka would be great to practice for India.
 
Can anybody explain how pak are favourites for one days when saffers are at full strength especially when they playing in south africa where they have an awful record
A full strength South African team is a relatively mediocre ODI side.

Pakistan on the other hand are an elite side, they have the talent to be the best team in the world. The top order has statistically all-time great numbers.

Shaheen Shah Afridi and Hasan Ali are better bowlers than anybody in the South African side barring Kagiso Rabada.

In terms of quality, Pakistan is a better team on paper. The only way South Africa wins this match is if they use their home conditions to their advantage.
 
In what world are Pakistan favourites? You need pace and bounce to win in SA. Shaheen is ok, Hasan seems to have found some rhythm but they're not a patch on Rabada and co in these conditions. Shaheen is the shortest tall bowler in the world and Hasan is just short.

Add to that Pakistan having a naff batting line up at the best of times and they'll be playing on pitches where they've historically really struggled. Babar is literally our only hope.

I'm pretty certain that the first two ODI's will be easy for SA and they're the favourites.
 
In what world are Pakistan favourites? You need pace and bounce to win in SA. Shaheen is ok, Hasan seems to have found some rhythm but they're not a patch on Rabada and co in these conditions. Shaheen is the shortest tall bowler in the world and Hasan is just short.

Add to that Pakistan having a naff batting line up at the best of times and they'll be playing on pitches where they've historically really struggled. Babar is literally our only hope.

I'm pretty certain that the first two ODI's will be easy for SA and they're the favourites.

Pakistan lost the series 3-2 on their last tour yet Imam ul Haq still won Man of The Series because he was the leading run-scorer from both sides. Fakhar Zaman batted well in both white ball series after struggling in the Tests. Faheem Ashraf has also completely transformed himself as a cricketer.

I really do not see how SA can beat a team with as many match-winners that Pakistan has.
 
Just hope Misbah has changed his mindset and brings a more modern plan than just trying to score 240s if batting first and then trying to defend.

We should aim for mammoth totals of 340+ and be equally comfortable chasing 300+ if the pitches are decent.
 
Just hope Misbah has changed his mindset and brings a more modern plan than just trying to score 240s if batting first and then trying to defend.

We should aim for mammoth totals of 340+ and be equally comfortable chasing 300+ if the pitches are decent.

One step at a time mate, as [MENTION=53290]Markhor[/MENTION] said ; ya”ll need to score 200 first :yk
 
I UL HAQ
F ZAMAN
B AZAM *
M RIZWAN +
D AZIZ (6th bowler/ 2nd spinner)
H ALI
F ASHRAF
S KHAN
H ALI
S AFRIDI
M HASNAIN

Batting till # 09
 
Imam
Fakhar
Babar
RIzwan
Haider
Danish
Faheem
Nawaz/Qadir
Hassan
Shaheen
Hasnain
 
Fakhar
Imam
Babar
Rizwan
Haider Ali
Nawaz
Faheem
Hassan Ali
Shaheen
Rauf
Qadir
 
Last 3 are absolute duds in batting which is a slight concern otherwise its a good side.
Shadab is mediocre but he still might play as he's vice captain which is a shame really
 
Still cant wrap my head around Shadab being the VC & not Rizwan. Hope he is not an automatic selection.

Otherwise a good team.
 
Ngidi has lost his early pace and charm, while Rabad despite being incisive seems to have lost a bit of an edge when compared to Nortje who is the one Pakistan should be careful negtiating. He has the ability t run through a team in helpful conditions. Its gonna be a close call, this series. Good luck Team Pakistan
 
Fakhar
Imam
Babar
Rizwan
Haider
Faheem
Nawaz
Shadab
Hassan
Shaheen
Hussnain
 
Pakistan on the other hand are an elite side, they have the talent to be the best team in the world. The top order has statistically all-time great numbers.

Wow, the same elite Pakistani team lost an ODI to Zimbabwe who were probably not at their full strength at home not too long ago. Pakistan ODI team is mediocre & so is South African side that's why both teams can win this series.
 
Is there T20 or test series after this? ODIs are pointless at this point of time.
 
Is there T20 or test series after this? ODIs are pointless at this point of time.

The ODI series is part of the ODI league & top 8 teams from this league will book their place in 2023 WC directly so these ODI's aren't pointless, I'll say apart from T20 WC international T20's are waste of time & are pointless.
 
The ODI series is part of the ODI league & top 8 teams from this league will book their place in 2023 WC directly so these ODI's aren't pointless, I'll say apart from T20 WC international T20's are waste of time & are pointless.

T20I s are generally pointless but not this WC year. As far as ODIs are concerned , the league will take care of itself.
 
With the bowling SA has, pakistan need to play enough batsman to do the scoring , I feel the selectors have not taken enough middle order batsman but there are 5 allrounders or say bits and pieces (Danish, Shadab, Nawaz, Faheem , Wasim jr) is an overkill

Only two middle order batsmen they have Babar, Haider Ali.. Even then Haider opens the batting in domestics. Saud was a good addition, but Haris Sohail should also be in the side, Asif cant be considered as a middle order batsman.. If Haris was lazy and unfit then should have gone for Umar Amin or Kamran Ghulam with the form he was in.. This hole in the lineup will surely and be badly exposed.

Im sure lack of proper middle order batsman will be exposed in this ODI series.. And im afraid in the first 2 matches were Nortje and Rabada will play , pakistan will have a scorecard of 10-2 or 22-3 and then on it will always be catch up, If we take the last series, if hafeez fails to score a 50 the team crawled to make 200

Why because 2 quick wickets at the top if one of the wicket is Babar then the team will struggle to reach 200. Time for Haider Ali to step up and play long innings and cement his place in the side. His quick 40s will be of no use, he will turn out the u.akmal.


In this case Im thinking they should play both Rizwan Sarfaraz to strengthen the middle order instead of Asif ali or Nawaz or Danish.


Sarfraz will easily will in the gap in the middle order with his current form and experience. Or they have to play Shafique in the middle order or open with Shafique and Fakhar and play Imam at 3. or play Shafiq at 3 and let Babar play the role of steadying the ship at 4.. Pakistani openers will find difficult to negotiate with Rabada, Nortje early into the inns without causing an early collapse..


My team would be

Fakhar
Imam
Babar
Haider Ali
Rizwan
Sarfraz
Shadab
Faheem
Hasan Ali
Shaheen
Hasnain
 
I think Pakistan will play it safe and look to go with a well experienced line-up, but for me I would play:

1. Imam-ul-Haq
2. Fakhar Zaman
3. Babar Azam (C)
4. Mohammad Rizwan (WK)
5. Danish Aziz - Would like to see Danish Aziz get a chance despite this being a difficult tour to debut in.
6. Mohammad Nawaz
7. Faheem Ashraf
8. Hasan Ali
9. Shaheen Shah Afridi
10. Usman Qadir
11. Mohammad Hasnain

This would be my line-up, I understand Nawaz and Aziz are similar but I think Nawaz's future in this team will be tried out as a finisher whereas Aziz is more of a middle order batsman even though for Northern side Nawaz plays as a No.5.
 
Can anybody explain how pak are favourites for one days when saffers are at full strength especially when they playing in south africa where they have an awful record

South africa will be losing a few players for the last odi if pakistan win either the first or second they should go on a win the series
 
Just hope Misbah has changed his mindset and brings a more modern plan than just trying to score 240s if batting first and then trying to defend.

We should aim for mammoth totals of 340+ and be equally comfortable chasing 300+ if the pitches are decent.

I have heard either haider ali Danish aziz will not play or even both may not play i hope it isnt the truth
 
Excited for this match!

Pakistan's ODI team is strong. Even though they are missing their top ranked bowler and all-rounder (Amir and Imad), it is gonna be fun to see the prolific Pakistani Top 3 back at it. Our fast bowlers should enjoy the pace of the African pitches. And let's see if Mohammad Rizwan can cement his spot in the playing XI.

Huh? This is a strong ODI team?

After the top 4 of Imam/Fakhar/Babar/Rizwan, do they even have a single reliable batsmen after that? Aziz's List A track record is mediocre. Asif Ali averages in domestic in general are closer to a tail ender than an actual batsmen. Haider Ali might be good but he is also really young and early into his career so he's a complete wild card. They should have added Haris instead of Aziz after Saud's injury and it wouldn't surprise me if that comes back to haunt them.

To me, it looks like a team that we may see very easily collapse and put up low totals as a result. They struggle a lot in SENA conditions anyways so I can easily see the ODI's going extremely poorly. Certainly can't see them chasing big totals if South Africa scores big.
 
My line up would be
Imaam
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Haider ali
Danish aziz
Shadab
Fahim
Hassan ali
Shaheen
Husnain

Batting is all the way upto 9.you also have a part time option in danish Aziz . this team should be able to get 300+
 
I have heard either haider ali Danish aziz will not play or even both may not play i hope it isnt the truth

He'll be raging the likes of Iftikhar, Wahab, Musa, Sohail Khan, Asad Shafiq etc didn't get selected. Someone has to pay the price.
 
Imam
Rizwan
Babar
Danish (not many other options, want Rizwan to open)
Haider
Nawaz
Shadab
Faheem
Hasan
Shaheen
Hassnain
 
South Africa should consider future great of the game, Aiden Markram in their ODI side.

Watching Shaheen bowl to Aiden Markram in ODIs up front with the new bowl is a sight that will not be matched by many in the modern era.
 
South Africa should consider future great of the game, Aiden Markram in their ODI side.

Watching Shaheen bowl to Aiden Markram in ODIs up front with the new bowl is a sight that will not be matched by many in the modern era.


Aiden Markham is in the ODI squad. He has done well in domestic cricket in white ball cricket. I think Markham will play, JP Malan will probably miss out as Bavuma has to play as captain and De Kock will play the first two games.
 
If pakistan want to become a half decent odi side these are series they need to start winning regularly.
 
Huh? This is a strong ODI team?

After the top 4 of Imam/Fakhar/Babar/Rizwan, do they even have a single reliable batsmen after that? Aziz's List A track record is mediocre. Asif Ali averages in domestic in general are closer to a tail ender than an actual batsmen. Haider Ali might be good but he is also really young and early into his career so he's a complete wild card. They should have added Haris instead of Aziz after Saud's injury and it wouldn't surprise me if that comes back to haunt them.

To me, it looks like a team that we may see very easily collapse and put up low totals as a result. They struggle a lot in SENA conditions anyways so I can easily see the ODI's going extremely poorly. Certainly can't see them chasing big totals if South Africa scores big.

Middle-order is a potential weakness, but there are some reasons to be hopeful.

Nawaz had an excellent FC season with the bat followed by an all-round match-winning performance in the deciding T20I vs SA at home.

Danish Aziz and Asif Ali both played some brilliant innings in the recent 50 over Pakistan Cup. Asif Ali has a couple ODI fifties outside Asia so if he can tame his aggression, his experience may come in handy. Danish should not be debuted in this series though.

Asif and Nawaz have both played in the SA T20 League so they know the conditions.

Faheem Ashraf scored well in tough Test match conditions in New Zealand. He followed that with some explosive batting in PSL. ODIs in South Africa should not be difficult for him.

Hasan Ali and Shadab Khan are also there down the order if needed.

Abdullah Shafique and Usman Qadir scored half-centuries in the practice match.

“They struggle a lot in SENA conditions anyways so I can easily see the ODI's going extremely poorly. Certainly can't see them chasing big totals if South Africa scores big.”
^
That above statement is not true as all of Fakhar’s hundreds are outside Asia, Imam won Man of The Series here last time and Babar Azam batted amazingly on the last South Africa tour. Rizwan’s performances overseas in the past couple years speak for themselves. Recent statistics show that Pakistan is scoring over 300 in ODIs consistently. You cannot see them chasing big totals in South Africa, but I can.
 
Aiden Markham is in the ODI squad. He has done well in domestic cricket in white ball cricket. I think Markham will play, JP Malan will probably miss out as Bavuma has to play as captain and De Kock will play the first two games.

Any chance in first two ODIs?
 
Wow, the same elite Pakistani team lost an ODI to Zimbabwe who were probably not at their full strength at home not too long ago. Pakistan ODI team is mediocre & so is South African side that's why both teams can win this series.

It was not the full strength team. Faheem and Hasan were out injured. Haris and Imad were rested because Pakistan had won the 1st two matches and Amir was rested for the whole series.

Furthermore, that match was tied and even then, anything can happen in a one-off game.

Pakistan ODI team is young and improving as opposed to the South African team which is on the way down. If Pakistan get their combination right this is their series to lose.
 
My line up would be
Imaam
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Haider ali
Danish aziz
Shadab
Fahim
Hassan ali
Shaheen
Husnain

Batting is all the way upto 9.you also have a part time option in danish Aziz . this team should be able to get 300+

Tail is too long. We lack quality batsmen to support Babar and Rizwan.
 
Any chance in first two ODIs?

JP Malan scored an excellent century against Australia last year, I think South Africa will go for Markham as he has done well in list A cricket. JP Malan will probably play the 3rd ODI and the T20s.

Temba Bavuma will be a good ODI player but I don't see him outperforming Malan and Markham if given the same chances.

My SA batting line up would be

JP Malan
De Kock
Markham
Van Der Dussen
Miller/Klassen
Wian Mulder

Kyle Verreynne,Zubayr Hamza,and Tebay Bavuma would be the back options. I would have made Markham or Van Der Dussen captain.
 
[MENTION=139595]Ab Fan[/MENTION],JP Malan was not given a central contract. Markham and Klassen were. Whilst Bavuma is the captain so has to play. Logically these players will be preferred over Malan. But I think SA should play Malan and De Kock as ODI openers.
 
Tail is too long. We lack quality batsmen to support Babar and Rizwan.

Babar,rizwan and imaam can bat throw.all the rest play thier shots.danish aziz is good enough to play as a batter.shaheen and husnain are the tail everyone else can bat
 
[MENTION=139595]Ab Fan[/MENTION],JP Malan was not given a central contract. Markham and Klassen were. Whilst Bavuma is the captain so has to play. Logically these players will be preferred over Malan. But I think SA should play Malan and De Kock as ODI openers.

Yeah but now with Bavuma as captain, let's see what is the XI that they start with.
 
The interesting thing will be that everyone in Pakistan's probable top 5 has played as a regular opener at some point:

Imam, Fakhar (regular OD openers)
Babar, Rizwan (regular T20 openers)
Haider (regular opener at U19 level)
 
Pakistan, over the last 15 - 20 years have always gone with '3 pacers - 3 spinners' combo and, in the absence of Hafeez, will struggle by not selecting a spinning 6th bowler option in either Haris Sohail or Iftikhar Ahmed.

Is there anyone in the squad who can bowl a few part time overs aka Hafeez and bat too, either at no 5 or 6?

MY LEFT SIDE CHOICE WOULD BE SHADAB KHAN.

Workable Eleven:

Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Haider
SHADAB
Faheem
Nawaz
Hasan
Qadir
Afridi
 
Looking forward to Shaheen's performance in this series. If Pakistan are to win anything he is the key player.

Imam and Shadab might be a bit rusty tho.
 
My Best Eleven from given squad:

Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Haider
Asif
Faheem
Nawaz
Hasan
Qadir
Afridi

Fakhar can bowl some handy part time spin if one of the main bowlers is having terrible day but we can't compromise on already weak batting for so called sixth bowling option, it's luxury which a team like Pak can't afford right now.
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

That would be silly people are expecting too much from Rizwan. He has done well in last few months but he will struggle in South Africa should stick to being a keeper.
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

Mashallah he has expeeriyans of failing in SA. We are doomed
 
It was not the full strength team. Faheem and Hasan were out injured. Haris and Imad were rested because Pakistan had won the 1st two matches and Amir was rested for the whole series.

Furthermore, that match was tied and even then, anything can happen in a one-off game.

Pakistan ODI team is young and improving as opposed to the South African team which is on the way down. If Pakistan get their combination right this is their series to lose.

All excuses, Pakistan is just a mediocre side in all formats of the game. Basically, Pakistan was playing against Zimbabwe at home, if they had lost that game to Bangladesh, SL or W.I it would've been acceptable as these sides are much better than Zim.
 
Looking at conditions and form this is what I reckon our XI should be.
1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Rizwan
5. Danish
6. Haider
7. Faheem
8. Nawaz
9. Hasan
10. Shaheen
11. Qadir
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

:facepalm :facepalm :mw :mw

TYPICAL PAKISTAN MANAGEMENT instead of giving chances to the youth we're still trying to give a chance to 35 years old guy who at his best was an average player just to make KARACHI media happy.
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

Hope this doesn't materialise.
 
Why the hell would you drop Haider for a has-been like Sarfraz? This kind of selection is expected from Misbah but if this is real, then Babar needs to be set straight.
 
Some stats with regards to the Super Sports Park:

Head to Head; SA 4 & Pak 2

Pacers Vs Spinners; Top 20 wicket takers have 18 pacers and 2 spinners and in recent times only Chahal and Ajmal were able to create any impact. Tahir averaged 45 on this ground.

Highest successful chase: Only once a total over 300 has been chased
 
Looking at the stats of the ground maybe Pak should go with four pacers and one spin option. A sixth option would be pretty decent to have incase of a bad day for a bowler or two and Danish Aziz is the only one who has been bowling much in domestic cricket recently unless team management trusts Fakhar to chip in with few overs or they are thinking of going with an allrounder in the spot of a batsman.
 
Last edited:
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

Talk about fixing what ain't broken, to suddenly the specialist captain have become better keeper than Rizwan and better prospect than Haider or someone like Rohail, even if they have to play him than do it as batter at 4 or 5, why would you take away gloves form one of the best keepers in world cricket. Than we wonder what self destruction is.
 
Not defending the rumors but, thing is with Saud (A proven domestic performer) injured and lack of experienced options currently in the middle can be the potential reasons to think about Sarfaraz in the role. He showed decent form in PSL but, not sure if he will be able to transfer that to SA conditions in ODIs. If he plays then obviously he will have to take the gloves as he is a liability as a fielder while Rizwan is one of the best fielders we have on the field.

Other than Babar, Rizwan and Sarfaraz other options in the middle order are Asif Ali with 18 matches, Haider Ali with 2 matches, Abdullah Shafique and Danish Aziz are yet to debut. This is the least experienced middle order setup from Pakistan to ever tour SA.

One can definitely argue that Hafeez could have been included in ODIs as he could have given a bowling option as well along with experience but, then this decision could have been criticized as well stating why a 40 year old guy is making a comeback in ODIs.
 
I UL HAQ
F ZAMAN
B AZAM *
M RIZWAN +
D AZIZ (6th bowler/ 2nd spinner)
H ALI
F ASHRAF
S KHAN
H ALI
S AFRIDI
M HASNAIN

Batting till # 09

Good team. I would open with Rizwan and Fakhar and bat someone else at #4. We should really stop meddling when something good is found. Rizwan is a good opener.
 
Looking at conditions and form this is what I reckon our XI should be.
1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Rizwan
5. Danish
6. Haider
7. Faheem
8. Nawaz
9. Hasan
10. Shaheen
11. Qadir

One of the worst selections , as per the ground stats.

Three spin options for the ground that has favored pace in the past. Only ajmal and chahal had a decent amount of success in the ground tells a lot about the ground..

Also both Nawaz and Danish in the same 11 ( why two same kind of players)..
 
Not defending the rumors but, thing is with Saud (A proven domestic performer) injured and lack of experienced options currently in the middle can be the potential reasons to think about Sarfaraz in the role. He showed decent form in PSL but, not sure if he will be able to transfer that to SA conditions in ODIs. If he plays then obviously he will have to take the gloves as he is a liability as a fielder while Rizwan is one of the best fielders we have on the field.

Other than Babar, Rizwan and Sarfaraz other options in the middle order are Asif Ali with 18 matches, Haider Ali with 2 matches, Abdullah Shafique and Danish Aziz are yet to debut. This is the least experienced middle order setup from Pakistan to ever tour SA.

One can definitely argue that Hafeez could have been included in ODIs as he could have given a bowling option as well along with experience but, then this decision could have been criticized as well stating why a 40 year old guy is making a comeback in ODIs.


Well we know who to blame for not selecting an extra batter or two in the squad. I had a look at the ODI squad for this series and the way the squad has been selected is bizarre. Don’t see the need for 3 spinners on these pitches, some middle order batters should have been selected instead.
 
Media reports saying that Sarfaraz Ahmed is likely to play in the three-match one-day international (ODI) series against South Africa starting April 2 as Keeper, with Mohammad Rizwan playing as a batsman.

A good decision , Sarfraz with his experience and the eager to get back his spot in the lineup would be licking to outperform Rizwan with the bat, which is a good tussle to have ..

Understand the gloves being given to Sarfraz as he will find difficult to field instead whereas Rizwan is electric in the field with or even without gloves.

Haider Ali or Danish Aziz should be in as no. 5 or 6.. Asif ali addition is a self destruction , he cant be relied to score runs for the team when the team loses 5 wickets inside 35 overs which is likely to happen with the pace bowling attack SA has and the pitch offering pace and bounce.

Pak batsman gifted wickets in the previous series here against short pitched bowling and Duanne Olivier who was a rookie back then claimed a lot of wickets....Asif is good for late order hoicks like 30 runs which will help the team in 20-20s....
 
With the current management in place , and the love of Misbah for seniors i believe they will field the following 11 which will get hammered.. This could be one of the worst possible 11 that can be selected which i expect them to do because they will not take the ground stats or pitch or anything that matters. All they need is familiar faces to challenge the opposition.

Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Sarfraz
Asif Ali
Nawaz
Shadab Khan
Faheem
Hasan Ali
Shaheen
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top