What's new

South Africa v Pakistan | 3rd T20I | Pretoria | 14 April 2021 | Pre-Match Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,133
Too aggressive and losing wickets by the bucket-loads was Babar Azam's assessment of Pakistan's loss in the 2nd T20I.

What changes should be made for Pakistan to win the 3rd T20I?

Discuss.
 
With that atrocious middle order I really dont have much hope. 3-1 is well and truly on the cards.
 
Fakhar for Sharjeel
Mohammed wasim Jr for Hasnain
Zahid Mahmood for Usman Qadir
Sarfraz for Faheem to bat in middle order. Our middle order is going nowhere, and Faheem is not adding much value at his position.
 
Just lost one match and people are losing confidence already.

Could have easily lost both if not for schoolboy errors from SA in last 3 overs. Second game was a hammering which i think has completely exposed our problems in our T20 batting. No firepower at the top and a non existent lower middle order.
Bowlers have also been expensive in both games.
At best its going to be 2-2.
 
Sharjeel needs another go but only if Fakhar Zaman is still unwell.
 
Sharjeel needs another go but only if Fakhar Zaman is still unwell.

Completely agree plus gotta drop Hasnain for Rauf, that’s my only change and if Fakhar is well then try the dream opening of Fakhar and Sharjeel.
 
Babar will learn from his mistakes. One of the biggest reason Pakistan team has not been able to find a stableness in Captaincy process, it’s because we are too impatient and wants quick fix and results.

Let him settle down, let him make mistakes that is the only way you learn this process of Captaincy. In this process he will learn and will find out, which players is what capability.

Kohli has not won India a single WC as a Captain did BCCI drop him from Captaincy. Sarfraz Ahmed was becoming a good Captain and what did we do, we made a lobby against him and escorted him out of the Captaincy process. This is not how you build Leaders. Fine Sarfraz had Fitness Issues but he was doing an excellent job as a T20 Captain and ODI.
Had he been continuing, we could have utilise him even better as a batsmen only.

For Me Continuing and Consistency in selection is the only we will become a good side. 1 T20 lost and Ex-cricketers brings their guns out. I have not seen this kind of statement process from ex-cricketers from India.

For me this line up which played yesterday should continue.

Fakhar if fit
Rizwan
Sharjeel
Babar
Hafeez
Haider
Fahim
Nawaz
Hassan Ali
Rauf
Usman Qaider

Shaheen need a rest.
 
Rizwan has over done in last game.. I would go with

Sharjeel
Fakhar
Babar
Rizwan
Hafeez
Haider
Faheem
Hassan Ali
Usman Qadir
Husnain
Rauf
 
I would change Nawaz for Wasim Jnr and Haris for Hasnain. Haider needs last chance on this tour.
 
You cannot play Faheem and Nawaz alongside 4 bowlers and i don't know why this combination was ever tried in the first place. Someone has to make way for the extra batsman.
 
Not a lot working at the moment...Rizwan has to open, anywhere else he is hopeless.
Why not try Sharjeel lower down the order?

Rizwan
Fakhar
Babar
Hafeez
Sharjeel
Faheem
Hasan
Nawaz
Hasnain
Usman
Afridi/Rauf
 
You cannot play Faheem and Nawaz alongside 4 bowlers and i don't know why this combination was ever tried in the first place. Someone has to make way for the extra batsman.

Haider needs to make way then in that case, cause honestly he's been far from impressive for me.

My XI i'll trial for the next game:

1. Fakhar Zaman (hear he's fit)
2. Sharjeel Khan (he merits another game)
3. Babar Azam (c)
4. Muhammad Hafeez
5. Muhammad Rizwan
6. Muhammad Nawaz
7. Faheem Ashraf
8. Hassan Ali
9. Usman Qadir
10. Haris Rauf/Arshad Iqbal
11. Shaheen Shah Afridi
 
Too many openers. There’s hardly any middle order batsman in the squad. So obviously there’s going to be a huge selection headache. Cupboards are bare. Can’t think of a single batsman from the domestic level who can make it into the squad.
 
Too many openers. There’s hardly any middle order batsman in the squad. So obviously there’s going to be a huge selection headache. Cupboards are bare. Can’t think of a single batsman from the domestic level who can make it into the squad.

Shoaib Moqsood? Azam Khan? Shahibzada Farhan?

Can't blame the selector both Hussain Talat and Khushdil Shah flopped.
 
Babar's position is confusing, does he come in the middle order or should he open the innings?

There's two teams we can go with, both are quite unique and untested:

Option #1:

Babar Azam (c)
Mohammad Rizwan
Sharjeel Khan
Mohammad Hafeez
Fakhar Zaman
Haider Ali
Faheem Ashraf
Mohammad Nawaz/Usman Qadir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Shah Afridi
Haris Rauf

In option 1, we see an unorthodox approach where we want stability at the top of the order rather than explosiveness. Once a wicket falls, Sharjeel is allowed to come on and play his natural game. If Sharjeel pulls off a Sharjeel and is dismissed cheaply, Hafeez is there to steady the tempo in the middle overs, where I have placed Fakhar Zaman specifically to combat the threat of Tabraiz Shamsi. Haider Ali is down further at 6 because it's where he's least likely to face Shamsi, assuming that SAF doesn't hold an over of Shamsi near the death specifically for Haider. Bowling resources are a bit limited, and it requires Hafeez to be the sixth bowling option. I wouldn't mind slotting in Danish Aziz for Haider as the 6th bowling option, but I think it's fair to give Haider one more opportunity to produce some compelling results.

Option 2:
Fakhar Zaman
Sharjeel Khan
Babar Azam (c)
Mohammad Hafeez
Sarfaraz Ahmed/Mohammad Rizwan (wk)
Haider Ali/Danish Aziz
Mohammad Nawaz/Usman Qadir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Shah Afridi
Haris Rauf

This option is ultra-aggressive at the top of the order, going for maximum output and high-risk play. It could backfire as we could suffer yet another collapse, but if it works out, it will put us in a better position. If Danish Aziz slots in ahead of Haider, it gives us another bowling option, especially if we aren't confident in Hafeez's bowling ahead of the World Cup.

I haven't really spoken about our bowling, but one person's role needs defining: Shaheen Shah Afridi.

He bowls a brute of a yorker when he lands it well, but he hasn't taken the pressure of bowling in the death too well. His economy rate is about 10 in the death overs versus 6.8 in the powerplay. Now, I think it would be quite foolish to make him bowl in places where he isn't comfortable bowling. It's a skill he'll learn as he bowls more in T20s, but right now, we need the best possible performance from him. This is why I think Shaheen should be bowling the 1st, 3rd, and 10th overs, before bowling one in the death. That way, he is able to bowl one over with freedom in the middle overs where he can utilize his slower ball variations, short balls, and bouncers which he can't do in the powerplay or in the death. One option could also be to finish all his overs by the 12th over, and I'm thinking this because we aren't looking at Shaheen's strengths properly. With the new ball in hand, he will always go looking for swing which is acceptable, before he starts to put the ball in on a length. A bouncer in the powerplay is risky because any contact can result in a boundary, and slower-balls are both risky in the powerplay and in the death. This is why I think he needs to come in the middle overs. He can bowl the yorkers, the bouncers, the slower balls and any other variations to get wickets without the external pressure of bowling in the death. It will improve his game a lot in my opinion.

Hasan Ali should bowl one over in the powerplay and the rest in the death. Faheem needs to be utilized in the powerplay so that Hasan and Haris can have overs to spare in the middle and near the death as well.

That's what I'm thinking as of now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top