What's new

The exorbitant costs of treatment for Coronavirus in Pakistan - are they justified?

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
Here is a sample:


South City Hospital Khi charging Rs 150,000 per day for COVID-19 patients

AKU is charging Rs 135,000 per day for a COVID isolation ward bed. And over Rs 160,000 per day for a COVID vent. This does not include admission costs

South City also asks for a 10-day advance deposit

==

Can a normal wage earner afford this?
 
Private hospitals have played a very disgraceful role in this pandemic. I am not sure about other provinces, but in KP, private hospitals refused admit COVID patients for a long time because they didn’t want to deal with this mess.

Eventually, they were forced to act because the public hospitals were operating at full capacity. Now that they have finally decided to do a “favor” on the public, they are charging amounts that the poor man - who is at a higher risk - cannot afford treatment.
 
Yes it’s a disgrace.

I recently saw an invoice for south city hospital and I thought it was for the whole duration.

I literally spat out the water I was drinking when I found it was just for a day.
 
Thats roughly £750 a day, £7500 for a 10 day stay

How can that be justified? Surely even the middle class cant afford the amounts being quoted
 
South City and Aga Khan are very expensive private hospitals offering international level of care. They cater to the elite class and not to the average Joe.
 
South City and Aga Khan are very expensive private hospitals offering international level of care. They cater to the elite class and not to the average Joe.

Aga Khan you maybe right.

South City is just a money making machine which is an existential fire and disease hazard. The hospital is made in what were houses and placed in among the most dense parts of city charging barely believable sums. It is a pure money making machine since it doesn’t even have a training or schooling component. At the most it should be for dentists, dermatologists etc who can have their clinics there. But definitely should’ve he got contagious and deadly doseases
 
Does it really matter?

The number of deaths due to covid 19 is very low.

The poor in Pak and the major part of the country is poor never had access to healthcare.

Its nothing new.
 
Reports stated that Naeem Akhoond Deputy MD Sui Southern has passed away today. Yesterday he was taken in Ambulance to South City Hospital Karachi who refused to admit him. Then the family went around looking for some other facility but no hospital took him. Late last night his condition further deteriorated so they again tried South City who said they would take him if One Million was deposited in advance. After this was done, he was admitted and died today.

Capture.JPG
 
Last edited:
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">This is a single patient bill for 10 days. The family shared it so that we should see what’s going on. It baffles me how 1800 latex gloves & PPE suits are charged to single patient for ten days & the price per unit is ridiculous. I understand the business but this is unfair. <a href="https://t.co/X2RqJHJQho">pic.twitter.com/X2RqJHJQho</a></p>— Fakhr-e-Alam (@falamb3) <a href="https://twitter.com/falamb3/status/1271354823515017222?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 12, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

EaTCd3rXgAAW8eK

EaTCd3lXQAE01Ir

EaTCd3sWsAIKgwQ

EaTCd3nX0AIjgmM
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Sigh really! We r not a welfare state so Unfortunately Govt Facilities r not satisfactory so Anything u opt in Private sector leads to *Mafia* Families of Innocent patients hav to pay&#55357;&#56496;extras. Sergical accessories prices r 10 times higher &#55357;&#56911;&#55356;&#57341; in markets since this pandemic <a href="https://t.co/plZKTiEAVN">https://t.co/plZKTiEAVN</a></p>— Mohammad Hafeez (@MHafeez22) <a href="https://twitter.com/MHafeez22/status/1271735396590903299?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 13, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">My grandmother (Nani) passed away 3 days ago. It's been an extremely tough time for our family. <br>Our experience with South city Hospital Karachi was horrific, have shared a detailed account of what happened:<br>Would request everyone to reshare:<a href="https://t.co/AdvG3UaQdF">https://t.co/AdvG3UaQdF</a> <a href="https://t.co/EwcYkda1dL">pic.twitter.com/EwcYkda1dL</a></p>— Ahsan Alavi (@ahsanalavi) <a href="https://twitter.com/ahsanalavi/status/1272230498832658442?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 14, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Text of post in spoiler.

South City Hospital – A sad tale of Negligence, Incompetence and Apathy!

Our ordeal with South City Hospital (Karachi) started when our beloved grandmother was admitted on the third Day of Eid. She was diagnosed with a tumor which was pressing her optic nerve. The doctor suggested a neurological procedure to remove the tumor through the nasal passage. The procedure happened, she regained consciousness and was seemingly fine putting us at ease. However, due to lack of trained staff, incompetence of the hospital administration and negligence by the Surgeon, her post-operative care was a complete disaster. In fact there was none at all (no physiotherapy & no mucus suction). Hence, she was diagnosed with a severe lung infection while recovery. Even this condition was diagnosed because one of our family members, who was attending to her had pointed out how she was breathing heavily and pressured the hospital staff to do a chest X-ray.

Due to the COVID-19 scare, the doctor’s insisted that their clinical diagnosis suggests she has COVID therefore two tests were conducted in a span of 48 hours but even before the results of the first test came back, she was shifted into isolation. Both results were negative but still the doctors insisted that according to their "clinical diagnosis" she was a COVID-19 patient and hence continued to keep her in isolation as per the SOPs.

Later, the doctors declared that she had a serious case of bacterial pneumonia. Still, she was kept in isolation because they were unable to rule out the “COVID-19 suspicion”. Her physician explicitly informed us she was slipping into acute depression due to isolation which was why her body was not responding to the medications the way it was supposed to. How hard can it be for a hospital charging us more than Rs.175,000 per day (in isolation) to set up some facility so that the patient could be connected to their families 24/7 via technology? The only preparation that they had was a 5 minute face time facility that the family could use by physically going to the hospital and standing outside the COVID ward risking their own health in the process. She spent 3-4 days in isolation in a state of fear (she had never slept alone for even one day in her entire life) and under severe depression. Finally she could not sustain and she breathed her last on 11th June 2020.

The chain of events demonstrating South City Hospital’s sheer incompetence is as follows:

1. The insensitive and callous attitude of the doctors, specifically Dr. Shahid Javaid Hussain (Pulmonologist) After days of trying to reach him, the morning that she passed away, he called us and had the audacity to say that he was ‘busy’ since the past 2 days. How busy could he possibly be to fulfill the basic requirement that he had to keep the family in the loop knowing that we had no other source of getting updates especially when he had agreed to do so over a text conversation? Considering how she was in isolation and completely cut off from her family and the fact that we were paying a fortune, was it such a big ask to get regular updates from the specialist doctor? While I understand that we are in the midst of a pandemic and our healthcare workers are already stretched thin, callousness and apathy are attitudes we should never justify when it comes to a medical practitioner’s duty of care. In the last few days that she spent in isolation, we are doubtful if he even did his duty rounds and saw her since this case fell under his area of expertise. We even tried contacting him via mutual contacts and WhatsApp but he was nowhere to be found. Keep in mind that this was an extremely aged patient who had never spent a day apart from her family and now she was confined into the four walls of an unknown hospital room.

2. The hospital staff and management were a blend of incompetence, insensitivity and lack of responsibility. Our grandmother went into the hospital with no underlying lung infection but post procedure, her lungs were heavily infected. This shows that she contracted this pneumonia while being in the hospital premises. Moreover, there were discrepancies and contradictions between the statements that the hospital was providing. Also, calling the hospital was the only form of connection that we had but there were countless instances when they didn’t pick up the phone, including the night before she passed away, which put us in a complete communication blackout.

We were charged an exorbitant amount of Rs.700,000 for the 4 days that she was in isolation. Were we being charged for negligence, complete ignorance for our grandmother’s mental health or the communication gaps that the doctors and staff had caused? This is probably the most expensive hospital of the city and the least they could do is have an efficient management and competent medical practitioners and with the amount of money that we paid, it was well within our right to expect the best possible treatment. It was well within our rights to expect that her mental health was given a priority. It was well within our grandmother’s right to not go away from this world in a state of fear and loneliness.

The point of this post is to spread awareness about the lack of accountability and the unmatchable ignorance of the hospital. Their irresponsible attitude created a massive trust deficit between us and South City Hospital because of which, even now, there is so much uncertainty that lies within us regarding what the hospital did or did not do. Bear in mind, her death certificate mentioned the reason for death as pneumonia & cardiac arrest clubbed with the fact that she did not have fever or body aches even once during her respiratory illness. Did she really have COVID-19? Did she really need to be isolated? Was the hospital just minting money? These are the type of questions we are asking ourselves. This is to remind everyone how for some of these hospitals, that charge us an arm and a leg, our loved ones are just another statistic. We will not be able to get our grandmother back but maybe our horrifying experience may help save the lives of your loved one.

I also appeal to the relevant authorities to take note of this matter and form some sort of a regulatory body to monitor such hospitals that charge extortionate amounts of money without any standard of service leading to the loss of valuable lives.
 
Last edited:
Private hospitals have played a very disgraceful role in this pandemic. I am not sure about other provinces, but in KP, private hospitals refused admit COVID patients for a long time because they didn’t want to deal with this mess.

Eventually, they were forced to act because the public hospitals were operating at full capacity. Now that they have finally decided to do a “favor” on the public, they are charging amounts that the poor man - who is at a higher risk - cannot afford treatment.
The owners or management of these private hospitals need to pay a hefty fine if this is how they have behaved when there is a national emergency
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">This is a single patient bill for 10 days. The family shared it so that we should see what’s going on. It baffles me how 1800 latex gloves & PPE suits are charged to single patient for ten days & the price per unit is ridiculous. I understand the business but this is unfair. <a href="https://t.co/X2RqJHJQho">pic.twitter.com/X2RqJHJQho</a></p>— Fakhr-e-Alam (@falamb3) <a href="https://twitter.com/falamb3/status/1271354823515017222?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 12, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

EaTCd3rXgAAW8eK

EaTCd3lXQAE01Ir

EaTCd3sWsAIKgwQ

EaTCd3nX0AIjgmM

According to various articles in the UK, covid-19 patients need a large team of doctors and nurses continuously monitoring, turning, ventilating, cleaning the patient 24/7. Taking into account a 24 hour coverage, and the medical staff also needing to take time off, you're talking about a minimum of 4 teams of doctors and nurses.

How much would a top specialist earn in a day? And you'll need a whole load of them, of different specialties, for a covid-19 patient on a ventilator.

If nurses, doctors, cleaners ... are changing their gloves/PPE equipment each time they move from one patient to another, it's not inconceivable that a nurse will be changing her/his gloves many dozens of times per an 8 hour shift.
Multiply that by a whole team of nurses and doctors.
And then again to cover 3 shifts in any 24 hours.
You'll be surprised how it all adds up.

Add to that the overhead costs of running a hospital (building costs, utilities, admin and management, I.T., receptionists, cleaners, security, technicians,...etc), and it all adds up.

Furthermore, If a top private hospital expects to attract rich clients, it also needs to attract the best doctors. And I'm betting they get paid many times more than a public hospital.

And last, but not least, a private hospital exists to make money. That's why it's private in the first place!!
If you want to stay at a 5 star hotel and eat in a Michelin star restaurant, you'll be paying many times than renting a room above a pizza shop, and eating a take-away pizza from that shop.

If you can't afford it, don't go there.

(I’m not a medic or work in a hospital. But I do know about the hidden costs of running any large enterprise, costs that the public don’t always see)

And finally, it's said that less than 3% of working Pakistanis actually pay income tax. Contrast that with the UK when over 95% of those working pay income taxes and National Insurance taxes (can total over 50% of gross salary for higher earners), along with 20% VAT (sales tax) on most goods and services.

So you Pakistanis, if you want good quality free public hospitals, then pay taxes!!
 
According to various articles in the UK, covid-19 patients need a large team of doctors and nurses continuously monitoring, turning, ventilating, cleaning the patient 24/7. Taking into account a 24 hour coverage, and the medical staff also needing to take time off, you're talking about a minimum of 4 teams of doctors and nurses.

How much would a top specialist earn in a day? And you'll need a whole load of them, of different specialties, for a covid-19 patient on a ventilator.

If nurses, doctors, cleaners ... are changing their gloves/PPE equipment each time they move from one patient to another, it's not inconceivable that a nurse will be changing her/his gloves many dozens of times per an 8 hour shift.
Multiply that by a whole team of nurses and doctors.
And then again to cover 3 shifts in any 24 hours.
You'll be surprised how it all adds up.

Add to that the overhead costs of running a hospital (building costs, utilities, admin and management, I.T., receptionists, cleaners, security, technicians,...etc), and it all adds up.

Furthermore, If a top private hospital expects to attract rich clients, it also needs to attract the best doctors. And I'm betting they get paid many times more than a public hospital.

And last, but not least, a private hospital exists to make money. That's why it's private in the first place!!
If you want to stay at a 5 star hotel and eat in a Michelin star restaurant, you'll be paying many times than renting a room above a pizza shop, and eating a take-away pizza from that shop.

If you can't afford it, don't go there.

(I’m not a medic or work in a hospital. But I do know about the hidden costs of running any large enterprise, costs that the public don’t always see)

And finally, it's said that less than 3% of working Pakistanis actually pay income tax. Contrast that with the UK when over 95% of those working pay income taxes and National Insurance taxes (can total over 50% of gross salary for higher earners), along with 20% VAT (sales tax) on most goods and services.

So you Pakistanis, if you want good quality free public hospitals, then pay taxes!!

Obviously Pakistanis should pay their taxes and there’s clearly an issue when only one city ie Karachi is running the country by contributing more than half of the current taxes. But what makes you think that our governments will use those tax money wisely even if they get it? It’s not like they don’t engage in corruption and wastefulness of whatever little we contribute right now.
 
A 70-year-old man in Seattle survived the coronavirus, got applauded by staff when he left the hospital after 62 days -- and then got a $1.1 million, 181-page hospital bill.
 
A 70-year-old man in Seattle survived the coronavirus, got applauded by staff when he left the hospital after 62 days -- and then got a $1.1 million, 181-page hospital bill.
There's a 'black humour' joke about a very similar situation. The punchline being that after seeing the bill, the patient has a heart attack and dies.
 
Obviously Pakistanis should pay their taxes and there’s clearly an issue when only one city ie Karachi is running the country by contributing more than half of the current taxes. But what makes you think that our governments will use those tax money wisely even if they get it? It’s not like they don’t engage in corruption and wastefulness of whatever little we contribute right now.
Ah, the good old 'Pakistani politicians are corrupt but the rest of the populace are angels'.

Fact of the matter is that if the soil and roots of a tree are diseased and rotten, the fruit at the top of the tree will also be rotten.

Pakistani politicians are simply a reflection of the rest of society.

A parent paying a teacher to give his/her child a better grade is corruption. on both sides. And then depriving the honest child who's place is taken by another as a result of bribery makes it even worse. But many Pakistani parents brag about doing that. Whilst everyone knows the teacher's salary is insufficient for him to purchase his up market house and latest car.

A motorist stopped for a traffic violation slipping a traffic policeman a few hundred rupees to look the other way is corruption. On both sides. As for the policeman's nice new house, same as for the teacher above,

A house owner bypassing the electricity meter is theft. And then paying the electricity meter reader to look the other way, is corruption. on both sides.

And the list goes on, and on, and on, and on .....

One well known PPer once admitted his families business regularly pays large bribes. To taxmen, suppliers agents, buyers agents, utilities engineers and other companies admin staff, ..etc. He then justified it by saying it was 'normal', and 'necessary' when doing business. And yet he regularly lambastes politicians for being corrupt.


Pakistani society as a whole is corrupt. And not just the politicians. And those complaining about corruption by others, but happy to pay (or accept) bribes (however small) in their everyday lives are hypocrites.
 
Ah, the good old 'Pakistani politicians are corrupt but the rest of the populace are angels'.

Fact of the matter is that if the soil and roots of a tree are diseased and rotten, the fruit at the top of the tree will also be rotten.

Pakistani politicians are simply a reflection of the rest of society.

A parent paying a teacher to give his/her child a better grade is corruption. on both sides. And then depriving the honest child who's place is taken by another as a result of bribery makes it even worse. But many Pakistani parents brag about doing that. Whilst everyone knows the teacher's salary is insufficient for him to purchase his up market house and latest car.

A motorist stopped for a traffic violation slipping a traffic policeman a few hundred rupees to look the other way is corruption. On both sides. As for the policeman's nice new house, same as for the teacher above,

A house owner bypassing the electricity meter is theft. And then paying the electricity meter reader to look the other way, is corruption. on both sides.

And the list goes on, and on, and on, and on .....

One well known PPer once admitted his families business regularly pays large bribes. To taxmen, suppliers agents, buyers agents, utilities engineers and other companies admin staff, ..etc. He then justified it by saying it was 'normal', and 'necessary' when doing business. And yet he regularly lambastes politicians for being corrupt.


Pakistani society as a whole is corrupt. And not just the politicians. And those complaining about corruption by others, but happy to pay (or accept) bribes (however small) in their everyday lives are hypocrites.

Well I hope non-Karachiites also start paying taxes
 
I'm involved in treatment of many patients in Pakistan , from USA, all of them my friends/extended family members, majority of them are doctors themsleves. There is indiscriminate use of steroids, antibiotics and convalescent plasma. Many of them don;t need it. Also many patients who do not need Acterma ( Tocilizumab ) have been given it or have access to it and keeping it, even patients who are at home , and many who need it can;t afford it or have no access to it.

This is one of many factors increasing the cost there.

Many people do not need hospitalization and they are admitted and if they have money private hospitals will take them . Many need hospitalization but they can;t afford such high cost, its really very unfortunate situation there.
 
Ah, the good old 'Pakistani politicians are corrupt but the rest of the populace are angels'.

Fact of the matter is that if the soil and roots of a tree are diseased and rotten, the fruit at the top of the tree will also be rotten.

Pakistani politicians are simply a reflection of the rest of society.

A parent paying a teacher to give his/her child a better grade is corruption. on both sides. And then depriving the honest child who's place is taken by another as a result of bribery makes it even worse. But many Pakistani parents brag about doing that. Whilst everyone knows the teacher's salary is insufficient for him to purchase his up market house and latest car.

A motorist stopped for a traffic violation slipping a traffic policeman a few hundred rupees to look the other way is corruption. On both sides. As for the policeman's nice new house, same as for the teacher above,

A house owner bypassing the electricity meter is theft. And then paying the electricity meter reader to look the other way, is corruption. on both sides.

And the list goes on, and on, and on, and on .....

One well known PPer once admitted his families business regularly pays large bribes. To taxmen, suppliers agents, buyers agents, utilities engineers and other companies admin staff, ..etc. He then justified it by saying it was 'normal', and 'necessary' when doing business. And yet he regularly lambastes politicians for being corrupt.


Pakistani society as a whole is corrupt. And not just the politicians. And those complaining about corruption by others, but happy to pay (or accept) bribes (however small) in their everyday lives are hypocrites.

A bit off topic but I agree with you. This culture of corruption was not started , but definitely was nurtured in last 30 years or so and now its way of life there. Everyone has an excuse and self made reason for every corruption he/she commits.
 
Across the border, the best hospitals in India are Apollo and Max. The daily rates for Apollo are INR. 7,000 for a "General Ward" and INR. 2,700 for a ventilator. That totals to about PKR 20,000 a day. That is considerably less expensive than the top Pakistani hospitals.

https://www.medifee.com/hospital/2113-apollo-hospital-(jubilee-hills)/

You are right, it does not make any sense for crazy money private hospitals in Pakistan are making during this pandemic.
 
Time to learn from India.

===

Some of India's richest people and health-tech startups have created an alliance to try and transform India's failing health-care system.

The loose alliance, whose backers include Infosys Ltd. co-founders Nandan Nilekani and Kris Gopalakrishnan as well as prominent startups from Practo to Policybazaar, will be formally unveiled as soon as this week in an attempt to salvage a decrepit system by digitizing everything from patient data and records to creating online platforms for hospital care and doctor consultations. Called Swasth -- meaning health in Hindi -- its 100-plus members have pledged to build new services and coordinate efforts to improve emergency responses.

Faced with an exploding health crisis as coronavirus infections look likely to surpass a million, the country's digital health-care backbone -- the Bharat or National Health Stack -- has come into focus and will buttress Swasth's efforts. Much like the digital payments system that today underpins e-commerce, the Stack is designed to wrench into the 21st century an industry whose deplorable conditions have become increasingly apparent as the pandemic broadens across the world's second-most populous nation.

In India, where hospitals and clinics are rife with corruption, only a fraction of its 1.3 billion people have access to insurance and private health-care costs keep millions in poverty. Many rural health centers don't have electricity, running water or toilets, while public hospitals are often so filthy that coronavirus patients have fled the squalor. Many years in the making and sporting elements from a verified registry of doctors and portable personal health records (with patient consent), the Stack was conceived to improve access to affordable services and boost research.

"Coronavirus has exposed glaring vulnerabilities, and technology can improve reach, quality and cost-effectiveness of health care and be the leveler in a country with a woeful shortage of hospital beds, doctors, nurses, medicines," Gopalakrishnan, a member of Swasth's governing council, told Bloomberg News. "Bharat Health Stack will form the backbone of a platform that aims to offer multiple services from hundreds of vendors and give individuals flexibility," said Gopalakrishnan, the billionaire co-founder and former chief executive officer of Infosys.

Privacy advocates have raised concerns over the handling of sensitive information like medical history and test results. Those are likely to get linked to India's ubiquitous biometric digital ID system, called Aadhaar, making it personally identifiable. Such leaked health data could compromise privacy and endanger a person's economic future. Swasth's website says it is non-profit and its coronavirus initiative is non-commercial.

But some activists aren't convinced. "India needs to modernize the flow of health-care information but this move-fast-and-break-things, by outsourcing the entire health infrastructure to a coterie without any checks and balances, is undemocratic," said Mishi Choudhary, legal director at the New York-based Software Freedom Law Center.

India's United Payments Interface offers a model of sorts. Just as a real-time financial technology platform impelled digital payments in just four years, the cloud-based digital health framework -- owned and operated by the government -- may spur speedy creation of health services by doctors and entrepreneurs.Shocking videos of coronavirus patients lying next to corpses in overrun hospitals and ambulances with critically-ill driving around in search of hospital beds have conferred fresh impetus to the task of rescuing Indian health care. Swasth draws together more than 100 health-care providers and startups like online insurer Policybazaar, e-pharmacy 1MG and telehealth provider Practo. Its influential backers also include venture capital firms Sequoia Capital and Accel.

In addition, volunteers from dozens of companies, including online retailers Amazon.com Inc. and Walmart Inc.'s Flipkart, are writing code or engaging with regional governments on information exchanges.This week, Swasth will begin offering a bucket of Covid-related services. Individuals can call a helpline to speak with a doctor for free or get information about the nearest testing center and hospitals. More than 1,000 doctors on the platform will offer free consultations, share advice on emotional wellness and dispense instant prescriptions by text. Those with mild symptoms can access monitoring services for home isolation or quarantine.

While the coronavirus is the starting point, the coalition's larger goal is to devise protocols and mechanisms for testing and treatments for the masses, as part of the National Health Stack.It's working with iSpirt, a software think tank, to set health standards and build interoperability across players and segments. In the coming weeks, iSpirt is set to release open application interfaces for the Stack that'll allow information exchanges on once-closed areas like billing information for insurers or diagnostic lab results.

"India needs an open digital ecosystem to unlock innovative solutions to key societal challenges," said Roopa Kudva, managing director of Omidyar Network India. Such platforms have emerged in areas like financial services and education. "Health care is a very relevant area, given the benefits an interoperable system can bring." Omidyar is among the donors to a 1 billion-rupee Action Covid Team fund, which is also backing the Swasth alliance. Kudva also sought to alleviate privacy concerns.

"In designing such a system, getting the rules of data exchange and safeguarding individual privacy are important," she said.

https://www.aljazeera.com/ajimpact/...llionaires-startups-team-200623060632521.html
 
Seems problems in India also

==

A doctor at a government hospital in Hyderabad has filed a police complaint alleging that she was charged Rs 1.19 lakh for a day by a private hospital for Covid-19 treatment in violation of the state government’s guidelines on treatment costs.

However, the hospital said that she was charged for the “services and medicines given to her”.

In her complaint at Chaderghat Police Station on July 4, Dr Asra Sultana, who is an assistant civil surgeon at the Government Fever Hospital, said that she went to the Thumbay Hospital on June 1 after she experienced problems in breathing. She had tested positive for Covid-19 two weeks ago and was in home isolation prior to the night of June 1, she said in the complaint.

Sultana was asked to pay Rs 40,000 at the time of admission and when she wanted to leave the next day, the hospital did not allow her to go till a payment of Rs 79,000 was made, the complaint further stated.

“They did not give me proper medicines and the nurses were irresponsible. They did not give me medication on time… For just one day, I was at the hospital on July 2, they charged me Rs 1.19 lakh. I paid Rs 40,000, but as I did not have the remaining amount they detained me for several hours until my brother, who is also Covid-positive, came and paid the remaining amount. Eventually we paid Rs 1.19 lakh for a day’s treatment at the hospital,’’ she stated in her complaint.

A statement released by the hospital said Sultana was admitted without any issues. “She was billed for the services and medicines given to her during her stay at the hospital,” the hospital stated.

The hospital authorities did not respond to attempts for comment by The Indian Express.

Sultana also posted a video from the hospital on social media, following which, health officials shifted her to the Nizam’s Institute of Medical Sciences (NIMS).

The Telangana Doctors’ Association said the incident has highlighted how private hospitals are looting people and called upon the government to take strict action.

The association’s president, Dr Lalu Prasad Rathod, said, “Even in this pandemic situation, private hospitals are looting helpless citizens. Dr Sultana is a well-respected and experienced doctor and she herself was at the forefront of the battle against Corona. When she has to undergo this kind of humiliation at the hospital and was issued a bill of over Rs 1 lakh, just imagine how the private hospitals are looting middle-class patients. When Dr Sultana questioned the medication and billing, she was asked to leave the hospital but was not allowed to go until she paid the bill. We demand that the government take strict action against private hospitals which are looting or overcharging people.”

https://indianexpress.com/article/i...ovid-treatment-telangana-govt-doctor-6491719/
 
Cost of COVID Vaccine : India vs Pakistan

I was browsing youtube and saw some Pakistani news channel, pointing out that cost of COVID vaccine in India is 250 INR,
whereas in Pakistan the cost is 15,000 to 20,000 PKR(7000 INR approx)..

I was shocked to hear this. I know in India you can get vaccine for free in public hospitals. But if you don't want to wait in long queue then pay 250 INR. But, 15000 PKR.. Really.. It is shockingly high price if true. Can someone confirm if this is true or not ?
 
I was browsing youtube and saw some Pakistani news channel, pointing out that cost of COVID vaccine in India is 250 INR,
whereas in Pakistan the cost is 15,000 to 20,000 PKR(7000 INR approx)..

I was shocked to hear this. I know in India you can get vaccine for free in public hospitals. But if you don't want to wait in long queue then pay 250 INR. But, 15000 PKR.. Really.. It is shockingly high price if true. Can someone confirm if this is true or not ?
Free Vaccination and Testing are happening in every nuke and corner.
No need to pay 250 rs.
Only few people are taking vaccination from private hospitals. Many private companies are providing vaccination reimbursement for their employees.
 
Free Vaccination and Testing are happening in every nuke and corner.
No need to pay 250 rs.
Only few people are taking vaccination from private hospitals. Many private companies are providing vaccination reimbursement for their employees.

Private hospitals in Delhi started charging 750 Rs for Covidshield vaccine from September 21 onwards. But because of free vaccine at govt facility there was almost zero waiting period now at pvt hospital. A far cry from 2 hour waiting line a month during April-May.

When i got admit in April 21 in private hospital in quiet critical condition due to Covid. I was there 9 days , out of which 5 were in ICU. I was handed bill of around 2,50,000 Rs for cash payment or inflated bill of 4,25,000 Rs if health insurance is covered.
 
Private hospitals in Delhi started charging 750 Rs for Covidshield vaccine from September 21 onwards. But because of free vaccine at govt facility there was almost zero waiting period now at pvt hospital. A far cry from 2 hour waiting line a month during April-May.

When i got admit in April 21 in private hospital in quiet critical condition due to Covid. I was there 9 days , out of which 5 were in ICU. I was handed bill of around 2,50,000 Rs for cash payment or inflated bill of 4,25,000 Rs if health insurance is covered.

Thats big amount.
Hope you are doing well. Tc
 
Back
Top