What's new

The over-critical Australian TV commentators

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
I can understand criticism but it appears listening to our friends on TV that Pakistan are some associate side here for fun.

Not sure if Pakistan players listen or understand or care but if the idea is mental disintegration then they are in my head already! :ma
 
They're absolutely right about the way Misbah is using Yasir. It's shocking stuff. I can understand how Warne must be feeling as a former leg spinner
 
That's what happens when you have the 2 utmost annoying and biased commentators in Ian Healy and Mark Taylor together spouting their garbage repeatedly.

They have serious conflicts of interests with both being actively involved with the Aus Cricket team.
Their complete obsession over certain players like Warner and his Kaboom bat is beyond cringeworthy.
Even when they were getting a hammering from SAF they were spouting the same nonsense like the Aus team is a god chosen team to rule the world.
Lucky Pietersen was there at times to point out the nonsense from those 2.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Btw I'm not defending channel 9. These commentators are awful apart from Mark Nicholas and Warne (I used to hate him but he's growing on me)
 
If you think Channel 9 is bad enough just tune into the radio commentary for ABC GrandStand.......

Listening to those chaps just puts me in a bad mood :sanga
 
The Channel 9 commentators are notoriously poor so this is nothing new.
 
At times it is a bit callous. But their criticism isn't entirely misguided. Yasir has been continously bowling the wrong line. Fielding has been atrocious. Captaincy is too reactionary.
 
Ganguly does the same thing for India. The most unbiased commentators/analysts are the English ones. Nasser Hussain is absolutely the best.
 
I am sure it's not aimless but anything which is not 100% right isn't a disaster
 
If you think Channel 9 is bad enough just tune into the radio commentary for ABC GrandStand.......

Listening to those chaps just puts me in a bad mood :sanga

Grandstand has real top quality commentary
 
You have a choice, don't watch or listen to what you don't like. Nothing worse than someone doing something they don't like by choice then complaining about it.
 
Ganguly does the same thing for India . The most unbiased commentators/analysts are the English ones. Nasser Hussain is absolutely the best.

Eh?

You sure you aren't mistaking Manjrekar for Ganguly..Ganguly has been critical of India plenty of times in the past.
 
If you think Channel 9 is bad enough just tune into the radio commentary for ABC GrandStand.......

Listening to those chaps just puts me in a bad mood :sanga

Grandstand?

It's the equivalent of the TMS. Generally have heard good things about it.
 
Nah, the criticism was warranted yesterday, some of Misbah's tactics were brainless.

Pakistan are just overly sensitive, it was fair criticism.
 
Nothing better than watching them trying to make excuses whenever aus fails.
 
Truth is always bitter!!!! This team deserve sever criticism in order for future positive changes
 
Australian commentators are far better than Pakistan, Indian and Bangladesh commentators for sure. Its constructive criticisms and fact. Ppiers will be more harsh if they get opportunities because of expectation. No body will put up with pathetic performances for years
 
Channel 9 commentary has gone to hell since Lawry and Benaud have left the booth. Taylor, Healy, Brayshaw. Excuse me while I step out and dry heave.
 
Australian commentators are far better than Pakistan, Indian and Bangladesh commentators for sure. Its constructive criticisms and fact. Ppiers will be more harsh if they get opportunities because of expectation. No body will put up with pathetic performances for years

you are talking about a team which was number one in Tests - so dont know what long standing issues you are talking about
 
you are talking about a team which was number one in Tests - so dont know what long standing issues you are talking about

Yes by playing in Asian condition. But we are pathetic in overseas specially Australia and South Africa. So that's the frustration
 
Yes by playing in Asian condition. But we are pathetic in overseas specially Australia and South Africa. So that's the frustration

England must be in the UAE.
 
Eh?

You sure you aren't mistaking Manjrekar for Ganguly..Ganguly has been critical of India plenty of times in the past.

Yes, he does. Sorry, I didn't word that properly. What I meant to say was that he overly criticizes India's opponents.
 
I am saying we need to get rid of some under performers and oldies and inject new players with energy so we may play with energy. Don't like our players give up easily
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Innings just started and we are told that there is a huge difference between Aussie and Pak fast bowlers etc - MUTE time.
 
Innings just started and we are told that there is a huge difference between Aussie and Pak fast bowlers etc - MUTE time.

I haven't been watching all the match but I have agreed with most of what the commentators have been saying while I've been watching. Eg., that the Aussie opening bowlers made the batsmen play in the first few overs more than the Pakistani opening bowlers.

Also that Yasser's leg stump line was very negative.
 
I haven't been watching all the match but I have agreed with most of what the commentators have been saying while I've been watching. Eg., that the Aussie opening bowlers made the batsmen play in the first few overs more than the Pakistani opening bowlers.

Also that Yasser's leg stump line was very negative.

I dont mind it but when you constantly listen to Pakistan as if they were some mohalla side then it gets on your nerve
 
Given what's happening out there, they might have a point especially about the two pace attacks. Nothing wrong with comparing a pace attack averaging 31, 33 and 37 unfavorably with one averaging 25, 26 and 27.
 
I dont mind it but when you constantly listen to Pakistan as if they were some mohalla side then it gets on your nerve

Its just how they think. They feel they are superior than Asians in many ways and unfortunately not many Asian cricketers dispute that. Perform in Australia and England and your record in ROW is discounted.

Just have a look at Daily Mail's headline -

England are still on track for Ashes glory despite their humbling in India - there's no need to panic

Well as long as they retain Ashes, who cares if their record in Asia reads 1-6
 
English commies are hands down THE best commies in the world. Unbiased, knowledgeable, smooth voices and zero nonsense.
 
Pakistan are 97/8. What do you want the commentators to do? To clap and say 'well done pakistan, very good batting'?. It has been an abject surrender from Pakistan. If I were an Australian crowd I would be claiming my money back because no one want to see matches like this. This is just embarrassing.
 
Pakistan are 97/8. What do you want the commentators to do? To clap and say 'well done pakistan, very good batting'?. It has been an abject surrender from Pakistan. If I were an Australian crowd I would be claiming my money back because no one want to see matches like this. This is just embarrassing.

The thread was started when Pak were bowling so relax.
 
Yes, he does. Sorry, I didn't word that properly. What I meant to say was that he overly criticizes India's opponents.

I don't really think that's the case. Ganguly is a fair commentator as far as I've heard. Doesn't fawn over the Indian team like Shastri often does and at the same time doesn't castigate the team too much as well. He is probably the best in Asia imo, too bad he went into administration job because he had a great insight on the game.

Many desi fans become overly sensitive with guys who criticise their team like Boycott and Hussain. But they do it equally with England as well when it is flopping. Ganguly is a bit similar. The Channel nine ones are a different breed though.
 
Innings just started and we are told that there is a huge difference between Aussie and Pak fast bowlers etc - MUTE time.

However cutting their comments are, they are laced with an element of truth. I don't care about the batting. Pak batting has always been woeful on green bouncy pitches. Its the bowling that concerns me, the cupboard is completely bare and the current lot are at best mediocre. Healy rightly commented that Yasir "comes back for his 1000th over". That's because Misbah knows Rahat offers no control which leaves Amir and Wahab as the only pacers alongside Yasir at the other end. Its the sorry state of a 4 man attack and one that will wither the longer the opposition innings goes on through let offs and missed chances.

They should point it out again and again, with acerbic sarcasm and loud and clear until we get something right..
 
I dont mind it but when you constantly listen to Pakistan as if they were some mohalla side then it gets on your nerve

why?? its just a game. Pakistan in Australia ARE a mohalla side. We love them, but cant hide from their flaws. Bowling wide of off stump to new batsmen....Ufff toba toba...im holding my ears. Wasted the new ball.

if you wanna know how to bowl in Australia, just look at Hazelwood to Younis..make the batsman play every ball.

Pakistan got their strategy completely wrong. Should have had Imran khan bowling wicket to wicket.

3 left armers??? who in the world has this kind of samey attack??? At least with Irfan there was the extra height to vary it slightly but wahab, Amir and Rahat is an awful attack.

we should make a thread on this....
 
The Aussie commentators are like Fox Reporters, extremely biased and lovey dovey towards their people and bash the rest.
 
English commies are hands down THE best commies in the world. Unbiased, knowledgeable, smooth voices and zero nonsense.

Love the way how they bring in experts and analyze certain players and you start seeing cricket in a whole new different way.
 
I don't think they were being over-critical, they were right on the money. They were demolishing Misbah's incomprehensible tactics with regards to Yasir and rightfully so, that was disgraceful to watch.


You have the premier leg-spinner in world cricket in your arsenal and you use him to "curb the runs" :facepalm:


Can't wait to see the back of Misbah. Good riddance to such gutless cricket.
 
England must be in the UAE.
Well if you had performed well in England then the failure today and especially that in NZ is total embarrassement. But I was expecting this.
Pak toured england in late summer when the wickets in England are best for batting. Lanka who visited before us failed miserably as the wickets at that time had seam and swing. So pak was lucky to tour England at the right time.
The tour to Australia has always been the hardest. It just exposes you to the bones. Your whole cricket setup is exposed. We unfortunately never learn
 
That was some pretty brainless field settings for Yasir against lefties, they had a point. What will a leggie get out of bowling at middle and leg to a leftie...
 
I have been really impressed by Waqar's commentary. He is very knowledgeable about fast bowling, and when he's on he speaks with focus, talking about the batter's technique, what the bowler should be doing, and so on. He stays on point and doesn't get distracted. And his English is good too. It would be great to see him paired with Warne at some stage this series.
 
I have been really impressed by Waqar's commentary. He is very knowledgeable about fast bowling, and when he's on he speaks with focus, talking about the batter's technique, what the bowler should be doing, and so on. He stays on point and doesn't get distracted. And his English is good too. It would be great to see him paired with Warne at some stage this series.

The good thing about Waqar is that Healy actually respects Waqar enough to cut the rubbish.
 
I don't think they were being over-critical, they were right on the money. They were demolishing Misbah's incomprehensible tactics with regards to Yasir and rightfully so, that was disgraceful to watch.


You have the premier leg-spinner in world cricket in your arsenal and you use him to "curb the runs" :facepalm:


Can't wait to see the back of Misbah. Good riddance to such gutless cricket.

Exactly my thoughts. The commentators have been spot on with their analysis. I'm glad someone finally spoke up about Misbah's pathetic captaincy.
 
If you're a well wisher of Pak cricket, then you should thank Aussie commentators for pointing out the weaknesses in our team. Need a reality check.
 
The good thing about Waqar is that Healy actually respects Waqar enough to cut the rubbish.

I wish we could have him permanently. Every commentary team needs a fast bowler. He can do a job similar to what Holding does for Sky.
 
I wish we could have him permanently. Every commentary team needs a fast bowler. He can do a job similar to what Holding does for Sky.

KP also needs to do more than England and South Africa.
 
Its just how they think. They feel they are superior than Asians in many ways and unfortunately not many Asian cricketers dispute that. Perform in Australia and England and your record in ROW is discounted.

Just have a look at Daily Mail's headline -



Well as long as they retain Ashes, who cares if their record in Asia reads 1-6

Lol the funny thing before the match was how Steve smith totally disregarded cricket in Asia and basically doesn't even count it as cricket

He said sth on the lines of - " i haven't faced Pakistan much at all. I played them in tests in the debut series in England in 2010 and now they are here."
 
Lol the funny thing before the match was how Steve smith totally disregarded cricket in Asia and basically doesn't even count it as cricket

He said sth on the lines of - " i haven't faced Pakistan much at all. I played them in tests in the debut series in England in 2010 and now they are here."

Lol.. was he a part of Aussie team in UAE? I am guessing he was. :))
 
Chappell is begging for to sound like Bob Willis now: forever having a sook
 
The commentary has been very insular: there's a difference between telling it like it is vs trying to understand how something that you might not agree with is a strategy.
 
Need to earn respect. Being 8 down for under a 100 deserves harsh criticism for sure. I see nothing wrong in what the Aussie commentators are saying.
 
I think they were full of praise today for the fight Pakistan showed. Aussies just say it how they see it. They don't do favours and don't ask for any.
 
I think they were full of praise today for the fight Pakistan showed. Aussies just say it how they see it. They don't do favours and don't ask for any.

As a whole most Australian cricket fans are pretty impressed with Pakistani cricket at the moment.
 
Some ridiculous replies. What do you mean need to earn respect?

Pakistan can atleast bat here these guys cant even survive in our land, does that mean we start critisizing these guys and say they have to earn our respect.

All most all these aussies and english are rubbish against quality spin. Infact, these aussies were being tossed around by zulfiqar babar who was our secondary spinner.
 
“I might get him tossed out of the game : Ian Cappell

http://www.news.com.au/sport/cricke...a/news-story/786042bc631d3d0ad64243e5eaef319a

The Pakistani batsmen frustrated the Aussies throughout the opening session as Steve Smith’s bowlers were unable to make a breakthrough.

Younis Khan and Azhar Ali defended stoutly for the most part. The home side’s quicks found Khan’s outside edge several times, but he played with soft hands and the ball dropped short of the waiting slips each time.

It wasn’t just the pair’s work with the bat that was proving to be annoying, though. Khan was certainly taking his time in between balls when facing up, often forcing the hosts’ bowlers to wait at the top of their mark.

Former Australian captain Ian Chappell said it was disrespectful from the 39-year-old veteran, going against the etiquette of the game.

“Gee he wastes some time at the crease, Younis. The umpires have really got to tell him, ‘Mate, the bowler’s ready, you’ve got to be ready to face up’,” Chappell said. “It’s against the game’s etiquette.

“If I was the fielding captain I’d be telling him to hurry up because you’re the one who’s going to get fined.

“I might get him tossed out of the game for a game or two for holding up the over rate.”

His patient approach was clearly working for him though as he hit seven boundaries en route to scoring 65, although it did almost prove his downfall later in the afternoon.

Steve Smith brought part-time finger spinner Nic Maddinson into the attack, and the Aussie rookie was rushing through his first over. Khan wasn’t ready for one of his deliveries, and by the time he looked up the ball was already in the air.

Pakistan’s no. 4 stayed in his batting stance and just watched the ball go past leg stump as a bewildered Smith raised his arms at slip.
 
Last edited:
Atleast now they know that "hum bhi khelnay aye hain", it has been a bit of a walk in the park Australia before today.

Love how they were panicking, however we are still a LONG way away.
 
“I might get him tossed out of the game : Ian Cappell

http://www.news.com.au/sport/cricke...a/news-story/786042bc631d3d0ad64243e5eaef319a

The Pakistani batsmen frustrated the Aussies throughout the opening session as Steve Smith’s bowlers were unable to make a breakthrough.

Younis Khan and Azhar Ali defended stoutly for the most part. The home side’s quicks found Khan’s outside edge several times, but he played with soft hands and the ball dropped short of the waiting slips each time.

It wasn’t just the pair’s work with the bat that was proving to be annoying, though. Khan was certainly taking his time in between balls when facing up, often forcing the hosts’ bowlers to wait at the top of their mark.

Former Australian captain Ian Chappell said it was disrespectful from the 39-year-old veteran, going against the etiquette of the game.

“Gee he wastes some time at the crease, Younis. The umpires have really got to tell him, ‘Mate, the bowler’s ready, you’ve got to be ready to face up’,” Chappell said. “It’s against the game’s etiquette.

“If I was the fielding captain I’d be telling him to hurry up because you’re the one who’s going to get fined.

“I might get him tossed out of the game for a game or two for holding up the over rate.”

His patient approach was clearly working for him though as he hit seven boundaries en route to scoring 65, although it did almost prove his downfall later in the afternoon.

Steve Smith brought part-time finger spinner Nic Maddinson into the attack, and the Aussie rookie was rushing through his first over. Khan wasn’t ready for one of his deliveries, and by the time he looked up the ball was already in the air.

Pakistan’s no. 4 stayed in his batting stance and just watched the ball go past leg stump as a bewildered Smith raised his arms at slip.

This series Could get very ugly and exciting ...Good for the game we need some spice. Love it.
 
That's what happens when you have the 2 utmost annoying and biased commentators in Ian Healy and Mark Taylor together spouting their garbage repeatedly.
.

have you ever listened to taylor? i dont think so.

one of the smartest brains in cricket and never biased.
 
“I might get him tossed out of the game : Ian Cappell

http://www.news.com.au/sport/cricke...a/news-story/786042bc631d3d0ad64243e5eaef319a

The Pakistani batsmen frustrated the Aussies throughout the opening session as Steve Smith’s bowlers were unable to make a breakthrough.

Younis Khan and Azhar Ali defended stoutly for the most part. The home side’s quicks found Khan’s outside edge several times, but he played with soft hands and the ball dropped short of the waiting slips each time.

It wasn’t just the pair’s work with the bat that was proving to be annoying, though. Khan was certainly taking his time in between balls when facing up, often forcing the hosts’ bowlers to wait at the top of their mark.

Former Australian captain Ian Chappell said it was disrespectful from the 39-year-old veteran, going against the etiquette of the game.

“Gee he wastes some time at the crease, Younis. The umpires have really got to tell him, ‘Mate, the bowler’s ready, you’ve got to be ready to face up’,” Chappell said. “It’s against the game’s etiquette.

“If I was the fielding captain I’d be telling him to hurry up because you’re the one who’s going to get fined.

“I might get him tossed out of the game for a game or two for holding up the over rate.”

His patient approach was clearly working for him though as he hit seven boundaries en route to scoring 65, although it did almost prove his downfall later in the afternoon.

Steve Smith brought part-time finger spinner Nic Maddinson into the attack, and the Aussie rookie was rushing through his first over. Khan wasn’t ready for one of his deliveries, and by the time he looked up the ball was already in the air.

Pakistan’s no. 4 stayed in his batting stance and just watched the ball go past leg stump as a bewildered Smith raised his arms at slip.

He has always played like this, why an issue now? Ian Chappel gets on my nerves and can't wait for him to retire from commentary, he thinks he is really important.
 
Anyone else getting tired of the Aussie commentators? especially Michael Clarke

Anyone else getting tired of the Aussie commentators? Apart from the fact that they're probably the most biased commentators in the game, they now seen to have forgotten they're playing another team and not themselves. It annoys me how full of themselves they are and sometimes they don't even properly acknowledge or applaud Pakistan if they do something significant because they're too busy talking about themselves.


I've never enjoyed the Channel 9 commentatary but it seems to have gone even more downhill since they brought on Michael Clarke who has got to be the absolute worst.
A few examples: the other day, he was literally cheering repeatedly for Stanlake to hit a boundary rather than commentate on the game and today again, he kept blaming the pitch for Wade not being able to get the ball away rather than admit Wade's own failings as a batsman or applaud the bowling. To which Bill Lawry went: "Oh come on, Michael."

Lawry is the only exception. The guy is a commentary icon and maybe Shane Warne who has improved as a commentator.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Michael gave Pakistan bowling "full credit" multiple times. Warne and Healy are the unbearable idiots. The rest offer good insight.
 
Back
Top