What's new

"The PCB should not sign players who are not willing to tour Pakistan" : Moin Khan

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
FORMER national captain Moin Khan posed serious questions to the custodians of the HBL Pakistan Super League (PSL) when he said on Thursday if appropriate measures are not taken for the proper organisation of the competition, it may become a case of love, labour lost.

Moin, head coach of twice PSL runners-up Quetta Gladiators, urged the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB to pay serious attention to a number of issues that have had marred the tournament, one away or the other.

“For example, I say categorically that it seems a practice of double standards is being followed in treatment of players. All of us are baffled as to how come Sunil Narine is allowed to get away with unfair means and those who are responsible for assessing the actions have not dared to declare his action illegible,” asked Moin while talking to Dawn a few hours before the start of Quetta’s final league-round fixture against leaders Islamabad United at the Sharjah Cricket Stadium.

“Being a former [Pakistan] captain as well as a layman, I’m entitled to question the authorities that when [Mohammad] Hafeez is not allowed to bowl [by the ICC] and the world cricketing body had also earlier banned Saeed Ajmal, then how come Narine is given the freedom to bowl and use tactics which are against the spirit of cricket. And if these are not dual standards, what really are?” he argued.

“Collectively we have to work on this sensitive issue because the prestige of the PSL has to be guarded and strengthened to a level of respectability. The true value of our league will be achieved when we make it a world-standard competition,” he said.

“Furthermore, I must insist that the PCB should not sign players who are not willing to tour Pakistan for any reason whatsoever. I think being Pakistanis, all of us take lot of pride in the PSL and none of us, I can vouch, has any personal motive,” said Moin.

“The cricket enthusiasts certainly deserve to see the world’s top players playing and performing in our own country. And if players are not comfortable at playing in Pakistan, they shouldn’t be included in the player-draft in the first place.

“Preference should be given to those who are willing to play in Pakistan.”

The former wicket-keeper/batsman also came down hard at the substandard umpiring standards in the ongoing tournament, while requesting the authorities to take measures to improve the general standard.

“I feel quite upset when we note the umpiring isn’t up to the standard the PSL should have. There have been number of blunders that had changed the results of some matches which is very, very unfortunate and the PCB should rectify the problems the teams have to face,” he concluded.

Meanwhile, Quetta team manager Azam Khan disclosed that apart from Kevin Pietersen no other overseas players have indicated anything as regards to travelling to Pakistan.

“As far as we know at this stage, the overseas players in our squad, apart from KP [Pietersen] of course, have spoken to the team management on this issue. Our team owner Nadeem Omar, Moin and [Quetta captain] Sarfraz [Ahmed] will be contacting them one by one after the Islamabad United game to know where they stand,” Azam said.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1395513
PlayerOversMdnsRunsWktsE/RWdNB
 
Dont the individual franchises sign players? What has PCB got to do with this?

Maybe he should have checked whether players he is signing for QG are willing to come to Pakistan...

But he was too busy giving contracts to his son
 
PCB is responsible for selecting the pool of players that are available for draft, the teams simply pick the players off of the pool as far as I understand. So I guess he is stating that PCB should do due diligence before bringing people into the pool of selection
 
Moin is totally correct here. It completely devalues the latter stages of the PSL when these foreign players chicken out. Moreover it disrupts the balance of the team in the crucial matches as Quetta found out last year when their chickens flew home before the final.

Either hold the entire tournament in UAE or don't sign these players.
 
Dont the individual franchises sign players? What has PCB got to do with this?

Maybe he should have checked whether players he is signing for QG are willing to come to Pakistan...

But he was too busy giving contracts to his son

PCB gives the franchises a pool of players to pick from.The fault lies with both,not only the PCB.
 
Dont the individual franchises sign players? What has PCB got to do with this?

Maybe he should have checked whether players he is signing for QG are willing to come to Pakistan...

But he was too busy giving contracts to his son

The buck lies with the owner who is paying for these contracts to thr players. Not sure why people assume the owner of QG to be a doodh peeta bacha who is getting screwed by Moin. It's very Pakistani-esque to blame Moin when he isn't even the boss. Both Nadeem Omar and Fawad Rana are to be blamed for handing over the selection of players to Moin and Aqib...and not the other way around.
 
Right and wrong. Right about Narine. Wrong about not picking players who aren't willing to go to Pakistan. Right about Hafeez. Rules should be the same for everyone. Right about high standards and making PSL world class. Wrong when u yourself resort to nepotism.
 
Isn't Moin Khan at Quetta, the team who will be losing most of their overseas players now as they don't want to go to Pakistan?

Seriously bad planning, but I do agree with what Moin is saying.

I would much rather see less famous players playing in the PSL who actually had the best interests of Pakistan cricket at heart and not just worried about filling their pockets.
 
Isn't Moin Khan at Quetta, the team who will be losing most of their overseas players now as they don't want to go to Pakistan?

Seriously bad planning, but I do agree with what Moin is saying.

I would much rather see less famous players playing in the PSL who actually had the best interests of Pakistan cricket at heart and not just worried about filling their pockets.

I believe his team is knocked out so it doesn't matter anyways
 
I would also rather see less famous players that are willing to play the duration of the tournament. There's enough local talent in each team, and some of the international stars are willing to tour pakistan and that is enough to have a good tournament.
 
I agree about Narine, whose action is terrible (a different case to Ajmal). I can see he is literally chucking on
a 2D screen yet the umps can't?

As for international players, I think the next PSL has to have a clause. Unless these players are willing to play the Pakistan leg, they can not be picked. This is likely the second richest league for these players, look at Morgan coming over for a couple games then excusing himself to "see his family".
KP coming over for retirement pay and then leaving. It is unacceptable and in all honesty, the league is now bigger than the players, plus some of the best t20 cricketers are Pakistani or Windian, so who needs those that wont tour?

Hopefully the PCB remedies this.
 
Can't force Foreign players at gunpoint to tour Pakistan, you can provide proof of security, you can provide incentives, bonuses, you can provide Leisure, Recreation but can't force them at gunpoint to come over.
 
Can't force Foreign players at gunpoint to tour Pakistan, you can provide proof of security, you can provide incentives, bonuses, you can provide Leisure, Recreation but can't force them at gunpoint to come over.

Moin didnt say they should be forced. He simply states those that state an unwillingness to tour should not be picked.
 
Isn't Moin Khan at Quetta, the team who will be losing most of their overseas players now as they don't want to go to Pakistan?

Seriously bad planning, but I do agree with what Moin is saying.

I would much rather see less famous players playing in the PSL who actually had the best interests of Pakistan cricket at heart and not just worried about filling their pockets.

No this is wrong and it’s his own fault.

Islamabad’s manager tweeted after the draft that they preferred players who were willing to come to Pakistan.

These clowns retained guys like Riley rossouw so it’s on them.
 
Which azam.khan do you think he is being referred too!!!

One Azam Khan is that semi-bald guy who is always there in Quetta's dugout wearing Suit; he is manager.
Other is Panda sized guy who is most of the times seen having Sarfraz’s son in his lap; he is MK's son
 
Who asked Moin Khan to retain KP & select Watson? You got to be delusional to presume that KP, who had already refused to play in Pakistan in the last edition for them, will agree to play this time.
 
Some news channel was reporting that most of the foreign players of Quetta have refused to come to Pakistan. However, Sri Lankan Player Thisara Parera who is a part of Multan Sultans have been released by Multan team and he will be joining Quetta.
 
Quetta do not deserve to win the PSL because of the nepotism that goes into its selections, Azam khan, Moins son, shafique and Anwar Ali, two mediocre players who are selected because of their friendship with Sarfraz.

These brainless fools come out with this statement and yet they select players who they know are unlikely to come to Pakistan, that is the funniest part in all of this :))

Very easy to dislike this awful team who have only reached finals of prior PSL because of Nawaz.
 
Isn't Moin Khan at Quetta, the team who will be losing most of their overseas players now as they don't want to go to Pakistan?

Seriously bad planning, but I do agree with what Moin is saying.

I would much rather see less famous players playing in the PSL who actually had the best interests of Pakistan cricket at heart and not just worried about filling their pockets.
I blame Quetta themsleves for being in this position again choosing the same players that refused to travel in PSL2.

Why was KP selected again after how rudely he turned down the requests of the magnet last time, KP for 3 years has been given a free holiday to Dubai to play golf and offer nothing on the field. He refuses to do anything with the team including team dinners after the matches and practice. I cant believe QG when for him again.
 
No this is wrong and it’s his own fault.

Islamabad’s manager tweeted after the draft that they preferred players who were willing to come to Pakistan.

These clowns retained guys like Riley rossouw so it’s on them.

Quetta are saying that some of the players they picked agreed to come to Pakistan before the draft and after the draft, but now have changed their mind when the time came to go to Pakistan.
 
Quetta are saying that some of the players they picked agreed to come to Pakistan before the draft and after the draft, but now have changed their mind when the time came to go to Pakistan.

Just a curious question, don't Franchises/PCB get agreement signed on dotted lines or these things are agreed verbally :kp
 
Regarding playing in Pakistan - I think it's a verbal thing.

That's a poor effort, no written contract. That's like booking a student accommodation for a year with no signed contract, if it is not written anywhere then you can work around it which is what some players have done here.

I hope PCB are more professional about this next year, have the right procedure and pick the right players. Should rely mostly on players outside of Australia and England.
 
Quetta are saying that some of the players they picked agreed to come to Pakistan before the draft and after the draft, but now have changed their mind when the time came to go to Pakistan.

If this is true then these players deserve to be criticised and mocked and called chickens. Anyone defending these players “right to choose” is not correct.
 
First of all its Quetta's fault to select KP and likes who they knew very well 100% werent coming to Pak... so why did Moin and company pick them. They could have spoken to the players alaa PZ and IU and confirmed the willingness of a player coming to Pak come playoffs. PCB should not include players who are unwilling to come to PAK (select a player say if they are only available for the beginning bit of the tournament, but not the likes of KP's and watto's).

Even if the pcb gets a player to write down and sign a document that they will visit to PAK, the player can still pull out citing security concerns. So PCB should get them to sign the dotted line that the player will only pull out due to the security concerns if the body which is responsible for the security assessment says so that it is unsafe. So if the ICC task body says its safe the player should/must play the playoffs in Pak, and if they back out still (without a legitimate emergency) they will forego their monies earned during the tournament, or something to that extent.

Maybe, reduce the international player limit in the playing 11 to 3 from 4... this will get you cream of the cream of whatever cream is available to you. Better go out with players who are willing to come to Pak than guys who will take the wallet and run with it when it comes to action time.
 
Last edited:
Also, I hope QG get eliminated in a humiliating fashion, so for PSL4 it will be a lesson well learnt for them and a bit for PCB (if)...
 
Regarding playing in Pakistan - I think it's a verbal thing.

A better thing to do would be to make them sign a written agreement to confirm that they’ll come to Pakistan if they’re drafted and if they pull out they’d be fined certain amount of their pay.

But the key to this would be that players wouldn’t need to sign this agreement, they would still be able to play in the PSL but they’d be told that franchises will be less interested in them and that they will probably be put into a lower catergory in the draft.
 
A better thing to do would be to make them sign a written agreement to confirm that they’ll come to Pakistan if they’re drafted and if they pull out they’d be fined certain amount of their pay.

But the key to this would be that players wouldn’t need to sign this agreement, they would still be able to play in the PSL but they’d be told that franchises will be less interested in them and that they will probably be put into a lower catergory in the draft.

Real ancient way of doing business in modern world ...!

Regarding playing in Pakistan - I think it's a verbal thing.

It’s difficult to get such a thing in writing.. Basically putting something like that can lead to legal issues with dangerous environment to work in and stuff coming into play.. Probably a lawyer can shed more like into it [MENTION=131867]London_Lahori[/MENTION]
 
Back
Top