What's new

VAR to be used in UEFA Champions League knockout phase

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,989
https://www.theguardian.com/footbal...ity-fleetwood-town-fa-cup-replay-match-report

In years to come, this might be considered the first success of a football revolution. Or, the beginning of the machines taking over and removing the joy from football. Either way, for the first time in the English game, VAR was used to reverse a decision, awarding Kelechi Iheanacho his and Leicester’s second goal.

Iheanacho was the hero on what was at first a tricky night for Leicester and the closing stages could have been pretty nerve-racking had his second not been allowed, an erroneous linesman’s flag corrected by TV replays.

Predictably enough, the managers were split along party lines about the new technology. Claude Puel, previously a VAR sceptic and with a grin playing upon his lips, said it was perfect whereas the Fleetwood manager, Uwe Rösler, was not so certain. “Can they really say it was onside, or are they guessing?” he said. “Sometimes even VAR is not clear. In general – don’t complicate football too much. The game is beautiful. Let it be pure.”

Puel made the standard phalanx of changes with Aleksandar Dragovic and, surprisingly, Riyad Mahrez remaining from Saturday’s draw with Chelsea.

Adrien Silva was one of those to come in: the midfielder, who spent September-December as Schrödinger’s transferee, has made two starts in English football and they have both been against Fleetwood. Presumably, that was not in Leicester’s sales pitch.

The problem with making this many changes is they cease to be a team, rather 11 blokes who work in the same place. Unused to playing with each other, Leicester frequently looked like the only thing they had in common was the colour of their shirts and for much of the first half Fleetwood looked the more threatening.

Conor McAleny buzzed from the left and forced Eldin Jakupovic into a full-length save and the Leicester keeper was forced into action again, tipping an Ashley Hunter shot over the bar.

Hope grew from the visitors but two minutes before the break Leicester took the lead. Iheanacho had hitherto looked like he was playing on roller skates, but just before half-time he brilliantly flicked a hooked Islam Slimani pass with the outside of his left boot and slotted the ball under Chris Neal. This was a faint, rare flicker of that old, now ludicrous sounding debate over who was the better player: Iheanacho or Marcus Rashford.

Iheanacho had the ball in the net again a few minutes after the break, but Demarai Gray had just failed to keep the ball in play from the cross from which our first moment of VAR drama (VARma?) came. The referee, Jonathan Moss, pressed a finger to his ear while the chaps in front of the TVs at Premier League base double-checked it was the right decision. It was and for a while VAR just looked like a disruptive pest.

But then came technology’s moment of redemption. Mahrez slipped a delicious through ball to Iheanacho, who dinked home. Celebrations paused as the linesman raised his flag for offside, but Moss again stood, earpiece forced into his skull like a receptionist in a noisy office, as word came down that the decision was incorrect. The rectangle sign was made, Moss pointed to the centre-circle and history was made.

That wrapped up the tie. “We gave them a right good go for their money,” said Rösler, and they did.

The former Fleetwood hero Jamie Vardy emerged from the bench to the delight of everyone present and the last 10 minutes were spent trying to get him a goal. That did not come, but Leicester go through to face Peterborough in the fourth round.

Cardiff set up an FA Cup fourth-round meeting with Manchester City following a 4-1 win at Mansfield Town, with Pep Guardiola an unexpected visitor to Field Mill. Bruno Ecuele Manga gave Neil Warnock’s side the lead but Danny Rose struck for the League Two hosts before half-time. In the second half, Junior Hoilett scored twice and Anthony Pilkington added another to ensure the Championship side avoided an upset.

Reading beat Stevenage 3-0 thanks to a hat-trick from Jon Dadi Bodvarsson in front of a crowd of fewer than 5,000 at the Madejski Stadium. The hosts were forced to change their strip at half-time to avoid a clash, playing the second half in their orange away shirts. Reading will face Sheffield Wednesday in the fourth round after they saw off Carlisle at Hillsborough. Goals from Marco Matias and Atdhe Nuhiu were enough to earn the new manager Jos Luhukay his first win in a game played in heavy rain and snow.
 
People have some problems with technology in sport but I personally feel that overall, it will be beneficial more times than controversial.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">BREAKING: FIFA executive Philippe Le Floc'h says video replays will be used at this summer's World Cup. <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/SSN?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#SSN</a> <a href="https://t.co/gVxGsL7BDD">pic.twitter.com/gVxGsL7BDD</a></p>— Sky Sports News (@SkySportsNews) <a href="https://twitter.com/SkySportsNews/status/955480570355691520?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 22, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">The ABSOLUTE STATE of VAR <br><br>Look at those lines &#55357;&#56834; <a href="https://t.co/QHPUIEN5Rx">pic.twitter.com/QHPUIEN5Rx</a></p>— Dream Team (@dreamteamfc) <a href="https://twitter.com/dreamteamfc/status/964927849630232579?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 17, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

What is this nonsense?
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">The ABSOLUTE STATE of VAR <br><br>Look at those lines �� <a href="https://t.co/QHPUIEN5Rx">pic.twitter.com/QHPUIEN5Rx</a></p>— Dream Team (@dreamteamfc) <a href="https://twitter.com/dreamteamfc/status/964927849630232579?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 17, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

What is this nonsense?

I thought this was a joke but this is how the actual lines showed up on TV and Mata's goal was ruled out for off-side :danish
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">The ABSOLUTE STATE of VAR <br><br>Look at those lines �� <a href="https://t.co/QHPUIEN5Rx">pic.twitter.com/QHPUIEN5Rx</a></p>— Dream Team (@dreamteamfc) <a href="https://twitter.com/dreamteamfc/status/964927849630232579?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 17, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

What is this nonsense?

oh dear...wth is that
 
Spurs game yesterday was...eventful. VAR not proving to be too popular so far.
 
Watched the game, VAR was absolutely horrifying. Stole 2 goals from spurs.
 
I thought this was a joke but this is how the actual lines showed up on TV and Mata's goal was ruled out for off-side :danish

This is just how it appeared to the viewers. The decision was made with straight lines and the correct decision was made.

VAR does take time which is not something fans are used to but overall it's very good. There are around 5-6 people watching different angles throughout the game, they then select the best angle and make the decision according to the rules. I'm all for it.
 
It is disrupting to the flow of a match but I disagree with those demanding VAR be scrapped.

I think a referral system would be best like in cricket and tennis. The team captain should get two referrals each game for penalty decisions, sending offs and disallowed goals.
 
VAR: Video assistant referees set to be used in Premier League next season

Video assistant referees are set to be used in the Premier League next season, after clubs agreed in principle to the move.

The Premier League will now make a formal request to the International Football Association Board and Fifa.

VAR was used at the 2018 World Cup, is in operation in Italy and Germany's top divisions, and has been utilised in some FA Cup and Carabao Cup games.

The Premier League has been carrying out "non-live" trials this season.

VAR will also be used in the Champions League from next season.

There have been growing calls for it to be introduced into the English top flight for several years.

But in April Premier League clubs voted against it being used for the 2018-19 season.

On Saturday, Southampton forward Charlie Austin called for a change after he was denied a goal for offside against Watford, a decision he called a "joke".

Saints manager Mark Hughes added: "All the major sports have video reviews and for some reason the Premier League, which is watched all around the world, is still in the dark ages."

VAR has been trialled regularly in a "non-live environment" in the Premier League this season, although match officials have not been contacted by those conducting the trials.

Clubs were given an update at a meeting on Thursday.

A statement from the Premier League said its testing programme would continue for the rest of the season "with a continued emphasis on those Saturday afternoons which have several matches being played concurrently".

How VAR decisions are communicated to fans in the stadium will also be addressed.

Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey, speaking on BBC Radio 5 live's Afternoon Edition: "I think it is a good thing. I know a lot of people are against it but we've got to embrace it now and move forward.

"We've seen this season a number of incidences that have been called wrong, especially this weekend when there were a number of goals ruled out when they shouldn't have been.

"I think as long as we get the training and education right, and we get the right personnel, that's the most important thing for me.

"The referees will still want to go out and get the key match decisions right, it's very important that referees are not hiding behind the VAR - they've still going to be making these big calls correctly."

What is VAR?

The theory behind VAR is simple: more accurate decisions, more often, and at the most important points in matches.

The on-pitch referee makes all the same calls, at the same speed and unaided, as he would without the system in place.

However, the VAR - a current or former top-level referee - is in place to check decisions on four sorts of incidents:

  • Goals, including 'missed' attacking offences in the build-up
  • Penalties awarded and not awarded, including 'missed' attacking offences in the build-up
  • Direct red cards
  • Cases of mistaken identity where the wrong player is shown a red or yellow card
The referee can accept the information relayed through his earpiece by the VAR team, an option usually reserved for objective calls of fact such as if a player is offside.

Or, for more subjective decisions such as red cards and penalty-box fouls, he can review the footage on a pitch-side television monitor before deciding whether to change his initial call.

The VAR team will also proactively contact the referee if they spot "a clear and obvious error" around these four types of incident or a "serious missed incident" - usually off-the-ball violence.

The referee can then decide whether or not to have a review - this is where the replay is officially consulted and is indicated by the referee showing the TV signal.
 
040 - England to host UEFA Women’s EURO 2021

The UEFA Executive Committee today met in Dublin, Republic of Ireland, and decided to use Video Assistant Referees (VAR) in the UEFA Champions League as from the Round of 16 in February 2019 following successful technological testing and the training of referees over the last few months.

In addition, the committee decided to also use VAR at the UEFA Europa League Final 2019, in the UEFA Nations Leagues Finals 2019 and in the final tournament of the UEFA European Under-21 Championship 2019.

As already decided during the September meeting of the UEFA Executive Committee, VAR will then also be used in the 2019/20 UEFA Champions League, as of the play-off stage of the competition, and at the 2019 UEFA Super Cup. UEFA still plans to subsequently extend the use of VAR at the final tournament of UEFA EURO 2020, in the 2020/21 UEFA Europa League (group-stage onwards), and in the 2021 UEFA Nations League Finals.

UEFA President Aleksander Čeferin, said:

"We are ready to use VAR earlier than initially planned and we are convinced that it will be beneficial for our competitions as it will provide valuable help to match officials and will allow to reduce incorrect decisions."

The UEFA Executive Committee appointed the hosts for various competitions as follows:

• 2018/19 UEFA Nations League Finals – Portugal – 5 to 9 June 2019

• UEFA Women’s EURO 2021 – England – July 2021

• 2019/21 UEFA Under-21 Championship final tournament – Hungary/Slovenia – June 2021

• 2018/19 UEFA Futsal Champions League finals – Kairat Almaty, Kazakhstan - 25 to 28 April 2019

The UEFA Executive Committee approved the proposal of the European Leagues to appoint Mathieu Moreuil (Premier League) as one of the four representatives of the leagues on the UEFA Professional Football Strategy Council in order to replace Javier Tebas for the remainder of his term until 2019.

The next meeting of the UEFA Executive Committee is scheduled for Wednesday 6 February 2019 in Rome, Italy, on the eve of the 43rd UEFA Ordinary Congress.

Note to media:

UEFA will organise a dedicated media briefing on VAR with Roberto Rosetti in the new year.

https://www.uefa.com/insideuefa/about-uefa/news/newsid=2586230.html
 
Players making a TV-style gesture with their hands should be given a yellow card according to Uefa.

The guidance has been given to referees ahead of VAR being introduced into the Champions League next week.

The gesture is already a bookable offence but the policy was not enforced in the World Cup last summer or other competitions where VAR is in operation.

"If players make the VAR signal and if they surround the referee, there must be disciplinary action," Uefa said.

At a briefing ahead of Uefa's congress in Rome, Uefa's chief refereeing officer Roberto Rosetti used a clip of Harry Maguire during England's World Cup match against Colombia to demonstrate when players should be booked.

The Leicester City defender made the sign believing Jordan Henderson had been headbutted.

"Where Maguire is standing making the square signal - that is a yellow card," Rosetti said. "We want action in these situations, we don't want players interfering with referee on reviews."

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/47149484
 
Good decision. Without VAR Liverpool will be denied clear goals with ridiculous offside rulings all the time. The linesman always puts up his flag when Salah, Mana and Bobby are clear on goal:hasan
 
The Premier League is confident the use of video assistant referees (VAR) next season will bring clarity on key decisions and not affect the entertainment value of top-flight football in England.

After seeing the technology used extensively over the summer - including during the Nations League finals, the Women's World Cup and the African Cup of Nations - VAR will make its Premier League debut this season.

VAR was introduced in last season's Champions League knockout stages
VAR was introduced in last season's Champions League knockout stages
Interim Premier League chief executive Richard Masters is hopeful that the lengthy delays which have often been a feature of VAR will be kept to a minimum when it is rolled out this term.

He told Sky Sports News: "We're ready to go [with VAR] for next season and I think fans want to see those clear and obvious errors cleared up, but they also want to see the game moved on quickly.

There are no plans for widespread pitchside referee reviews next season
There are no plans for widespread pitchside referee reviews next season

"And so in the Premier League, you're probably going to see the referees not use the referee review area - which is that camera to the side of the pitch - as often as you might see in other competitions.

"You have to operate within the guidelines that the IFAB (International Football Association Board) gives you to operate VAR.

VAR was used in some matches during last season's FA Cup
"But, hopefully - a) it will work and it will clear up those decisions and b) it won't interrupt the fast-flowing pace of the Premier League. Those are basically our two objectives."

A thrilling Premier League season last term was marred by a number of incidents of discrimination at grounds across the country.

0:42
Premier League launches 'No Room for Racism'
No Room for Racism campaign launched by Premier League to help combat discriminatory behaviour across football.

The No Room for Racism campaign was launched by the Premier League to help combat discriminatory behaviour across football
Part of the Premier League's response was the launch of the No Room for Racism campaign, and Masters says further measures to tackle discrimination will be implemented before the season kicks off with Norwich's visit to Liverpool, live on Sky Sports on August 9.

"Any single incident is an incident too many and when these things happen you have to take a step back and wonder if you are doing enough," Masters said.

"We're going to be doing more and we're going to be announcing more over the course of the summer to try and ensure these things don't happen again.

"Of course you can never make sure that they won't, but I think it's about a raft of issues - it's about making our stadiums safer, making it easier for people to report [discrimination] and ensuring we have proper diversity throughout the whole game."

4:11
Manchester City 4-1 West Ham
Highlights from the Premier League Asia Trophy match between Manchester City and West Ham.

Highlights from the Premier League Asia Trophy match between Manchester City and West Ham.
Masters was speaking in China where he has been attending this week's Premier League Asia Trophy matches in Nanjing and Shanghai.

Also See:
How does VAR work?
2019/20 Premier League rules
VAR replays to be shown in PL stadiums
No VAR penalty for PL goalkeepers
He feels the event, which has featured Manchester City, West Ham, Newcastle and Wolves, has been a success and is likely to return to the country in the near future.

He said: "Although we've only been to China twice in the nine [Asia Trophies] we've done, I think we may be coming here more regularly."

https://www.skysports.com/football/...emier-league-hopes-var-will-improve-standards
 
VAR has to be in the PL. Time and time again teams are refused stone-wall penalties because the player in question who is fouled is someone who regularly is kicked to shreds and therefore the referee somehow thinks it's acceptable to be more harsh on the attacker. Hazard had many blatant penalties not given, for example.
 
Back
Top