What's new

[VIDEO] Sikh police officer who saved Muslim man from mob is hero on social media

When you think about it though, it's only Islam at the fulcrum - be it in India or any other country. It's rarely Hindus vs Jews, or Sikhs vs Christians or anything like that right?



I will only talk about Indian Muslims here who I believe are very strict about their religion..

Problem with Muslims is that they are not very flexible.
Problem with Hindus is they expect Muslims to be flexible.. Hindus go to darghas and offer prayers however they expect Muslims to be flexible like them.

Now we are seeing the rise of Hindus who are bringing in Hindi first agenda to garner votes/support.. However these are same people who divide Hindus on basis of caste and social/economic status..

I do get your point about problems generally with Islam it’s just that Muslims are too strict about their religion and they seem to have more lunatics than other religions who give them a bad name.

Ultimately one should mind their own business and live their life the way they seem fit without causing any harm to anyone else however that doesn’t happen in real world for some reason.
 
I will only talk about Indian Muslims here who I believe are very strict about their religion..

Problem with Muslims is that they are not very flexible.
Problem with Hindus is they expect Muslims to be flexible.. Hindus go to darghas and offer prayers however they expect Muslims to be flexible like them.

Now we are seeing the rise of Hindus who are bringing in Hindi first agenda to garner votes/support.. However these are same people who divide Hindus on basis of caste and social/economic status..
.

Lol. Hindus dont go to dargahs to show flexibility. They go to any place where they see promise of prayers being answered by bribing with offerings.

lolmax at hindi first agenda. Any national party which tries that will lose votes. Another lol at caste division. Hindu first parties want caste barriers to go so that they get more numbers.

Looks like you got knowledge from whatsapp university.
 
He could only protect because the "mob" was peaceful and respected the police, otherwise no way in hell could he have overpowered an unruly mob.

The mob wasn't peaceful, one protestor had already delivered a slap to the guy they were protesting, it was that point the policeman stepped in otherwise it would surely have escalated as the mob was visibly growing increasingly agitated. They did respect the policeman and that is the good we can take from this ugly incident, at least they knew where to draw the line.
 
The mob wasn't peaceful, one protestor had already delivered a slap to the guy they were protesting, it was that point the policeman stepped in otherwise it would surely have escalated as the mob was visibly growing increasingly agitated. They did respect the policeman and that is the good we can take from this ugly incident, at least they knew where to draw the line.

Just a slap. That is very peaceful compared to what lynch mobs are famous for. I think that was a parental way of correcting the couple who had crossed a line, there was nothing vengeful about it.

Again, if the mob was really baying for blood, the policemen would not have been able to do jack. But media will never tell you the truth and instead of praising the gentle mob they are praising the policeman who was lucky to face peaceful protestors.
 
Just a slap. That is very peaceful compared to what lynch mobs are famous for. I think that was a parental way of correcting the couple who had crossed a line, there was nothing vengeful about it.

Again, if the mob was really baying for blood, the policemen would not have been able to do jack. But media will never tell you the truth and instead of praising the gentle mob they are praising the policeman who was lucky to face peaceful protestors.

It was just a slap because Indian mobs take some time to build up courage for physical violence. You could see the temperature rising with lots of hooting and hollering, but it took a critical mass before that guy delivered the slap, that too in a half-hearted manner like someone who thought it was a real daring thing to do but was given confidence in having large numbers behind him.

Not that this is a bad thing, Indians should be proud that violence doesn't come naturally to them, just look at the well drilled fights between Russian and English football fans to see what damage can be done by those who take these things as a matter of pride.
 
It was just a slap because Indian mobs take some time to build up courage for physical violence. You could see the temperature rising with lots of hooting and hollering, but it took a critical mass before that guy delivered the slap, that too in a half-hearted manner like someone who thought it was a real daring thing to do but was given confidence in having large numbers behind him.

Not that this is a bad thing, Indians should be proud that violence doesn't come naturally to them, just look at the well drilled fights between Russian and English football fans to see what damage can be done by those who take these things as a matter of pride.

Mob violence is not a new thing in india. These days hardly goes a day when a mob have not beaten a guy be it for a suspicion of a chil kidnapper which has happened thrice now in karnatka,or beating up lovers,killed a guy in kolkata metro or somewhere due to being touchy with her girlfriend ...or just recently thrashed a couple in punjab or beating a thief in public...mind you it has nothing to do with religion but still so much shameful that public itslef take matters in to hands....uncivilized society....really
 
Last edited:
It was just a slap because Indian mobs take some time to build up courage for physical violence. You could see the temperature rising with lots of hooting and hollering, but it took a critical mass before that guy delivered the slap, that too in a half-hearted manner like someone who thought it was a real daring thing to do but was given confidence in having large numbers behind him.

Not that this is a bad thing, Indians should be proud that violence doesn't come naturally to them, just look at the well drilled fights between Russian and English football fans to see what damage can be done by those who take these things as a matter of pride.

Agreed. If all mobs were like this so called mob, the world would be such a better place. They were schooling the couple, that do love jihad if you want, but dont make the sanctum sanctorum a playfield of your wanton lust. A slap meant to correct those who had crossed the line of decency. Seeing a minority cop come in picture, they stepped back, as any peaceful majority would do, to let the minority discharge his duties. This should be a lesson for mobs everywhere, that they should give corporal chastisement only to correct the corrupt, but also let minorities live without fear from the majority. But the sell out media will never show you the truth.
 
Mob violence is not a new thing in india. These days hardly goes a day when a mob have not beaten a guy be it for a suspicion of a chil kidnapper which has happened thrice now in karnatka,or beating up lovers,killed a guy in kolkata metro or somewhere due to being touchy with her girlfriend ...or just recently thrashed a couple in punjab or beating a thief in public...mind you it has nothing to do with religion but still so much shameful that public itslef take matters in to hands....uncivilized society....really

You are being dishonest by labelling this parental behaviour from the elders as mob violence. Either you don't know what violence is or want to malign this peaceful gathering of moral guardians by lumping them with lumpen elements.
 
Agreed. If all mobs were like this so called mob, the world would be such a better place. They were schooling the couple, that do love jihad if you want, but dont make the sanctum sanctorum a playfield of your wanton lust. A slap meant to correct those who had crossed the line of decency. Seeing a minority cop come in picture, they stepped back, as any peaceful majority would do, to let the minority discharge his duties. This should be a lesson for mobs everywhere, that they should give corporal chastisement only to correct the corrupt, but also let minorities live without fear from the majority. But the sell out media will never show you the truth.

Yes but I don't understand what was the line of decency that the couple had crossed? I asked this question earlier, how do these people know this couple was indulging in love jihad? Was this guy waking round wearing a proud to be Muslim t-shirt or something? Or the locals can tell by skin tone and facial features perhaps?
 
Yes but I don't understand what was the line of decency that the couple had crossed? I asked this question earlier, how do these people know this couple was indulging in love jihad? Was this guy waking round wearing a proud to be Muslim t-shirt or something? Or the locals can tell by skin tone and facial features perhaps?

That is a stupid question to ask. it is not difficult to identity a muslim, as they wear their religion on their sleeves, and they were locals who may know him.They identified the religion correctly. how they did was immaterial and tangential to the topic. Do love jihad all you want, but not inside a temple. get an OYO room. there are many couple friendly accommodations available. Respect for the people who handled a potentially sensitive issue with such maturity and tact and hopefully the couple would find some other place for their coochie coo.
 
Agreed. If all mobs were like this so called mob, the world would be such a better place. They were schooling the couple, that do love jihad if you want, but dont make the sanctum sanctorum a playfield of your wanton lust. A slap meant to correct those who had crossed the line of decency. Seeing a minority cop come in picture, they stepped back, as any peaceful majority would do, to let the minority discharge his duties. This should be a lesson for mobs everywhere, that they should give corporal chastisement only to correct the corrupt, but also let minorities live without fear from the majority. But the sell out media will never show you the truth.

These sorts of mobs are so much coward people on the earth when they have to stand up individually they would pee in their pants...they cannot take stand for right thing...hardly have any morals ....sort of loosers....who have themselves got beating whole their life and now want to take out their frustation.....uncivilized people....
Hardly goes a day when we dnt get to hear about a mob beating a guy or couple ,sucpicion over a theft or child kidnapping or anything...why cannot they just call the police ,may be they dnt trust police that they will get free by giving some bribe but is this the way of justice ?
Amyone can be targeted this way....
 
You are being dishonest by labelling this parental behaviour from the elders as mob violence. Either you don't know what violence is or want to malign this peaceful gathering of moral guardians by lumping them with lumpen elements.

I dnt agree this was peaceful violence...they were saying to girl that they would cut the girl in to pieces and they were shouting to lock the gates....
Sikhs are respected everywhere in the world whoever knows their history,may be they were afriad in front of sikh police offficer or being respectful of a policemen being a sikh ...not sure...but saying that this was peaceful protest is nothing short of a troll.....
 
I don't think Muslim girls are allowed to date anyone in masjid in Pakistan, at least not openly. Probably they would have to sneak around a bit, although maybe that is changing these days. Pakistan is an Islamic country, maybe they could emigrate to India to live a hassle free dating life like the couple in the OP video.

Same in India , its only the muslim men who are allowed to have relationships .

What does islam say about it ? from the thread it seems all ppers here just go by the book like not eating prasad, does it say about relationships before marriage for men ?
 
Yes but I don't understand what was the line of decency that the couple had crossed? I asked this question earlier, how do these people know this couple was indulging in love jihad? Was this guy waking round wearing a proud to be Muslim t-shirt or something? Or the locals can tell by skin tone and facial features perhaps?

Good question. Actully what i have heard is nearby temple area is famous for couples..many couples visit there..may be one of those days whem some people might have seen them there together and asked them about their id card and then later on got to know he was muslim and the it turned in to more of a ugly thing...i am not sure how they got to know...may be someone can put light into this...
 
These sorts of mobs are so much coward people on the earth when they have to stand up individually they would pee in their pants...they cannot take stand for right thing...hardly have any morals ....sort of loosers....who have themselves got beating whole their life and now want to take out their frustation.....uncivilized people....
Hardly goes a day when we dnt get to hear about a mob beating a guy or couple ,sucpicion over a theft or child kidnapping or anything...why cannot they just call the police ,may be they dnt trust police that they will get free by giving some bribe but is this the way of justice ?
Amyone can be targeted this way....

Agreed, mob justice can be dangerous. But not when the mob is like these gentlemen. If there were more of such wellwishing guardians, there would be less need of police to police us. That is why we must celebrate this gathering of superheroes, who have brought the buzurgon ka saaya on the streets which have been orphaned of moral authority by the lecherous and the lascivious.
 
Same in India , its only the muslim men who are allowed to have relationships .

What does islam say about it ? from the thread it seems all ppers here just go by the book like not eating prasad, does it say about relationships before marriage for men ?

They cleared tgeir stance that muslim people altogether cannot have relationship with non muslim untill non muslim convert in to islam..there are higher chances of non muslim women convert in to muslim after marriage so that is a common thing for them...
 
I dnt agree this was peaceful violence...they were saying to girl that they would cut the girl in to pieces and they were shouting to lock the gates....
Sikhs are respected everywhere in the world whoever knows their history,may be they were afriad in front of sikh police offficer or being respectful of a policemen being a sikh ...not sure...but saying that this was peaceful protest is nothing short of a troll.....

A mob which is afraid of a single sikh?? If that was the case there would be no 1984. Please show some respect to the elders who have shown remarkable restraint in the face of extreme provocation and averted a calamity.
 
Same in India , its only the muslim men who are allowed to have relationships .

What does islam say about it ? from the thread it seems all ppers here just go by the book like not eating prasad, does it say about relationships before marriage for men ?

Not an expert on Islam, but I was brought up to believe relations outside of marriage were not allowed. No idea whether this was a desi mindset or an Islamic one. Certainly not a British one as most of British born Pakistanis will ignore it and rightfully follow the British norms when it comes to dating in order to integrate.
 
Not an expert on Islam, but I was brought up to believe relations outside of marriage were not allowed. No idea whether this was a desi mindset or an Islamic one. Certainly not a British one as most of British born Pakistanis will ignore it and rightfully follow the British norms when it comes to dating in order to integrate.

What did you follow Cpt? The native brit way of sowing the wild oats, or the desi moral way of preserving your purity?
 
A mob which is afraid of a single sikh?? If that was the case there would be no 1984. Please show some respect to the elders who have shown remarkable restraint in the face of extreme provocation and averted a calamity.

1984 was done by goons of congress. Many of them were bought from the jails ,many of them were not even locals......it was a fully planned genocide carried on...
Many hindus or even muslims saved life of sikhs in delhi be letting them stay in their homes....i cannot and nevwr want to talk about that blackest spot on the name of our country....leave it...In general people do respect and love sikhs and i dnt have any sympathy over a mob who likes to take matter into their hands....if they are against love jihad whatever .....they should have warn them ,may be tell ther parents about this and all...although couple were not doing anything against our constitution.....
 
What did you follow Cpt? The native brit way of sowing the wild oats, or the desi moral way of preserving your purity?

It would be wrong to label all native Brits as sowing wild oats, many of the genteels of previous generations didn't sow their wild oats willy nilly. They would ask the father's permission to court the females that aroused their ardour and treat them with respect that a good family deserved.
 
1984 was done by goons of congress. Many of them were bought from the jails ,many of them were not even locals......it was a fully planned genocide carried on...
Many hindus or even muslims saved life of sikhs in delhi be letting them stay in their homes....i cannot and nevwr want to talk about that blackest spot on the name of our country....leave it...In general people do respect and love sikhs and i dnt have any sympathy over a mob who likes to take matter into their hands....if they are against love jihad whatever .....they should have warn them ,may be tell ther parents about this and all...although couple were not doing anything against our constitution.....

I don't understand this special respect for Sikhs that has been happening in last few years, instead of doing that rather punish the 1984 culprits,giving the families affected some closure and get on with it,its not like they are going to be diff compared to other Indians there are going to be good and bad ones.
 
I don't understand this special respect for Sikhs that has been happening in last few years, instead of doing that rather punish the 1984 culprits,giving the families affected some closure and get on with it,its not like they are going to be diff compared to other Indians there are going to be good and bad ones.

Dude its india ,how many mass killed people have got justice here ?? Did kashmiri pandits who got masscared got justice ? Did godhra train killed people got jistice ?did gujrat killed peoppe got justice ? Did tamil naidu related to ltte or something got justice ?? And there are some other riots in west bengal or assam or anywhere else to every community....
I seriously want and hope for justice to every damn people....but sadly when political people itself are involved it gets very difficult in india to get justice....
 
I don't understand this special respect for Sikhs that has been happening in last few years, instead of doing that rather punish the 1984 culprits,giving the families affected some closure and get on with it,its not like they are going to be diff compared to other Indians there are going to be good and bad ones.

Dude its india ,how many mass killed people have got justice here ?? Did kashmiri pandits who got masscared got justice ? Did godhra train killed people got jistice ?did gujrat killed peoppe got justice ? Did tamil naidu related to ltte or something got justice ?? And there are some other riots in west bengal or assam or anywhere else to every community....
I seriously want and hope for justice to every damn people....but sadly when political people itself are involved it gets very difficult in india to get justice....
Mind you most of the sikhs also these days are living up to on their past glory ......and so you are right they are not going to be different either compared to others,there are going to be good and bad ones
 
Why the hell arn't they beating the crap out of the mob? Where is the rule of law, zero respect for the officer. If you throw a punch and it hits an officer in Oz then your done for.
 
Why the hell arn't they beating the crap out of the mob? Where is the rule of law, zero respect for the officer. If you throw a punch and it hits an officer in Oz then your done for.

In australia and most of the countries ,ratio of police to common people is well distributed whereas in india for 125 crore populated country,police are only making number for names..Mind you india is tge most unpoliced nation on world . Still we are managing somehow good compared to many well policed nations if we take in to larger perspectives.
And secondly police work directly under political people. A 10th fail minister can make a a most qualified ias or ips officer dance on its tunes....
 
They cleared tgeir stance that muslim people altogether cannot have relationship with non muslim untill non muslim convert in to islam..there are higher chances of non muslim women convert in to muslim after marriage so that is a common thing for them...

So there is a testing period allowed for men in Islam , during which if they can confirm the girl is convertible ? if there is no such thing it is a sin , but I have never heard anyone complain here though , may be its not as big a deal as eating prasad .
its amazing how Muslims are so open minded in this one aspect .
 
Not an expert on Islam, but I was brought up to believe relations outside of marriage were not allowed. No idea whether this was a desi mindset or an Islamic one. Certainly not a British one as most of British born Pakistanis will ignore it and rightfully follow the British norms when it comes to dating in order to integrate.


Have problems wishing people for Christmas , valentines day is unIslamic , trimming beard is a problem ..but follow British norms when it comes to dating just to integrate ? OK
 
So there is a testing period allowed for men in Islam , during which if they can confirm the girl is convertible ? if there is no such thing it is a sin , but I have never heard anyone complain here though , may be its not as big a deal as eating prasad .
its amazing how Muslims are so open minded in this one aspect .

Maybe the ones willing to marry outside their faith are open minded about prasad too. Anyways no one has an obligation to accept food from other people. If people are not willing to accept it than simply give it to someone else. It’s amusing how people are making a big deal about prasad in this particular thread. What possibly could be the reason?
 
Have problems wishing people for Christmas , valentines day is unIslamic , trimming beard is a problem ..but follow British norms when it comes to dating just to integrate ? OK

I think you didn't really understand what I said, not all British Pakistanis are practising Muslims, so I would guess those who are integrating by dating are probably fine wishing Merry Christmas and trimming beards as well. In fact even practising Muslims do those things. You have a very prejudiced view of British Pakistani community, perhaps you should bring up these issues in one of the many threads on British Pakistanis, I would be happy to assist you with your research further in one of those if you like. I think on of the mods just bumped an old thread, try that one.

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/showthread.php?88971-The-Pakistani-British-Youth
 
Last edited:
India police officer threatened for saving Muslim man from mob
An Indian police officer hailed as a hero for protecting a Muslim man from being lynched by a mob has begun receiving death threats, police say.

Gagandeep Singh, an officer in the northern state of Uttarakhand, shot to fame after a video of him saving a Muslim man from a Hindu mob went viral on social media last week.
The man was visiting a temple with his Hindu girlfriend.
The mob surrounded the man and tried to attack, accusing him of "love jihad".

The term has been popularised by radical Hindu fringe groups who accuse Muslim men of participating in a conspiracy to turn Hindu women from their religion by seducing them.
When the video was first shared online, many called Mr Singh a "role model" for all Indians, and his story was carried in many mainstream Indian publications.

"I was just doing my duty. Even if I was not in uniform, I would have done the same thing and every Indian should do the same," he was quoted as saying by local media.
However it did not take long for people to criticise Mr Singh's actions, accusing him of defending "indecent behaviour".
Police officials working with him have said that he has received threats to his life, and has been sent on leave.

Some politicians have also publicly justified the actions of the mob.
"It's wrong when these people (Muslim men) bring Hindu girls to our places of worship despite knowing it's a temple and it's pious," Rakesh Nainwal, an MLA of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), told BBC Punjabi's Sunil Kataria.
Another BJP MLA Rajkumar Thukral told the ANI News Agency that this was an attempt by the man to hurt the feelings of the Hindu community.
"We don't go to mosques because we don't have the right to go there," he added.
"Then why did these men go to our temple with an intention to destroy the Hindu culture?"

But for some residents of Ramnagar district, where the incident took place, the turn of events has been disturbing.
"When a boy and a girl go somewhere together by choice, then how can these right-wing groups call it a case of "love jihad" and attack them?" Ajit Sahni, a resident of Ramnagar, told BBC Punjabi.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44289957
 
India police officer threatened for saving Muslim man from mob

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44289957
Days after a video of a police inspector saving a Muslim boy from the wrath of a mob at a temple in Uttarakhand's Ramnagar went viral, the BBC reported on Wednesday, 30 May, that the officer has been receiving death threats.

However, speaking to The Quint, the officer in question – Gagandeep Singh – denied getting any death threats.

"There’s no such thing. In fact, I got to know about this (that I have been receiving death threats) from other people. I have been enjoying my holiday. There is no question of me receiving death threats." - Gagadeep Singh to
The Quint
In its report, BBC cites police officials working with him as saying that he has received such threats and has been sent on leave.

Gagandeep, who is currently at home, is joining back the service on 2 June.

The incident in question happened when a Muslim boy met a Hindu girl in a temple in Girija village, where they were caught by a group of violent men. In the viral video, sub-inspector Gagandeep Singh is shown coming to the boy's rescue, fearing that the angry mob may lynch him to death.

https://in.yahoo.com/news/not-receiving-death-threats-cop-172928240.html


There is a bloody dirty smell of politics everywhere to each incident. People forget crores of indians made him hero overnight by sharing his bravery or his dedication to duty ,on f.b or any social media....
 
Back
Top