the Great Khan
Senior Test Player
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2005
- Runs
- 27,032
- Post of the Week
- 1
Shah got his debut on the 2006 India tour because of Cook (averaging 61 on his debut series so far) coming down with illness, Trescothick returning home and Vaughan missing the tour with injury. He had a pretty good debut but it would be extremely hard to justify not dropping him in favour of Cook and Trescothick come the first test of the next summer, especially given he didn't score any runs in the early county season prior to the squad being selected.
He had a pretty average county season and returned to the team at the start of the next summer thanks to injuries to Vaughan and Flintoff. He didn't score anything notable and Vaughan was fit and ready to return to captaining in the next game. Again, hard to justify him keeping his place over the captain or anyone else at the time.
His final chance then came in 2009 where he got 4 tests (1 of which was abandoned due to a dodgy outfield) coming in for the dropped Ian Bell in which he averaged 23.8. Due to Flintoff's fitness Ravi Bopara also got a chance later in the same series and scored a hundred in his only innings. When it came to picking the side for the series after that Bopara was preferred as a batting option over Shah resulting in him getting dropped from the test team for the final time. Like I said, I don't think any of these droppings can be argued to be unjustifiable.
After 6 tests across 3 stints he averaged 26.90. Comparatively after Collingwood's first 6 tests which occurred across 2 stints he averaged 46.50, along with being a more valuable part time bowling option and far superior fielder.
I will have to dig out the analysis. it wasnt as straightforward as you have made it out.