RedwoodOriginal
Senior T20I Player
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2018
- Runs
- 20,351
- Post of the Week
- 4
In white-ball a player like Butler is a game-changer, but in tests I'm not if I would select him at all. His glovework is good but not on the level of a Ben Foakes, who also falls in the specialist wicketkeeper category. I think Jamie Smith right now is the perfect guy for them who checks all the boxes and someone who has the most potential to be a Gilchrist-like player.100% agreed with you.
A safe keeper is the ultimate requirement of test cricket & if they can contribute around 30-40 runs at 6 or 7 it's a great bonus.
Just listed all the good keepers from various countries in my post for both white and red ball cricket. Prior was the better keeper batter for England, but personally I rate Butler as well because he's one of those players who always turns up against us no matter what the format is even though his overall test record isn't that great. That said, we don't have anyone like Butler and that's the real point.
Last edited by a moderator: