What's new

Virat Kohli named captain, Yuvraj Singh returns to squad for ODI and IT20s vs England

RamLakhan

First Class Captain
Joined
Apr 1, 2011
Runs
5,421
Post of the Week
1
New Delhi: The selection committee meeting to pick the Indian team for the one-day series against England will go ahead on Friday despite the BCCI being hit by administrative crisis following the latest Supreme Court order.

The BCCI announced on Wednesday that the selection panel headed by former India wicketkeeper MSK Prasad will gather in Mumbai on Friday to pick the Indian team for England series, comprising three ODIs and as many T20 Internationals, starting 15 January.

The selectors will also pick the India A squad for two warm-up matches against England to be held at CCI, Mumbai.
However, it remains to seen whether team is chosen by the five-member panel, which was the case earlier, or a three-member committee as suggested by the Supreme Court appointed Lodha panel.

As per the Lodha recommendations, senior selection committee was supposed to be a three-member team comprising Test players.
However, the BCCI had announced the new panel in September, with its now sacked president Anurag Thakur and secretary Ajay Shirke defying the court's diktat.

As of now only Prasad, Devang Gandhi and Sarandeep Singh -- all former Test players -- meet the eligibility criteria set by the Lodha panel. The other two selectors Gagan Khoda and Jatin Paranjpe have only played two and four ODIs respectively.

The BCCI finds itself in a crisis following the Supreme Court order on Monday.

Besides sacking Thakur and Shirke, the apex court directed all office bearers of BCCI and state associations to give an undertaking that they will abide by the recommendations of the Lodha panel. The recommendations have rendered most of the office-bearers ineligible to continue in their respective roles.

The court also ordered the senior most vice-president of the BCCI and joint secretary to perform the duties of president and secretary till January 19 when a new set of administrators will take charge of the world's richest cricket board.

However, none of the five vice-presidents and joint secretary meet the eligibility criteria set by the Lodha panel.

Adding to the confusion is BCCI's move to remove the names of all office-bearers from its website including the ones in the important working committee and selection committee.

In the absence of "eligible" office-bearer, the selection meeting is likely to be convened by CEO Rahul Johri.

http://www.firstpost.com/sports/ind...ries-to-be-selected-on-6-january-3188262.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why cant Varun Aaron ever make it back into the side ? The fastest and most exciting bowler from India not getting a chance is highly disappointing
 
Trying him again is a futile exercise I feel!
What are the scores in his last 5 International outings?

Bhai don't be a Parosi. Think objectively. If we had a ready domestic newbie to replace him in his role, we would have. I can assure that we don't.
 
[MENTION=19857]stree[/MENTION]t cricketer [MENTION=134809]sensible-indian-fan[/MENTION] why rahane and yuvraj again ?
 
Last edited:
Yuvraj is finished long back.he is a sitting duck against pace and any good spin
 
Good to see Samson, Chahal, Kuldeep, Hooda, Ishan Kishan, Sheldon Jackson, Vijay Shankar, Nadeem and Rasool getting picked for the warm ups.

Youngsta beauties FTW!:akhtar
 
Bhai don't be a Parosi. Think objectively. If we had a ready domestic newbie to replace him in his role, we would have. I can assure that we don't.

Indian test team did so well by trusting the newbies and seasoned players. We got answers for middle order (Nair) and late order batting. Not sure why it can't be obtained even in LOIs (not necessarily with same players/combination but). Parthiv was selected in tests because he was the only option in that area!

Why we need so-called experience? That too for LOIs when we are looking to carry the team forward (it is just a normal bilateral series).

Anyhow I am not sure if Yuvaraj even gets a chance in playing XI (I would pick Rahane over him if fit! It will be embarrassing for him to warm the bench!)

Not sure why you referred to Parosi!
 
Both raina and yuvraj looked like sitting ducks against johnson in india 4 yrs back.i didnt get the logic of yuvraj selected again and again as he regressed big time.even in t20 world cup he is a passenger and in the match against australia he struggled big time and got injured .even after injury he didnt try to attack
 
Yuvraj and Dhawan are not good selection.
Dhawan is a far better player than rahane who is not a power player and who cannot utilise power play overs,wastes lot of balls and gets out to nothing shots or soft dismissals
 
This should be the first XI (assuming it's not a rank turner)

Rahul
Dhawan
Kohli
Pandey
Jadhav/Yuvraj
Dhoni
Pandya
Ashwin
Jadeja
Umesh/Bhuvi
Bumrah

In an ideal world, Rohit should replace Jadhav/Yuvraj and Shami in place of Umesh/Bhuvi. Still not convinced about Yuvraj though who seems scratchy. They could have tried a new bloke, they don't have any ODIs now to experiment before the Champions trophy.
 
Dhawan is vital in ICC tournaments. Need to give him enough exposure after his injury return .

He might be a hack but the dude hacks it when it matters the most !!

#iccTournamentBully
 
Last edited:
Yuvraj has been making comebacks ever since Ganguly's captaincy,remarkable really hope he was consistent but the Man always has had consistency issues,If Bhajji had made it back as well would had called it Punjabi bias but lets see how this goes.

Also is Shami injured?
 
Not risking Shami is a good move

Also, Yuvraj back? Now we know what Dhoni meant when he said this is Kohli's team now. No way Yuvraj would have come back under Dhoni
 
Indian test team did so well by trusting the newbies and seasoned players. We got answers for middle order (Nair) and late order batting. Not sure why it can't be obtained even in LOIs (not necessarily with same players/combination but). Parthiv was selected in tests because he was the only option in that area!

Why we need so-called experience? That too for LOIs when we are looking to carry the team forward (it is just a normal bilateral series).

Anyhow I am not sure if Yuvaraj even gets a chance in playing XI (I would pick Rahane over him if fit! It will be embarrassing for him to warm the bench!)

Not sure why you referred to Parosi!

I agree with everything you say. We did find new test players like Nair and Jayant. But they didn't come out of woodwork yesterday. They were tested and progressed through the system. Players like Ishan Kishan, Sarfaraz Khan etc will play for us in future and they will perform better than Rahane and present Yuvraj But they are not ready at this moment. Moment these youngster shows that spark I will be first one to advocate his promotion. It's good that we are gambling with him Yuvraj now instead of Champions Trophy. If he fails here against one of top LOI team then we can easily drop him and be done with it. FYI He was really hitting it clean in Ranji.

Rahane isn't a LO player IMO. He doesn't fit in with any possible role for our team.
 
Pant called to T20 squad.

BCCI already preparing for Dhoni's exit.

He is an ordinary keeper. Infact poor. India A team also has Pant but Ishan Kishan is the designated keeper. May be he has been selected for his batting I suppose and get some coaching from Dhoni.
 
He is an ordinary keeper. Infact poor. India A team also has Pant but Ishan Kishan is the designated keeper. May be he has been selected for his batting I suppose and get some coaching from Dhoni.

Picked as specialist bat probably and he is not as bad as you make him out to be. He kept for Delhi full season and wasn't atrocious. Ishan is better keeper but pant if he clicks will add very much needed explosiveness to Indian LO teams.
 
Strong squad. Surprised at Yuvi being brought back. A good decision, however. With Dhoni on his last legs, the only thing the current Indian team would lack is international experience and Yuvraj can provide that in ample amounts. PCB should take note. Justice being done to a player who performed in domestics despite being an oldie.
 
Where's Raina? He should be in the team looking ahead to the 2013 CT and the 2019 WC. His record in England is a strong one, and he's hardly an oldie either.
 
It would be a dream come true to see old Yuvi performing.

But I don't see it happening.

The new Yuvi looks a million bucks against mediocre bowlers but gets into all sorts of trouble against proper bowlers. That's what I found.

Let's see if he has found his mojo back.
 
Picked as specialist bat probably and he is not as bad as you make him out to be. He kept for Delhi full season and wasn't atrocious. Ishan is better keeper but pant if he clicks will add very much needed explosiveness to Indian LO teams.

To be quite honest he is poor if not atrocious for a keeper. I caught Ishan Kishan's keeping on TV during the Ranji QF and was seriously unimpressed with his trigger movements. He dropped a catch and missed a stumping in the brief session I saw. If Ishan is chosen over Pant then either they see Ishan as a potential keeper bat or one can imagine what selectors think of pant's keeping. He can improve of course. Another thing to note is that Samson is also in the A squad and even he is not the first choice keeper. Some weird times.
 
It would be a dream come true to see old Yuvi performing.

But I don't see it happening.

The new Yuvi looks a million bucks against mediocre bowlers but gets into all sorts of trouble against proper bowlers. That's what I found.

Let's see if he has found his mojo back.

Since 2001 seen this mojo has gone and come back ,gone and come back, he has been one of my fav players but his inconsistency is only because he gets complacent and its his fault.

Should be finished now,should had retired but guess selectors still see something in him.
 
I would have liked to see Harshal Patel in the squad. He bowls well and i recently saw his game in Ranji, was bowling really well, i thought. Always does a decent job for RCB. With Kohli at the helm, thought he or Srinath Arvind may get a look in.
 
To be quite honest he is poor if not atrocious for a keeper. I caught Ishan Kishan's keeping on TV during the Ranji QF and was seriously unimpressed with his trigger movements. He dropped a catch and missed a stumping in the brief session I saw. If Ishan is chosen over Pant then either they see Ishan as a potential keeper bat or one can imagine what selectors think of pant's keeping. He can improve of course. Another thing to note is that Samson is also in the A squad and even he is not the first choice keeper. Some weird times.

Keeping can be improved. Boi's(Pant and Ishan)have played only one season of real cricket. :msd
 
Since 2001 seen this mojo has gone and come back ,gone and come back, he has been one of my fav players but his inconsistency is only because he gets complacent and its his fault.

Should be finished now,should had retired but guess selectors still see something in him.

I never saw it come back post cancer/

Just glimpses of it in few games and then gone.

[MENTION=140266]JattMaula[/MENTION] - What's your take mate? Can he do it against good bowlers?
 
No. He will fail for the last time. Odd six here and there against a medium pacer will be his swansong.

I am confused.

Who is the other big hitting late order all-rounder in form?

Bhai don't be a Parosi. Think objectively. If we had a ready domestic newbie to replace him in his role, we would have. I can assure that we don't.

Are you for or against this selection?

Or you saying this selection was needed to see if he can hack it against international bowlers or not?
 
I am confused.





Are you for or against this selection?

Or you saying this selection was needed to see if he can hack it against international bowlers or not?

Don't be confused, be Dhoni.

I am not for or against his selection. I don't care. He will not matter for long. He is the best candidate for that role which is quite sad for us.
 
It would be a dream come true to see old Yuvi performing.

But I don't see it happening.

The new Yuvi looks a million bucks against mediocre bowlers but gets into all sorts of trouble against proper bowlers. That's what I found.

Let's see if he has found his mojo back.

He struggles against spin. Maybe he got picked since England don't have any quality spinner. Not sure.
 
I was looking for the squad in this post :(

Here it is

ODI squad: KL Rahul, Shikhar Dhawan, Virat Kohli (capt), MS Dhoni, Manish Pandey, Kedar Jadhav, Yuvraj Singh, Ajinkya Rahane, Hardik Pandya, R Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja, Amit Mishra, Jasprit Bumrah, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Umesh Yadav

T20I squad: KL Rahul, Mandeep Singh, Virat Kohli (capt), MS Dhoni (wk), Yuvraj Singh, Suresh Raina, Rishabh Pant (wk), Hardik Pandya, R Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja, Yuzvendra Chahal, Manish Pandey, Jasprit Bumrah, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Ashish Nehra

I think, more than Ranji form, they wanted a bit solidity & experience in middle order, which I think is the better option, considering MS's form. Oblate, IND has been almost single dimensional with top 3 firing or failing. Besides, a Left-hander at 5/6 is like gold, when you have Adil to fire cannon in every direction & length. Mandip is a fantastic choice - he along with Babar & Hammad impressed me in 2010 U19 WC.

I think, MS might play T20 as specialist bat. Just didn't find any logic of Nehra - 2018 T20 WC (if it happens) is almost 2 years away.
 
I was looking for the squad in this post :(

Here it is

ODI squad: KL Rahul, Shikhar Dhawan, Virat Kohli (capt), MS Dhoni, Manish Pandey, Kedar Jadhav, Yuvraj Singh, Ajinkya Rahane, Hardik Pandya, R Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja, Amit Mishra, Jasprit Bumrah, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Umesh Yadav

T20I squad: KL Rahul, Mandeep Singh, Virat Kohli (capt), MS Dhoni (wk), Yuvraj Singh, Suresh Raina, Rishabh Pant (wk), Hardik Pandya, R Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja, Yuzvendra Chahal, Manish Pandey, Jasprit Bumrah, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Ashish Nehra

I think, more than Ranji form, they wanted a bit solidity & experience in middle order, which I think is the better option, considering MS's form. Oblate, IND has been almost single dimensional with top 3 firing or failing. Besides, a Left-hander at 5/6 is like gold, when you have Adil to fire cannon in every direction & length. Mandip is a fantastic choice - he along with Babar & Hammad impressed me in 2010 U19 WC.

I think, MS might play T20 as specialist bat. Just didn't find any logic of Nehra - 2018 T20 WC (if it happens) is almost 2 years away.

Wasn't Ahmed Shehzad playing during the same time? What were your first impressions about him?
 
Wasn't Ahmed Shehzad playing during the same time? What were your first impressions about him?

Shehzad was already an International then, hence I didn't take him seriously. PCB is dumb & idiot, hence picked a player who had no motivation to prove anything - he won a T20 WC with PAK, only PCB buffoons will believe that the same guy, 6 months later will bother for a U19 WC. That spot should have been given to a youngster - Ahmed just went through the motions, lifting his collar high.

But, regarding your question - I saw Ahmed much before than that, he came to BD for a A tour & played few matches, when I was in Dhaka. Even before that, PAK U19 team toured UK in 2007 or sometimes - one of my friends wrote that, there are 3 gems in that team - who should play 100+ Tests for PAK - one was Ahmed.

Of the 3, one went for few more bucks too early, one is a wrong headed guy who went for Virat's persona from poor mentoring & the 3rd one was a lefti , exquisite timer of the ball through gaps, played his last Test in 2010 ENG summer. That's PAK cricket for you, when it comes to grooming young players. 35 years back - each of these 3 would have been given a retainer ship at some County - practice & training facilities, medication, food, accommodation & allowance for 2 years, but no salary commitment - good enough to convert medium pacer or spin all-rounders in to Mazid, Asif, Imran or Javed.
 
Can't believe they have gone back to Yuvraj - he does not even perform in the IPHell any more. Last season he scored 236 runs in 10 matches, the year before he hit 248 runs in 14 matches. Since the last IPL he hasn't played a single limited overs match, only first class matches. In his last year of odi cricket he hit 276 runs in 18 matches. The man just isn't good enough any more. Sure he's been piling on the runs in the Ranji trophy but so have lots of others.
 
What happened to Axar Patel and Stuart Binny ? You know the guys that MSD referred to as "Two best all rounders in the country" ?
 
IPL hasn't given even one big hitter to India that's the reason selectors have to keep calling back guys like Yuvraj. They have already started looking for dhoni's replacement but yuvi won't be replaced.
 
All the picks and absentees point to Kohli getting the team he wants.

:))) At all the Yuvi haters tripping over each other.
 
Yuvraj is playing as a spin option , his batting is not much required.

Left arm spinner would give third spin option for kohli.
 
Shehzad was already an International then, hence I didn't take him seriously. PCB is dumb & idiot, hence picked a player who had no motivation to prove anything - he won a T20 WC with PAK, only PCB buffoons will believe that the same guy, 6 months later will bother for a U19 WC. That spot should have been given to a youngster - Ahmed just went through the motions, lifting his collar high.

But, regarding your question - I saw Ahmed much before than that, he came to BD for a A tour & played few matches, when I was in Dhaka. Even before that, PAK U19 team toured UK in 2007 or sometimes - one of my friends wrote that, there are 3 gems in that team - who should play 100+ Tests for PAK - one was Ahmed.

Of the 3, one went for few more bucks too early, one is a wrong headed guy who went for Virat's persona from poor mentoring & the 3rd one was a lefti , exquisite timer of the ball through gaps, played his last Test in 2010 ENG summer. That's PAK cricket for you, when it comes to grooming young players. 35 years back - each of these 3 would have been given a retainer ship at some County - practice & training facilities, medication, food, accommodation & allowance for 2 years, but no salary commitment - good enough to convert medium pacer or spin all-rounders in to Mazid, Asif, Imran or Javed.

Thanks for the post, so Pak domestic being bad is not exaggerated.
 
He has 0 wickets in last 8 bowling innings in FC.

His international wickets are always a mystery to me. They don't follow conventional laws of reality. He gets wickets on most rubbish balls and at very crucial moments!#KaalaBakra
 
His international wickets are always a mystery to me. They don't follow conventional laws of reality. He gets wickets on most rubbish balls and at very crucial moments!#KaalaBakra

He bowled well in 2010-2011 ish. He was a very useful part time bowler. Sachin's wickets were the ones that surprised me.
 
He bowled well in 2010-2011 ish. He was a very useful part time bowler. Sachin's wickets were the ones that surprised me.

Sachin is a far better bowler than yuvraj.he could spin the ball miles ,bowls off spin,legspin along with regular full tosses,longhops in between particular at the start of his spell.he has 5 fors in onedays u know and he helped india win kolkata test and adelaide test with his bowling
 
Sachin is a far better bowler than yuvraj.he could spin the ball miles ,bowls off spin,legspin along with regular full tosses,longhops in between particular at the start of his spell.he has 5 fors in onedays u know and he helped india win kolkata test and adelaide test with his bowling

He bowled on rank turners and 4/5th day of test match :facepalm:.
 
He bowled on rank turners and 4/5th day of test match :facepalm:.

I think u r too young to think that pitches in india were rank turners when sachin was playing.rank turners are a recent phenomenon after 2011 only. If pitches in india are rank turners how could india score very big scores at that time
 
His international wickets are always a mystery to me. They don't follow conventional laws of reality. He gets wickets on most rubbish balls and at very crucial moments!#KaalaBakra

Wickets are wickets , whether of good or bad balls.
 
Back
Top