What's new

Was Virat Kohli eager to walk to get praise for honesty & sportsmanship like Adam Gilchrist in 2003?

Slog

Senior Test Player
Joined
Feb 15, 2015
Runs
28,984
Post of the Week
1
Was Virat Kohli eager to walk to get praise for honesty & sportsmanship like Adam Gilchrist in 2003?

I was only saying recently how he spends a lot of time on constructing an image
 
No because if he thought he was out then DRS would have given him out as well.
 
He tries hard to maintain a good image with the Pakistani fans which is annoying, since we are an irrelevant bunch.

However, that is never going to impact his intensity on the pitch. He thought he had nicked it and there was no point standing his ground because our yawning captain would have taken a review.

It probably cost India about 15 runs though, so he should be livid with himself.
 
Kohli is a true gentleman. We just like to find keeray in everything as it's our number 1 job.
 
It was probably the bat handle clicking with that swing and making him think hes nicked it.
 
Kohli is a true gentleman. We just like to find keeray in everything as it's our number 1 job.

This and the whole fans drama with Smith seems like it’s a concerted effort
 
Every man is intrinsically good until proven otherwise.
 
It happens.

The clicking sound can be quite convincing when the handle is loose.
 
Nope he walked cos he thought hed nicked it which he did
 
He did his part, and he got robbed by a faulty handle that is that.

I don't think India needed 20 runs more here.
 
I think he is trying to build a culture rather than constructing his image.
 
You could hear a sound if you had access to good feed. So, may be he did feel something. But you know what's the real reason i called him gentleman? he didnt wait for umpire's decision knowing he knicked it. and look how cool he gets with wahab and amir. He is a changed man. Anyone who have seen him recently would agree. I love virat kohli. He has won me over. Can't hate him. May be hated him 2 years ago because of his attitude, but who doesn't have that aggression?

Stop with finding flaws. You aren't getting paid for that. Learn to appreciate such moments. Such paranoid quom are we.
 
I think he is trying to build a culture rather than constructing his image.

THIS. He doesn't badmouth anyone. How he patted wahab and had a cool chat with amir & other bowlers. doesn't get better than that. I love him.
 
I was only saying recently how he spends a lot of time on constructing an image

Couldn't agree more, as if he is a politician with a massive votebank in Pak who he must appease to stay in power. He must go easy on this achha bachha front. It looks fake, stupid and super annoying.
 
Based on some reactions on this thread, he has succeeded as far as improving his brand goes.

If India loses a tight match, he will receive quite a backlash for costing 10-15 runs.
 
Based on some reactions on this thread, he has succeeded as far as improving his brand goes.

If India loses a tight match, he will receive quite a backlash for costing 10-15 runs.

No match is done

He obv wouldn’t have done that if India was 250 instead of 310 at the time.

Also note I’m not saying he didn’t think he was out. He probably did hear a nick but the point is that he seems overeager to one up for his PR
 
Wow what a pathetic mentality this is ? He walked because he thought he edged it. Such a shame we try to find keeray in each and everything. He is certainly a very big player and does not need any of this stuff really.
 
Kohli sure has won over millions of more fans in Pakistan with this act.
 
Kohli is trying to be Mr. Nice guy these days and it just doesn't look like the old Kohli. Image building cost hisnside a good finish in the end.
 
There is a reason you should leave the decision making to the umpires and not make decisions yourself
 
A man does what he does.

Not an advocate of walking though. How many times do fielding captains or bowlers call back batsmen wrongly given out? Never
 
I was only saying recently how he spends a lot of time on constructing an image

Sir, a simple question. How do you live with such negativity in your life? What do you take for your ulcers?
 
Virat Kohli praised for walking during India v Pakistan clash despite being not out.

Virat Kohli has been praised for walking during India's clash with Pakistan at the Cricket World Cup despite doing so incorrectly.

In a match billed as cricket's biggest rivalry and watched by over a billion people, the India captain played a false pull shot on 77 against the bowling of Mohammad Amir.

Kohli brought up his 11,000th ODI run in record time during his stay at the crease - coming in his 222nd innings, 54 outings faster than previous record holder Sachin Tendulkar.

Standing umpire Marais Erasmus did not give Kohli out despite appeals for a catch from Amir and Pakistan skipper Sarfraz Ahmed. But he did not need to as Kohli had already taken it upon himself to leave the ground.

Kohli was later seen with his head in his hands as replays showed him appearing to miss the ball. Speculation abounded that he may have effectively given himself out based on a noise from a 'clicking' bat handle.

Despite his error, Wide World Of Sports' Mark Taylor praised Kohli for his sportsmanship in the context of ongoing tensions between the two nations.

"Virat Kohli is once again trying to do the right thing," Taylor said.

"I don't think he wants any controversy in this match. He knows and understands how big a game this is worldwide.


"He probably thinks, 'well I have hit that, I heard a noise. I don't want the umpire to give me not out and them to review it, or if he gives me out to review it myself. I think I've hit it, I'm just going to go, take all the sting out of it and get off the ground .'"

This was not the first time Kohli's leadership has been on show during the tournament after his highly-publicised rebuke of Indian fans booing Steve Smith.

"Hats off to Virat Kohli who has done that and the gesture with Steve Smith, he is doing some great things for cricket," Taylor said.

Fellow commentator Ian Healy said Kohli's actions were reflective of his maturity in the role of Indian captain.

"He has developed as a man," Healy said.

"He is leading and inspiring a new India. That's a huge weight but he is doing it so comfortably and with such authority.

"He has really stood up in the last few years and is playing our game with huge respect."

But he did indicate that Kohli's generosity with giving up his wicket may not extend to the business end of the tournament.

"Anyone who gets him in a semi final would like that handle to click and he walks off!"

https://wwos.nine.com.au/cricket/vi...orld-cup/50382c3e-c3bf-43ef-8e9a-636dd9f9ba4c

Think Kohli has mellowed in his old age?
 
That was probably the most stupid act I have seen on the cricket field.
 
Kohli needs to get his winning attitude back, winning at all cost that are fair w.r.t the game, and he should had just reviewed.
 
just continuing his bromance with amir :P , but seriously clearly in the moment he thought he nicked it and had thought a review would have confirmed as much. kudos to him for not wasting time but its not like anyone is really getting away with nicking it in this day and age.
 
That was absolutely pathetic from Kohli. Even if he heard the sound should have waited for the umpire, costed us at least 20 runs.
 
hope he learns from his mistake. The umpire didn't rule him out. That being the case he should have waited for the result of the review decision.
 
Last edited:
He is increasingly looking like he is creating a brand for himself. Never seen him walk like this.
 
Dinesh Karthik was given out during the English series at 91 i think. Line was shown flat. KKD said he nicked it lol. Probably similar case.
 
honestly I was super ****** at what he did. You're one of the best batsmen in the the team, take that damn drs if you are unsure. No point of keeping it for someone else who is lesser of a batsmen than you are, even if you nicked it
 
Kohli is making an effort for a PR contract. He is all pally with the Pakistani players, but he makes an outward show of aggression with the rest of the teams. His reprimanding Indian cricket fans for booing an opposition cricketer was fake and trite as were some of his other attempts at being a Social Justice Warrior like asking people not to burst firecrackers during Diwali. Since when was booing an opposition player a bad thing when supporting the home team is beyond me.
 
Kohli is making an effort for a PR contract. He is all pally with the Pakistani players, but he makes an outward show of aggression with the rest of the teams. He was the first person to support rehabilitating of Mo-Amir. His reprimanding Indian cricket fans for booing an opposition cricketer was fake and trite as were some of his other attempts at being a Social Justice Warrior like asking people not to burst firecrackers during Diwali. Since when was booing an opposition player a bad thing when supporting the home team is beyond me.
 
Pathetic. Would've looked silly if Pakistan were to make a tight chase. Umpire was not gonna give him out.
 
Neither Kohli nor Gilchrist did it to get praise. Don't doubt someone's noble intentions just because you yourself are unable to do or think something like this.
 
honestly I was super ****** at what he did. You're one of the best batsmen in the the team, take that damn drs if you are unsure. No point of keeping it for someone else who is lesser of a batsmen than you are, even if you nicked it

That's the thing. He was sure.

Kohli started walking right away and probably felt taking the DRS was selfish when he's nicked it.
 
That's the thing. He was sure.

Kohli started walking right away and probably felt taking the DRS was selfish when he's nicked it.

There's nothing selfish in taking DRS in the 49th over. Umpire was not gonna give him out. Not saying he is playing to the galleries but one should wait for the umpires. These things even out as you could get howlers from umpires.
 
2018:this is fake agression and abuse kohli tries too hard to look tough.
2019:this is fake modesty, kohli tries too hard to look mature.

Some fans are not enjoying that kohli is performing well in world cup, so its just their way to find some fault in him.
 
He thought he was out. He was getting brand deals with how he has always been. So I really doubt he will need to change.
 
There's nothing selfish in taking DRS in the 49th over. Umpire was not gonna give him out. Not saying he is playing to the galleries but one should wait for the umpires. These things even out as you could get howlers from umpires.
But he was not going to take DRS because he thought he was out.
 
It's hilarious that you guys think the only cricketer in the Forbes richest sport person list is doing this to build his 'brand'.

It was a stupid decision to walk though. With the invention of DRS, any cricketer who walks is a *****.
 
Maybe he wanted to make the match interesting and frankly India were already at a comfortable score by then.
 
But he was not going to take DRS because he thought he was out.

That is my issue. You dont walk because you think you are out. You shud only walk if the umpire thinks you are out. There is no case of being honest or cheat here. You are helpless in the case if umpire makes a howler. So no need to do his job.
 
If anyone thinks can Kohli can get more contracts and more respect by stupidly losing his wicket, one is highly deluded and has not seen Kohli in the last 10 years.

This was a genuine mistake. Kohli was upset when he realised his error back in dressing room. Mistakes happen from everyone. Dhoni (as well as umpire) made a bigger blunder by not calling out Fakhar who was plumb.

I am sure Kohli will make up for it in the next crunch match, may be against England or in Semis.
 
If anyone thinks can Kohli can get more contracts and more respect by stupidly losing his wicket, one is highly deluded and has not seen Kohli in the last 10 years.

This was a genuine mistake. Kohli was upset when he realised his error back in dressing room. Mistakes happen from everyone. Dhoni (as well as umpire) made a bigger blunder by not calling out Fakhar who was plumb.

I am sure Kohli will make up for it in the next crunch match, may be against England or in Semis.

He'll definitely make up for it in the next match cuz it's not gonna be against Pak. His friendly attitude and sharing laughs during the match was so annoying to watch too. He tries too hard to score some brownie points with Pak cricketers and fans for the obvious reasons. A well-set batsman not taking the DRS in 49th over of a crucial WC match is CRIMINAL and that's from a Captain? seriously? He should be investigated for this utter stupidity. What if Kohli's missed runs in the last over costed the match for India? I had enough of this man's PR stunts for Pak fans and media. I don't see him displaying these stunts against any other team. To put it in his style, "if you wanna please Pak fans and media, go play for Pakistan"! As simple as that!
 
Last edited:
He'll definitely make up for it in the next match cuz it's not gonna be against Pak. His friendly attitude and sharing laughs during the match was so annoying to watch too. He tries too hard to score some brownie points with Pak cricketers and fans for the obvious reasons. A well-set batsman not taking the DRS in 49th over of a crucial WC match is CRIMINAL and that's from a Captain? seriously? He should be investigated for this utter stupidity. What if Kohli's missed runs in the last over costed the match for India? I had enough of this man's PR stunts for Pak fans and media. I don't see him displaying these stunts against any other team. To put it in his style, "if you wanna please Pak fans and media, go play for Pakistan"! As simple as that!

Ok! Let’s drop Kohli and Get Rayudu in his place!
 
Or you know.... Kohli may have just grown up with age and responsibility of captaincy?

I can't say for certain but I think after the Smith-Warner episode happened he had a very strong look at what it means to be a captain and what is the template he needs to set for the rest of his team. His behaviour during the India Australia series in 2017 where he and Smith completely lost the plot was his lowest point as captain.

It is pretty evident he has put a conscious effort in improving his on-field and media conduct so good on him. He was excellent during the tour down under despite the barrage of verbal volleys thrown at him. A younger Virat would have just flipped the bird at the audience and gone on a hypocritical media rant on the behaviour of the opposition.

He is now asking more from himself, more from his players, and even the audience as well when he told them to stop their disgraceful booing.

I think his long-term aim is to become a proper ambassador for cricket.

---------

The level of cynicism here is pretty laughable though. Small people, small minds.
 
He tries hard to maintain a good image with the Pakistani fans which is annoying, since we are an irrelevant bunch.

However, that is never going to impact his intensity on the pitch. He thought he had nicked it and there was no point standing his ground because our yawning captain would have taken a review.

It probably cost India about 15 runs though, so he should be livid with himself.

To be honest, I think there is genuine connection between Kohli and Pakistani fans. I think he connects with Pak players. And I do believe it’s genuine affection.
 
Such a disgusting thread. PPers were praising Morgan when he rudely replied to a journo yet blame Kohli for everything he does. Not every thing is a conspiracy guys.
 
2018:this is fake agression and abuse kohli tries too hard to look tough.
2019:this is fake modesty, kohli tries too hard to look mature.

Some fans are not enjoying that kohli is performing well in world cup, so its just their way to find some fault in him.

This.

Seriously rubbish thread.
 
Gilly is a good guy, this seems like Kohli trying to earn brownie points/building his brand.
 
Kohli is a champion!
Kohli doesn't need to cheat to win cricket matches!
He thought he nicked it and like a true gentleman, walked before the umpitr made a decision.
Shame on the people making it out kohli had ulterior motives. Didn't you see how angry he was at himself, in the dressing room, when he realised his mistake.
 
Kohli is a champion!
Kohli doesn't need to cheat to win cricket matches!
He thought he nicked it and like a true gentleman, walked before the umpitr made a decision.
Shame on the people making it out kohli had ulterior motives. Didn't you see how angry he was at himself, in the dressing room, when he realised his mistake.

Yeah his dressing room reaction is the only reason we can let this slide pathetic nevertheless, you are there to win not walk away that too in a WC match.
 
No. It was the handle of his bat that made a clicking noise. Virat wrongly thought he'd edged it realising his error later.
 
he walks off simply bcs of he felt it; not bcs of he heard something...
 
Kohli needs to get his winning attitude back, winning at all cost that are fair w.r.t the game, and he should had just reviewed.

lol I guess Umpire gives that out only after Kohli walked..
 
He walked off to avoid injury knowing dhawan is already out. Wahab was targeting his fingers in previous over & he got him hit on the hand too. When he found out Amir also trying to do the same, considering Amir's accuracy he wisely decided to walk off with only two over remaining & enough score on the board.
 
Back
Top