What's new

What do you think about Pink Ball and Day/Night Test cricket?

GoUgandaCranes

Time Pass Post of the Week Winner
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Runs
5,377
Post of the Week
9
I'll start by saying no. They said it'd be good for the fans but no one really showed up for it. The second reason was for practice for Australia but it's impossible to imagine that such a dead pitch will be present in Australia.

The third session and dew take the only interesting thing reverse swing out of the equation.

I'm all for experimentation and what not but for me pink ball cricket isn't something that I'm looking forward to at least in the UAE. Australia maybe but not over here. Regardless of the result, this is absolutely boring cricket on display because of the day-night factor which results in dew on the ground.

We've risked a test here for almost zero gains and not even taken a proper risk.

I'm not satisfied with this experiment. are you?
 
Depends on the TV ratings.

That'll determine whether it was worth it or not.
 
Will be a complete failure if you end up drawing a Test to the WI.
 
No.

If you playing in dew , its not a good idea. Need to have a green top at least.
 
Depends on the pitch, have one like this and you won't like it. 300 needs to be a 1st innings total for a thrilling test match.
 
You know the pitch is super road when friggin West Indies scores 300 on it. Disgraceful pitch.

A draw for West Indies is as good as a win for them. If West Indies manages another 75 runs on this pitch, it will be a definite draw.
 
The value (in terms of monetary units) of a test match in the U.A.E. can only be measured by how much TV ratings it generates on average. Since all of the posters here will be watching the said game on TV and they are showing dissent on this particular experiment then I guess given the sample size and the reaction I would put this pink ball idea as a non successful event, especially in the Middle East.

The pitches more or less cannot be changed here due to the nature of the soil going around in the area. It would be much more feasible to stick to day cricket if they are playing in UAE
 
If the stands are empty then it's a failure.

Stands would be empty in day cricket as well

I think the real issue as Wahab pointed out is the dew which is effecting the ball

This is not suitable for Test cricket
 
I'll start by saying no. They said it'd be good for the fans but no one really showed up for it. The second reason was for practice for Australia but it's impossible to imagine that such a dead pitch will be present in Australia.

The third session and dew take the only interesting thing reverse swing out of the equation.

I'm all for experimentation and what not but for me pink ball cricket isn't something that I'm looking forward to at least in the UAE. Australia maybe but not over here. Regardless of the result, this is absolutely boring cricket on display because of the day-night factor which results in dew on the ground.

We've risked a test here for almost zero gains and not even taken a proper risk.

I'm not satisfied with this experiment. are you?

So far it is fine.

Flat wickets and poor bowling don't help but it is what it is.

Should expect us to still win anyway. Wish the crowds were better however.
 
It'll be a complete failure.

Who seriously will goto stadium after whole day working just to see some tuk tuk with results coming in 3-4 days minimum?

Do people have time for that? Even if people do have time, are they patient enough?

Test cricket is surviving only because t20 and odi exists.
 
Crowds in the UAE, especially Dubai and Abu Dhabi will not turn up for Tests unless we play India. D/N will not help much, if it all in that regard.

As far as the cricket is concerned, as I said before, D/N Tests will not be any different to regular Tests in general, except that the dew factor might play a small role. However, results will not be impacted in the long run.

If people except every D/N Test to end in 3 days like the Adelaide one because the ball is pink, they are in for disappointment.
 
Crowds in the UAE, especially Dubai and Abu Dhabi will not turn up for Tests unless we play India. D/N will not help much, if it all in that regard.

As far as the cricket is concerned, as I said before, D/N Tests will not be any different to regular Tests in general, except that the dew factor might play a small role. However, results will not be impacted in the long run.

If people except every D/N Test to end in 3 days like the Adelaide one because the ball is pink, they are in for disappointment.

Listen to what Wahab said about the dew factor. There is a big issue there.
 
A d/n test in Pakistan may have attracted a bigger crowd due to the novelty factor and the fact there is a bigger middle class, students etc over there. Here we only have labourers who cant really afford to go and watch cricket. ODI's are fine but in general the jazba isnt the same.

as for the pink ball, ive only managed to watch the last session and highlights..and its been pretty ininteresting stuff..any cricket without reverse swing is a big turn off for me..its like watch a long ODI match..that neuters bowling..
 
A d/n test in Pakistan may have attracted a bigger crowd due to the novelty factor and the fact there is a bigger middle class, students etc over there. Here we only have labourers who cant really afford to go and watch cricket. ODI's are fine but in general the jazba isnt the same.

as for the pink ball, ive only managed to watch the last session and highlights..and its been pretty ininteresting stuff..any cricket without reverse swing is a big turn off for me..its like watch a long ODI match..that neuters bowling..

ICC should be held accountable.

The balls should have been tested in all conditions. In this day and age of science, such products being put out are nonsense.
 
Certainly not in UAE ... I thot crowd would turn up in evening or night session.. but I was wrong.... if tv ratings doesnt look good it will be discarded in asia...

Tests which ends in 3 days and which does not seems to end atall...both are not good.....

Interesting to see how 4th day pitch helps bowlers..
 
It's been a big yawn.

Funny how everybody would turn up back in the day in Sharjah and when they held the IPL there, but nobody seems to care for games held in the UAE today.
 
It's been a big yawn.

Funny how everybody would turn up back in the day in Sharjah and when they held the IPL there, but nobody seems to care for games held in the UAE today.

LOI and Tests. Think about it.
 
Listen to what Wahab said about the dew factor. There is a big issue there.

It's an issue and I highlighted it already, but we will still win the match and the series comfortably.

My point is that the pink ball and the playing hours are not going to impact the results as long as curators continue to dish out the same pitches.

The Adelaide Test has given people unrealistic expectations regarding D/N Tests, which ended in 3 days not because of the pink ball but because it was a green pitch with a lot of seam movement.
 
Sharjah crowd is still decent. The 5th day of the Sri Lankan Test in 2014 was almost a full house and last year against England it was pretty good.

Dubai and Abu Dhabi are probably the two worst venues for Test cricket in the world.
 
The ODI games Pakistan play in the UAE are hardly packed either. Probably 40% tops.

not true - we do get big turn out - games against WI have an image problem. Obviously not as big as Pakistan or India
 
ICC should be held accountable.

The balls should have been tested in all conditions. In this day and age of science, such products being put out are nonsense.

Nah. All of the boards have to share in the blame.

Everyone got a bit too excited about the Adelaide Oval test and wanted to accelerate it which is why all the boards have already announced new day night tests.

I still think Australia rushed it but at least Australia had 12+ first class matches over 3 years in advance to prepare things
 
Dew seems to be the biggest issue for Asian conditions. The anti-dew spray might help.
 
I am still not convinced by day night test cricket. Lets stick to tradition for test cricket. Experiment how with LOIs only
 
Day night Tests aren't a problem.

Any sort of cricket, specially Test cricket is a problem IN THE UAE.

Worst venues out there and do a bad advertisement for the game. Plus, pitch should've been favorable for the seamers. Spinners get dew.
 
This is bcci/icc plan to destroy Pakistan cricket

Whole point of d/n game in UAE was to generate a crowd and increase television viewers it has failed

But the real agenda of bcci/ICC is to undermine Pakistan bowlers in UAE , the crap pink ball and dew neuters reverse swing and more importantly our spinners

Red ball no day night I guarantee nawaz and shah would have run through this windies batting and wahab sohail would have got reverse.


Can we please have our real test cricket back
 
We will not be seeing a D/N Test again in the UAE. Says enough.

That pink ball is a spinner's enemy. Yasir would have had a five for on a normal day.
 
ICC should be held accountable.

The balls should have been tested in all conditions. In this day and age of science, such products being put out are nonsense.
That's a bit over the top.

The PCB chose to ignore the lessons that we had already learned in Australia, namely:

1. Only one session should be after dark to minimise the effect of dew.

2. There is no spin or reverse, so for reasons of both giving bowlers a chance and maintaining the ball, the pitch can only be a greentop.

The PCB as hosts disregarded those parameters, and ended up with the same results we'd already seen in Australia which led us to schedule play earlier in the day and to use greentop pitches only.

Nobody, least of all the ICC, claimed that you could use a pink ball on a dead wicket. Or schedule two sessions each day after dark.

That's just the PCB failing to do its homework.
 
pink Ball doesn't seem to work in subcontinental conditions or UAE
 
This is bcci/icc plan to destroy Pakistan cricket

Whole point of d/n game in UAE was to generate a crowd and increase television viewers it has failed

But the real agenda of bcci/ICC is to undermine Pakistan bowlers in UAE , the crap pink ball and dew neuters reverse swing and more importantly our spinners

Red ball no day night I guarantee nawaz and shah would have run through this windies batting and wahab sohail would have got reverse.


Can we please have our real test cricket back

There is an ongoing dispute between the BCCI and the ICC right now. The BCCI and the ICC heads are not in good terms with each other.

So you cannot blame both this time around, it's either the BCCI or ICC.
 
No, complete failure and should never be tried again in the UAE.

The pitch is meant to break up and start turning, but how will it crack, when the dew keeps it moist and holding it together?

Also, there is no chance of reverse swing either, so everyone is a sitting duck from pacers to spinners.
 
Its been underwhelming after all the buildup.

The pink ball hasn't reversed, partly because of the dew making it difficult to keep one side rough and hasn't prodigiously swung under the lights as was forecasted. Combine that with the road of a surface produced in Dubai and its been extremely dull cricket.

The crowd has been only slightly better than usual for UAE Tests but that's not saying much. The UAE is simply a terrible place for cricket with the exception perhaps of Sharjah where turnout is much better than Dubai and Abu Dhabi where the grounds are harder to reach for the Pakistani expats and labourers.

However I do think turnout would've been a lot better in Pakistan. For the D/N QAE Final there was a decent crowd in. If dew factor can be minimised by the groundsman and the pitches have some live grass to protect the pink ball more then D/N Tests could work.
 
The value (in terms of monetary units) of a test match in the U.A.E. can only be measured by how much TV ratings it generates on average. Since all of the posters here will be watching the said game on TV and they are showing dissent on this particular experiment then I guess given the sample size and the reaction I would put this pink ball idea as a non successful event, especially in the Middle East.

The pitches more or less cannot be changed here due to the nature of the soil going around in the area. It would be much more feasible to stick to day cricket if they are playing in UAE

The thing is, I had time yesterday to watch the match but I didn't because by God it was boring. It was so boring that I turned it off and looked at my desktop wallpaper (which happens to be simple plain black), and it was more interesting than the match.

I'm all for rank turners that India is producing because at least the match moves forward. Even if I have time, I don't want to watch Darren Bravo play a million balls for nothing or even Azhar Ali scoring a triple century because it just tells me how slow the pitch is.

I just think the pink ball day night test takes more from cricket than it gives back. But this is a premature opinion but still.
 
Stands would be empty in day cricket as well

I think the real issue as Wahab pointed out is the dew which is effecting the ball

This is not suitable for Test cricket

The point of Day/Night tests is to combat poor attendance. If people still don't attend the games then it's a waste of time and we should continue playing tests during normal hours. The only thing that will change my mind is if TV ratings have sky rocketed which I find extremely unlikely.
 
Why the hell are you guys fighting over the color of a cricket ball? the color!!! geesh grow up.
 
It's more to do with the location of the stadium. I am not sure but I have heard its out of the city. Those who work there won't come at night and go home late because they have to leave for their job early morning. In UAE it won't work at all. Stands have been empty during some odi's also.
 
The Aussies don't seem too happy.

After one of the great matches, Test cricket is in the ascendant but not so the pink ball, which has taken a battering in ways other than the literal. The players say the ball’s latest incarnation stops swinging after about five overs and quickly goes soft thereafter.

Steve Smith evoked images of a flat Sherrin or a beach ball *punctured by ground security in describing how the ball seemed to lose its “air’’.

As such, the effort by Mitchell Starc to lift a vicious delivery at Asad Shafiq’s throat yesterday — a Test-winning delivery if ever there was one — was superhuman, Smith said.

“All the air was out of it — it was incredibly soft,” Smith said of the ball’s condition as Pakistan had earlier closed on the Aust*ralian target. “To get one to bounce the way he did, with the pink ball being 60 overs old (and not) really doing much and get us that key scalp, a lot of credit has got to go to Mitchell.’’

Smith says there is room for improvement in the ball now day-night Tests are in the schedule.

“You have to improve the game as much as we can. We saw in this game that once the pink ball got a little bit softer, probably after 25 or 30 overs, it was quite hard to get players out. You need to improve the product.’’

And the skipper said the pink ball was no friend of the spinners. Shane Warne loved bowling at the Gabba because the ball bounced as well as spun. Nathan Lyon has a great record in Brisbane too, but he suffered from the lack of bounce in this Test.

“In periods of the game he bowled well,” Smith said. “In *others he was a little bit off. *Bowling at the Gabba with the pink ball that was pretty soft does make it a difficult place to bowl spin. He has a great record at the Gabba in red ball cricket, where the ball stays harder for longer and he’s able to generate that bounce out of the wicket, but he couldn’t get that bounce with the way the ball was.”

Smith shed light on the umpires’ decision to extend play by half an hour on Sunday night.

It seemed an odd call given the Pakistani batsmen appeared to shut up shop ahead of the scheduled close. They opened up again in the last half hour.

“Early on in the day, I sort of said ‘It’s great that we have that extra half hour up our sleeve if we need it’,” Smith said.

“And then later on, (umpire Ian) ‘Gunner’ Gould was pretty adamant that he wanted to sort of stay out there and try and get the game over and done with.

“The umpires deemed for it to be the opportunity for a result. We went with that.

“I would have liked to come off and given our bowlers a rest.

“They’d worked incredibly hard all day and Pakistan were just starting to get on to a bit of a roll — but you’ve got to go with the umpire’s call.”

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...g/news-story/83b4e5c41329e20f112ef615821cc037
 
http://www.smh.com.au/sport/cricket...e-of-pink-ball-criticism-20161220-gtf7wp.html

Cricket ball manufacturer Kookaburra has hit back at suggestions the pink ball isn't up to the rigors of Test cricket.

Australia captain Steve Smith questioned its hardness in the aftermath of his side's gripping 39-run win over Pakistan at the Gabba in Brisbane on Monday.

According to Smith, the ball softened quicker than the traditional red ball and was partly to blame for Pakistan getting within touching distance of a world-record fourth-innings run chase.

"We saw in this game that once the pink ball got a little bit softer, probably after 25-30 overs, it was actually quite hard to get players out,"
Smith said.

Kookaburra spokesperson Shannon Gill said on Tuesday that players would take some time to adapt to the new ball.

"The pink ball will feel a little different to players due to the pink coating, so it's understandable they will take some time to adjust," he said.

"Structurally, the ball is the same, so we think it is the coating that changes the perception.

"We welcome player feedback though because we want to keep improving this ball."


The pink ball made its international debut in the inaugural day-night Test match between Australia and New Zealand in Adelaide last year, with fans and players alike lauding the switch.

Since that clash, Kookaburra altered the seam ahead of the recent Adelaide and Brisbane day-night Tests.

"The most significant and noticeable change [this year] is the black seam," Gill said.

"After the [Adelaide Test] last year, the player feedback was that they needed greater contrast between the seam and the leather for visibility.

"Player feedback across the world in the past 12 months has been positive and while we don't profess it to be perfect yet, we've seen definite improvement in it holding its colour and visibility longer."


While the recently announced 2017-18 Ashes series will have only one day-night Test, future series not involving England in Australia are expected to see a push for more night cricket.

Gill said Kookaburra had had contact will all relevant stakeholders after both the Adelaide and Brisbane Tests.

"We've had some general communication without anything formal and on the whole it's been positive with no major issues," he said.

"We're keen to keep working with [the stakeholders] on it because it brings a real excitement to Test cricket that we'd love to be part of."
 
It's TERRIBLE everywhere in the world except Aus.

Why?

Because there's friggin' DEW at night in other parts! :danish :danish It was a joke in the UAE, esp!

Will be a joke in IND, possibly England too.
 
The whole pink ball idea is stupid


Wear color clothes and play the test with a white damn ball. Simple solution
 
I personally really like the idea of D/N tests but the biggest problem is clearly how important the toss has became especially in D/N games. It's almost like a bat first and win situation which needs to be more balanced.
 
Use a yellow ball next. Then we can try orange after..

Lots of colors left in the pallete at the moment.
 
Either all countries play with the pink ball or none does

Totally unfair if this is selective as it has a bearing on rankings
 
Either all countries play with the pink ball or none does

Totally unfair if this is selective as it has a bearing on rankings

Yep good point. If they do carry on with pink ball tests each side should be made to play X number of pink ball tests per season/year.
 
Liam Dawson: Pink balls create "boring" cricket

HAMPSHIRE all-rounder Liam Dawson believes the pink ball creates boring cricket.

Dawson (53) passed fifty in the Specsavers County Championship for the first time this season after digging in against Somerset.

He helped put on 84 in 34.2 overs for the first wicket before Jimmy Adams (47) was caught at slip against Craig Overton.

“If you look at the score we were 80 for none but we didn’t score quickly,” said Dawson, who faced 139 balls and scored four fours.

“If you are prepared to be quite boring I think that is what we are going to have to do. We are short of runs.

“It is the sort of wicket you can be boring and take the game deep.”

Dawson’s first impressions of day/night Championship cricket were not favourable after Hampshire made 211-9d, having collapsed to 172-7.

“The crowds haven’t changed, we haven’t had any more people in.

“It is early days and it is something that might work.

“From my first experience of it, I think they need to have a good look at what balls they are going to use.

“If you are going to keep on using those balls then you are going to get some pretty boring cricket.

“It just goes very soft, very quickly.

“We are behind the game but this is a new game for everyone and if we get a few quick wickets then who knows what will happen.”

Somerset fast bowler Overton said: “The ball was strange. It swings and then goes really soft. It didn’t really do much.”

http://www.romseyadvertiser.co.uk/sport/15373305.Liam_Dawson__Pink_balls_create__boring__cricket/
 
The first pink ball test in England is not too far away (vs WIs in August) - wonder how it goes?
 
I am in favour of day/night cricket. Hopefully it can attract viewers and als hopefully we get a more even contest between bat and ball.

Also when teams are scoring quickly before it gets dark and making early declarations will ensure we get results. Think it does make the game a bit more exciting as well.
 
Last edited:
I don't mind it but then again I'm not the one playing it. They should definitely do something about the dew at night. Invent some sort of a chemical solution to the problem.. something to dry up the moisture.

There are not too many stadia attendance in most parts of the world for test cricket in the first place. So it's unfair to gauge the popularity of d/n tests on the basis of crowd sizes. There is a lot of following for test cricket on tv.
 
I stand by my earlier comments......

The PCB chose to ignore the lessons that we had already learned in Australia, namely:

1. Only one session should be after dark to minimise the effect of dew.

2. There is no spin or reverse, so for reasons of both giving bowlers a chance and maintaining the ball, the pitch should be a greentop.

Nobody, least of all the ICC, claimed that you could use a pink ball on a dead wicket. Or schedule two sessions each day after dark.

That's just the PCB failing to do its homework.
I would add that Kevin Mitchell Jr messed up at Brisbane by cutting the grass too short, so Asad Shafiq almost chased down a huge total.

I'd also add that on the fourth evening at Brisbane, play went on far too long in the dark to make up for earlier rain delays.

Bowlers only profit in the hour either side of sunset. In the later hours of darkness the ball is easy to see and doesn't deviate, so batting is too easy.
 
Doesn't seem like county attendances were any higher as a result of day night matches.

The ball seems to lose its shape quickly and becomes soft. The concept is worth pursuing but they need to make the ball more durable.
 
Looks like a glorified night-time practice match. International Cricket without it's audience is nothing/dead.

The pink ball could be made a shade or two darker though. I can't stand the feminization of the red cherry.
 
Looks like a glorified night-time practice match. International Cricket without it's audience is nothing/dead.

The pink ball could be made a shade or two darker though. I can't stand the feminization of the red cherry.

Or you could be a real man and embrace the glory of pink.
 
To be honest I don't think Day/Night cricket is suitable for serious competitions, especially when dew is likely to be an issue. In England I think D/N Test cricket is a ridiculous idea, both because of dew and because it's usually too cold here even during the day, let alone at night! There's also the issue of getting home afterwards. I can't attend the Edgbaston Test match this year because I have no way of getting home at that time of night. One positive thing I will say, having watched a D/N County Championship match at Chelmsford recently is that the pink ball is easier for me as a spectator to see and appears to keep its colour better than the white ball.
 
To be honest I don't think Day/Night cricket is suitable for serious competitions, especially when dew is likely to be an issue. In England I think D/N Test cricket is a ridiculous idea, both because of dew and because it's usually too cold here even during the day, let alone at night! There's also the issue of getting home afterwards. I can't attend the Edgbaston Test match this year because I have no way of getting home at that time of night. One positive thing I will say, having watched a D/N County Championship match at Chelmsford recently is that the pink ball is easier for me as a spectator to see and appears to keep its colour better than the white ball.

Ever heard of uber, mate?
 
I have no problem with the concept.

The problem is the damn cricket ball. The manufacturers especially uslesss machine made Kookaburras can't make a durable white ball, let alone pink ball. Even their red balls have been going out of shape very quickly.
 
Edgbaston does its homework before England’s first day-night Test

The first of many questions that executives at Edgbaston had to ask as they commenced preparations for England’s first ever day-night Test was: what do you call the breaks? Standard, daytime Tests have their lunch break at, well, lunchtime, and their tea break at, give or take, tea time. A 2pm start distorts the timetable and, while 4pm can be referred to in many ways, if you are calling it lunchtime something has gone badly wrong with your day.

In Adelaide, where Australia played day-night Test matches against New Zealand in 2015 and South Africa the following year, and where England will appear in another this December, the breaks were switched, with the first becoming shorter and known as tea, and the second – coming, as it does, at approximately dinnertime – stretching longer and renamed dinner.

“We decided in discussions with the ECB not to do that, because we think that would be more confusing,” says Neil Snowball, Warwickshire’s chief executive and veteran of both 2012 Olympic and 2015 Rugby World Cup organising committees. “We’ll be starting at 2pm, have the first two-hour session and our main interval will be the first interval, which we’ll call ‘lunch’, even though it’s at 4 o’clock, then we’ll have the second break between 6.40pm and 7pm which again we’ll call ‘tea’. It’s just to avoid confusion. We don’t know if this is going to be the first of many or whether it’s a one-off but we thought it was easier to explain.”

For all their experience of hosting floodlit matches, preparing for England’s first day-night Test has been nowhere near as straightforward as it might have been to put on five successive day-night ODIs. Snowball, as part of his preparations, has been in regular contact with Keith Bradshaw, the former chief executive of MCC who now holds the same position at the South Australian Cricket Association and has been involved in all the Adelaide matches. In March Snowball and Gary Barwell, Warwickshire’s head groundsman, were in Abu Dhabi to see the Champion County match played, as this week’s Test will be, with a pink Dukes ball.

“One of the things we learned out there was not to try to be too clever with the actual pitch,” says Snowball. “There have been various debates about whether you leave a bit more on, whether you take a bit more off, but what we’ve concluded is that we should just produce a good Edgbaston strip, a good Test pitch with good carry, nice and firm.”

They also returned from Abu Dhabi with a supply of adjuvant spray, regularly used in hotter climates to help disperse evening dew. “You’ve probably seen sometimes – we do it and they do it abroad – they whizz round on a tractor with a rope,” says Snowball. “So basically you put a very fine spray over the outfield which coats the blades of grass so that, if the dew does fall, it just sits on the top of the grass, so that when you whizz round with the rope it flicks it all up in the air and a percentage of it evaporates. So it doesn’t stop the dew forming, it just enables the dew to stick on the top of the grass and then it makes it easier for us to flick it off. Abroad they’re pretty confident the dew will form and when it’ll fall. Obviously it’s a bit unpredictable here, so we’re just doing it as a precaution.”

Among the lessons learned from Adelaide was the importance of illuminating not only the actual ground but also the practice areas and the car parks, both of which were unpopularly dark when they hosted their first day-nighter. Another change is that, if more play is required to make up time lost during the day, another hour will be split between its end, as is traditional, and the start of the following one. So ticket-holders on days two and beyond should be aware that, if they turn up at 2pm they may already have missed half an hour’s action, and that ideally they should check on Warwickshire’s website or on social media in case the start time has been brought forward.

But while fans have been warned not to be late, staff are being told not to be early. “If you have a full five days, like we did last year against Pakistan, it’s quite gruelling for everybody involved – whether it’s the chefs, the groundstaff or the security guys,” says Snowball. “And people are used to getting in very early on Test days, at 7.30 ready for an 11am start. One of the things we’ve had to tell people is: ‘Don’t come in at 7.30am. Because you’re not going to get to bed until about 2am, and you need to get some rest.’ A five-day Test means more pressure on the stadium, more pressure on the infrastructure and more pressure on the people. It’s about getting the staff to pace themselves, that’s probably the main thing we’ve been focusing on.”

A sighting of the pink ball has, meanwhile, given caterers the chance to go back to the fuchsia. “We’ll be getting into the spirit of the pink ball,” says Snowball. “We’ve got quite a bit of rosé, pink champagne, we’ve got some pink cocktails. We’ve created a beach area behind the Wyatt stand, partly because it’s the West Indies as well, so we’ve got a rum shack, a big screen, we’ve got deckchairs. People will see a bit of a pink theme about the place.”

Day two is officially a sell-out, with days one and three expected to join it before action gets under way – no mean feat when, in Snowball’s words, “West Indies these days are probably not as easy a sell as some of the other touring sides.”

But despite the commercial success, no imminent repeat is likely: television viewers in Pakistan and India, next summer’s tourists, are unlikely to welcome the delayed finish time, which would keep them up until somewhere between 1am and 3am. Though the timing is even worse for Australians, the 2019 Ashes will sell out easily enough anyway. Still, Snowball expects the experiment to be popular.

“What I found out in Abu Dhabi was each of the three sessions almost has its own unique identity,” he says. “The first session was fairly traditional, played in bright sunshine. Then you moved into that sort of twilight zone when different things happened: the ball did a little bit more; there was not a clatter of wickets but it was clearly hard work for the batsmen. Then you moved into the proper night-time, the third session, which was just really atmospheric, with the floodlights and the pink ball. At Edgbaston with a full crowd, I’m really looking forward to that.”

Warwickshire were the pioneers of floodlit cricket in England, hosting the first competitive match 20 years ago last month. “We were very proud of that fact and, when we were approached by the ECB, we thought it would be nice to have the double with the first ever floodlit Test match,” says Snowball. “We thought there was a good commercial angle, which has proved to be the case because tickets have sold very well. It is an experiment. We might get to the end of this and say, ‘Never again.’ Or we might say, ‘You know what, that was terrific.’ Either it’ll be the one and only or it’ll be the first of many. Either way it’s going to be a history Test. So it’s nice to be part of history.”

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2...ston-england-first-day-night-test-west-indies
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Paul Collingwood said after his experience of playing with the pink Dukes in the recent round of County matches that the ball swung all over the place for the first ten overs.

But then it gets soft quickly and does nothing off the pitch, describing it like hitting plastic.
 
I'm struggling to see what value pink ball cricket is adding to the current test match. If anything it seems to be widening the gulf between the two sides.
 
I'm struggling to see what value pink ball cricket is adding to the current test match. If anything it seems to be widening the gulf between the two sides.

Not sure the balls got much to do with that. 3 days straight of packed houses with great atmospheres for tests involving the West Indies is probably a handy start though.
 
I'm struggling to see what value pink ball cricket is adding to the current test match. If anything it seems to be widening the gulf between the two sides.

Not sure the balls got much to do with that. 3 days straight of packed houses with great atmospheres for tests involving the West Indies is probably a handy start though.

Wait until England have a bowl.

WI's have generally bowled terribly and not exploited the moments where the ball begins to deviate, delayed bowling under the lights as well; they've not hit their lengths and lines either, although admittedly the wicket is an absolute belter and given the ineptness of WI's at the moment it would have made things very interested had England declared during the evening yesterday, they'd have won regardless but we'd not have to endure so many boring periods. The sell out crowds are great but they also need to be entertained.
 
Besides the pitch, I think the ECB has the breaks wrong as well. Do what CA did, have a shorter first break for tea and longer second break for dinner. This will give people more cricket under lights, prime time for tv audience.
 
‘Cricket chiefs discriminating against colour blind by using pink ball’

A letter from campaign group Colour Blind Awareness has urged the England and Wales Cricket Board to reconsider their use of the pink ball, which it said was difficult to see for both players and spectators.

The first match of the three-Test series between the two teams is a day-night affair as the ICC is taking its latest step to keep alive the oldest format of the game.

The ongoing Birmingham Test is the fifth day/night Test match. The first day/night Test was played in Adelaide between Australia and New Zealand in 2015.

Dubai hosted the second day/night Test in October last year when Pakistan beat the West Indies. Australia played the next two day/night matches at home against South Africa and Pakistan.

So, this is the first time England has hosted a day/night five-day game. But some people have raised concerns on the use of the pink ball in the day/night Test matches.

DIFFICULT TO SEE

According to the Daily Telegraph, a letter from campaign group Colour Blind Awareness has urged the England and Wales Cricket Board to reconsider their use of the pink ball, which it said was difficult to see for both players and spectators with the condition.

“In the UK there are approximately three million people with colour blindness,” the Telegraph quoted the letter from CBA founder Kathryn Albany-Ward as saying.

“So, it would be extremely difficult to argue that it is reasonable to use a pink ball when so many people are potentially adversely affected,” the letter added.

Yorkshire and England batsman Gary Ballance, not playing at Edgbaston, is among those who’ve struggled to see the pink ball because of his colour blindness, although he recently said he was finding it easier to pick up after the ball had been modified.

And three years ago, Australia opening batsman Chris Rogers withdrew from a pink-ball trial match because he has the condition.

But it is understood all the England players at Edgbaston had eyesight tests in a bid to ensure they could cope with the pink ball.

http://m.hindustantimes.com/cricket...g-pink-ball/story-p9jXNtCHkbTGa0EIHjfc7K.html
 
Today is day/night test number 6 I believe. Still a tiny sample however at some point a call will need to be made as to whether we continue on with pink ball tests.
 
Today is day/night test number 6 I believe. Still a tiny sample however at some point a call will need to be made as to whether we continue on with pink ball tests.

No call can be made until the no. 1 team in the world has played a d/n test match :srini
 
/\/\/\

So far the BCCI have remained almost silent on this issue.

Going back to today’s test, do folks think the day/night pink ball format has led to an increase in attendance numbers?
 
Certainly made watching test cricket more possible for people who work at office hours.

Wish it stayed this way.
 
/\/\/\

So far the BCCI have remained almost silent on this issue.

Going back to today’s test, do folks think the day/night pink ball format has led to an increase in attendance numbers?

BCCI don't accept changes to cricket that quickly going by their history. Last to accept T20 format, last to give up red ball ODI's in whites etc.
 
On topic, the ball is a pain to watch. I'd rather they play test cricket in coloureds with a white ball. What difference does it make anyway?
 
BCCI don't accept changes to cricket that quickly going by their history. Last to accept T20 format, last to give up red ball ODI's in whites etc.

Also took them a while to accept DRS in home games.
 
BCCI don't accept changes to cricket that quickly going by their history. Last to accept T20 format, last to give up red ball ODI's in whites etc.

Yeah, surprisingly it is true, BCCI doesn't like change, still remember those red ball odis in the late 90s
 
Back
Top