What's new

Where would Saleem Malik rank amongst the pantheon of greats? Test World XI?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,520
Post of the Week
2
I have seen few players on their day who have been as dashing as Salim Malik.In full flow he looked like a galleon in full sail.He could bissect every region of a field with the ease of a baker slicing a cake and when the chips were down revealed the mental resilience of a soldier.

I can never forget the grit and determination Salim Malik revealed when his team faced adversity.He had the capacity to single-handedly turn the course of a game creating the effect of a total reversal of plot in a movie.His face and strokes could tell it all.Who can forget his 72 of 35 balls that won game that looked lost in the 2nd O.D.I. in Kolkata in 1987?He simply clobbered the Indian bowling making them look like cattle fodder with 65 run srequired of 1 overs and steered his team home to famous win.At leeds in 1987 in a winning cause when scoring 99 a nd in a losing cause scoring a century in 99 Malik resembled a surgeon tackling a patient considered incurable successfully.When every other good batsmen was struggling he displayed great sense of judgement and precision in negotiating the moving ball in overcast conditions.He blended the courage of a soldier with the skill of an architect.In 1992 he topped the batting averages in test matches in England averaging 81.66 and also topped the averages in the home series v West Indies in 1991.Batted like a champion in winning causes v England in the 1987 Reliance Cup and 1991 Nehru Cup and was also at his dazzling best in a home series v Australia in 1994 where he amassed a record aggregate of 557 runs.His epic 237 at Lahore and century at Faisalabad ressurected Pakistan from the grave to save the tests and win the series by a 1-0 margin.Few batsmen have blended determination,concentration and artistry ever as Salim Malik did then.In early 1994 in New Zealand his batting played a major role in his side's series victory.

In England his overall average in 3 full test tours in 1987,1992 and 1996 was over 60 which is remarkable.Few batsmen negotiated the moving ball better.Above all Pakistan emerged victorious in all those series.Sadly he was hardly prolific in West Indies or Australia.Still one must remember his fifty that revived a sinking ship at Trinidad in 1988 in the 2nd test when Pakistan looked doomed at around 70 runs for the loss of 7 wickets.It enabled Pakistan to gain a slender 19 innings lead in game hat Pakistan came within touching distance of winning.It could rank amongst the finest test fifties ever scored in a crisis.

Sadly his later career got affected by claims of match-fixing and after being convicted he finally got cleared by 2000 in the court.

His away record apart from England was not as impressive as many greats.However at his best he was a class act exhibiting strokeplay of the highest degree and able to master the worst wickets.In a crisis he was one of Pakistan's best batsmen of all time ,similar to Wasim Raja,Asif Iqbal or Majid Khan.I think when the chips were down he was better payer in tests than Zaheer Abbas.For some time in the mid 1990's Salim Malik would make my world test xi.In that period few batsmen so proportionately blended durability,artistry and determination.In the most precarious situtations Malik was an epitome of combat,determination personified.He would have joined Gooch,Mark Taylor Lara,Tendulkar,Mark Waugh etc.It may have been a photo finish between Malik and one of the Waugh brothers.In 1992 and 1994 I would have given him the benefit of the doubt over Border,Inzamam or one of the Waugh brothers,in selection for a world test xi.
 
i heard he dominated warne like no other

but i doubt he makes any World XI
 
i heard he dominated warne like no other

but i doubt he makes any World XI


See his stats v Australia in 1994,England in 1992 and West Indies in 1991.See his best innings at Leeds on wet tracks in a crisis.Then judge
 
I believe he was one of the best players of spin and swing in his time (late 80s early 90s)

The problem with Malik was his consistency across his career He had some really great series where he looked like a bonafide great but this was mixed with some really poor series particularly away like the 92 wc where he just went missing too frequently

As well as the above The match fixing activities of that time also soured what shouldve been a truly world class player and a great legacy
 
Between 1992 English summer to 1994 ill fated SAF tour, he was indeed world's top 4/5 batsmen - should have made the Test XI.
 
Between 1992 English summer to 1994 ill fated SAF tour, he was indeed world's top 4/5 batsmen - should have made the Test XI.

agreed.on par or better than Zaheer Abbas overall in test cricket?
 
agreed.on par or better than Zaheer Abbas overall in test cricket?

Zaheer was different class before WSC. He made the World XI to face AUS in 1971. His first 3 tours in UK, UK & AUS brought 274, 240 & 101 (?) - but, I believe he was exposed first by Lloyd in 1976 Series by his pacers, which was clinically executed in WSC. I have no other explanation, because during that period of 1975 to 1980, Zaheer scored over 10K runs in County with 35+ hundreds & he holds an unbelievable record of a Double & 150+ in same FC match 4 times, 3 probably in one season & 2 in back 2 back matches (but not sure). His game was based on front foot, which was perfect for County (and ODI), but I actually won't pick him in any PAK team (Test) ahead of Mazid Khan.

At their pick, I'll always take Zed over Malik, but that 2/3 years Malik was outstanding - so would have been Zaheer between 1971 to 1976, had PAK played say 3/4 times than their customary 3/4 Tests/year.
 
It's hard to rate Salim Malik

One minute he would look like a tailender the next minute he would be batting like a high class batsmen

He does play spin wonderfully well however I wouldn't rate him playing the quicks to good
 
It's hard to rate Salim Malik

One minute he would look like a tailender the next minute he would be batting like a high class batsmen

He does play spin wonderfully well however I wouldn't rate him playing the quicks to good

To me one of the greats in a crisis or on bad wickets.***** his role in Rise of Pakistan cricket to the top of the pedestal,
 
A very good and wristy batsman on his day. Not world class though.
 
Nowhere near ATG XI

Decent player but sadly my last memories of him was during the 1999 WC where he was rubbish...
 
Back
Top