Why is Salman Ali Agha considered a modern T20 hero compared to Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan?

[Caved12]

I suggest replacing Saim with Imam-ul-Haq.

I suggest you finally speak the truth for once, and stick to cricket instead of wasting everyone’s time with nonsense.

 

[topspin]

BUT BUT BUT we need Saim Ayub to be replaced by Imam

Kind Regards
Credible Caved

 

[Caved12]

I’m not batting them in the middle order, simple as that. They’ve got limitations and just don’t fit anywhere outside the top three. Best way is to play them where they belong and then build the team around them with proper hitters. For Asia cup

1- Rizwan
2- Saim
3- Babar
4- Farhan
5- Salman
6- Hasan
7- Faheem
8- M. Nawaz
9- Shaheen
10- 4, 4, dot, 6, wicket, 4
11- Abrar or Sufiyan or Wasim Junior.

Fakhar is my 12th man

 

[topspin]

You keep coming back for more, it’s honestly pathetic. Show me proof where I ever said Imam should replace Saim in all white ball cricket. Bring me anything, a hint, a line, a past post, anything at all, where I even suggested that. You won’t find it, because it doesn’t exist. Even an eight year old could come up with a better response than claiming my post was deleted because I got personal with another user. The fact that you drag in Rana and Mominsaigol to “confirm” things only further exposes who you are and what you’re really about. Stop wasting my time and have some shame, you’ve already been badly exposed here. This is my last post on the matter, I won’t engage with you further, but I can guarantee you’ll keep craving my attention and continue to tag or quote me.

The very thing that you’re accusing Rana of is exactly what you did.

Now about momin, he confirmed what you wrote a few days ago without me having to tag him.

You are disagrace to the forum for the following reasons:

- Your reading of the game is as slow as Misbah’s batting
- You preach others to be honest when you are dishonest
- You are a hypocrite

 

[topspin]

Fakhar is my 12th man

Thank you for confirming. This is exactly what I’ve been staying up for. I guess I can now go to sleep.

 

[BouncerGuy]

Yet another humiliating defeat... People seemed to be happy over useless wins against UAE and afghanistan in the first game but the reality hit badly... Team failed once again and we all saw the usual culprits and over-hyped players playing like minnows.... Salman really needs to get rid of that tulla Haris..He is a walking wicket. Also fakhar experiement is not working tbh.

 

[shamaan]

I’m not batting them in the middle order, simple as that. They’ve got limitations and just don’t fit anywhere outside the top three. Best way is to play them where they belong and then build the team around them with proper hitters. For Asia cup

1- Rizwan
2- Saim
3- Babar
4- Farhan
5- Salman
6- Hasan
7- Faheem
8- M. Nawaz
9- Shaheen
10- 4, 4, dot, 6, wicket, 4
11- Abrar or Sufiyan or Wasim Junior.

If they won't bat in the middle then no thankyou.

 

[Rana]

I suggest you finally speak the truth for once, and stick to cricket instead of wasting everyone’s time with nonsense.

Who are you to define the truth?

You said Pakistan should have Imam batting at 4 in ODI

Then you made some crap team with Sahibzada Farhan at 4

That’s not telling the truth. That’s reaching as always.

 

[Ahmed216]

Salman Ali Agha is good.

We have fans here who say Mo Haris is better than Rizwan because he doesn't play more than 5 balls.

In comparison Agha is a legend.

 

[Rana]

u’re the one who called Rizwan our best player, especially the year he won T20 Player of the Year.

What nonsense. You were never temporarily blinded, and you've disliked him from day one.

Abey kehna kya chahte ho? Why are you flip flopping like Rizwan does at the crease against spinners?

 

[Rana]

I’m not batting them in the middle order, simple as that. They’ve got limitations and just don’t fit anywhere outside the top three

So the solution is very simple, and that’s what the PCB applied.

They told the two to basically ….off

That’s the way it should be. Now deal with it!

 

[Rana]

The very thing that you’re accusing Rana of is exactly what you did.

Now about momin, he confirmed what you wrote a few days ago without me having to tag him.

You are disagrace to the forum for the following reasons:

- Your reading of the game is as slow as Misbah’s batting
- You preach others to be honest when you are dishonest
- You are a hypocrite

Very accurate

I really hope this guy stays around. I told him, no one will feel sorry for him when I am done with him.

Previously he was looking for sympathy here, trying to paint me as some bully. Well, now people will understand why I have had to become this menace towards these freshies.

 

[mominsaigol]

Very accurate

I really hope this guy stays around. I told him, no one will feel sorry for him when I am done with him.

Previously he was looking for sympathy here, trying to paint me as some bully. Well, now people will understand why I have had to become this menace towards these freshies.

He's a poster from 2006, not a freshie lol. Even if his analysis is = to one lol.

 

[HaiderAmmar]

Shaheen has far more international experience than Agha and he has won the PSL thrice as captain, the only player to do so. What more maturity do you want?

Surely, LQ winning PSL after PSL under his leadership must have something to do with his leadership style. It can’t just be because he has the right team. Why can’t PCB see that and let him tap into this qualities in international cricket?

I don’t mind a selfish captain if he wins stuff and Shaheen does, at least at the PSL level. All I am asking is give him an opportunity to showcase if he can or cannot replicate it at the international level.

If Shaheen fails as a T20 captain at the international level, hold him accountable and feel free to sack him and move towards Agha.

However, it is completely absurd and unjustifiable why Agha got a proper crack at the role before Shaheen did when he has done absolutely nothing to deserve being pushed ahead of him in the queue.

I am, of course, discounting that one series farce in 2024 where Naqvi made him captain for one series in NZ and then decided to sack him which was a crazy thing to do and I really respect Shaheen for turning up for Pakistan after that humiliation.

A lot of players with fragile egos would have retired after that disrespect but Shaheen put the country first.

Winning the cup does not necessarily mean that Shaheen is the best captain. There can be many factors which can contribute to winning the tournament.

And promoting himself over other proper batsmen may not have hurt a much in domestic cricket, but if Shaheen does the same in International cricket, then it will become unforgivable.

Agha is hands down better than Shaheen in this department of selflessness.

It seems the team is united under him, and no widespread politics have to be seen under his captaincy.

 

[Cricket Warrior]

Old problem of every Pakistani player... consistency!

 

[mominsaigol]

Old problem of every Pakistani player... consistency!

You guys bump every thread after 1 failure .

Failures are analysed and determined over 3 to 4 month seasons worth multiple series.

Not per game.

 

[Cricket Warrior]

You guys bump every thread after 1 failure .

Failures are analysed and determined over 3 to 4 month seasons worth multiple series.

Not per game.

nahi bhai we are pakistani,.. we cant wait that long to criticise lolzzz

 

[Rana]

@Caved12 you had a lot to say the other day.

Shall we lay into you today or we should wait for Sunday night?