I can't argue if someone thinks Adelaide is a turner. Virat played brilliantly, for his credit - but he is no where near even VS or Ganguly when it comes to play spin; I am not even comparing Azhar, Tendulkar, Dravid, GG or Sehwag. Lyon is a decent spinner, but if a finger spinner takes 12 against Indian batsmen on Adelaide track, instead of trying to prove someone wrong, you should study some history.
But for the other part, your post is an attempt to steal the credit of one of the best ever Test innings played against spin at Mumbai. That was a turning wicket, but you have to be poor in batting to lose by 10 wickets, batting 1st on that track. IND in 2nd innings were all out for 130 or so, ENG made 56/0 - it can't be only for Ashwin's fault, you know. England won that series because easily they were the better spin playing team - don't accept that, fine.
Regarding Tahir - he had 14 wickets in 3 Test (Bangalore, hardly bowled) at 21; and had a poor match at Delhi - that only indicates what he did in other 2 Tests.
I know Herath didn't play that Test, Kaushal took 5 in 1st innings. BUT, Herath was dropped from that Test, and SRL won't drop a bowler who had outstanding record against same team unless it made sense. You might not have noticed, in that comparison, I wrote "Herath & SRL" - that's the cover for this uncalled for argument, which I knew would be mentioned. A side chased 377/4 in 5th day, another side 3 weeks later lost 9 wickets in a session chasing 160 - we can argue that it doesn't indicates anything as both teams were not identical.
Look, this thread is regarding Yasir & indirectly his achievement vs Warne. Now, what Warne, in another thread I didn't even put him ahead of Quadir or Mushi for the short span of career & the quality of spin play these days. SAF is going through a tough patch now, but one of the reason they were No. 1 & won/drawn Series in IND/SRL/UAE was their spin playing capacity just about couple of years back; and YK, Misbah & Sarfarz is simply different class, in contemporary world when it comes to spin play; even MoHa, Asad & Ahzar as well. You are talking about the SR of current Indian batting - please check the SR of PAK team against spinners.