What's new

Young Australian cricketers still in primary school compared to Indian counterparts: Greg Chappell

karthikc

Tape Ball Star
Joined
Aug 27, 2013
Runs
787
https://m.timesofindia.com/sports/c...ts-greg-chappell/amp_articleshow/80410927.cms



MELBOURNE: Young Australian cricketers are still in "primary school" compared to their Indian counterparts, feels former India coach Greg Chappell and has urged his country's cricket board to invest in talent to avoid becoming "also-rans" in no time.

An injury-hit India sans their star players notched up an incredible 2-1 win over Australia in the four-Test series and Chappell believes it is the robust domestic structure and efforts put in by BCCI which prepares its youngsters to take on the rigours of international cricket.

Our young cricketers are weekend warriors compared to their Indian compatriots, who get challenging matchplay from the Under-16 age group onwards," Chappell wrote in a column for 'Sydney Morning Herald'.

"By the time an Indian player reaches the national XI, he has had an all-round apprenticeship that prepares him to walk into the Indian side with a reasonable chance of success.
"I am afraid, in comparison, Will Pucovski and Cameron Green are still in primary school in terms of experience."

Pointing out the huge difference in the amount spent by the two boards, Chappell said Cricket Australia "cannot be making 1960s Holdens in this age of electric cars."

"The BCCI is investing millions of dollars in budding Indian cricketers. Cricket Australia, by comparison, spends $44m dollars on the Sheffield Shield. The comparative spending gap isn't a gulf; it is the size of the Indian Ocean," he wrote.

"If Cricket Australia doesn't realise what it takes to be competitive in Test cricket and our entire cricket administration does not change its attitude on where to invest in talent, we will be also-rans in no time."

Chappell said "the skill level of Indian youth teams would embarrass some of our first-class teams".

"Their ability to deal with pressure has been cultivated in the cauldron of hard-fought matches. That level of intensity cannot be replicated in nets or against lesser opponents. The fact that India has 38 first-class teams should give you an idea of the depth of talent available," he wrote.

"What one sees when watching Indian youth and A teams is the surprising degree of maturity and an intuitive understanding of all aspects of the game. It is as rare as it is stark. So much so that one can be forgiven for thinking a team of men is playing a group of schoolboys."

Chappell said India's "level of investment from grassroots up has left the rest of the cricket world in its wake" and "the havoc that COVID-19 has wreaked on cricket coffers around the world will only widen the gap between India and the have-nots."

"For those of you who were surprised that India could deal with all that was thrown at them in this series, and could hold their nerve and win in such courageous fashion, I say: you better get used to it.
"Don't worry about India becoming the best team - they are already capable of producing the best five teams in world cricket

Chappell also felt it was a mistake to play the same bowlers in all the four Tests.
"The biggest mistake was playing the same four bowlers in every Test. For pacemen, playing four Tests in five weeks is akin to running four marathons in as many weeks. There were signs in Sydney that Mitchell Starc, in particular, was jaded," he wrote.

The former Australian batsman blamed the batsmen for the loss.

"I don't blame Tim Paine and our bowlers for this defeat. The culpability lies fairly and squarely with the batsmen, who simply didn't make enough runs on friendly wickets."

Chappell said Australia will soon need to find replacements for David Warner and Steve Smith.

"Our days of domination are past, unless we start producing a group of batsmen who bat through 125 overs in the first innings. David Warner is struggling and Steve Smith won't be around forever, so we need to find the champions who are going to replace them - and soon."

He also backed Paine, who faced a lot of criticism for his wicket-keeping and captaincy.
"For those calling out for heads to roll, especially those seeking Tim Paine's head on a pike, I say REALLY? Tim is one of only five players who can claim an automatic place in this Australian team. Sure, he didn't have his best Test series behind the stumps, but he still averaged 40 with the bat," he wrote.
 
Sorry Greg. You're not getting that coaching gig again.
 
Aussies should stop making excuses like big population, big talentpool, too rich etc.. we heard all this stuff after India won the WC in 2011 as well.

Just appreciate the performance for what it was.. a determined team effort that was partly helped by low expectations. 300 plus chases at the Gabba or anywhere are rare and it is not going to be repeated by India.
 
Last edited:
Greg could be better coach than Misbah. If we cannot get Andy or Kristen, Greg should be brought in to fill in the gap.
 
Greg could be better coach than Misbah. If we cannot get Andy or Kristen, Greg should be brought in to fill in the gap.

If you want to see Babar Azam open the bowling with Shaheen or Shaheen open the batting with Babar Azam then yeah please proceed and hire Greg as your coach. :inti
 
This blow-in, both on forums and column inches, has to end. Heartily sick of it.
 
Greg could be better coach than Misbah. If we cannot get Andy or Kristen, Greg should be brought in to fill in the gap.

Greg is very knowledgeable but has no personal skills. He doesn't understand people or how to motivate them- he will always have blow ups due to misunderstandings, misplaced assumptions and poor communication. People who have met him say he is the dullest, least inspiring guy on the planet and that is when he's out being social...
 
India with its passion and resources should always be at the top, and with the competition the young players face in a country of a billion + and role models they hope to emulate, they can't go far wrong.
That said Australia will also be near the top because of their talent, competitive nature and great domestic structure.
 
Greg is a great technical consultant. He is not a coach or manager, he completely lacks that ability.
 
I am not sure what Greg is trying to imply here. Pucovski and Green (With bat) both did reasonably well in the series. They both have 20+ FC matches under their belt which is similar to 20 odd of Shubman Gill. I am not sure what kind of apprenticeship he is referring to. Yes they can be given more A tours and maybe should play some more BBL (For pressure handling against international players) but, other than that I am not sure if these two had much to do with struggles of Aus.

If anything I think transition of the domestic FC teams of Aus to younger talent is a bit slower which can definitely be expedited and there should be some sort of a rule or procedure. Yes teams need experience as well to be competitive but, I think balance can be improved further.

As said in other threads, main problem I can think of is that batting depth of Aus cricket is at alarmingly low levels. Something needs to be done there, maybe promote some young talents to the domestic sides a bit earlier to replace some non performing past gen batsmen. There arent many decent spin options as well in longer formats.
 
Ian Chappell Blames BBL 2021 For Full-strength Australia's Test Series Loss To India

A formidable Australian side consisting of several seasoned campaigners lost the Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2-1 to a second-string Indian side who were without the services of most of their star players. After the Adelaide debacle where India were bowled out for just 36, no one had given them a chance to even draw the series, let alone win it. But Ajinkya Rahane's inexperienced side defied all odds and went on to clinch the series.

Australia's loss at the hands of an impaired Indian side garnered criticism galore. Cricketing pundits, as well as, fans slammed the hosts for their mediocre performances throughout the series. Now, former Australia captain Ian Chappell has opened up on Australia's humiliating defeat in their own backyard and also pointed out the reason behind it.

While writing for Wide World of Sports, Chappell pinned the blame for Australia's loss on never-ending Big Bash League calling it a major hindrance to the performance of the Australian Test side. The BBL 2020, which started on December 10, is going to run till February 6. The ongoing season has seen extra time being allowed to give players some relief from the bio-bubble restrictions due to which the Sheffield Shield season has been sidelined for three months.

Chappell reckoned that the BBL just gets in the way. He added that the league might be a money-spinner, but there's got to be a balance between the money-spinner and what it's producing. The Australian veteran further said that the BBL 2020 consumes more than 50 days out of the schedule which is right in the middle of the Test season. Citing the example of Marcus Harris who had not played since an Australia A match a month earlier and was included in the playing XI in place of an injured Will Pucovski, Chappel asked, 'Where do you go looking for the replacement batsmen?'

Speaking about the South Africa vs Australia 2021 tour, Chappel further asked that if it has been decided that changes need to be made against the Proteas, then the basis of selection has to be defined clearly. If the South Africa vs Australia 2021 series goes ahead as scheduled and Australian selectors want new players in the side, they will have to reply on Sheffield Shield form from November.

Chappel opined that the selectors will be forced to go back to Travis Head instead of Matthew Wade at number five. However, he added that a decent South African attack of Kagiso Rabada, Anrich Nortje and Lungi Ngidi will end up troubling Head. Chappell further said that he is not sure where else the selectors can go. The former cricketer stated that they just have to find the next guy with potential who's in form which he said is hard at the moment without Shield cricket.

Link: https://www.republicworld.com/sport...gth-australias-test-series-loss-to-india.html
 
Back
Top