What's new

‘Don’t know who’s using it’: US President Trump mocks PM Modi for funding library in Afghanistan

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,988
Upset over New Delhi’s efforts in the Afghanistan peace process, United States President Donald Trump on Wednesday took a jibe at Prime Minister Narendra Modi for funding a library in the war-torn country by suggesting that it was of no use.

Speaking on the role of countries to facilitate dialogue with Afghanistan, Trump, who was addressing his first Cabinet meeting of the year, said, “I could give you an example where I get along very well with India and Prime Minister Modi. But he is constantly telling me, he built a library in Afghanistan. Library! That’s like five hours of what we spend (in Afghanistan).”

“And he (Modi) tells me. He is very smart. We are supposed to say, oh thank you for the library. Don’t know who’s using it (the library) in Afghanistan. But it’s one of those things. I don’t like being taken advantage of,” he added.

Alleging that countries were not doing enough in the war-ravaged country, the US President emphasised the need for regional countries, including India, Russia and Pakistan, to fight the Taliban in Afghanistan. He said, “Why is not Russia there (in Afghanistan, fighting the Taliban)? Why isn’t India there? Why isn’t Pakistan there? Why are we (US) there? We are 6,000 miles away. But I don’t mind. We want to help our people. We want to help other nations.”

Trump also drew a comparison between the expenses borne by the US and other countries in the peace talks. “What other countries have done for the last long period of time is given us some soldiers and then talk about it like it’s the end of the world. And we are subsidizing their military is by billions and billions and billions of dollars, many, many, many times, what those soldiers cost that country,” he said.

Claiming that the Afghan war costs billions of dollars to the US, Trump said, “I want people to treat us fairly”. He noted that heads of countries have told him that they are involved in the peace process by “just sending some 100 or 200 soldiers”.

Asked if India’s role in Afghanistan was going to be security related, Trump said, “We are going to be doing something that is right. We are talking to the Taliban. We are talking to a lot of different people.”

“But here’s the thing, because you mentioned India. India is there. Russia is there. Russia used to be the Soviet Union. Afghanistan made it Russia because they went bankrupt fighting in Afghanistan. Russia. So you tend to look at other countries. Pakistan is there. They should be fighting. But Russia should be fighting,” he said.

“The reason Russia was in Afghanistan was that terrorists were going into Russia. They were right to be there. The problem is it was a tough fight and literally they (Russia) went bankrupt,” he added.

In 2017, India and Afghanistan had agreed to initiate an ambitious and forward-looking ‘New Development Partnership’, according to which India agreed to take up 116 high-impact community development projects to be implemented in 31 provinces of Afghanistan, including in the fields of education, health, agriculture, irrigation, drinking water, renewable energy, flood control, micro-hydropower, sports infrastructure and administrative infrastructure.

Sources had told The Indian Express that the new Indian ambassador to Afghanistan, Vinay Kumar, has been in touch with the Afghan authorities to push forward these projects.

https://indianexpress.com/article/i...ra-modi-library-afghanistan-us-india-5520986/
 
We built a library in Afghan - frikkin - istan?

Ridiculous. Why not build one back home?
 
Because your govt is doing its best to have good relations with the Afghan.

Can't even maintain a proper city street back home and we're setting up castles and roller coasters in Kandahar. Lovely. ::J
 
Did Trump just suggest that Afghans don't read? What a bigot!!!
Building libraries, schools, dams and hospitals is any day better than bombing the cities and targeting civilians, POTUS is speaking the language of Taliban here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Did Trump just suggest that Afghans don't read? What a bigot!!!
Building libraries, schools, dams and hospitals is any day better than bombing the cities and targeting civilians, POTUS is speaking the language of Taliban here.

Very well said, sir! It is a pathetic statement and is a good insight into the mind of a racist and sick individual
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can't even maintain a proper city street back home and we're setting up castles and roller coasters in Kandahar. Lovely. ::J

Thats international politics and diplomacy, my friend.. a good relation with afghan will keep pakistan on its toes..
 
Did Trump just suggest that Afghans don't read? What a bigot!!!
Building libraries, schools, dams and hospitals is any day better than bombing the cities and targeting civilians, POTUS is speaking the language of Taliban here.

I didnt interpret it that way, I thought he meant, they have bigger things to worry about (like terrorism and getting killed) than to spend their time at a library. i.e. who would be using that library?

But I can see how someone may have interpreted it differently.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Trump also drew a comparison between the expenses borne by the US and other countries in the peace talks. “What other countries have done for the last long period of time is given us some soldiers and then talk about it like it’s the end of the world. And we are subsidizing their military is by billions and billions and billions of dollars, many, many, many times, what those soldiers cost that country,” he said.

Claiming that the Afghan war costs billions of dollars to the US, Trump said, “I want people to treat us fairly”. He noted that heads of countries have told him that they are involved in the peace process by “just sending some 100 or 200 soldiers”.

Can someone tell this idiot that America created this mess by bombing an entire country just because a handful of Americans died in 9/11.

More have died in gun-crimes! yet you don't see him repealing the 2nd amendment.
 
Alleging that countries were not doing enough in the war-ravaged country, the US President emphasised the need for regional countries, including India, Russia and Pakistan, to fight the Taliban in Afghanistan. He said, “Why is not Russia there (in Afghanistan, fighting the Taliban)? Why isn’t India there? Why isn’t Pakistan there? Why are we (US) there? We are 6,000 miles away. But I don’t mind. We want to help our people. We want to help other nations.”

These are all great questions. As Trump says, they are 6,000 miles away so why ARE they there? Should give an honest answer to that one before asking for other countries to foot the bill for American military expansion.
 
US should just leave Afghanistan and let them sort out the mess themselves with nearby countries.
 
India has economy but India isn't there yet, to re-build a nation, particularly a nation like Afghanistan.

I believe as soon as America depart, China will walk in to invest in Afghanistan, China already has presence in northern Afghanistan.

On Trump, he says what he believe is correct.
 
Afghanistan should merge with Pakistan. Or be divided between Iran and Pakistan. Stronger armies control terrorism. And People will live happily ever after.
 
Afghanistan should merge with Pakistan. Or be divided between Iran and Pakistan. Stronger armies control terrorism. And People will live happily ever after.

Haha, no. Absolutely. Not.

We have enough Afghan refugees, drug addicts, extremists and Taliban coming from that side of the border. No need to embrace them. Afghanistan has never supported PAK in any political stance ever.
 
India has economy but India isn't there yet, to re-build a nation, particularly a nation like Afghanistan.

I believe as soon as America depart, China will walk in to invest in Afghanistan, China already has presence in northern Afghanistan.

On Trump, he says what he believe is correct.

India isn't in a position to rebuild Afghanistan, neither does it have any interest in doing so. Their (limited) presence will be for propaganda purposes and to cause mischief for Pakistan and perhaps introduce some Hindutva principles through reading material to go alongside the Bollywood films in what they refer to as soft power.
 
I didnt interpret it that way, I thought he meant, they have bigger things to worry about (like terrorism and getting killed) than to spend their time at a library. i.e. who would be using that library?

But I can see how someone may have interpreted it differently.

Knowing Trump I'm pretty sure he meant it the other way.
 
This is where Indians need to wise up. Their hate towards Pakistan has left them looking up to westerners such as Trump but fail to realise to the likes of Trump they are just poor backward brown people like others in the region.

Trump here is telling India and Modi, we are leaving soon. You will have to deal with the Taliban on your own now in Afghanistan and very good luck as you'll need it.
 
:)) :)) Trump is right, Modi keeps bragging to him about building some library as if he's doing America or Afghanistan a favor :))

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Donald Trump finds PM Modi's contribution to Afghanistan - which happens to be a library, useless. <br>Imagine PM Modi's contribution to India: a statue &#55357;&#56849;<br>I'd take a library any day.<a href="https://t.co/UiEoBb2QSJ">pic.twitter.com/UiEoBb2QSJ</a></p>— Zainab Sikander (@zainabsikander) <a href="https://twitter.com/zainabsikander/status/1080798274062348288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 3, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
This is where Indians need to wise up. Their hate towards Pakistan has left them looking up to westerners such as Trump but fail to realise to the likes of Trump they are just poor backward brown people like others in the region.

Trump here is telling India and Modi, we are leaving soon. You will have to deal with the Taliban on your own now in Afghanistan and very good luck as you'll need it.

Fallacy that is paraded by most BJP and RSS and their supporters on any forum that ignoring Pakistan would bear any fruits is laughable and immature, it makes them feel "tough guy", and that is all it has achieved, making them feel tough in their own backyard.

BJP and RSS will continue with same antics because it fetches them votes to be elected but everyone with a tiny brain knows that it isn't doing any favor to India, but with any supporters of extremists organisation, BJP and RSS supporters aren't any different, ignorant.

India will never be able to gain significant ground in Afghanistan unless US decided to stay and rebuild, but, as history is witness, US has no intention in rebuilding Afghanistan, again. 7000 troops aren't enough to protect and rebuild Afghanistan.

That is when China and Pakistan will come in.
 
India isn't in a position to rebuild Afghanistan, neither does it have any interest in doing so. Their (limited) presence will be for propaganda purposes and to cause mischief for Pakistan and perhaps introduce some Hindutva principles through reading material to go alongside the Bollywood films in what they refer to as soft power.

Exactly.

Even if they were interested in rebuilding they wouldn't be able to.

And as long as extremists groups keep the government of India hijacked they will continue with their petty propaganda because that is what they are limited to.
 
Can someone tell this idiot that America created this mess by bombing an entire country just because a handful of Americans died in 9/11.

More have died in gun-crimes! yet you don't see him repealing the 2nd amendment.

This is America. He's not a dictator, he can't go repealing amendments to the constitution willy nilly. For such a thing to happen would require the states and congress all on board.

As far as Afghanistan goes, OBL played W and managed to bankrupt the US. He didn't learn the lessons of the USSR and every other empire that has tried to conquer the Afghans.
 
Trump is so ignorant he makes me side with Narendra Modi.

Hey idiot, I know you've never seen the inside of a library but for a country like Afghanistan, education is critical.
 
“The reason Russia was in Afghanistan was that terrorists were going into Russia. They were right to be there. The problem is it was a tough fight and literally they (Russia) went bankrupt,” he added.
WHAT ?

Do you even bother to READ on any subject before commenting?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Trump is so ignorant he makes me side with Narendra Modi.

Hey idiot, I know you've never seen the inside of a library but for a country like Afghanistan, education is critical.

If you watch the video the main point isn't the library but India's minimal role in Afghanistan and how they aren't carrying their weight like other allies mooching off of America, he's like mocking the fact that Modi kept on bragging about some library they built as if he's doing America a favor. :))
 
Trumps often mocks Modi. He is also well known to joke about the English accent of Indian people:ma
 
Trump is right and is finally hitting nail on the head....

Everyone is mooching off America. Nato countries rely on America to prop the defence so they don’t put their share in and save billions.

Why should America spend when it doesn’t have to. They are not directly threatened by anyone. The Europeans are, and they are also now rich enough and should be looking after their own defence.

In that regard, the European gravy train is over.

In Afghanistan, India has its strategic aims but they are totally reliant on American spending billions for their presence and keeping the current regime in place. If the Americans weren’t there, India’s objectives would be terminated overnight. So trump is right in being irked by all this. Everyone has their own objectives, but it all relies on mooching off the Americans.
 
Trump is right and is finally hitting nail on the head....

Everyone is mooching off America. Nato countries rely on America to prop the defence so they don’t put their share in and save billions.

Why should America spend when it doesn’t have to. They are not directly threatened by anyone. The Europeans are, and they are also now rich enough and should be looking after their own defence.

In that regard, the European gravy train is over.

In Afghanistan, India has its strategic aims but they are totally reliant on American spending billions for their presence and keeping the current regime in place. If the Americans weren’t there, India’s objectives would be terminated overnight. So trump is right in being irked by all this. Everyone has their own objectives, but it all relies on mooching off the Americans.

I think it's quiet the opposite.
 
This is America. He's not a dictator, he can't go repealing amendments to the constitution willy nilly. For such a thing to happen would require the states and congress all on board.

As far as Afghanistan goes, OBL played W and managed to bankrupt the US. He didn't learn the lessons of the USSR and every other empire that has tried to conquer the Afghans.

Afghanistan has been conquered many times. I mean the region thats Afghanistan.

The people there just change themselves to the version of their conquerors. They were hindus under Mauryans, Buddhists under Kushans, Hindus again under Kabul Shahis and then Muslims. They also ceded every inch of Afghan land south of the durand line to British.
 
Imagine Trump is so bad that he makes darenda Modi look like the good guy :))
 
Afghanistan has been conquered many times. I mean the region thats Afghanistan.

The people there just change themselves to the version of their conquerors. They were hindus under Mauryans, Buddhists under Kushans, Hindus again under Kabul Shahis and then Muslims. They also ceded every inch of Afghan land south of the durand line to British.

The peoples you’re referring to are the Indic races, which have been pushed eastward over the centuries by the Iranic races (notably Pashtuns). These peoples made up nearly half (or more) of Peshawar (itself a Persianized Sanskrit name) until a century ago, they’re called Hindkowans and are ethnically related to Pubjabis. The father of Shahrukh Khan was one, and not a Pashtun as he claims, but then even Anil Kapoor, with the obvious Punjabi-Khatri name, claims to be a « Pathan » just because his forefathers have lived in Peshawar for some time.

The actual ethnic groups of Afghanistan (Pashtuns/Tajiks/Hazaras/Uzbeks) have been Zoroastrians and some Buddhists (Bactria/Gandhara) but were never Hindus. You have to understand that Hinduism, like Judaism, is a « racial » religion, linked with Indic races (Punjabis in the north to Tamils in the south) so it’d be weird to expect Hindus from the Iranic races.
 
Lets hope this encourages both countries to build Afganistan up.

Unfortunately whenever Indian influence builds in Afghanistan, that country automatically turns anti-Pakistan. The Indian govt like the American one will want some value for their investment, and for them hurting Pakistan's prospects is a major priority.
 
Can't even maintain a proper city street back home and we're setting up castles and roller coasters in Kandahar. Lovely. ::J

The Indian government spends tens of billions of dollars on social services in India every year. Especially impactful are the providing food at subsidized prices to the poor.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Food_Security_Act,_2013

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_welfare_in_India

It is okay if the Indian government spends a few million dollars helping Afghanistan with the expectation of better relations.
 
He didn't learn the lessons of the USSR and every other empire that has tried to conquer the Afghans.

Genghis Khan had no problem in Afghanistan, but then again his idea of pacifying a conquered country was chopping off the heads of all males higher than the wagon wheel.
 
Funny thing is that India never built a library in recent past, India funded a libraby in Jalalabad but that was many years ago.
 
So you invade Afghanistan, then it into a war zone and when you can't win blame other countries for your shortcomings?
 
Back
Top