What's new

“Babar on the upward curve now to maybe go down as the all-time greatest Pakistani batter": Ponting

How do we measure greatness when comparing Babar to the other greats of Pakistan cricket?

Winnings world cups? Winning Tests away from home? Individual stats?

In my mind his performance against difficult oppositions and testing conditions need to be taken into account before he is tagged as the GOAT Pakistani batsman.

How does he stand when compared against Zaheer Abbar, Saeed Anwar, Javed Miandad, Yousuf Youhana, Inzamam ul Haq etc ? If we simply go by runs Babar will be ahead because high average and big scores are part of today's game when bowling quality has declined, LOIs are completely played in white ball that too ODI s have two and pitch conditions are much more batting friendly. A team total 250 was a fighting score 25yrs back, a 350 does not ensure a win in today's world.
 
Yes I distinctly remember those great Pakistani umpires David Constant and Ken Palmer guiding Javed to 260 at the Oval in 1987

A bit of context.

Miandad batting on a road on which Foster broke down after one session, Dilley picked up an injury and could only bowl medium pace, and Botham was completely past it. Then on the last day, England lost just one wicket facing Imran, the young Wasim and Qadir.

But he did bat for two days, taken gEdmonds and Emburey to pieces, ending the career of one and putting a dent in the other’s reputation.
 
A bit of context.

Miandad batting on a road on which Foster broke down after one session, Dilley picked up an injury and could only bowl medium pace, and Botham was completely past it. Then on the last day, England lost just one wicket facing Imran, the young Wasim and Qadir.

But he did bat for two days, taken gEdmonds and Emburey to pieces, ending the career of one and putting a dent in the other’s reputation.

Yes I was there on the very boring last day. It was a very flat pitch I agree and I’m not saying it proved any greatness. My point I was trying to make was that this notion that he only scored because his umpires didn’t give him out lbw is a joke. Even on a flat track, randoms don’t go around scoring 260 abroad.

And before neutral umpires, every country benefitted from home umpires - that’s why neutral umpires were introduced. Even Gooch in the 1992 headingley test looked plumb a few times in his great 136*. But I don’t discount that innings, it was a great innings by any standard against a great attack on a tough pitch.
 
Miandad stats are highly inflated by home bashing thanks to home umpires. His record in Windies was poor which is why you cannot rate him in the same league as Lara, Tendulkar, Ponting, Kallis(as cricketer), Richards, Gavaskar, Greg Chappell, Steve Smith and Virat Kohli.

He is in the league of Dravid, Greame Smith and Younis Khan.

Younis was a great batesman in turning conditions.
 
In Odi and T20s yes but with so few tests played by Pakistan it may be difficult to for him to achieve it.
But undoubtedly he is currently one of the top batsman in world
 
Pakistan skipper Babar Azam said it was an honour to hear Australia great Ricky Ponting's recent claim that his best form with the bat and as a captain is still ahead of him.

Ponting was full of praise for Babar when he spoke with Sanjana Ganesan on a recent episode of The ICC Review, with the former Australia captain saying the Pakistan star was capable of breaking even more records during the remainder of his career.

"I think Babar’s still got a little bit of improvement to come, which is a pretty scary thought with what he’s been able to do, pretty much across all three formats over the last three, four years," Ponting said, after Babar won the Sir Garfield Sobers Trophy for ICC Cricketer of the Year for the first time and ODI Cricketer of the Year for the second straight year.

Ponting hails double ICC Awards winner Babar Azam
"I love watching him play. I think there’s some room for improvement, let’s hope we see it.”

Babar said it was a great thrill to hear what Ponting had said and that it would provide him with further confidence.

"You get confidence when a legendary player gives you a compliment and you try to be better," Babar told ICC Digital.

"When such a huge player passes positive comments, it adds to your confidence and you have it in your mind that such a huge player is talking good about you.

"Because these players have been through a similar stage so they know what mindset I have. They have been through similar scenarios and have knowledge of the game.

"So yes, I try to take these comments in a positive way and try to produce my best."

With Babar leading the team Pakistan reached the semi-finals of a second consecutive T20 World Cup, but Ponting feels their skipper will continue to learn and grow as a captain.

“I must admit he looked like he got a little bit flustered at times at the T20 World Cup, certainly the game against India when things got really tight at the end,” Ponting said in January.

“You could see a few of the senior players, Shadab Khan in particular, going over to him and trying to settle him down and just make him think a little bit clearer.

“But that’s the T20 game. Being a captain of the T20 team is never an easy thing to do, especially in a World Cup, and especially in a moment that was as big as that one was when things were getting really tight.”

“I’m sure with a bit more experience under his belt, like he’s done with his batting, I’m sure he’ll find the right way to lead and be a very successful captain of Pakistan.”

When questioned on his leadership style, Babar said he focuses on getting the best out of his teammates.

“My (captaincy) style is that you have to be honest with your decisions," said Babar.

“Play the team that is best for Pakistan and go with the right players.

“When you are on the field, you have to give confidence to your players. The more you give confidence the better you can get out of them.”

“What a player is thinking and how can you put him in his comfort zone, that is what matters to me.”

Babar is also comfortable collaborating and seeking advice with his teammates when necessary, naming Imam-ul-Haq, Shadab Khan and Mohammad Rizwan as players he often talks with off the field.

"The good thing about us is we all are united," Babar said.

"That’s a plus point for our team. When someone is down, he will already have a player to support him.

"That’s a positive sign for us as a team. It’s been five or six years that we are playing together so we know each other’s nature and mindset.

"Whenever there is such a situation we embrace each other and give confidence to ourselves."

ICC
 
Back
Top