What's new

“Mohammad Rizwan is better than Rishabh Pant these days" : Aaqib Javed

Hassaan HS

Tape Ball Regular
Joined
Mar 11, 2021
Runs
361
'Pant is aggressive but gets out after hitting couple of big shots. Rizwan takes the responsibility': Ex-Pakistan pacer

Comparisons have been common in any form of sport - between two rival nations, between two generations or between players from the same team vying for a similar spot in the set up. Rishabh Pant and Mohammad Rizwan have been two stalwarts of modern era cricket. While the Indian rose the fame with his aggressive batting and heroics across formats, Rizwan has not just become a key member of the Pakistan side in all formats, he is also part of the leadership group.

With both Pant and Rizwan being wicketkeeper-batters, their comparison among veterans and analysts have been freshly brewing and former Pakistan pacer Aqib Javed joined the bandwagon earlier this week, having his say on the debate during an interview with ARY News’ show Sports Room.

Javed picked his compatriot over Pant, opining that Rizwan take more responsibility in finishing off games rather than his Indian counterpart, whom he did hail as a skilful player but added that he tends to get out after hitting just a few big shots.

“Rizwan is better than Pant these days. There is no doubt that Pant is an extremely skillful player but the way Rizwan takes the responsibility, Pant is well behind him. It is often said that Pant is an aggressive player, but the aggressiveness doesn’t mean to hit a couple of big shots and got out but to stay at the crease, fight, and finish the game,” Javed said. The former cricketer also reiterated his opinion on comparing Shaheen Afridi and Jasprit Bumrah again, during the interview.

“I now think that Shaheen is better than Bumrah because when Shaheen came into the international circuit Bumrah had already established himself and the critics used to say that Bumrah is doing well in Tests, T20Is, and so but now Shaheen has proved he is even better and has more capacity than Bumrah,” he said.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/cric...akistan-pacer-aqib-javed-101651916338016.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Think since LQ win - Aaqib making some bold statements :)
 
“Rizwan is better than Pant these days. There is no doubt that Pant is an extremely skillful player but the way Rizwan takes the responsibility, Pant is well behind him. It is often said that Pant is an aggressive player, but the aggressiveness doesn’t mean to hit a couple of big shots and got out but to stay at the crease, fight, and finish the game,” Javed said.

Hard to disagree with him here. :inti
 
Statements to follow in next few days :

Mohsin Khan is a better bowler than Shaheen Shah Afridi these days.- Gautam Gambhir


Ayush Badoni is a better hitter than Asif Ali these days. - Gautam Gambhir

:inti
 
Statements to follow in next few days :

Mohsin Khan is a better bowler than Shaheen Shah Afridi these days.- Gautam Gambhir


Ayush Badoni is a better hitter than Asif Ali these days. - Gautam Gambhir

:inti

My IQ is better than Shahid Afridi these days - Gautam Gambhir

:inti
 
My IQ is better than Shahid Afridi these days - Gautam Gambhir

:inti

This one he is right though as he has shown with his captaincy skills and now that he has moved into the coaching too. Afridi not really all that good with IQ as apparent by fact that he was openly chewing the ball on ground and when he was asked then he said that he was smelling the ball on ground. :))
 
This one he is right though as he has shown with his captaincy skills and now that he has moved into the coaching too. Afridi not really all that good with IQ as apparent by fact that he was openly chewing the ball on ground and when he was asked then he said that he was smelling the ball on ground. :))

Well that's Afridi for you. :sa :inti
 
I don’t know why pant compared to anybody . He has a role in test cricket and he is doing that v well in test cricket .

In odi /t20 pant is slowly evolving . His role was not yet clearly defined . The indian team in odi has been struggling cos of lack of powerhitters . Him and pandya are perhaps the ones who will always be criticized for getting out . But I see them playing selflessly and am happy that they try . Prefer a 15 ball 25 from pant to a 50 ball 50 from kohli ( v much like sehwag - pant is an impact player . Avg does not matter but strike rate does )
 
I don’t know why pant compared to anybody . He has a role in test cricket and he is doing that v well in test cricket .

In odi /t20 pant is slowly evolving . His role was not yet clearly defined . The indian team in odi has been struggling cos of lack of powerhitters . Him and pandya are perhaps the ones who will always be criticized for getting out . But I see them playing selflessly and am happy that they try . Prefer a 15 ball 25 from pant to a 50 ball 50 from kohli ( v much like sehwag - pant is an impact player . Avg does not matter but strike rate does )

Kohli has a strike rate of 137 in T20s compared to Pant's 125. Sehwag was an impact player on the field, whereas Pant is an impact player only on forums or papers especially in LOIs he has done nothing special yet. Other players don't even get endless chances which Pant is getting. :inti
 
Kohli has a strike rate of 137 in T20s compared to Pant's 125. Sehwag was an impact player on the field, whereas Pant is an impact player only on forums or papers especially in LOIs he has done nothing special yet. Other players don't even get endless chances which Pant is getting. :inti

Tells us that Pant is a special player which is why he gets so many chance.

This was Rohit Sharma in ODIs in first five years :-

Matches - 88
Bat AVG - 30
Bat S/R - 78

https://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/e...3;spanval1=span;template=results;type=batting
 
I don’t know why pant compared to anybody . He has a role in test cricket and he is doing that v well in test cricket .

In odi /t20 pant is slowly evolving . His role was not yet clearly defined . The indian team in odi has been struggling cos of lack of powerhitters . Him and pandya are perhaps the ones who will always be criticized for getting out . But I see them playing selflessly and am happy that they try . Prefer a 15 ball 25 from pant to a 50 ball 50 from kohli ( v much like sehwag - pant is an impact player . Avg does not matter but strike rate does )

It looked like role was pretty clear from the get go which was to be a hard hitting wicket keeper batter. In fact, Rizwan's role was always in question as to what number he should play at. We still have people criticizing him for opening
 
Pant better in tests and Odis, Rizwan better in t20is but again he has a strike rate of 128 in t20s so he's basically an accumulator.
We don't need an accumulator at all.
 
It looked like role was pretty clear from the get go which was to be a hard hitting wicket keeper batter. In fact, Rizwan's role was always in question as to what number he should play at. We still have people criticizing him for opening


True - hard hitting batter and keeper . Has fulfilled his potential in tests . What happens in odi and t20s ?
Muddled captaincy has been an issue with indian odi and t20 . If you go through the no of players tried at no 4-5-6 in last 4 years , it’s no surprise u see nothing special . Pant is ideally a no 3-4 bat in odi and a floater in t20 . But team mgt seldom gave him a consistent run in roles suited to him . He is not a Yuvraj style hitter . He is more In the mould of romesh kalu / jayasurya combined . He will do well with field restrictions but sending him in last 15 overs is actually gonna cos him to hole out . His sixes are always 60-70 metres and not the long sixes . His mode of dismissals are always catch out at boundary .

Rohit is a better odi /t20 captain and you will see better performance from pant under him .
 
Pant is not sehwag class . He is more romesh kalu type . You need a ranatunga to extract the best out of him . Our captain kohli is too rigid to get best out of him . Under Rohit , hoping to get better results.
 
Pant is not sehwag class . He is more romesh kalu type . You need a ranatunga to extract the best out of him . Our captain kohli is too rigid to get best out of him . Under Rohit , hoping to get better results.

Romesh Kaluwitharana? Pant fans won't like this comparison. :misbah :inti
 
This one he is right though as he has shown with his captaincy skills and now that he has moved into the coaching too. Afridi not really all that good with IQ as apparent by fact that he was openly chewing the ball on ground and when he was asked then he said that he was smelling the ball on ground. :))

Nailed it .
 
Romesh Kaluwitharana? Pant fans won't like this comparison. :misbah :inti

Romesh was highly impactful . In t20 , pant has to be used in that manner . Being left handed , can dominate spinners and fast bowlers alike , he is best suited as a floater who can be sent to disrupt the bowlers .

Samson is more valuable a player in t20 - should replace Kohli at no 3

India does not have too many powerhitters and indias best bet for any t20 /odi win is a strong bowling show coupled with a decent battling outing .

Ipl has thrown a few hitters - tewatia , patidar etc but none of Yuvraj class . India is trying to make pant a yuvi style guy but pant is not gonna destroy attacks .

There are two khans - SRK from chennai and sarfaraaz khan from mumbai who have an x factor : again they have not been included in teams due to whatever reasons .
India will go into World Cup with a lower middle order of pant , karthik , sky/ Ayer , pandya hoping that Rohit and rahul will give them good starts .

India will be in last 4 as usual . Will exit in semis .
 
Romesh was highly impactful . In t20 , pant has to be used in that manner . Being left handed , can dominate spinners and fast bowlers alike , he is best suited as a floater who can be sent to disrupt the bowlers .

Samson is more valuable a player in t20 - should replace Kohli at no 3

India does not have too many powerhitters and indias best bet for any t20 /odi win is a strong bowling show coupled with a decent battling outing .

Ipl has thrown a few hitters - tewatia , patidar etc but none of Yuvraj class . India is trying to make pant a yuvi style guy but pant is not gonna destroy attacks .

There are two khans - SRK from chennai and sarfaraaz khan from mumbai who have an x factor : again they have not been included in teams due to whatever reasons .
India will go into World Cup with a lower middle order of pant , karthik , sky/ Ayer , pandya hoping that Rohit and rahul will give them good starts .

India will be in last 4 as usual . Will exit in semis .

Both haven't made any impact in the IPL. In fact, Sarfaraz is an average white ball player even in domestics (he is an excellent red ball player though). X Factor, Z factor counts to nothing if you don't perform.
 
I think Rizwan is better than Pant.

I know Pant played some good knocks in Australia but Rizwan has done much better overall.
 
Romesh was highly impactful . In t20 , pant has to be used in that manner . Being left handed , can dominate spinners and fast bowlers alike , he is best suited as a floater who can be sent to disrupt the bowlers .

Samson is more valuable a player in t20 - should replace Kohli at no 3

India does not have too many powerhitters and indias best bet for any t20 /odi win is a strong bowling show coupled with a decent battling outing .

Ipl has thrown a few hitters - tewatia , patidar etc but none of Yuvraj class . India is trying to make pant a yuvi style guy but pant is not gonna destroy attacks .

There are two khans - SRK from chennai and sarfaraaz khan from mumbai who have an x factor : again they have not been included in teams due to whatever reasons .
India will go into World Cup with a lower middle order of pant , karthik , sky/ Ayer , pandya hoping that Rohit and rahul will give them good starts .

India will be in last 4 as usual . Will exit in semis .

Pant is not fit to tie Raina's shoelaces in shorter formats let alone Yuvi lol. IPL has failed to create even one batsman with a calibre of Yuvraj Singh. :inti
 
Pant is not fit to tie Raina's shoelaces in shorter formats let alone Yuvi lol. IPL has failed to create even one batsman with a calibre of Yuvraj Singh. :inti

And one weird thing I remember is yuvraj was never able to crack it in ipl. Yuvraj was always better in international cricket.
 
Pant,What’s going on these days
The challenge for you is to promote Aqib as some genius cricketing brain and criticize his stance on the Pant v Rizwan at the same time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Even with a dodgy knee Pant is better than Rizwan. Rizz will have to settle for 2nd best current Wk batsman, and maybe 3rd soon enough if Jamie Smith continues to deliver on his promise
 
Back
Top