You asked why India is not able to become prosperous like it was during hindu rules in the past, despite having a hindu rule.
Not to mention the poster you quoted is among a few who are adamant that China is to replace the US as the next global superpower and get you still saw a net migration of 350000 + away from China in 2023 alone.
I have been honing my skill in having conversations with people for whom logic is not their forte. This was just my practice session.
I haven't browsed the full thread but where is this data of 350k from China. Is it migration or people acquiring citizenships of other countries as per the OP here?
Many Chinese nationals are crossing illegally into US at the Mexico border in Arizona.
There are many Indians doing the same.
Indians are also doing the same. Mostly Punjabis entering US. Their final destination is Canada though.
"One of the highest', not 'The highest"
I'm assuming you have actually completed high school here so forgive me if I'm wrong.
His expertise revolves around chanting Hindutva in every post
Lol. Try again.
Lol.
People migrating from third world to first world is normal.
I wish India had dual citizenship. Throwing Indian passport in dustbin is too harsh to say. You surrender the passport to the nearest embassy and immediately apply for the OCI card. We still have family in India.
True. Surrendering that green card was one of the hardest decisions I've taken. Not that I regret it but I wonder if I've done wrong by my daughter.
6 milion+ from Iron brotherland agree with you
Is it better to be dual citizen and pay tax to get your other country bombed like no t'rrow?
What's your circumstances brother? Sometimes Indian sometimes Canadian? Is there paperwork that confirms that flexibility?
Yeah I agree. It has pros and cons but making people eventually cut off their links to their home country is harsh. Most people move abroad to help others back home too.
still can't play the delivery huh? don't worry, its very common.
@Champ_Pal also
I ask again. what does citizenship mean?
Sorry you mentioned in the other thread this question was for me but it's for champ pal.
It was for both of you.
Yes, that's why I tagged @Rajdeep, @Romali_rotti, and @gani999. I might also tag @rpant_gabba, as he seems to be the one feeling most guilty about giving up his Indian citizenship.
On this forum it's funny coz those people are usually the ones who are hyper nationalist and are those who have a crazy vendetta against Brit Pakistanis
It’s true for Brit Pakistanis as well, they are hyper nationalists compared to ones in Pak..
You statement is half correct and other part is wrong.
Why you tagging me, didn't you say earlier I wasn't Indian, so per you I ain't NRIYes, that's why I tagged @Rajdeep, @Romali_rotti, and @gani999. I might also tag @rpant_gabba, as he seems to be the one feeling most guilty about giving up his Indian citizenship.
Yes in many cases that's true.
Interesting. My experience is the opposite. I spent most of the years from around 2006 to 2014 out of India - the last 4 years in the States. I'm deeply grateful for it - allowed me to experience a work environment that encouraged ownership, experimentation and equity as well as a lifestyle that was just not possible for even an upper middle-class guy in India. I returned to India in 2014 and well the change in the last 10 years has been incredible - both in terms of work opportunities as well as lifestyle.
Over the past few year many of my extended family moved back to Pakistan. I say back, even though many of those moving were born here. Post covid remote working gave them the opportunity to get paid in pounds but not need to be in the country. The elders had built up small assets by UK standards but given the disparity in currencies some modest rental income in pounds can go a long way in Pakistan.
The religious obligations aren’t from society, if anything India is way more neutral now than it was in the 1990s, it’s more from family etc.
Don't want to sound too virtuous. I moved back for parent and in-law health reasons primarily not because I loved India or saw some incredible opportunity here to participate in the growth story. It's worked out pretty well for professional, social and family stuff and I've declined an opportunity to move back since.
Yes, you have done wrong for your child. But there is always opportunity to send her abroad for studies.
Is it really? if the the two countries head butt and make you chose?
To be fair if Brit Pakistanis were in charge of Pakistan now, Kashmir wouldve been liberated a long time ago.
I don't really understand the question.
I'm asking,
Even those who disagree will not collude with the enemy
I'm asking what do dual citizens do when they have to?
Or like Canada harboring Khalistani's terrorists, SL tamil terrorists and bengali muslim terrorists
Thank you for the additional examples. Many Indians still seek to move to Canada despite the country harbouring what they call terrorists.
Yeah, most of us do.
Where is the dance?
That was not the question and you know it. Sad really.
What was the question?
What is the source of this map? How many are Afghan migrants who have been repatriated?
Wrong.
Pakistanis don't make the claim, because they cannot.
I can only imagine how intolerable these guys must have been in the 80's when they were living off uncle sam's largesse pretending that it was all their own making.
www.xe.com
Irrelevant whether Pakistanis can or cannot, fact it, they do not. In the same way Pakistanis barely talk about the British rule, unlike Indians who cannot let go of their past.
They do not, because they CANNOT.
That right, Pakistanis cannot claim Pakistan is sound, never did. Indians on the other hand........
Because some indians are progressing at a faster pace than the progress of the country. Same reason why people move to a richer neighbourhood when they get richer.
Flee is when you are escaping persecution. When you are upper middle class, then you want better roads, less crowd, more access to beach.
Forget Europe. It is toast.
What about Gibraltar?
Unless you want to live on a rock.
