What's new

Ashes 2017 - Australia’s Ashes selection takes a twist

giri26

T20I Debutant
Joined
Apr 1, 2009
Runs
8,468
Post of the Week
1
The second round of the Sheffield Shield concluded on Monday and some new names have been thrown into Australia’s Ashes selection mix.

There were few performances which stood out more than that of 24-year-old Cameron Bancroft. The wicketkeeping spot was seen as a battle between Peter Nevill, Matthew Wade and Alex Carey, but Bancroft might have put himself into contention with a pair of brilliant batting performances.

Bancroft being an opener for Western Australia gives him an edge over the others and with Matt Renshaw struggling for runs, his chances suddenly look bright.

The fact he scored runs against Australia’s Test attack makes it all the more impressive.

The other young player who impressed was Jake Lehmann. Lehmann scored both a century and a fifty to make things interesting. Callum Ferguson also got an unbeaten 182 to put himself in contention.

Glenn Maxwell will breathe a sigh of relief as he finally found some form. He scored back-to-back fifties, while Shaun Marsh also continued some good form to keep his chances alive.

Australian captain Steve Smith scored a hundred and a fifty, while first drop Usman Khawaja did well enough to remain one of the top run-scorers in the competition.

The team management will also be happy to see Peter Handscomb scoring runs as he is an important member of the middle order. The biggest disappointment of the first two rounds was the performance of young opener Matt Renshaw.

Renshaw came into the competition needing runs after going through a tough period with the bat. With four failures in a row, his chances of making the Ashes squad look bleak.

The Australian bowlers looked in fine form though, with Mitchell Starc topping the bowling charts. He became the first bowler to claim two hat-tricks in a first-class match in Australia. Meanwhile, Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon all looked in fine touch with the ball.

Chadd Sayers and Jake Ball both had a good game and have been among the wickets in the first two rounds. It will be interesting to see if New South Wales will rest Starc and Cummins for Round 3 with the first Test approaching.

Undoubtedly the biggest winners from Round 2 were Bancroft and Lehmann. The performance of Bancroft, in particular, puts pressure on the selectors to pick him ahead of Renshaw.

Bancroft also has a double hundred in county cricket as an opener just a couple of months ago and he has been safe behind the stumps as well. He surely has emerged as the dark horse for the Ashes selection, given playing him as an opener also means Australia can play an extra batsman or a bowler at No.7.

Lehmann played with great freedom in both the innings with the bat and scored runs freely. He puts his name up for selection and the No.6 spot might not be an as easy decision as it was thought before the start of the Shield season.

The spot, which was seen as a toss-up between Hilton Cartwright and Glenn Maxwell, doesn’t seem straightforward. With young Lehmann showing tremendous form with the bat and Shaun Marsh also in contention, things are very interesting indeed in the lead-up to the Ashes.
 
Renshaw will be picked for the first 2 Tests at least in my opinion. He has done well on some tough tours and deserves a shot at home.

I think they will go for Neville to keep. Wade has been declining for years now & just getting worse.
I hope they go for Lehmann at #6 but he'll need to keep scoring as he's coming from far down the selectors list.
Bancroft might be offered a #6 spot if he keeps it up.

1) Warner
2) Renshaw
3) Kwahaja
4) Smith
5) Handscomb
6) Lehmann
7) Neville
8) Starc
9) Cummins
10) Lyon
11) Hazlewood
 
The number 6 needs to bowl at least 15 overs of seam each day to keep the three strike quicks rested and quick.
 
I think, AUS will play Shaun Marsh, for a bit of experience in middle order. Probably Renshaw will be dropped and either Khwaja opens or they keep with Bancroft & open with him. But unlikely - Bancroft has only about 80 catches in 65 FC matches, mostly in AUS which probably tells about his keeping.

Mitch Marsh isn't bowling this season, so he is out - AUS, might like to play an all-rounder, but Cartwright isn't bowling much and he is a batting failure in this Shield season; I think AUS will go with 6-1-4 formation. They'll play one young batsman - not sure if it's Lehman, Bancroft, Renshaw or Farguson; I'll take J Lehman.

Bowling selects themselves if all are fit.

Warner, Khawaja
Smith, S Marsh, Handscombe, Lehman
Neville
Starc, Cummins, Lyon, H'wood

Can't say absolutely sure about 5-0, but one thing probably certain - Poms are not winning any Test. I was hoping big things from Finn :(
 
The number 6 needs to bowl at least 15 overs of seam each day to keep the three strike quicks rested and quick.

Any potential all-rounder, I think Micth stopped bowling this summer, while Cartwright is bowling lesser & lesser. This kid Lehman can bowl a bit, but not aware how good he is.
 
Lehman is a hack with the bat, the English seamers would work him over in 10 balls.
 
Lehmann is very much a part time bowler.

If Oz want to use Starc & Cummins at full tilt [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] may be right and someone like Stoinis, Cartwright or even (god forbid) Maxwell come into calculations if they show the slightest bit of form in the last round to play as an allrounder. In that case, Lehmann will wait until 3rd test if others are failing.
[MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] Lehmann is very much an occasional, part-time bowler. Maybe 2 overs a game while nothing is happening or a draw is certain & you want to rest your quicks in a FC game kind of guy.

There is no way Renshaw will be dropped. He has a good record in Australia and he's shown the ability to fight & learn in Asia, selectors are invested in him long term and he shows signs of growth as a batsman. Pakistan might drop him for FC form but this is Oz, he will be given the opportunity to defend his test spot based on his international form line & the desperate need to stop chopping & changing.

PS. Sean Marsh is further from Oz selection than ever. he'll need a double ton in FC just to get in the conversation.
 
Cartwright is a much better batsman than Lehmann and one match doesn't change that.
 
My gut feel is that Bancroft will be keeping.
Haven't seen much of Bancroft keep, is he at par with per say Handscomb or Wade?

It's unfortunate Whiteman is out due to injury. I feel he would have had a genuine shout for test selection if he was still fit.
 
I think, AUS will play Shaun Marsh, for a bit of experience in middle order. Probably Renshaw will be dropped and either Khwaja opens or they keep with Bancroft & open with him. But unlikely - Bancroft has only about 80 catches in 65 FC matches, mostly in AUS which probably tells about his keeping.

Mitch Marsh isn't bowling this season, so he is out - AUS, might like to play an all-rounder, but Cartwright isn't bowling much and he is a batting failure in this Shield season; I think AUS will go with 6-1-4 formation. They'll play one young batsman - not sure if it's Lehman, Bancroft, Renshaw or Farguson; I'll take J Lehman.

Bowling selects themselves if all are fit.

Warner, Khawaja
Smith, S Marsh, Handscombe, Lehman
Neville
Starc, Cummins, Lyon, H'wood

Can't say absolutely sure about 5-0, but one thing probably certain - Poms are not winning any Test. I was hoping big things from Finn :(

You never know, in a game of cricket.

S Marsh, Handscombe, Lehman

That middle order has holes if Anderson/Broad can exploit it and do not let the tail rebuild it.

These ashes will decide whether Cook/Root are ATG material or not.
 
Haven't seen much of Bancroft keep, is he at par with per say Handscomb or Wade?

It's unfortunate Whiteman is out due to injury. I feel he would have had a genuine shout for test selection if he was still fit.

Whiteman would have been a monty.

Bancroft's keeping isn't bad. He's much better than Handscomb and he's probably about the same level as current Wade (who has improved a lot).
Bancroft was the first choice keeper for Australia's U19 team and kept for WA in the one day cup and has also kept in BBL to Brad Hogg.

I wouldn't want him as the long term keeper because I feel it will hold his batting back but given how unimpressive Wade and Nevill have been he has to be in consideration.
 
You never know, in a game of cricket.



That middle order has holes if Anderson/Broad can exploit it and do not let the tail rebuild it.

These ashes will decide whether Cook/Root are ATG material or not.

Can happen many things, but I can’t see Poms taking 20 wickets effectively even with Stokes in it. AUS batting in AUS may be inexperienced, but lots of quality there. Also, Poms will face Aussie bowlers, Aussies will face Poms - that’s 2 different universe we are talking.
 
Lehmann is very much a part time bowler.

If Oz want to use Starc & Cummins at full tilt [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] may be right and someone like Stoinis, Cartwright or even (god forbid) Maxwell come into calculations if they show the slightest bit of form in the last round to play as an allrounder. In that case, Lehmann will wait until 3rd test if others are failing.
[MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] Lehmann is very much an occasional, part-time bowler. Maybe 2 overs a game while nothing is happening or a draw is certain & you want to rest your quicks in a FC game kind of guy.

There is no way Renshaw will be dropped. He has a good record in Australia and he's shown the ability to fight & learn in Asia, selectors are invested in him long term and he shows signs of growth as a batsman. Pakistan might drop him for FC form but this is Oz, he will be given the opportunity to defend his test spot based on his international form line & the desperate need to stop chopping & changing.

PS. Sean Marsh is further from Oz selection than ever. he'll need a double ton in FC just to get in the conversation.

Cartwright’s FC stats are very good, may be opening with him wasn’t a good idea. He should be selected based on his overall FC stats particularly for the reason Junaids mentioned.
 
Australia should not make the mistake of playing bootleg allrounders just for the sake of it. They'd be gifting England a wicket and free runs. Marsh is the only one capable but he hasn't proven himself.
 
Cartwright is a much better batsman than Lehmann and one match doesn't change that.

Probably true but he couldn't put bat on ball in India. He looked a nervous wreck. And though a different format, I am not sure if Australia will be willing to trust him in Ashes, where the pressure will be much more. He may have the skill but does he have the mettle?
 
Last edited:
Probably true but he couldn't put bat on ball in India. He looked a nervous wreck. And though a different format, I am not sure if Australia will be willing to trust him in Ashes, where the pressure will be much more. He may have the skill but does he have the mettle?

Cartwright isn't even a first choice one day player for Western Australia. I have no idea why he was selected to play ODIs in India let alone open the batting,
 
Australia should not make the mistake of playing bootleg allrounders just for the sake of it. They'd be gifting England a wicket and free runs. Marsh is the only one capable but he hasn't proven himself.

You rate Mitch Marsh like I do?
 
Any potential all-rounder, I think Micth stopped bowling this summer, while Cartwright is bowling lesser & lesser. This kid Lehman can bowl a bit, but not aware how good he is.

Mitchell Marsh will resume bowling later in the summer.
 
Mitchell Marsh will resume bowling later in the summer.

Yup Mitch Marsh is the only competent all-rounder at the moment but again he isn't bowling until December. He is currently playing for WA as a batsman alone.
 
Whiteman would have been a monty.

Bancroft's keeping isn't bad. He's much better than Handscomb and he's probably about the same level as current Wade (who has improved a lot).
Bancroft was the first choice keeper for Australia's U19 team and kept for WA in the one day cup and has also kept in BBL to Brad Hogg.

I wouldn't want him as the long term keeper because I feel it will hold his batting back but given how unimpressive Wade and Nevill have been he has to be in consideration.

Keeper or not, I feel Bancroft is a good option to bat in the middle or the top order for Australia. Keeping is just an added incentive. Hope he gets a chance to play sometime.
 
Yup Mitch Marsh is the only competent all-rounder at the moment but again he isn't bowling until December. He is currently playing for WA as a batsman alone.

Mitch Marsh is talanted. He'll come good if he is invested in. His spell in county cricket next year will be vital for his development.
 
Back
Top