What's new

"Can't compare Indian players with Pakistan players because Pakistan has more talent" : Abdul Razzaq

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,133
"Can't compare Indian players with Pakistan players because Pakistan has more talent" : Abdul Razzaq

Pakistan has more talent than India, can’t compare players of both countries: Abdul Razzaq

Former Pakistan all-rounder Abdul Razzaq believes that Pakistani cricketers are more talented than their Indian counterparts and said that players from his country should not be compared to Indian cricketers.

Razzaq also said that India skipper Virat Kohli and Pakistan's Babar Azam are "completely different players” and should not be compared to each other.

"Firstly, we should not say such a thing [compare Virat Kohli with Babar Azam]. You can't compare Indian players with Pakistan players because Pakistan has more talent. If you look at our history, we have so many great players who we can draw comparisons with like Mohammad Yousuf, Inzamam-ul-Haq, Saeed Anwar, Javed Miandad, Zaheer Abbas and Ijaz Ahmed," Razzaq said during an interview with Cricket Pakistan.

"Virat Kohli and Babar Azam are completely different players. If we want to compare the two, then it's important to hold matches between Pakistan and India and then judge who is a better player," he added.

"Virat Kohli is a good player and he has performed well against Pakistan. I have nothing against him but if Indians don't compare their players with Pakistan, then we shouldn't do that as well," he added.

India recently secured a spot in the final of the ICC World Test Championship after defeating England 3-1 in the four-match series. The Kohli-led team sits atop the men's Test rankings while Pakistan is placed fifth.

In ODI and T20I rankings as well, India ranks higher than their arch-rivals, Pakistan. India ranks second in both ODI and T20I rankings whereas, Pakistan hold the sixth and fourth position in the ODI and T20I rankings respectively. Moreover, India has never lost to Pakistan in the World Cup.

Praising Azam, Razzaq said the player is very talented and will go on to break all the records.

"He [Babar Azam] played under me for five to six years at ZTBL and I never dropped him as captain. He was very talented and a very decent batsman. He proved himself [on the world stage] and is now the number one batsman. If we look after him properly, he will go on to break all the records," he said.

Razzaq feels that local coaches should be hired as they have a better understanding of the players.

"I don't think hiring foreign coaches is the right thing to do. There is a communication gap between players and the coaching staff where foreigners are hired. Whereas, local coaches have a better understanding of players which is why they should be backed instead of experimenting with foreign coaches," he said.

https://zeenews.india.com/cricket/p...s-of-both-countries-abdul-razzaq-2346998.html
 
Last edited:
That’s a novel excuse to make India play Pakistan. And I thought I have seen every excuse.
 
From where does so much delusion come for this guy?
 
Razzaq Savage with the bat and now with his mouth

Ash Kar mera bhai!
 
Kudos for him being consistent. He is a one consistent delusional guy. He one said Shehzad has more talent than Sachin ever had...

He knows such "awful", "silly" praises put him in good books, in many other delusional people of the country.
 
From a scale of 0 to bohut (1), the talent levels of nations are as follows:

Pakistan: bohut
India: 0.873
England: 0.795
New Zealand: 0.644
Australia: 0.612
Sri Lanka: 0.531
 
From a scale of 0 to bohut (1), the talent levels of nations are as follows:

Pakistan: bohut
India: 0.873
England: 0.795
New Zealand: 0.644
Australia: 0.612
Sri Lanka: 0.531


Haha this is accurate.

Razzaq always makes really weird cringe statements. A super talented guy who didn’t even fulfill his own promise is hyping up blatantly average players.
 
Razzaq should be made the Pakistan team coach. He won domestic treble.

Misbah underestimates Pakistan players' ability.
 
From a scale of 0 to bohut (1), the talent levels of nations are as follows:

Pakistan: bohut
India: 0.873
England: 0.795
New Zealand: 0.644
Australia: 0.612
Sri Lanka: 0.531

Bangladesh: Sehwag's rating
 
Oozing with talunt. No wonder a legend like muhammad musa was dropped after a few games.
 
Whatever happened to turning the likes of Faheem Ashraf in to power hitters in 2-3 days? Someone keep this man busy.
 
Talent is an overused word in Pakistan cricket.

I don't think there is as much talent as the likes of Razzaq think there is.

If there was so much talent then we would be top or thereabouts in all of the rankings.

We used to produce incredible, world-class cricketers, but nowadays there is a lot of mediocrity.
 
Last edited:
From a scale of 0 to bohut (1), the talent levels of nations are as follows:

Pakistan: bohut
India: 0.873
England: 0.795
New Zealand: 0.644
Australia: 0.612
Sri Lanka: 0.531

Afghanistan has bohut bohut talent. Needs infrastructure support.
 
From a scale of 0 to bohut (1), the talent levels of nations are as follows:

Pakistan: bohut
India: 0.873
England: 0.795
New Zealand: 0.644
Australia: 0.612
Sri Lanka: 0.531

I beg to disagree. It should be accurate to one millionth. Allow me

Pakistan: 0.999999 bohut
India: 0.873676
England: 0.795394
New Zealand: 0.644765
Australia: 0.612582
Sri Lanka: 0.531427

:akhtar
 
Last edited:
A majority of our ex players are as clueless as the PCB when it comes to understanding modern day cricket.
 
It all depends what you mean by talent.

I prefer the talent in batsmen to score 100s and bowlers to take 5-wicket hauls consistently to win matches - not seen that kind of talent in Pakistan in ages, with the exception of Babar.

Otherwise even Imran Nazir and Umar Akmal had talent to play good-looking shots in a score of 13.
 
Talent without its proper management is meaningless. Razzaq is only playing to the gallery, nothing else. I wonder if he is angling for an entry into politics from IK’s party? 😜
 
Talent without output is nothing So it means jack to be talented

Ps i dont agree pakistan has talent anyway Not anymore like it use to
 
Even if you ignore the performance over a period of time, Talent should dazzle you with occasional brilliance. That was the USP of Pakistan for decades. Incredibly talented players that can take the game away. Probably Shaheen is the only guy that fits the bill in this team. Babar doesn't dazzle you. He's almost an Indian batsman from 2000s. Consistent runs without that killer instinct.
 
Would recommend everyone to watch the actual interview.

It’s a clickbait misrepresentation of what Razzaq said by the youtube channel, Cricket Pakistan - I listened to the interview and his main point was we need to get out of this inferiority complex of comparing Pakistani cricketers to Indians.

Pakistan mai talent raha hai, why do we not compare Babar to Yousuf or Inzi but only to Kohli?

Razzaq is advocating an attitude shift. Enough of this meekness from fans and players where we don’t have any self worth.

The rest of the interview will be drowned out in the noise but it was quite good, Razzaq talked about emerging cricketers and how when picking his KPK team he sidelined any cricketer who he felt would perform here and there but go missing in the playoffs/knockouts. Strong mental toughness is key.
 
Last edited:
Why are people mocking him? Can't people have their own opinions?

Even if what he says has little bias, who amongst us is the perfect objective judge?

And Babar is better than our Kaptaan.
 
Why are people mocking him? Can't people have their own opinions?

Even if what he says has little bias, who amongst us is the perfect objective judge?

And Babar is better than our Kaptaan.

It’s very sad to see even Pakistanis hurling derogatory comments about a servant of the country. We don’t respect our heroes, then wonder why we never seem to be able to develop any more.
 
Why are people mocking him? Can't people have their own opinions?

Even if what he says has little bias, who amongst us is the perfect objective judge?

And Babar is better than our Kaptaan.

Mocking him is also an opinion. Ridiculous opinions have always been mocked in history. He has a right to opinion, other people have a right to comment on that opinion
 
Would recommend everyone to watch the actual interview.

It’s a clickbait misrepresentation of what Razzaq said by the youtube channel, Cricket Pakistan - I listened to the interview and his main point was we need to get out of this inferiority complex of comparing Pakistani cricketers to Indians.

Pakistan mai talent raha hai, why do we not compare Babar to Yousuf or Inzi but only to Kohli?

Razzaq is advocating an attitude shift. Enough of this meekness from fans and players where we don’t have any self worth.

The rest of the interview will be drowned out in the noise but it was quite good, Razzaq talked about emerging cricketers and how when picking his KPK team he sidelined any cricketer who he felt would perform here and there but go missing in the playoffs/knockouts. Strong mental toughness is key.

That's a valid point, but Razzaq himself has made comparisons with Indian players many times. Couple of these are legendary threads on PP
 
Mocking him is also an opinion. Ridiculous opinions have always been mocked in history. He has a right to opinion, other people have a right to comment on that opinion

I didn't ask anyone to stop. I just asked what made his opinions so mockworthy?
 
Would recommend everyone to watch the actual interview.

It’s a clickbait misrepresentation of what Razzaq said by the youtube channel, Cricket Pakistan - I listened to the interview and his main point was we need to get out of this inferiority complex of comparing Pakistani cricketers to Indians.

Pakistan mai talent raha hai, why do we not compare Babar to Yousuf or Inzi but only to Kohli?

Razzaq is advocating an attitude shift. Enough of this meekness from fans and players where we don’t have any self worth.

The rest of the interview will be drowned out in the noise but it was quite good, Razzaq talked about emerging cricketers and how when picking his KPK team he sidelined any cricketer who he felt would perform here and there but go missing in the playoffs/knockouts. Strong mental toughness is key.

We should not compare Pakistani players with Indian players- Razzaq

Also Razzaq

Sehzad has more talent than Tendulkar

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...n-Sachin-Tendulkar-ever-had-quot-Abdul-Razzaq

Ahmed Shehzad could have left Virender Sehwag and Sachin Tendulkar behind" : Abdul Razzaq

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...and-Sachin-Tendulkar-behind-quot-Abdul-Razzaq

A team of the best players from PSL would beat a team of the best players from IPL" : Abdul Razzaq

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...f-the-best-players-from-IPL-quot-Abdul-Razzaq

He also hs other gems like how Kohli is just very lucky and how Bumrah is a baby bowler.

But hey others have inferiority complex
 
That's a valid point, but Razzaq himself has made comparisons with Indian players many times. Couple of these are legendary threads on PP

I am aware of such comparisons in the past, but I don’t think new statements have to be conflated with previous statements.

Also, a brief note on those previous statements — yes they were foolish but sometimes you tell a youngster they are extremely talented so that they begin seeing themselves at a certain level.

Life, not just cricket, is all a mental game and the people who have self belief transcend the rest. I have experienced this in my personal life and I have seen this instinct in the most successful entrepreneurs, sportsmen, and innovators. Critics will call it delusion, and if you fail you will be made fun of for thinking of yourself as Steve Jobs, Sachin Tendulkar, or Albert Einstein.

Some people have this ego naturally - Kohli once walked up to Alyssa Healy and Ellyse Perry when he was 16 and they had no idea who he was, and he told them “I’m the next big thing in Indian cricket” and they laughed him off.

Other people sometimes need this validation from their peers, seniors, and mentors. If you don’t believe me, Razzaq and Afridi were actually told the same things by Wasim Akram about their abilities, you can see interviews of them where they said these comments changed their lives and mentalities. This self-belief empowers human beings to achieve things they might not otherwise have been able to as it motivates hard work and aspiring to great heights.

Razzaq was an idiot because he did the same for Ahmed Shehzad, but took it one step further by proclaiming this to the press as well. Even then, it wasn’t that big of a deal — if Shehzad didn’t have mental problems and he had a long career for Pakistan, even if he wasn’t half of Tendulkar no one would have criticized Razzaq for being delusional.

These days, for example, Shubman Gill is being compared to Tendulkar, Gavaskar, Kohli and that must surely raise his self belief and inner confidence. Even if he has a humble career, no one will say we were deluded to compare him to such great cricketers. Fortunately Gill is a well educated lad with a good head on his shoulders, otherwise if he too develops a screw loose, the people who initially thought he was on a majestic tier of talent might be laughed at. Even Kohli got a lot of criticism early in his career but his self belief pulled him through. Failure to do so would have resulted in laughter from us mortals.

I don’t mean to defend Razzaq but you must see where he is coming from. We are the same fans who criticize cricketers as “mental midgets” or people who have “defensive mentalities”.

So why do we also criticize the people who have a genuine belief that Pakistan is the most talented nation on earth? That absurd level of self belief is what actually transforms what little talent we do have into fighters. Anywhere in the world, any country, and any region. People who have this elite mindset are the ones that have the most haters and develop the most followers.

Rishabh Pant has this elite mindset. Kohli has this elite attitude. Shoaib Akhtar had genuine delusions of grandeur and it turned him into the most brutal fast bowler of all time.

Yuvraj Singh had his menacing dad punish him repeatedly as a teenager for failing to perform at not just a basic cricketing standard, but a standard where he would become an elite cricketer.

Kevin Pietersen walked the talk. Imran Khan convinced a band of misfits that they could compete with the GOAT West Indies team.

Wasim Akram convinced three teenagers called Razzaq, Afridi, and Azhar Mahmood that they were born to be the next great all rounders after Imran Khan.

So what if Razzaq instills self belief in Pakistanis? This guy won the domestic treble as coach this year. Demolished all three tournaments with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, that too with a team that really wasn’t particularly talented.

Let’s celebrate his successes, not pull him down.

From me, Razzaq has a blank cheque to continue making statements about palak and the greatness of the motherland. It’s why he at the age of 41 has done more than most people will do in their lifetimes. It’s why he had the self belief to hit McGrath for 5 fours in an over, to take South Africa for a ride in one of the greatest ever ODI chases, and now inspire a dud KPK team without any coaching credentials to dominate Pakistan cricket.

Who cares about the truth of what comes out of his mouth? Of course Shehzad is incomparable to Tendulkar and of course India has more talent and infrastructure than Pakistan. Of course IPL is better than PSL. No one cares. In my eyes, this attitude has only had a positive effect for him and other cricketers, aside from giving fans who have nothing else to do with their time some troll material. Long may it continue.
 
Last edited:
Guys what he means is Talent to the money spent on player's development ratio. In that Pakistan is number one. No one can dispute that.:misbah:srt
 
Pakistan is obviously quite talented than India....otherwise how could they win an ICC trophy in the past 8 years when compared to India's none....Pakistan is a gun team, they know when to fire and when not to.....for the kind of money BCCI is spending on its players, the returns generated are meagre....India was not able to win anything substantial in LOIs in the last 8 years and were comprehensively beaten by SA NZ and ENG in Tests....all of Kohli's centuries in LOIs are quite meaningless...he is so overrated.
 
Pakistan is actually the least talented cricket nation in the world and I have explained why multiple times.

Our players as well as the fans oversell this talent factor because deep down they are also aware of the fact that Pakistan is largely a flop cricket nation.
 
Pakistan is actually the least talented cricket nation in the world and I have explained why multiple times.

Our players as well as the fans oversell this talent factor because deep down they are also aware of the fact that Pakistan is largely a flop cricket nation.

We have won both ODI and T20 world cups, have been a top rated test side, have the 4th best W/L %, some world class players, Eagan Mani is Pakistani. Aren’t we right to think we are in the top drawer of cricket nations?
 
We have won both ODI and T20 world cups, have been a top rated test side, have the 4th best W/L %, some world class players, Eagan Mani is Pakistani. Aren’t we right to think we are in the top drawer of cricket nations?

Apart from fast bowling, Pakistan has a middling legacy in all departments of the game. As far as the bowling legacy is concerned, it was primarily established with reverse-swing achieved with dubious means.

As soon as those dubious means became impractical due to high quality cameras, Pakistan’s fast bowling tumbled.

The reality is that Pakistan has only produced three genuinely great cricketers: Imran Khan, Javed Miandad and Wasim Akram. That is it.

Everyone else is overrated or successful due to certain circumstances.
 
Pakistan is obviously quite talented than India....otherwise how could they win an ICC trophy in the past 8 years when compared to India's none....Pakistan is a gun team, they know when to fire and when not to.....for the kind of money BCCI is spending on its players, the returns generated are meagre....India was not able to win anything substantial in LOIs in the last 8 years and were comprehensively beaten by SA NZ and ENG in Tests....all of Kohli's centuries in LOIs are quite meaningless...he is so overrated.

West indies won an ICC trophy too, the best current team
 
Pakistan is obviously quite talented than India....otherwise how could they win an ICC trophy in the past 8 years when compared to India's none....Pakistan is a gun team, they know when to fire and when not to.....for the kind of money BCCI is spending on its players, the returns generated are meagre....India was not able to win anything substantial in LOIs in the last 8 years and were comprehensively beaten by SA NZ and ENG in Tests....all of Kohli's centuries in LOIs are quite meaningless...he is so overrated.

Good point brother. Pakistan won the CT / de facto World Cup while all India has won is Mickey Mouse bilateral series against Aus, eng etc. anyone can get lucky in a bilateral whereas to win a global tourney you need talent and skills
 
Apart from fast bowling, Pakistan has a middling legacy in all departments of the game. As far as the bowling legacy is concerned, it was primarily established with reverse-swing achieved with dubious means.

As soon as those dubious means became impractical due to high quality cameras, Pakistan’s fast bowling tumbled.

The reality is that Pakistan has only produced three genuinely great cricketers: Imran Khan, Javed Miandad and Wasim Akram. That is it.

Everyone else is overrated or successful due to certain circumstances.

You left out the fielding. Probably the poorest fielding record in the history of the sport. Pakistan Cricket has probably made easy wins into losses because of poor fielding. Every major team, even now, has moments where their bowlers are unable to break through and get a wicket, and what you see is a runout, or a good catch bring the game back in their favor. In Pakistan, we treat fielding as a joke, our players dive over the ball and drop sitters. Had we taken the chances that came our way in the last few years, we would have seen some better performances. Similarly, our team is the worst when it comes to conceding singles. We allow the other team to keep knocking towards a good total by not applying pressure in the field. Good fielders put pressure on the batsmen. If you were a batsman with a brain, I don't think you'd try to go aerial when someone like Jadeja is there.

Pakistan hasn't seen any "world class" talent emerge in recent times, the best has been Shaheen Shah Afridi, and he's a very good talent. The difference between India and Pakistan is that you could give them someone like Ishant Sharma, and they'd make him world class, whereas in Pakistan, you can have someone like Naseem and make him worse than he was. That's the difference.
 
Pakistan is actually the least talented cricket nation in the world and I have explained why multiple times.

Our players as well as the fans oversell this talent factor because deep down they are also aware of the fact that Pakistan is largely a flop cricket nation.

Least talented nation is very obviously India that is because having a population of over 1.3 billion people with passion for only one sport and they are not number 1 team in all formats yet gives it all away. On top of that they have a great cricket domestic infrastructure / IPL etc which is second to none.

They do not have an excuse but to accept that on average they produce the least talent. Most talented nation is Australia / NZ for the reverse is true. India population is 6 times more than and other nation plus the best infrastructure plus IPL and yet all other teams are competing fine.
 
Razzak is getting flak because of his deluded hot takes.

He said shezad was better then tendulkar, no onw takes him seriously.
 
If we have the most talent, then we must be the worst at finding and nurturing that talent then, because there isn't much coming through at the highest level is there.

Recently every now and then a kid comes through for a while, most disappear and very few actually perform at the highest level and become world-class players.
 
Razzaq's insight into cricket is similar to his attitude on the field - insipid.

That statement about Indian Players is purely click Bait. Also hire local coaches (as if Misbah, YK and Waqar are foreigners ) in other words he was saying hire me as a PSL head coach.
 
If we have the most talent, then we must be the worst at finding and nurturing that talent then, because there isn't much coming through at the highest level is there.

Recently every now and then a kid comes through for a while, most disappear and very few actually perform at the highest level and become world-class players.

He didn't elaborate on his Talent statement, didn't really say who is the upcoming world class talent. Just an attempt to get attention in which he has succeed. & then just made some shallow meaningless statements afterwards.
 
Any country which needs to keep bringing back fixers to make up its squad and final XI , clearly does not have enough talent.
 
Back
Top