What's new

Deadly encounter between Naxalites and Indian security forces leaving 22 soldiers dead (update #42)

KingKhanWC

World Star
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Runs
50,455
As many as 12,000 people have lost their lives in Maoist violence over the last two decades, including 2,700 personnel of the security forces.

The April 24 assault on a CRPF road-opening party that claimed lives of 25 personnel was the deadliest since the April 2010 attack in Dantewada, also in Chhattisgarh, in which 76 personnel were killed.



Read more at:
//economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/59521195.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst


I cant recall Kohli and co wearing caps when 76 Indian security personnel were killed?

I can't recall see BJP and Modi in tears showing anger and talking revenge as much as they do after an incident in Kashmir?

Has there been tweets by Ghambir, Sehwag, Tendulkar or perhaps from John Rambo or whatever the Bollywood jesters names are?

Do lives in India have more value when Pakistan is accused of being behind their deaths?

Strange , strange nation.:dw
 
Our media doesn't care.

You're a respected poster by all here.

Surely if Modi or the senior politicians made strong statments as they do with Kashmir, the media has to report or comment?

Nearly 3000 killed in two decades is a huge number. Imagine if the same amount were killed in Kashmir.
 
Because Maoists are part of an internal conflict. And fight with Maoists is not considered a war for the same reason. "It's not us vs them" in people's minds
 
Because Maoists are part of an internal conflict. And fight with Maoists is not considered a war for the same reason. "It's not us vs them" in people's minds

This is even worse then. If parts of Yorkshire were killing British troops, believe me this would be huge news daily and Britain would mourning their soldiers deaths with huge displays of love etc.

I really dont understand India, it's a very strange nation with weird principles.
 
This is even worse then. If parts of Yorkshire were killing British troops, believe me this would be huge news daily and Britain would mourning their soldiers deaths with huge displays of love etc.

I really dont understand India, it's a very strange nation with weird principles.

Read up on maoists on wiki. They are weak now but in their peak, they had massive following among masses, especially the poor. Terrorists in Kashmir never had the same following outside of Kashmir There are even political parties affiliated with maoists. And check the news online. Even then there was outcry when there were army casualties. People equate army with patriotism and rightly so. There brave men and women in every country fight for their people and land while the rest of us sleep peacefully at home.
 
Read up on maoists on wiki. They are weak now but in their peak, they had massive following among masses, especially the poor. Terrorists in Kashmir never had the same following outside of Kashmir There are even political parties affiliated with maoists. And check the news online. Even then there was outcry when there were army casualties. People equate army with patriotism and rightly so. There brave men and women in every country fight for their people and land while the rest of us sleep peacefully at home.

A few questions?

1. Are they considered terrorists?

2. Are they finished or are they still fighting?

3. If tommorow 50 Indian security forces are killed by them, will Kohli and team India being handing out new army caps in the next match?
 
A few questions?

1. Are they considered terrorists?

2. Are they finished or are they still fighting?

3. If tommorow 50 Indian security forces are killed by them, will Kohli and team India being handing out new army caps in the next match?

They are considered terrorists. They actually have a name - Naxals

They are mostly finished

If 50 soldiers die by a suicide bomber in chattisgarh, forget military camps. Expect a few thousand people burning the maoist sympathizer villages. 40 army soldiers never died in any terrorist attack in India in a single event before. The outrage here matches the enormity of the event.
 
The entire world knows India's wannabe overblown reaction to the Pulwama episode had zero weight behind it.
 
You also have to give weight to the context here. Any casualities during an armed conflict is associated with bravery and has a different reaction compared to a casualty when the army personnel are resting or non active. It evokes a lot of sympathy and outrage as it also invokes the ego and fear of "defeat" considering how vulnerable the army personnel are. They are supposed to be the protectors and them being killed like sitting ducks is not acceptable to any.
 
They are considered terrorists. They actually have a name - Naxals

They are mostly finished

If 50 soldiers die by a suicide bomber in chattisgarh, forget military camps. Expect a few thousand people burning the maoist sympathizer villages. 40 army soldiers never died in any terrorist attack in India in a single event before. The outrage here matches the enormity of the event.

75 were killed in 2010?
 
So Indian dont care about the deaths of the security forces but only used the Kashmir incident for their political propoganda.

Makes sense.

You can tell
1 pilot got killed and about 8 in helicopter no 1 is talking about them
 
75 were killed in 2010?

Just read this. April 2010 Maoist attack in Dantewada

You are right. It's 76 CRPF killed in one incident. Well..I guess they are not considered as terrorists then. The press has been harping about how Phulwama was the largest terror attack on Indian soldiers. So, your point seems to have validity that the outrage is more if it's terrorism in Kashmir. And the outcry is not uniform across events and is dependent on who actually killed the soldiers.

Wiki: A Naxal or Naxalite (/ˈnʌksəˌlaɪt/)[1] is a member of any political organisation that claims the legacy of the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist), founded in Calcutta in 1969. Communist Party of India (Maoist) is the largest existing political group in that lineage today in India.
 
Just read this. April 2010 Maoist attack in Dantewada

You are right. It's 76 CRPF killed in one incident. Well..I guess they are not considered as terrorists then. The press has been harping about how Phulwama was the largest terror attack on Indian soldiers. So, your point seems to have validity that the outrage is more if it's terrorism in Kashmir. And the outcry is not uniform across events and is dependent on who actually killed the soldiers.

Wiki: A Naxal or Naxalite (/ˈnʌksəˌlaɪt/)[1] is a member of any political organisation that claims the legacy of the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist), founded in Calcutta in 1969. Communist Party of India (Maoist) is the largest existing political group in that lineage today in India.

There is also this

A Bharatiya Janata Party training guidebook, which is meant to orient its workers and office-bearers to its ideology and views on key issues, says that Maoists in India enjoy "regular support from Pakistan and China", making them a big threat to the country's internal security.

https://www.business-standard.com/a...china-bjp-training-manual-118090200272_1.html

So why not attack Pakistan or China then?
 

There is no doubt that Kashmir is at the center of this. Terror attack against soldiers in Kashmir helps India gain sympathy and can justify the army's presence. The press has the power to incite and they seem to be with the GOI in full flow if it's Kashmir related. The outrage against Maoists is still there are condolences pour from all circles based on the news articles I'm reading. However it doesn't last many news cycles and people slowly forget.
 
Just read this. April 2010 Maoist attack in Dantewada

You are right. It's 76 CRPF killed in one incident. Well..I guess they are not considered as terrorists then. The press has been harping about how Phulwama was the largest terror attack on Indian soldiers. So, your point seems to have validity that the outrage is more if it's terrorism in Kashmir. And the outcry is not uniform across events and is dependent on who actually killed the soldiers.

Wiki: A Naxal or Naxalite (/ˈnʌksəˌlaɪt/)[1] is a member of any political organisation that claims the legacy of the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist), founded in Calcutta in 1969. Communist Party of India (Maoist) is the largest existing political group in that lineage today in India.

Thanks for eventually making sense (in this thread). The outrage is not uniform because the muslim and Kashmiri angles arent there. As simple as that.
 
There is no doubt that Kashmir is at the center of this. Terror attack against soldiers in Kashmir helps India gain sympathy and can justify the army's presence. The press has the power to incite and they seem to be with the GOI in full flow if it's Kashmir related. The outrage against Maoists is still there are condolences pour from all circles based on the news articles I'm reading. However it doesn't last many news cycles and people slowly forget.

I would have more respect for India and take them more seriously if they showed equal respect for all thier soldiers killed in conflicts.

What are the mothers of those killed by Moaists thinking when they see their PM or Kohli wearing army caps for those killed in Kashmir but not a peep when their sons gave their lives.
 
Thanks for eventually making sense (in this thread). The outrage is not uniform because the muslim and Kashmiri angles arent there. As simple as that.

You should also understand one basic fact. Indians consider Kashmir as part of India. So when Kashmiris kill the soldiers with external support, they are considered as traitors and betrayers and hence the outrage is more. However the villagers supporting Maoists are not considered the same. I think it all comes down to reluctance of the people to accept being part of India or not. Muslim angle is also there but I think nationalist angle is dominant.
 
I would have more respect for India and take them more seriously if they showed equal respect for all thier soldiers killed in conflicts.

What are the mothers of those killed by Moaists thinking when they see their PM or Kohli wearing army caps for those killed in Kashmir but not a peep when their sons gave their lives.

It's the case with every country no? A soldier's death is valued more if it's against an arch enemy compared to a domestic conflict. At the end of the day it's all political and the mileage a death gets depends on the impact it has on political gains.
 
It's the case with every country no? A soldier's death is valued more if it's against an arch enemy compared to a domestic conflict. At the end of the day it's all political and the mileage a death gets depends on the impact it has on political gains.

Not here in the UK. Every time a soldier dies, all the media release his/her photo , their name and their regiment. Where they are located or who they are fighting has not bearing on this.

Sure they will use some soldiers such as Prince Henry to further propoganda in their immoral wars.
 
Not here in the UK. Every time a soldier dies, all the media release his/her photo , their name and their regiment. Where they are located or who they are fighting has not bearing on this.

Sure they will use some soldiers such as Prince Henry to further propoganda in their immoral wars.

Not in the US either. I don't think we should compare west with what happens in that part of the world. If 40 soldiers of US army were killed in the US by a group, they would be annihiliated in a day.
 
Not in the US either. I don't think we should compare west with what happens in that part of the world. If 40 soldiers of US army were killed in the US by a group, they would be annihiliated in a day.

This is where it gets messy. Do the politicians in the US and UK really care about the loss of life of their troops? No, they dont. US troops were killed by certain groups which they then supported with aid and weapons !

They use those deaths to further their war mongering. India has done the same but unlike the western nations has picked and chose it's soldiers.
 
i never understood what the naxalite aims were, revamp the current political system along chinese lines, supress religion, land redistribution?
 
i never understood what the naxalite aims were, revamp the current political system along chinese lines, supress religion, land redistribution?

They fight for the rights of tribals and aboriginals of India. Many of their lands were forcibly taken over by Govt (mining, construction..) with little compensation. So social injustice. The claim is these people have lived in India for thousands of years and now they are uprooted from their traditional places and relocated.

Maoists fight for their rights. Of course, they blame the Government and run their parallel govt in remote tribal places. If Govt interferes, they will kill the security forces (mostly CRPF men).
 
This is where it gets messy. Do the politicians in the US and UK really care about the loss of life of their troops? No, they dont. US troops were killed by certain groups which they then supported with aid and weapons !

They use those deaths to further their war mongering. India has done the same but unlike the western nations has picked and chose it's soldiers.

That's all abroad. There is no way US would support the killers of their soldiers at home.
 
That's all abroad. There is no way US would support the killers of their soldiers at home.

What do you mean? US has openly supported Al-Qaeda, the same group which has killed many of it's soldiers.
 
I once read a famous quote that said, “Some lives matter more than others. The bitter truth that we must accept.”
 
What do you mean? US has openly supported Al-Qaeda, the same group which has killed many of it's soldiers.

I'm saying soldiers killed in a war abroad is different from soldiers killed at home.
 
I'm saying soldiers killed in a war abroad is different from soldiers killed at home.

Ok, fair point.

I dont understand why India cant find a political solution to the Maoist issue? What are their demands?
 
Coz Maoists being non-Muslim's can't be "terrorists". They are just misinformed groups of people who needs some love too sort out the problem.
 
Because Maoists are part of an internal conflict. And fight with Maoists is not considered a war for the same reason. "It's not us vs them" in people's minds

so are kashmiris considered outsiders?
 
Thousands die everyday due to natural causes. Not a big deal. But if even 2 people die in a terrorist attack, it's a major news story. The same reasoning applies here.
 
Thousands die everyday due to natural causes. Not a big deal. But if even 2 people die in a terrorist attack, it's a major news story. The same reasoning applies here.

lol What?

Being killed by Moaists is the same as a natural disaster and they are not terrorists?
 
A tip-off, 3-hour-long gunfight in Chhattisgarh’s Sukma; 22 soldiers killed

Security forces were getting tip-offs that Madvi Hidma, a top Naxal leader, was hiding in Sukma. Hidma is linked with the 2013 Jhiram Ghati killings.

A day after five jawans were killed in a fierce gunfight between the security forces and Maoists at a forest in Chhattisgarh's Jonaguda, a total of 17 bodies were found from the encounter site on Sunday. After Saturday's encounter, 18 security personnel went missing. As details of the encounter keep emerging, it appears to be one of the biggest attacks on India's security forces in the last few years. Not much is known about whether the Maoists also suffered losses, or what kind of weapons they used against the security forces. But the possibility of this being a planned attack is not being dismissed yet. One woman Maoist is believed to have been killed.

Here is what we know about the encounter:

What happened?

A gunfight broke out between the security forces and the Naxals on Saturday which went on for three hours and five jawans were martyred. A day after, 17 bodies were found and the toll is likely to go up. Around 30 security personnel have been injured. A woman Maoist leader has been found dead.

After the encounter, Naxals looted more than two dozen weapons from security personnel, news agency ANI reported citing CRPF sources.

Where did the encounter take place?

A stronghold of Maoists, the encounter took place inside a forest near Jonaguda, which falls in Bastar's Bijapur and Sukma district border.

How did the encounter start?

On Friday night, separate teams of security forces launched a massive anti-Naxal operation in South Bastar forests. According to reports, the security forces were getting tip-offs about Madvi Hidma, a top Naxal leader linked with 2013 Jhiram Ghati killings, in which over 30 people, including senior leaders of Chhattisgarh Congress, were killed.

The joint operation was launched from five places — Tarrem, Usoor and Pamed (Bijapur), and Minpa and Narsapuram (in Sukma).

The gunfight took between when the patrolling team that was dispatched from Tarrem was inside the forest near Jonaguda. Cadres of the Peoples' Liberation Guerilla Army battalion ambushed the team and there was heavy firing for hours.

It is not yet clear whether the tip-offs were traps to draw security forces to the spot or whether the anto-Naxal operation actually stirred one of the layers that protect Hidma. Hidma's security cover starts from almost one kilometre. The top Maoist leader at the time of the encounter might have been in the vicinity, which triggered the heavy firing.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/chhattisgarh-encounter-a-tip-off-3-hour-long-gunfight-what-happened-in-sukma-101617528512522.html
 
22 security personnel and 25-30 Maoists killed in Chhattisgadh OP

RAIPUR: At least 22 members of Indian security forces were killed in a central Indian state by Maoist fighters, in one of the bloodiest attacks by the extreme left-wing group this year, officials said on Sunday.


Source: Dawn News


Apparently Indian forces were planning an 'operation' and walked straight into a Maoist pincer trap :facepalm:

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">If there was no intelligence failure then a 1:1 death ratio means it was a poorly designed and incompetently executed operation.<br><br>Our Jawans are not cannon fodder to be martyred at will. <a href="https://t.co/JDgVc03QvD">pic.twitter.com/JDgVc03QvD</a></p>— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) <a href="https://twitter.com/RahulGandhi/status/1378926983699124229?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 5, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

--

Thoughts and prayers:

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">My thoughts are with the families of those martyred while fighting Maoists in Chhattisgarh. The sacrifices of the brave martyrs will never be forgotten. May the injured recover at the earliest.</p>— Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) <a href="https://twitter.com/narendramodi/status/1378369121969086475?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 3, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Anti-Naxal ops will continue, says Chhattisgarh CM; Amit Shah holds high-level meet on deadly encounter



Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel on Monday asserted that anti-Naxal operations will continue till the Naxalites are completely uprooted from the state. He also said that Army camps will be established in Naxal-affected areas at a rapid pace and the development works in such areas will be accelerated.

The Chief Minister visited Jagdalpur in the wake of the deadly encounter between Naxalites and security forces near the Bijapur-Sukma border, which left 22 soldiers dead and more than 30 injured. The Naxalites claim they have abducted one of the personnel but the security forces are yet to confirm anything on it.

Baghel paid a tribute to the martyred personnel of security forces in Jagdalpury today and held a high-level meet to discuss the deadly incident. During the meeting, he saluted the martyrs and their sacrifice, and empathised with their grief-stricken family members.

He said that new camps are being established in the area, because of which Naxalites are panicking. The area of Naxalite dominance is shrinking rapidly. It is the first time when we have entered the den of Naxalites, he added.

"Central Government and State Government will work together to speed up the development works in the areas. Efforts are being made to improve connectivity through the construction of roads and to extend the benefits of the schemes to the interior areas," said the Chhattisgarh Minister.

Baghel concluded his address saying meaningful discussions have been held in this regard in the meeting and he is hopeful that the Central Government will take appropriate action on his demands.

https://www.timesnownews.com/india/article/amit-shah-chhattisgarh-cm-pays-pay-tribute-to-14-security-personnel-martyred-in-jagdalpur-naxal-attack/741177
 
The Mods/Admins should include in the heading that 22 indian soldiers killed in the latest fight. Then the more informed indian posters will shed more light on what is happening in Chattisgarh.
 
Maoists released a statement on Tuesday that the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) commando who went missing after the April 3 encounter at Tarrem in Chattisgarh’s Sukma was in their custody.

The banned Communist Party of India (Maoist) also demanded that the State government announce a mediator for the release of the commando.

Chhattisgarh Director General of Police D.M Awasthi said that the letter issued by the Maoists was authentic and the government would soon take a call on the mediator.

The commando, identified as Rakeshwar Singh Minhas, belonged to the Commando Battalion for Resolute Action unit (CoBRA) of the CRPF, a unit specially trained for operations in Left Wing Extremism (LWE) affected areas.

A senior government official said that a media person or a social activist could be considered as a mediator.

The statement signed by “Vikalp”, spokesperson of the Dandakaranya Special Zonal Committee of the Maoists, said that four People’s Liberation Guerrilla Army (PLGA) cadres were killed in the encounter at Tarrem on April 3. It added that they had also taken away 14 weapons, over 2,000 rounds of ammunition, and other items belonging to the security personnel.

The killed PLGA cadres were identified by the Maoists as Odi Sanni, Padam Lakhma, Kowasi Badru and Nupa Suresh, all residents of south Bastar. Sanni’s body was recovered by security forces on April 3.

The Maoists said that the men had died in the “courageous” counter attack. “We could not secure the body of Sunny. Final rites of the remaining three were held with revolutionary traditions,” they stated. The statement said that Madvi Sukkal, another villager, was also killed before the encounter.

The Maoists have named the condition that the officer would be set free if the government specifically announced the names of the mediators. “Till then he would be safe in the protection of Janatan sarkar,” a Telugu statement released in the name of CPI-Maoist’s Dandakaranya Special Zonal Committee official spokesperson Vikalp said.

The statement also said, “We are always ready for talks but the government had no integrity or conviction. Revolutionaries never gave up arms during the several previous talks held with governments. It is the government’s responsibility to creative atmosphere conducive for talks...Talks would materialise only if the government stopped deployment of forces, organising camps, attacks and restrictions. Policemen lost their lives in Kondagaon, Narayanapur and Bijapur since the government was carrying out attacks instead of holding talks. Government is responsible for this situation.”

Conveying condolences to the bereaved families of 23 policemen killed in the “counter attack”, the Maoists said the police were not their enemies. “We appeal to the police not to become scapegoats in the unjustified war brought about by the ruling classes,” the spokesperson said.

According to them, nearly 2,000 policemen “belonging to Modi and Amit Shah”, led by the Bastar Inspector General, had come to carry out attacks on villages in Sukma and Bijapur three days ago. The main objective of the “Samadhan-Prahar” operation was to decimate the PLGA, they said.

Close to 150 civilians and “our party workers and leaders” were killed in such attacks executed since November, 2020, the Maoists said. A similar offensive was organised by the police three days ago by deploying thousands of policemen, they said.


The seven-year rule of Narendra Modi, deepened economic crisis and deteriorated political situations had posed a serious threat to the lives and property of people, the Maoists said. Attacks on intellectuals and supporters of democracy were on the rise “by branding them Urban Naxals”. People were fighting against this suppression with the slogans of “Jal-Jungle-Jameen” and the Maoists would continue to support their struggle, the statement said.

Chhattisgarh Police had said in a statement on April 4 that teams had been dispatched to Tarrem as they wanted to corner PLGA chief Hidma, who was said to be in the area. Hidma heads the PLGA Battalion 1, one of the most lethally armed and trained units of Maoists active in southern Chattisgarh.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...?utm_source=national&utm_medium=sticky_footer
 
Naxals are not terrorists. govt has no business displacing these people.

So I did some research into the matter. In the end it was all so predictable:

http://chhattisgarhmines.gov.in/sites/default/files/treasure-trove-cg-minerals.pdf

Tin Ore is being produced only in Chhattisgarh amongst Indian States. Precious metals like Gold and Atomic minerals also occur in the State. Other minerals include Corundum, Clay, Quartzite, Base metals, Fluorite, Beryl, Anadalusite, Kyanite, Sillimanite, Talc, Soapstone and Garnet.

Apparently, Indian government is doing the dirty work for Ambhanis (?) and other big companies. Vintage Bollywood movie plot.
 
The family of the CRPF jawan, abducted by Naxals after a gun battle with security forces, on Wednesday blocked Jammu Aknoor road and appealed to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah for his safe release.

The relatives of the CoBRA commando raised slogans demanding his release and were seen carrying the tricolor.

Meenu, the wife of the abducted commando Rakeshwar Singh Manhas, said, “I appeal to Modiji to rescue my husband safely, just the way Abhinandan was brought back from Pakistan. I last spoke to him on Friday. He told me he was going on an operation and would speak to me later.”

Twenty-two security personnel were killed and at least 30 were wounded in the four-hour gun battle with Maoists that took place in the forests of Bijapur in Chhattisgarh on April 2.

This was the gravest attack in four years. During the encounter, the Maoists abducted Manhas who hails from Jammu.

“He is not in China or in Pakistan; he is in our own country, why can’t he be rescued?” questioned another relative of the CRPF jawan during the protest.

“Besides our relative, he belongs to the CRPF force and he has been abducted and the government is not doing anything. It has been five days and nothing has been done so far. Now the concerned CO of his battalion doesn’t even pick our phone,” says one of the protesters identifying himself a close relative of the CRPF jawan.

“For five days they haven’t said anything. Those who have abducted him are saying he is in their custody and want the government to talk with them but the government is not doing anything,” he said.

The family is seeking the intervention of the government.

“I want my brother back. Please get my brother,” said the wailing sister of the soldier.

After waiting for Manhas’ return for five days, his family blocked the Jammu-Poonch highway to draw the government’s attention towards the issue of his release.

“Had he been a son of some Minister, by now they would have forgotten all elections and devoted whole time to rescue him. But he is not. Even Lt. Governor of Jammu and Kashmir has not tweeted about it. Such is the government’s attitude. We want the Central government to take steps to rescue him.”
 
“I appeal to Modiji to rescue my husband safely, just the way Abhinandan was brought back from Pakistan. I last spoke to him on Friday. He told me he was going on an operation and would speak to me later.”

Damn. Feel for his family.

Maoists won't release him until their people are released from Indian jails.
 
2 years later from this OP, Naxalites are still killing Indian security forces.

More have been killed here than any other area inc occupied Kashmir.

Why is Ghambir, Sewhag, RSS Pandits and Indian posters all still mute on this?
 
2 years later from this OP, Naxalites are still killing Indian security forces.

More have been killed here than any other area inc occupied Kashmir.

Why is Ghambir, Sewhag, RSS Pandits and Indian posters all still mute on this?

Good question. Answer is simple though. The word "Pakistan" sells in India. Life of 1 soldier captured alive by Pakistan is more important than lives of 22 or even 50 Indian soldiers killed by Naxalities. This is how hypocrites and third class media in India think. Good luck getting answers from these joshila types. :inti
 
Last edited:
Good question. Answer is simple though. The word "Pakistan" sells in India. Life of 1 soldier captured alive by Pakistan is more important than lives of 22 or Indian soldiers killed by Naxalities. This is how hypocrites and third class media in India think. Good luck getting answers from these joshila types. :inti

It seems they are only good at spreading hate not using intelligence to understand conflicts.

Is the Indian media reporting these deaths in the same horror movie fashion they do when a soldier in Kashmir is killed?
 
It seems they are only good at spreading hate not using intelligence to understand conflicts.

Is the Indian media reporting these deaths in the same horror movie fashion they do when a soldier in Kashmir is killed?

Not really and this is expected from them. :inti
 
Not really and this is expected from them. :inti

So I assume it will be difficult to know the exact number of security forces killed by Naxalites since the conflict began?

But we can see so many groups who are angry with Indian government now, Muslims, Sikhs, occupied Kashmris, Naxalites. Jai Hind.
 
So Kashmiris and Sikhs fighting already and now the Naxals are murdering Indian soldiers too. Difficult to feel sympathy when the likes of Gaurav Arya encourage violence against neighbouring countries. The Hindu's should remember their own belief in karma, what comes around goes around.
 
The Indian media after this later battering of their terrorist soldiers are howling and wagging their tail in pain again. The Maoists who are true freedom fighters will keep on hurting India hard until they get what they want. Cheap threats will not get India anywhere when so many in their media are Maoist supporters. Pak should militarily support the Maoists like we do the Khalistanis.
 
The Indian media after this later battering of their terrorist soldiers are howling and wagging their tail in pain again. The Maoists who are true freedom fighters will keep on hurting India hard until they get what they want. Cheap threats will not get India anywhere when so many in their media are Maoist supporters. Pak should militarily support the Maoists like we do the Khalistanis.

Indian media is nothing but a bunch of sellouts, almost same as Pak media or any other 3rd world country's, but Indian media is on another level.

It took decades for Mullahs to spread extremism in SC but Indian media brainwashed millions of youths in less than a decade.

Anyways, Pakistan should stay away from all this mess. We are supporting Kashmir's legitimate cause. Our goal isn't India's destruction or spreading violence in India. Modi the Muslim Killer is already doing that. The very fabric of Indian society is shifting backwards.

Our goal is to liberate Indian Occupied Kashmir. We shouldn't lose focus on that.

Also, "helping" Khalistan/Maoists etc. will only worsen an already war-like ambient between the two countries. It will only benefit people who have support warmongering agendas.

Moreover Maoists' activities are literally on the other side of India:

India_Naxal_affected_districts_map.svg


India_map_Naxal_Left-wing_violence_or_activity_affected_districts_2013.SVG

Solution for India is simple and they know that but are too corrupt to execute it. Indian Army is used to unarmed Kashmiris, but Maoists are trained, motivated and have terrain knowledge.

In 2006, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh called the Naxalites the "single biggest internal security challenge ever faced by our country". In June 2011, he said, "Development is the master remedy to win over people", adding that the government was "strengthening the development work in the 60 Maoist-affected districts.


I firmly believe the only way forward for Kashmir is extensive negotiation.

War and violence is not the solution and it will destroy the whole region.
 
Last edited:
Amar bari, tomar bari, naxal bari. Have travelled through naxal areas, they don't touch you if you are a civilian. Their war is with the govt (whoever is in power), not the people. Most principled group. They only target combatants.
 
And they have released the commando they had abducted. Stupid indians should realize naxalites are not terrorists, merely fighting for their survival. The security forces they killed were not there on picnic, but to kill them.
 
[MENTION=139649]WhenSultansBowled[/MENTION]

Yes liberating IoK is our priority but when the likes of Gaurav Arya among others openly talk off spreading and supporting terrorism in FATA and Baluchistan then we too should arm the Sikhs and Naxals. Eent ka jawab patthar! Baluchistan and FATA are not UN recognized disputes so India and its people have no reason to complain when we play the same dirty game. India is an open playground for ISI where we can cause massive damage if ISI upped their game. Indian's like Arya are on video admitting to causing terrorism in Baluchistan and even Sindh. Pak should arm the Sikhs, Naga's and Naxals among others seeking separation from India.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Naxals release CoBRA jawan kidnapped during Bijapur attack, handoff captured on video. Watch! <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CoBRAjawan?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CoBRAjawan</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/BijapurAttack?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#BijapurAttack</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/RakeshwarSinghManhas?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#RakeshwarSinghManhas</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Bijapur?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Bijapur</a> <a href="https://t.co/e2Zq9LVfdT">pic.twitter.com/e2Zq9LVfdT</a></p>— IndiaToday (@IndiaToday) <a href="https://twitter.com/IndiaToday/status/1380166492545708032?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 8, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Jawan's family members thanked government lol, guess who forced them to do this.
 
[MENTION=139649]WhenSultansBowled[/MENTION]

Yes liberating IoK is our priority but when the likes of Gaurav Arya among others openly talk off spreading and supporting terrorism in FATA and Baluchistan then we too should arm the Sikhs and Naxals. Eent ka jawab patthar! Baluchistan and FATA are not UN recognized disputes so India and its people have no reason to complain when we play the same dirty game. India is an open playground for ISI where we can cause massive damage if ISI upped their game. Indian's like Arya are on video admitting to causing terrorism in Baluchistan and even Sindh. Pak should arm the Sikhs, Naga's and Naxals among others seeking separation from India.

Completely agree. If we had any sense of statecraft, we would've been supporting these separatist groups since long. Currently we hold no leverage over India, and then our naive PM is shocked that Indians aren't ready to talk on Kashmir :facepalm. Why would they ? They hold all the cards.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Naxals release CoBRA jawan kidnapped during Bijapur attack, handoff captured on video. Watch! <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CoBRAjawan?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CoBRAjawan</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/BijapurAttack?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#BijapurAttack</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/RakeshwarSinghManhas?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#RakeshwarSinghManhas</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Bijapur?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Bijapur</a> <a href="https://t.co/e2Zq9LVfdT">pic.twitter.com/e2Zq9LVfdT</a></p>— IndiaToday (@IndiaToday) <a href="https://twitter.com/IndiaToday/status/1380166492545708032?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 8, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Jawan's family members thanked government lol, guess who forced them to do this.

Naxals have massive local support. There are families in the gathering.

No way India can afford to deny them their rights.
 
Naxals have massive local support. There are families in the gathering.

No way India can afford to deny them their rights.

Their support base is mainly Adivasis (Tribals) and their leaders are all Upper Caste Communists.

Naxalites do not enjoy any support in urban areas and towns.
 
Completely agree. If we had any sense of statecraft, we would've been supporting these separatist groups since long. Currently we hold no leverage over India, and then our naive PM is shocked that Indians aren't ready to talk on Kashmir :facepalm. Why would they ? They hold all the cards.

They hold the card because of our pacifist PM. When Modi and his men openly threaten Pak our PM talks about making peace. Our PM is a coward.
 
I hope the Indian media is right when they say Pak is behind the recent murder of Indian soldiers. They insist that the heavy weapons used by the Naxals can only be attained through Pak.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Naxals release CoBRA jawan kidnapped during Bijapur attack, handoff captured on video. Watch! <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CoBRAjawan?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CoBRAjawan</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/BijapurAttack?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#BijapurAttack</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/RakeshwarSinghManhas?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#RakeshwarSinghManhas</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Bijapur?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Bijapur</a> <a href="https://t.co/e2Zq9LVfdT">pic.twitter.com/e2Zq9LVfdT</a></p>— IndiaToday (@IndiaToday) <a href="https://twitter.com/IndiaToday/status/1380166492545708032?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 8, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Jawan's family members thanked government lol, guess who forced them to do this.

Another Abinandhan case? Pakistan released him as a goodwill gesture, but what about the Naxals? Did they demand something in return?
 
Another Abinandhan case? Pakistan released him as a goodwill gesture, but what about the Naxals? Did they demand something in return?
Some are already propagating that Abhinandan was released due to Modi's efforts.

Now see him taking credit for this jawan's release. Jawan's family is already singing paeans of government.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another Abinandhan case? Pakistan released him as a goodwill gesture, but what about the Naxals? Did they demand something in return?
They don't have any issues with security forces, they always tells security personnel to stay away from antinaxal operations.
 
No. Any move to aid separatists or terrorists has only come back to bite the hand that feeds. No one benefits.

Only solution is to continue with development agenda.
Naxalites have reduced in numbers already. They fight a losing battle as no one wants a naxal as a leader. The villages they control now want progress. The leaders who were instigating them are slowly fading out of Indian political scene.
their last stand in chattisgarh is also going and the naxalites will have to find a better way to fight their battles, maybe on an election ground which is the way rest of India works.
 
Haven't been well versed with this Naxalite situation. Can someone shed some light briefly on history, what naxalites want, what indian govt want, and what is the current situation.
 
Haven't been well versed with this Naxalite situation. Can someone shed some light briefly on history, what naxalites want, what indian govt want, and what is the current situation.

They want a communist state
 
10 Cops, Driver Killed In Blast By Maoists In India

Chhattisgarh Maoist Attack: The policemen were returning from an anti-Maoist operation that was launched after intelligence inputs, officials said.

Ten policemen and their driver were killed on Thursday when their minivan was blown up by an improvised explosive device (IED) in the Bastar district of Chhattisgarh, officials said.
The policemen were returning from an anti-Maoist operation that was launched after intelligence inputs, they said.

The policemen belonged to the District Reserve Guard (DRG), a special force of the Chhattisgarh police that comprises mostly local tribals who have been trained to combat Maoists.

The DRG has been instrumental in several successful operations against the rebels in Bastar, a hotbed of left-wing extremism.

Union Home Minister Amit Shah spoke with Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel following the attack and assured all possible help.

"The news of the martyrdom of our 10 DRG jawans and a driver due to an IED blast targeting the DRG force which had arrived for anti-Naxal operation on the information of the presence of Maoist cadre under Aranpur police station area of Dantewada is very sad. We share the grief of their families. May their soul rest in peace," Mr Baghel tweeted.

The Maoists, also known as Naxals, have waged an armed insurgency against the government that has killed hundreds of people over six decades. They say they are fighting on behalf of the poorest, who have been left out of the country's economic boom.

Since 1967 the group seen as the greatest threat to the country's internal security have asserted control over vast swathes of land in central and eastern India, establishing a so-called "red corridor". They operate from thick forests, and their operations against the Indian administration and forces are shrouded in secrecy.

NDTV
 
Horrible tragedy.

Damn you naxals. No one has been able to contain them despite losing so many of our jawans over last few decades.
 
what do they really want?

Overthrow Indian central government and have a communist government.

OR form their own country if first option doesn’t succeeed.

They are clearly not going to win because unlike Kashmir they don’t have a third country actively rooting for them.
 
Overthrow Indian central government and have a communist government.

OR form their own country if first option doesn’t succeeed.

They are clearly not going to win because unlike Kashmir they don’t have a third country actively rooting for them.

They have significant support from CCP that can be ramped up at any time.

Indian govt just won't openly blame the Chinese the same way the blame Pakistan
 
They have significant support from CCP that can be ramped up at any time.

Indian govt just won't openly blame the Chinese the same way the blame Pakistan

but are their rights being trampled upon or somthing? there has to be a reason, why would you give up on democracy like that unless the government was really screwing you badly?
 
Back
Top