Does Sarfaraz Ahmed really suit coaching or mentorship roles?

[FearlessRoar]

What is Sarfaraz doing as the mentor for Dolphins? During the PCB Champions One Day Cup 2024, Dolphins were at the bottom of the table.

And in the ongoing PCB Champions T20 Cup 2024, Dolphins are also at the bottom. Sarfaraz has not even brought in any special talent to the team that could be considered a rising star. In bowling, batting, and fielding, the Dolphins are below par.

Points Table of on going PCB Champions T20 Cup 2024 (20-12-2024)

Does Sarfaraz Ahmed really suit coaching or mentorship roles?

 

[FearlessRoar]

Polls added

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Sorry but Sarfaraz is not a good mentor, still remember the day he brutally abused Mir Hamza for not finishing a chase for Quetta Gladiators.. although in no way was Hamza supposed to ace that.

 

[iPakistani]

Didn't half the Quetta players leave because of how bad of a captain he was? Naseem, Saim etc.
He was openly racist to Phehlukwayo live on air. This isn't a mentor for anyone.

 

[emranabbas]

Does sarfaraz have any coaching qualifications?

 

[mominsaigol]

Make him coach of the Pakistan cricket team.

 

[BunnyRabbit]

Could become a good mentor. But coaching takes special skills different from being a player that majority of our players lack and do not work on acquiring.

 

[Cricket Warrior]

He himself needs coaching classes... how can he coach youngsters?

 

[angrypathan]

individual who shouldn’t be anywhere near a mentorship role

 

[BouncerGuy]

Nay. Sarfaraz is not a coach. He might be a good captain or he was actually, but mentorship has backfired so far for him. His team dolphins were at the bottom in One day cup as well and now in t20 cup again.

Sarfaraz needs to groom some u19 level players at club level instead of wasting time here.

 

[shah9425]

Failed player now failed as coach

Retire please and get lost

 

[khyberlion]

Failed player now failed as coach

Retire please and get lost

And his fans are missing. If this was any other players this would have had a 1000 replied by now.

 

[shah9425]

And his fans are missing. If this was any other players this would have had a 1000 replied by now.

Yeah apart from 2015 WC performances

He was a total failed player and after becoming captain instead of being consistent his form continued to drop down and hid behind tailenders

Now failing as coach too

I hope he retires soon this fraud time is over

 

[khyberlion]

Yeah apart from 2015 WC performances

He was a total failed player and after becoming captain instead of being consistent his form continued to drop down and hid behind tailenders

Now failing as coach too

I hope he retires soon this fraud time is over

He was a decent player in SC for tests outside he was useless. Him shouting behind the stumps as if he in a market was an awful viewing. Just like his door is shut in international cricket same needs to be applied here. He's won 1 game in 13 odd games with a team which consists of many Pakistan players.

 

[FearlessRoar]

What is Sarfaraz doing as the mentor for Dolphins? During the PCB Champions One Day Cup 2024, Dolphins were at the bottom of the table.

And in the ongoing PCB Champions T20 Cup 2024, Dolphins are also at the bottom. Sarfaraz has not even brought in any special talent to the team that could be considered a rising star. In bowling, batting, and fielding, the Dolphins are below par.

Points Table of on going PCB Champions T20 Cup 2024 (20-12-2024)

Does Sarfaraz Ahmed really suit coaching or mentorship roles?

Under the mentorship of Sarfaraz Ahmed, the Dolphins finished the PCB T20 Cup 2024 without a single win.

 

[khyberlion]

Under the mentorship of Sarfaraz Ahmed, the Dolphins finished the PCB T20 Cup 2024 without a single win.

They also finished last in the champions cup too. Get rid of him before he causes further damage.

 

[followed]

Under the mentorship of Sarfaraz Ahmed, the Dolphins finished the PCB T20 Cup 2024 without a single win.

He is the biggest loser in the Pakistan cricket.
The most useless player ever to play this many matches.

Absolutely terrible player and he should be nowhere any team as a mentor or coach.

 

[Farhan The Man]

Owing to lack of education -- and prevailing societal conditions -- literally two earning options for him:

1. Grow a beard and monetize from islamic shows.
2. Become Unit in-charge of his mqm flavor of choice, be it mohajir, muthaida, jinnahpur etc, and monetize from bhatta khori.

Both choices are mutually exclusive.

 

[Bewal Express]

He is the biggest loser in the Pakistan cricket.
The most useless player ever to play this many matches.

Absolutely terrible player and he should be nowhere any team as a mentor or coach.

Sarfi is one of the best WKS we have produced, a solid WK/Bat and decent Captain

 

[Mamoon]

Failed player, failed captain, failed coach and mentor.

 

[mominsaigol]

Failed player, failed captain, failed coach and mentor.

No 1 t20 rank + ct 2017 winner aka pakistan's last icc trophy makes him a failed captain?

Okay

 

[The_KING]

Sarfraz is a toxic and uneducated person. There is no way he would ever succeed as a coach or mentor.

 

[Savak]

Being a decent captain doesn't necessarily translate into coaching.

 

[Muhammad Saad]

He is more of a censor then mentor with all the colorful abuses he’s got.

 

[MMHS]

Sarfraz was a very good on-field leader of own people, means he is good as a leader among his followers. But, I’m not sure he is that tactful or mature to accomplish a collaborative task with members from diverse backgrounds, some of whom might challenge status co.

Besides, coaching/team management is a different task than leading a cricket team - don’t think he is made for that. From a good player/captain, the transformation towards coaching needs lots of preparations and self-development, which might be challenging for him.

Mentor is the respectful wording of cheerleader, when it comes to cricket- not sure what mentors actually do. Last time I read that Afghans did well in 2023 WC because Jadeja (Ajay) was their mentor….. but then, Afghans went further in 2024 WC without any mentor.

 

[Nasty Naz]

How are the squads selected for this tournament? Is it a draft or are they assigned? He sucks at this but come on his squad is also a complete joke. If he drafted that then yeah it's 100% on him.

This whole mentor thing is nonsense idea anyways and the money all the mentors are getting is crazy.