What's new

England v Pakistan | 1st ODI | Chester-le-Street | 10/09/10 | Eng Innings

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ajmal has bowled well today! he deserves his 3rd wicket!
 
no.if he gives u out,u walk,if he doesnt u stay.its not ur job to decide.the players should do thier job,umpires thiers

We all know that but not walking when you know it's out is no different to claiming a catch you haven't caught.
 
We all know that but not walking when you know it's out is no different to claiming a catch you haven't caught.

no it is different.u claim the catch BEFORE the umpires decision,in a way trying to influence him.with not walking u r just doing what umpires tells u to do,stay on the wicket
 
3rd man up in circle for a fast bowler!!

Shoaib shud b captain....cannot do any worse than Afraidee
 
no it is different.u claim the catch BEFORE the umpires decision,in a way trying to influence him.with not walking u r just doing what umpires tells u to do,stay on the wicket

No your not, your simply asking the question by appealing. If anything it's the other way round, by not walking your trying to influence him.

Morgan is the danger man.
 
Bet you didnt say that when Symonds cheated us out of the Sydney test
We cheated ourselves from Sydney Test. If he wasn't given out no matter how low the target was we wont ever chase it, because it was fixed. You must thank Him for claiming catch.
 
England are easily picking up 7/8/9 runs an over here due to a gift boundary ball per over!

ffs!
 
We cheated ourselves from Sydney Test. If he wasn't given out no matter how low the target was we wont ever chase it, because it was fixed. You must thank Him for claiming catch.

Huh? i was talking about India's match at Sydney against Aus
 
Shoaib deserves a scalp - has bowled superbly, just doesn`t have anything to show for it.
 
Akthar has deserved 3/4 wickets today with effort hes put in!

still a class act even when hes past his prime!
 
No your not, your simply asking the question by appealing.

if they ask it like normal,then its okay,especially wen its hard to tell.but mostly they throw it up in the air n start celebrating as 100% its clean.that influencing the umpires
If anything it's the other way round, by not walking your trying to influence him.

Morgan is the danger man.
how is that?u r just standing?why should the batsman help the umpires,he'd simply follow his decision
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top