Extension to military chiefs and trampling of courts: barrage of stupid legislations in Pakistan, will anybody reverse it?

The Bald Eagle

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 25, 2023
Runs
12,261
Following approval from the federal cabinet, Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar presented bills in the National Assembly to increase the number of judges in the Supreme Court and Islamabad High Court, which has been subsequently approved

Additionally, the National Assembly also approved a legislative amendment to extend the service tenure of all military chiefs from three to five years. The bill was tabled by Defence Minister Khawaja Asif.

This amendment will extend the tenure of the Chief of Army Staff and heads of other military branches to five years, standardizing service durations across all branches, reported Express News based on sources.

During a session of the National Assembly presided over by Speaker Ayaz Sadiq on Monday, Tarar introduced a motion to suspend the question hour before the resolution was passed by a majority vote.

Following this, he presented the Supreme Court Practice and Procedure Ordinance for parliamentary approval, proposing an increase in the number of Supreme Court judges to 34.

As the bill was introduced, the opposition erupted into chaos, raising slogans and protesting. Despite the disruption, the minister briefed the assembly on the provisions of the bill, highlighting the backlog of thousands of pending cases at the Supreme Court's registry, which necessitates the increase in judicial capacity

Additionally, Tarar introduced the Islamabad High Court Amendment Bill 2024, explaining that the number of judges in the High Court would be raised from nine to 12. This legislative move aims to address the growing demand for judicial resources and enhance the efficiency of the legal system in Pakistan.

The amendment bill proposes significant changes, including a provision allowing appeals against decisions made by constitutional benches under Article 184(3) to be heard by a larger constitutional bench within 30 days, if possible. This amendment applies retroactively to cases before the 26th Constitutional Amendment.

Further additions, including Sections 7-A and 7-B, mandate that cases will follow a "first-in, first-out" basis for hearings. Another key change requires that proceedings for every case, matter, or appeal in the Supreme Court be officially recorded, with transcripts available to the public upon request.

The amendment specifies that court proceedings will be recorded, and official copies will be accessible to the public for a nominal fee of Rs50 per page. Verified copies of these records can be used for legal purposes, thereby increasing transparency in judicial processes.

Meanwhile, Asif presented amendments to the Pakistan Army, Navy, and Air Force Acts, which were passed by majority vote amidst intense protests from opposition members.

During the voting session, opposition members disrupted proceedings, chanting slogans, surrounding the Speaker’s dais, and tearing copies of the bill in protest. The uproar escalated, with some members engaging in physical altercations.

Immediately after the law minister and the defence minister presented the bills, the National Assembly proceeded with voting despite ongoing noisy protests from the opposition and approved the amendments.

These legislative moves reflect the government’s focus on judicial reform and the standardisation of military leadership tenures, addressing institutional demands and fostering continuity. The proposed amendments now await Parliamentary approval.

Source: The Express Tribune
 
Crux of stupid legislations today:

1. Army Chief gets 2 years extension ( term served amended from 3 to 5 years)
2. SC judges number doubled so basically a new SC established to be named as Constitutional Court
3. Islamabad High Court judges number increased from 9 to 12 so meddling easy now.
4. Anybody could be arrested for 90 days on suspicion of terrorism
5. Judges committee to include constitutional bench head as third member so Justice Munib Akhtar no longer again part of it.
 
Govt rushes bills in senate after NA on strength of Supreme Court judges, 5-year term of armed forces’ chiefs

The National Assembly on Monday passed six bills, including one seeking an increase in the number of Supreme Court judges and another related to the extension of the terms of armed services chiefs, amid deafening protest by the opposition.

The six bills passed by NA

The Supreme Court Number of Judges (Amendment) Bill, 2024
The Supreme Court Practice and Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 2024
The Islamabad High Court (Amendment) bill, 2024
The Pakistan Army (Amendment) Bill, 2024
The Pakistan Air Force (Amendment) Bill, 2024
The Pakistan Navy (Amendment) Bill, 2024
The first bill, related to the increase in the number of top court judges, was presented by Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar, who said that the government had proposed increasing the number of judges from 17 to 34.

“This amendment will increase the number of judges in the Supreme Court up to 34, so that the backlog of cases can be cleared, and that after the 26th Amendment, we can have judges to form the constitutional benches,” Tarar said.

Source: Dawn News
 
Not defending these ammendments but Pakistan desperately needs overall political and economic stability which can build the confidence of local and international investors. Without investment and big projects, this country cannot survive.

Army is just making use of these conditions and they have always taken. Imran khan can get something out of it (hopefully). Nobody can win by sitting in a jail in Pakistan. He has to come out and serve as opposition. Continue the political process. This country will remain same irrespective of who is PM and who is governing party, they will always be the puppets of Army either its Shehbaz, Nawaz or Imran is in power.
 
General Asim Munir is set for a long time now, Two terms of 5 years is the new rule. I do not have a problem with him bringing stability to Pakistan but he has increased cross border terrorist infiltration a lot in the past few months, this will again lead to instability between India and Pakistan which was quiet and stable since last 2-3 years.
 
Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said that Army Chief General Asim Munir will serve until 2027 following the recent approval of amendments to the Army Act

Asif highlighted that this legislative change would benefit democratic governments by setting fixed terms and eliminating the need for parliamentary approval for extensions.

Speaking with a private television channel, Asif confirmed that General Munir’s role as the country’s army chief will continue uninterrupted until 2027.

"Previously, several army chiefs were granted extensions, which required parliamentary endorsement," he explained, noting that the new amendment effectively closes this chapter on term extensions.

When asked about rumours of any deal involving the founder of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), Asif dismissed them, stating, “I’ve only heard it from you.”

He added that Pakistan’s future progress depends on self-improvement, steering the conversation toward broader governance reforms.

Asif declined to comment on matters concerning Bushra Bibi, the spouse of the PTI founder, saying only, “I have no comment on her whereabouts or activities.”

The amendment to the Army Act, which solidifies the terms for top military roles, aims to bring continuity and stability to Pakistan’s governance by reducing dependency on ad-hoc tenure extensions.

Parliament passes key bills on SC expansion, military chiefs’ tenure extension

The National Assembly on Monday approved a legislative amendment to extend the tenures of all armed services chiefs from three to five years. Hours later, the Senate approved the same set of bills, sending them to President Asif Ali Zardari for final approval.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif presented amendments to the Pakistan Army, Navy, and Air Force Acts, which were passed by majority vote amidst intense protests from opposition members. This amendment will extend the tenure of all military chiefs from three to five years.

The proposed changes will align the retirement and reappointment regulations across the armed forces, giving the president authority, upon the prime minister’s advice, to appoint, reappoint, or extend terms for these positions for up to five years.

The amendments remove previous age limits and extend tenure options, enabling the Chief of Army Staff and other military leaders to continue serving as generals beyond the earlier prescribed 64 years, should national security or critical needs arise.

Moreover, Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar also presented proposals to increase the number of judges in the Supreme Court and Islamabad High Court, which were subsequently approved by the House.

Tarar presented the the Supreme Court Number of Judges (Amendment) Bill 2024 for parliamentary approval, proposing an increase in the number of Supreme Court judges to 34. As the bill was introduced, the opposition erupted into chaos, raising slogans and protesting.

Additionally, the law minister introduced the Islamabad High Court Amendment Bill 2024, explaining that the number of judges in the High Court would be raised from nine to 12.

The changes also include amendments to the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act, 2023, to incorporate constitutional benches, expanding the scope and composition of judicial panels.

Proposed additions to Article 191A of the Constitution will enable these benches to address constitutional matters, with an administrative committee of senior judges responsible for allocating cases to either the Supreme Court or constitutional benches.

Despite the disruption, the minister briefed the assembly on the provisions of the bills, highlighting the backlog of thousands of pending cases at the Supreme Court's registry, which necessitates the increase in judicial capacity.

Tarar highlighted the need for additional judges to manage case backlogs and facilitate the formation of constitutional benches.

He noted that various bar associations, including the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), had advocated for this increase to expedite cases across Pakistan's judicial centers in Karachi, Quetta, Peshawar, and Lahore.

Immediately after the law minister and the defence minister presented the bills, the National Assembly proceeded with voting despite ongoing noisy protests from the opposition and approved the amendments.

During the voting session, opposition members disrupted proceedings, chanting slogans, surrounding the Speaker’s dais, and tearing copies of the bill in protest. The uproar escalated, with some members engaging in physical altercations.

These legislative moves reflect the government’s focus on judicial reform and the standardisation of military leadership tenures, addressing institutional demands and fostering continuity.

Source: The Express Tribune
 
Back
Top