What's new

Imam-ul-Haq as a Pakistan captain

m.shah

First Class Captain
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Runs
5,698
I know many would not agree with me but i just found him captaincy material. The way he carries in the interviews or the way he absorbs pressure like we saw his inning versus SA, Ban, Agf. There is something about him. How will he fare as a captain if given opportunity someday? But he definitely looks a man who can take pressure and deliver and not meek like others.
 
He is young right now, there are more senior players in the team. Plus I rather have a bowler as a captain rather than bat. Honestly there is no good candidate for captain right now. I hope we don't make someone captain who is not part of the playing 11 like we did with Waqar/Rashid/few others.
 
Imam would be a good choice in a few years because he can absorb pressure

Imad also because he’s competitive

Both of these guys need to fix their game first though
 
Someone who doesn’t get what his strength is after 25 games is definitely not captain material. Shan Masood would be a better bet.
 
Few years down the line when he learns to speak more responsibly

Or improves his English a little more. Already has the blonde touch on his hair so he’s definitely a leading candidate for captaincy.
 
And Bilawal AKA Billo Rani for PM of the country...

On a serious note, this is a preposterous post, if it wasn't for chachoo Inzi, Imam would find it hard to break into decent a club side...
 
He bats like a nightwatchman. I would pick Azhar Ali as an ODI opener over him.
 
Mohammad Amir for crying out loud. Imam is passive aggressive and has a massive chip on his shoulder being nephew of Inzi.
 
Imad Wasim would be a good choice but he's too arrogant/full of himself at least going off his interviews. Zaman is the best choice plus he was also a soldier so he's got that mental toughness.
 
Imad Wasim would be a good choice but he's too arrogant/full of himself at least going off his interviews. Zaman is the best choice plus he was also a soldier so he's got that mental toughness.

Zaman is a total tullay baaz who will get booted out sooner rather than later.
 
First let him prove himself. Show the match winning performances.

For now pak team can choice good bowler.

Amir will not represent because of the match fixing issues.
 
Imad Wasim would be a good choice but he's too arrogant/full of himself at least going off his interviews. Zaman is the best choice plus he was also a soldier so he's got that mental toughness.

Zaman is a total tullay baaz who will get booted out sooner rather than later.
 
Babar Azam is the only choice

First rule of captain selection: Pick a captain that is 100% certain starter in the team.
 
Imad Wasim would be a good choice but he's too arrogant/full of himself at least going off his interviews. Zaman is the best choice plus he was also a soldier so he's got that mental toughness.

Mental strength and Fakhar?? They don’t go together. I wonder how he got into the navy. No player in Pakistani team who is mentally strong. Making him the captain would be disastrous.
 
Make Babbar the captain and move towards a new direction with youngsters. Give wahab next world t20 and say that’s it. Move ahead with no 34+ years aged players in the squad. Build towards the next WC 2023 with most of these players, add few more youngsters.
 
I know many would not agree with me but i just found him captaincy material. The way he carries in the interviews or the way he absorbs pressure like we saw his inning versus SA, Ban, Agf. There is something about him. How will he fare as a captain if given opportunity someday? But he definitely looks a man who can take pressure and deliver and not meek like others.
.

Afridi and Sarfaraz were also brash and all, but on the field, quite conservative.

Perhaps Imam as captain for test matches over time but only if he has 'Strategy' chops.

Definitely not for one days. You need someone like Morgan or Finch or McCullum if you do not have gifted talents like Kohli or Williamson. Has to have the game for the format. My vote for one dayers will be for Fakhar.

Not Amir. He is tainted and can't be rewarded.
 
Maybe in a few years but he needs to cement his place in the team. He's been a disappointment this World Cup, but that doesn't make him a ****** either.
 
Make babar azam the captain.Captain must be guaranteed his place in the side,and preferably he should be able to lead from front.Cant make amir due to fixer tag.Fakhar zaman is hack and too old for rebuilding side aiming at a 5-10 yr project.
 
He is entertainment value with his comments and positive vibes.

Plus fairly well educated. Also a reliable performer. Quite a few ticks. It wont be a boring tenure for sure
 
cuptaany? kyon? what has he done to earn it? has he won us a word cup game yet? chup kur kay araam say bhetu bacha loag. The team needs new players not a new captain. We need Malik gone, Hafeez gone, Hasan ali dropped, wahab gone, Haris gone, (sorry too unfit and wont be around for the next world cup)..give the captain the right resources then judge him.
 
I know many would not agree with me but i just found him captaincy material. The way he carries in the interviews or the way he absorbs pressure like we saw his inning versus SA, Ban, Agf. There is something about him. How will he fare as a captain if given opportunity someday? But he definitely looks a man who can take pressure and deliver and not meek like others.

Your new captain will be
SHAAN MASOOD!
 
See that's wrong with everything that the PCB has done. There is nobody who is looking like a natural fit. Virtually any of the remaining 10 from the XI would like to think they have a shot at captaincy?

And when there is an official opportunity to groom someone this is what we do:
1. PSL - Make Hafeez, Sammy, Misbah, AB, Sami as captains
2. Zimbabwe tour - take full strength team, their wives and kids and make it a holiday

The management committee has failed big, big time and the only way they have got away with it is because it is Pakistan. If I was Imran Khan, I'd like to personally fire a kick in the butt of all members who are on the governing board of the PCB and tell them to pack their bags.
 
He is fluent in English, which is great but does not make someone captaincy material.
Seriously needs to improve batting strike rate to warrant a place in the team , let alone be considered as future captain.
 
Amir is the only choice.

Imam, babar, and all these others do not have the killer instinct. Nor does it seem they play to win.

We dont need another misbah era where losing centuries r celebrated by cuttibg cakes..

Imam clearly does not want to win by the style of his play.
His sr is too low and he does not take singles.

He is not a leader, nor a winner.
 
Captaincy material based on interviews !

Yiou know things are bad when............
 
I think the OP must have had a few cheeseburgers himself before making this thread.
 
Azhar Ali vol 2.

This guy is too emotional, can’t have someone like that at the helm.

Amir is a front runner if Imad was a better spinner he’d be in the running, should look to make himself more of a batsman who can bowl, he has a lot of potential as a batsman.
 
Azhar Ali vol 2.

This guy is too emotional, can’t have someone like that at the helm.

Amir is a front runner if Imad was a better spinner he’d be in the running, should look to make himself more of a batsman who can bowl, he has a lot of potential as a batsman.

Kohli too is emotional person and captain.This cannot be hold against Imam.Whatever i have seen him is the sense of responsibilty that Imam brings to the table and among the choices he is the best person to lead the side.
 
You can have any Railu katta as captain, the fact remains that it won't improve our skills. Unless Imam is some super coach with magical methods.
 
Failing like no tomorrow at the WC and people want him as the next captain. Fakhar or Amir should be the next captains.
 
No-one is captaincy material in the team because there is no-one who is motivated and aggressive enough. The closest that comes to mind in terms of that is Imad but he's not a very good player and in not a regular in the team.

This is a big dilemma
 
It’s between him, Babar, and Amir. One of these will be made captain by PCB after the WC.
 
We need a bowler as a captain; it's been a really long time.

Imam needs to go back to domestic cricket and play more for the A team.

I don't think I've ever seen him play conventional cricket shots; where the hell is the classic left handed cover drive?
 
Babar or Amir are the only alternatives and even they are not ideal captains. Babar could make a good captain but he needs one or two years of experience.
 
Last edited:
No Amir because of his past.

PCB needs to find someone else. None in this Xi are captain material.
 
A captain is an alpha-male and somebody the rest of the players you look up to. He doesn't have to be the best player in the XI but he needs to be good enough to merit a place in the side as a player alone.
 
I want Amir as captain.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Imam is not a practical option for captaincy for at least another two years.

A lot of people have made up their mind regarding him and only a consistent performance for at least 2 years with some match-winning performances under his belt will overcome nepotism claims.

Making him captain after the world cup will be a big mistake. Pakistan will most likely still lose which will put extra pressure on his individual performance. The guy will be abused left and right.

He may be a good option for long term but just the time is not right.
 
I’m gonna bump this thread. It will be interesting if Imam ul Haq is the next captain of Pakistan.

We surely can’t have Shadab or Shaheen as captains. They are just going to promote themselves to openers & start batting wrecklessly.

Imam ul Haq is a very technical guy and he plays 2 formats consistently. (50 avg. in ODIs & 39 avg. in Tests)

He is also a fluent English speaker and can handle media pressure with his left hand.
 
I’m gonna bump this thread. It will be interesting if Imam ul Haq is the next captain of Pakistan.

We surely can’t have Shadab or Shaheen as captains. They are just going to promote themselves to openers & start batting wrecklessly.

Imam ul Haq is a very technical guy and he plays 2 formats consistently. (50 avg. in ODIs & 39 avg. in Tests)

He is also a fluent English speaker and can handle media pressure with his left hand.
You lost me at “fluent English speaker” — that is not the standard. Sarfraz does not speak a lick of English and he brought us our most treasured ICC trophy in the last decade.
 
I’m gonna bump this thread. It will be interesting if Imam ul Haq is the next captain of Pakistan.

We surely can’t have Shadab or Shaheen as captains. They are just going to promote themselves to openers & start batting wrecklessly.

Imam ul Haq is a very technical guy and he plays 2 formats consistently. (50 avg. in ODIs & 39 avg. in Tests)

He is also a fluent English speaker and can handle media pressure with his left hand.

He’s the one that’s being accused of leaking stories about the dressing room.😬
 
Wo
He’s the one that’s being accused of leaking stories about the dressing room.😬
World Cup is just around the corner. The team as well as all the people supporting Team Pakistan should refrain from such rumors even if they are true, we really hope that they gel together before the big event and focus on bringing it home.
 
Wo

World Cup is just around the corner. The team as well as all the people supporting Team Pakistan should refrain from such rumors even if they are true, we really hope that they gel together before the big event and focus on bringing it home.

Unfortunately, there’s certain players in our team that are a bit too close to the journalists.
 
Unfortunately, there’s certain players in our team that are a bit too close to the journalists.
That is a crime that people commit and think as if they have done nothing. Back-biting has destroyed teams more than bad cricket at times.
 
It is big NO for me. The next captain of Pakistan is very much likely to be Shaheen Afridi.
 
It is big NO for me. The next captain of Pakistan is very much likely to be Shaheen Afridi.
I don't think thats the right choice at the moment. He might have won PSL trophy but the clear candidate for the captaincy is Rizwan. He is a tactician on the field. Shaheen can be made vice captain.
 
He’s the one that’s being accused of leaking stories about the dressing room.😬
He was initially suspected but he swore to Babar it was not him, but now they are certain it's another junior player in the squad, who apparently was promising a lot but did not deliver much, as per social media.
 
Making imam captain would be on a par with when shoaib malik was made captain back a long time ago. Pakistan don't need selfish mediocre players as captains.
 
Making imam captain would be on a par with when shoaib malik was made captain back a long time ago. Pakistan don't need selfish mediocre players as captains.

Best option was Imad. After the WC I'd try Saud Shakeel seems like an intelligent guy who's also mentally strong.
 
Best option was Imad. After the WC I'd try Saud Shakeel seems like an intelligent guy who's also mentally strong.

Ideally, you’d want someone that’s cemented his place in the national team. We have no real candidates to take over the captaincy unfortunately.

We might need a temporary captain, that can be rotated between 3 players until we find one player that can manage the team on his own.
 
Ideally, you’d want someone that’s cemented his place in the national team. We have no real candidates to take over the captaincy unfortunately.

We might need a temporary captain, that can be rotated between 3 players until we find one player that can manage the team on his own.
Azhar Ali never cemented his place and was made Captain. Same with sarfraz, the guy wasn't even a regular and him over nasir jamshed was a forced change.

Next thing you know, he's vice captain and soon becomes captain.

Just try saud out, I'd rather have him then have rizwan be captain. Rizwan is gonna captain no different then babar in terms of nepotism. Although he's likely gonna be superior In bowler rotation and field placements.
 
He was initially suspected but he swore to Babar it was not him, but now they are certain it's another junior player in the squad, who apparently was promising a lot but did not deliver much, as per social media.
Care to elaborate please? 😅
 
Well at this moment even a stick would be a better captain than our Number 1 player. So I'd definitely choose Imam over the Number 1 player.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't see Imam to be our captain anytime soon. Shaheen or Shadab are there having experience as well captaining a side in PSL. Shaheen even has won a PSL trophy. SO imam is not a choice for me.
 
This guy is a plague even yesterday he played selfishly just to keep him afloat in the side add to it he is a dot ball maestro
 
Ima is the worst thing to happen to Pakistan's LO cricket, he has enough of the stats that oldies look but with zero impact. He is buddy with Babar and we are stuck with him.
 
Back
Top