What's new

Mickey Arthur denies that he has asked for Sarfaraz Ahmed's dismissal as captain [post#18]

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,119
The Committee reviewed team’s performances in the last three years, including the World Cup, where Pakistan could not qualify for the semifinals.

Pakistan head coach Mickey Arthur has recommended to the PCB’s Cricket Committee that Sarfaraz Ahmed be sacked from captaincy as he himself sought two more years to deliver “remarkable results.”

The Committee reviewed team’s performances in the last three years, including the World Cup, where Pakistan could not qualify for the semifinals.

According to a source, Arthur suggested to the members that Shahdab Khan should replace Sarfaraz as captain in the limited-over formats while Babar Azam should be given the reins of the Test side.

“Arthur did have some negative things to say about Sarfaraz’s captaincy skills to the members,” the source said.

“I need two more years with the Pakistan team and then I can deliver remarkable results,” Arthur is believed to have told the Committee, headed by PCB Managing Director Wasim Khan.

Khan will have one more session with the members on Wednesday before forwarding recommendations on the appointment of the new team management to the board Chairman Ehsan Mani.

Arthur has been working as head coach with the Pakistan team since mid-2016. He has also applied for the position of head coach with the Sri Lankan Cricket Board.

Under him, Pakistan’s biggest gain was winning the ICC Champions Trophy two years back. The team became number one in ICC’s T20 rankings but performance in Test cricket dipped drastically while it remained inconsistent in One-day format.

The contracts of Arthur and other support staff member will expire on August 15.

Sources said Arthur, who made a presentation to the Committee on the team performances and selection decisions, is said to have left the members unimpressed with his arguments and explanations.

“The members were not satisfied with his argument that after the 2017 Champions Trophy the fielding standards of the Pakistan team went down after the forced exit of fielding coach, Australian Steve Rixon.

“Arthur made a big deal out of Rixon’s sudden departure in August 2018 as he had issues with the PCB management over delayed payments,” according to reliable sources.

The source added that after Arthur’s presentation, the committee members discussed other options and one of the members suggested trying Sri Lanka’s Mahela Jayawardena but was informed that since he was working with the Mumbai Indians in the IPL, the PCB would find it difficult to lure him with a better pay package.

https://www.thehindu.com/sport/cric...sarfaraz-ahmed-as-captain/article28819595.ece
 
note that in the article above - only quote as such is one about Arthur not being satisfied with Sarf captaincy - no actual quote about replacing him etc
 
shadab as captain... def not... he is one good spinner away from losing his place in the team and i think umer khan could be tht 1 spinner... so no

captaincy shld go to Harris Sohail for test and ODI and Babr for T20 with babar being Harris's deputy in ODI and test
 
Rubbish article full of hearsay.

If the Committee are "unimpressed" with his presentation, why are they going to extend his contract till the 2020 T20 WC as most reports say ?
 
shadab as captain... def not... he is one good spinner away from losing his place in the team and i think umer khan could be tht 1 spinner... so no

captaincy should go to Harris Sohail for test and ODI and Babar for T20

Exactly!!!!
 
Is it sarcasm? He is only 20!!!! How can you support someone around 20 in the team let alone a captain? Misbah will not like that

What experience of captaincy does Shadab have?
 
What experience of captaincy does Shadab have?

I am not supporting Sadab ODI captaincy for sure. This kid already thinks to highly of himself. I am just responding to Major's comment.
For me Haris should be for test and Babar for ODI and Sadab/Amir for useless T20.
 
It's no open secret about Mickey Arthur being unhappy with Sarfaraz performance as a player and as captain. He has been requesting the PCB to sack Sarfaraz since the end of the Asia Cup in 2018.
 
Just goes to show how incompetent Mickey and how he has no idea on what it takes to build a proper team.

Shadab shouldn’t even be a permanent member of the team let alone captain. An utterly absurd choice that should be enough to ensure that Mickey’s contract is not renewed.

Shadab is pushing for a place among the luckiest players in international cricket history. A totally average player who would barely make into a Ranji Trophy team with his nothing leg-spin and awful batting.

Apparently diving around like a dolphin in the field for the cameras is enough to become a captain at the international level. What a complete joke.
 
Too early for Shadab to be captain, for certain he could make good captain in future. First he needs to perform consistently and win more matches for Pakistan.
As I siad before in another thread Haris Sohail is also not good choice as he would be missing may matches due to his fitness/injures.
Babar A can be T20 and ODI captain.
For Test I cannot think of anyone if it would not be Shan Masood.
 
Sarfraz has done a phenomenal job with the T20 side and should remain the captain for the next two editions of the wc.

Making shadab captain would be illogical and ridiculous, however I wouldn't be surprised because it is the pcb.
 
Making Shadab a captain will not as absurd as giving the job to Malik, Hafeez, Imad or Shan Masood.

He makes it to every LOI match and is a regular. Don't have a better leggie right now in PAK - no, it's not Yasir Shah for LOIs!

Of course, Babar, Haris Sohail, or M. Amir - these are permanent fixtures and captain can also be made from one of these. For Tests it can definitely be Babar.

People forget that one has to make the team on merit first, and be able to play every match with strong performances.
 
We spoke with Mickey Arthur and he has dismissed these reports as incorrect
 
Just goes to show how incompetent Mickey and how he has no idea on what it takes to build a proper team.

Shadab shouldn’t even be a permanent member of the team let alone captain. An utterly absurd choice that should be enough to ensure that Mickey’s contract is not renewed.

Shadab is pushing for a place among the luckiest players in international cricket history. A totally average player who would barely make into a Ranji Trophy team with his nothing leg-spin and awful batting.

Apparently diving around like a dolphin in the field for the cameras is enough to become a captain at the international level. What a complete joke.
But he always plays with a smile on his face and he is the best friend of CT man of the series, and he is some sort of fire in his eyes which no world-class player possess
 
Who is satisfied with Sarfraz apart from himself so this is hardly any secret.
 
Of course, Babar, Haris Sohail, or M. Amir - these are permanent fixtures and captain can also be made from one of these. For Tests it can definitely be Babar.
[/B]
.

Amir has retired from test cricket. Haris is injury Prone. Babar would have too much on his plate if he is Test and Limited over captain, if so.
 
Just goes to show how incompetent Mickey and how he has no idea on what it takes to build a proper team.

Shadab shouldn’t even be a permanent member of the team let alone captain. An utterly absurd choice that should be enough to ensure that Mickey’s contract is not renewed.

Shadab is pushing for a place among the luckiest players in international cricket history. A totally average player who would barely make into a Ranji Trophy team with his nothing leg-spin and awful batting.

Apparently diving around like a dolphin in the field for the cameras is enough to become a captain at the international level. What a complete joke.

That diving like the dolphin comment made me laugh ,hahahaha..
 
If you guys watched PSL, Misbah would consult shadab on fielding places in the third psl.

In the 4th PSL, Shadab was captaining the team aswell
 
We spoke with Mickey Arthur and he has dismissed these reports as incorrect

Probably shocked to see this become public. Arthur has openly shown his disliking for Sarfraz as a captain even in the pressers.

If you remember correctly there was another leaked news of Arthur bashing Azhar, Asad and Sarfraz. And in return Sarfraz openly bashed bowlers in the press conference day after to prove rumours as true.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't blame him if he asked for Saifi's dismissal as a captain. Sarfraz has done nothing for this team. The credit for our CT win goes to Fakhar, Amir and Hassan Ali.
 
People getting excited over some report that no-one even knows to be true, and have sharpened their knives for the agendas they've been carrying for some time.
 
Mickey Arthur criticized Sarfaraz's captaincy in public against Australia vs the UAE for bowling Wahab instead of Abbas
 
Mickey arthur just trying to keep his job and milk pcb if he stays then wasim khan is not worthy of his job ...
 
@ MenInG,
Is there any news of coaching staff, captain and selectors? Today is 6th of August
 
Its 10.15 pm still no update. PCB needs to be more professional.
 
Mickey is arrogant and self-obsessed. There was a report linking him with the England squad and the feedback from fans was a massive no. Would rather have someone like Trevor Bayliss who stays in the background.
 
So it started? If so will there be any decision of supporting staff, selectors and captain in today's meeting?

There was no indication that it would be a meeting in person. It may have been done over the phone. (Might be wrong, haven't had time to check.) Don't expect too many updates, everything will be done privately.... Doubt recommendations will be made public.
 
If he actually wanted Shadab as captain that is very funny. Guy needs to improve his bowling before we talk about captaincy.
 
Its 10.15 pm still no update. PCB needs to be more professional.

The committee will forward its recommendations to the PCB Chairman who will have the final authority on which recommendations to accept and put aside.

The recommendations will not be made public yet and are for internal use for now
 
If he actually wanted Shadab as captain that is very funny. Guy needs to improve his bowling before we talk about captaincy.

If it is somehow true it's probably on the basis of his exemplary commitment and results on the field.

But as you said his bowling isn't good enough and as an AR his batting is sub-standard to say the least.
 
If it is somehow true it's probably on the basis of his exemplary commitment and results on the field.

But as you said his bowling isn't good enough and as an AR his batting is sub-standard to say the least.

We know Micky loves spin bowling all rounders so if it is true it wouldn’t shock me.
 
Back
Top