Honestly india played bad in 2021 and 2022 t20 cause they were tired after IPL. Majority of the Indian team take ipl seriously unlike the foreign players. Cummins plays like its a paid vacation.
Also india missed a few bowlers in t20 2022 wc.
I am not sure if Pakistan could have beaten a fully fit indua in 202q even.
My point was that consistency doesn't beat Value, it's why people like Travis head, Vvs laxman, Fakhar zaman(to a lesser extent) are valued more and actually get you tournament wins over consistent ones.
Yes if you are consistent and valuable like kohli and Dhoni then you're an atg.
Theirs a reason why rizwam, Babar, Misbah botch tournaments.
Let's take Misbah for example. His comfort zone is Accumulation, and he has won a few series and games for pakistan where that was the situation that was asked of him and he achieved it cause it's right up his ally, bit cricket is a game where your ideal situation does not come every game especially in tournaments.
You wanna know why Mohali, 2012 England game, 2013 ct west indies game happened?
It's because Even though the rr was 5.5 in Mohali, Misbah will play every game in the EXACT SAME FASHION, which is 2 of 10, then 7 of 20, then 16 of 30, then 22 of 40, then 30 of 55, then 40 of 65, then 50 of 74.
In a situation where you're asked to play according to the RR and don't have the luxury of an attacking batter batting at the other end, you are screwed and you will be blamed for the botch plain and simple.
It's also why rizwan was a failure at no 4 in t20, because legside Accumulation is his game, He doesn't know how to cone in and up and ante right of the get go.
It's also why he and chacha lost 2022 Asia cup final because 170 is beyond their caliber, They do not know how to play according to these standards so despite having wickets in hand, they left the team at a situation of 60 to chase of 24.
That's why Misbah is never considered even ampung top 25 batsmen for pakistan despite being the most consistent. Someone like Inzi or saeed Anwar or fakhar zaman may be inconsistent but when they are onsong, then it's game over for the opposition.
Whereas misbah and rizwan are always onsong but will only win you games IF THE PROPER CIRCUMSTANCES FOR THEIR COMFORT ZONE align for them. God forbid if they are asked to do anything else that's outside of their comfort zone like maybe for once play shots on the offside or actually play at a strike rate of the scoreboard and not your own 70 sr.