Pakistan vs South Africa | 3rd ODI | Dubai | 02-Nov-2010 | SA Innings [batting 1st]

[Maula Jutt]

Oh well, poor decision. But I guess that's how things go. YK was also a victim of such a deicision in the last match.

Let's move on.

 

[ZAK]

Well done Fawad.

 

[RehanG]

Notw : Match fixed!!!!!

 

[saj001]

Bowl short to amla!!

 

[Wanton]

What about when younis was given out from inside edge on sunday.

exactly....! Its not pak teams fault.

How many times they called a pakistani batsman back after a wrong decision.

 

[Sledger]

Some shine gone off the game. That was a real howler and could really affect the match. :billyd

 

[mZj]

the wrong button mistake has happened before in a match even :S why couldn't zameer just accept if this was the case????? :S

 

[JibranAnsari]

lets not, that was a very bad call

i would rather lose than win with such calls

I feel disgusted as well and have shown disgust in more posts

 

[Hamxa89]

i think he pressed the wrong button but didnt have guts to accept his mistake and press the right button

Exactly what I think.

 

[saj001]

nice finally he bowls one short

 

[RehanG]

Oh well, poor decision. But I guess that's how things go. YK was also a victim of such a deicision in the last match.

Let's move on.

that was the umpire.. this time it was 3rd umpire with 27 camera's and 1000s of reply's

 

[Jo_Don]

Is the 3rd umpire related to Zoni? Then it would make sense.

 

[Strike!]

If that had been a decision against us, The meltdowns here would be insane.

 

[NJamal]

63/3 after 17 overs

 

[Maula Jutt]

So why didn't he overturn the decision?

He already referred it to the third umpire. He cant reverse it then.

 

[ZAK]

63/3 after 17 overs.

 

[MrPakistan786]

Sadly win or lose this match will be remembered for the wrong dismissal by the Third umpire

 

[saj001]

Good start by

 

[usman_sheikh]

what the hell. why didnt afridi take his appeal back. bad sportsman ship after southafrica donated their wages to flood victims. Really disappointed

 

[mZj]

A howler by a third umpire, how often do you get to hear that??? God!! I would hate to think what would Zameer do if he is given charge of a UDRS in a match!!!

 

[90MPH]

Afridi would never call a player back in a million years, its a win at all costs in his style of play.

 

[Poison]

Get over it guise, its a bad decision fair enough, but over-reaction like usual!

Good play by De Villiers though, a lesser player would've waited and complained like a sissy girl.

 

[haroonrasheed320]

On a side note, can he come back later I mean if a wicket falls now?

 

[taxzu]

That was not third umpire but third class umpire. Should be fired by pcb.

 

[JibranAnsari]

that was the umpire.. this time it was 3rd umpire with 27 camera's and 1000s of reply's

the only things which come to my mind is that he is either drunk or can not fuking accept his mistake.

 

[Levity]

Poor guy, he will be sweating it out for the rest of the game, the umpire.

 

[Maula Jutt]

that was the umpire.. this time it was 3rd umpire with 27 camera's and 1000s of reply's

True. Very poor show. But wrong decisions are part and parcel of the game, we all know that. If anything, this would just go against Zameer in his career graph. Let's move on.

 

[saj001]

Direct wicket would have got him

 

[90MPH]

Oh well, poor decision. But I guess that's how things go. YK was also a victim of such a deicision in the last match.

Let's move on.

There is a big difference though.

 

[haroonrasheed320]

Stop effin blaming Afridi for everything

 

[Sledger]

Afridi bowling very well.

 

[Sledger]

On a side note, can he come back later I mean if a wicket falls now?

No he's out.

Big wide by Afridi.

 

[saj001]

Don bradman fielding well

 

[Hamxa89]

I do not think AB should not have walked so easily. Should have stayed there and put some pressure on the 3rd ump. He just shrugged as if " oh *uck it! *

 

[90MPH]

There is a bitter taste in my mouth still.

 

[ZAK]

66/3 after 18 overs.

 

[Shakil_pkcricket]

shud have ben reversed. atleast Afridi after seeing it on the big screen shud have called him back.

 

[MrPakistan786]

S.A. will lodge a complain against Zameer after the match and the referee will probably recommend he be removed from the ICC list

 

[saj001]

Smith got his mukka ready for Zameer Haider..

 

[Wanton]

what the hell. why didnt afridi take his appeal back. bad sportsman ship after southafrica donated their wages to flood victims. Really disappointed

Why Afridi shud call him back???? Did Botha did it after younis got wrong decision in the last game?

 

[UmarAkmals-fan]

Even Fawad Alam, who was walking past AB as he headed back looked surprised with the call. AB just shrugged, looking clueless as he kept walking

 

[JibranAnsari]

Stop effin blaming Afridi for everything

its not about blaming or anything , people just expected him to show some sportsman spirit as the umpire clearly got the decision wrong and u know that too.

 

[Maula Jutt]

How can Afridi call him back after third umpire has given him out? Come on people!

 

[usman_sheikh]

could some one tell us if umpire is related to zulqernain

 

[IAJ]

He already referred it to the third umpire. He cant reverse it then.

Well that was before the replays was showed. He could have at least asked him if he pressed the wrong button. Many things could have been done differently here yaar.

 

[Jo_Don]

I think this balances forever all the wrong decisions that have gone/will go against us

On-field decisions go against everyone, there's no conspiracy against Pakistan.

But to get it wrong on a clear replay is pathetic.

 

[saj001]

singles on offer

 

[Maula Jutt]

S.A. will lodge a complain against Zameer after the match and the referee will probably recommend he be removed from the ICC list

And hence he would pay for his mistake. Simple.

 

[ZAK]

Ajmal comes back into the attack.

 

[UmarAkmals-fan]

There is a bitter taste in my mouth still.

bhai kuch meetha kaoo

 

[Sledger]

Why the hell would Afridi call someone back and undermine the authority of the umpires. Serious lack of understanding being shown here.

 

[oracleg]

Bad thing about that decision is now the umpires might look to 'even things up' in the Pak innings.

 

[JellyBro]

stupid umpiring. Is there a facet of this game left where we don't look questionable in?

 

[haroonrasheed320]

haha its real funny people saying Afridi should have called him back, ohhh haters they never shut just wait for an opportunity to bash Afridi even if it wasn't his fault/mistake/job/involvement.

 

[saj001]

:4

 

[MRSN]

 

[usman_sheikh]

match 100 percent fixed by our 12 the man......haider umpire

 

[JibranAnsari]

How can Afridi call him back after third umpire has given him out? Come on people!

imran khan called srikanth back when umpire gave him out , that was some sportsmanship

 

[Afridirocks]

ajmal is not bowling good

 

[sanakazmi]

Whenever someone hits an aerial shot off his bowling Ajmal shouts CATCH IIIIIIT, haha.

 

[Sledger]

Amla playing Ajmal really well.

 

[tauseefm]

S.A. will lodge a complain against Zameer after the match and the referee will probably recommend he be removed from the ICC list

I hope never to see such an idiot ever again!!!

 

[JibranAnsari]

amla is in so good form

 

[Hamxa89]

And he didn't even take long to give that out! That was pretty funny actually. He just saw through the stump cam and was like " oh wait! Thats clearly out! " )

 

[Amjid Javed]

I have to say on AB decision if all the players could see the replays then AB should have been called back by the pakistan skipper. Anyways what is done is done.

 

[usman_sheikh]

This was the worst blunder by 3rd umpire in the history of the game

 

[ZAK]

74/3 after 19 overs.

 

[Hamxa89]

its not about blaming or anything , people just expected him to show some sportsman spirit as the umpire clearly got the decision wrong and u know that too.

We all know your love for Afridi. No bias involved at all. right?

 

[JibranAnsari]

is zameer haider 80 years old?

 

[usman_sheikh]

OUT OUT OUT....3rd umpire gives it out

 

[Free Hit]

I have to say on AB decision if all the players could see the replays then AB should have been called back by the pakistan skipper. Anyways what is done is done.

whatever!!!!

 

[Poison]

Imagine if there's another close stumping 3rd umpire call )

 

[MrPakistan786]

Ok guys we weren,t happy with what happened and we have all had our say, so lets not mention it now till after the game has ended.


Please

 

[Amjid Javed]

Pakistan need to get Amla out here!

S.A 75/3 after 19 overs.

 

[iZeeshan]

How are people on this forum so stupid?

Afridi CANNOT JUST CALL A PLAYER BACK if he's been given out.

So dumb.

 

[Sledger]

These players never hit the stumps ffs.

 

[somepassion]

What would have happened if this decision was given against a Pak batsmen.......!!!!!

 

[Maula Jutt]

Well that was before the replays was showed. He could have at least asked him if he pressed the wrong button. Many things could have been done differently here yaar.

I dont think once the deicision has been turned to the third umpire, anyone can challenge his decision. Correct me if I'm wrong by referring me to the ICC law.

 

[saj001]

duminy didn't know much about this one

 

[tauseefm]

I hope they don't call the third umpire onwards in this match.