What's new

Pakistan's Rotten Core – Mohammad Rizwan, Babar Azam, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Haris Rauf, Shadab Khan & Naseem Shah: Is the team better without them?

Should Mohammad Rizwan, Babar Azam, Shaheen Afridi, Haris Rauf represent Pakistan in any format?


  • Total voters
    33
According to many senior sports reporters, Hesson told the likes of Babar, Rizwan and Shaheen that the trio are not going to be in Pakistan's T-20 plans for a while now and the team management is now going to prioritize youngsters, PSL and domestic performers in this format but the trio is definately going to be in the team's ODI and test plans and if they wish to make a comeback they will have to work on their games and meet modern demands.

The problem with this approach is that Pakistan's international calender is mostly focused on T-20's, we already play so few ODI and Test matches and as a result the trio is going to feel marginalized. I predict the PCB is going to relax the NOC policies for Babar and Shaheen in order to compensate them.
 
Shaheen was the first pick in BBL 2025 draft. Rizwan was also picked by Renegades. Babar was already picked in pre-draft by SIxers.

Looks like Big bash teams want this rotten core to bounce back.
 
Shaheen was the first pick in BBL 2025 draft. Rizwan was also picked by Renegades. Babar was already picked in pre-draft by SIxers.

Looks like Big bash teams want this rotten core to bounce back.
Shadab Khan was also picked by Sydney Thunder.
 
Nawaz/ Shadab - only one can play and Nawaz is better option at this point.

Fakhar any day over babar , when Babar was batting we were not worried at all but same can't be true for Fakhar.

:kp
 
We’re just bad. It’s not that deep. We complain about flawed players when there are players doing nothing in the line up.

Best thing this team can do is to improve fitness, fielding and strength training. Maximise what you can actually control.

We haven’t had a single great or even very good T20 batsmen in our entire history. They’re all rubbish.
 
Babar, Shaheen, Rauf, Shadab, Rizwan - these guys shouldn't be in the T20 team in my opinion. They lost forms.
 
Seriously, let's organise a mass Hartaal Like during the Imran Khan episode..We keep using TRied and tested Failures !!! Babar, shaheen , Nawaz, Shadab, Salman This is absolutely infuriating

Why on God's earth do we keep using these failures? We needa mass protest outisde PCB HQ in Gaddafi stadium . I mean really cause a major Rukus ,

Think of any normal job , your hiring staff to run a office. Would you keep the same people employed who have ran your business in tonthe ground 13 times ? why on Earth do we keep trying the same failures over and over, thinking they will miraculously come good . Definition of insanity..

We need a purge , a complete overhaul. We need some fresh faces from the domestic scene, get rid of Fakhar even getting on near 40.

I WOULD BE COMPLETELY HAPPY WITH A BRAND NEW 11, Save maybe Saim Ayub, Farhan, Usma tariq. That's it , no one else. 8 new players , brand new team.

This is an absolute disgrace, a national shame. The government should step in at this point, this is a huge blow to our national identity , India has thrashing us now for near 2. decades .

A bunch of meek sheep's, No skill , No game sense , No tactical awareness , No technique. A complete and utter disgrace
 
Don't think they would get into Nepal's team, sad decline in standards.
 
Harbhajans latest comments "This Pakistani side is so poor and ordinary, they will struggle to beat a domestic side in India"

Truth hurts but facts
 
Harbhajans latest comments "This Pakistani side is so poor and ordinary, they will struggle to beat a domestic side in India"

Truth hurts but facts
Seems harsh but is that true though? Maybe they can beat an India A team unless Pakistan has a bad day or am I being an over delusional fan?
 
Harbhajans latest comments "This Pakistani side is so poor and ordinary, they will struggle to beat a domestic side in India"

Truth hurts but facts
Bhai the sooner we learn this the better our international team is not at standard for international competition. This is not an insult or criticism. This is a fact. We are playing Pakistan A team, because we don’t have players capable of being professional. So we have to send in Pakistan A team to represent us.
We really should be honest with ourselves. To improve in life, first step is admitting there is a problem.
 
Leave aside wild exaggerations made in the aftermath of an easy win, I think an India A team can seriously challenge Pakistan. I’d even say we would take 4 or 5 out of every 10 game.
 
Mohammad Yousaf speaking during an interview:
“We all want him to perform the way he used to—when his name was celebrated worldwide. Babar was called the King, there was constant hype, and his performances were outstanding. So, what has happened that these three players have declined so much during the tournament? My view is that such things shouldn’t normally be said, because we’ve played cricket ourselves. But repeated failures have forced us to speak up. After all, we are all here because of Pakistan. If Pakistan wins, everyone’s respect is intact. So why have their performances dropped so low?”

“Look at Shaheen—he used to bowl brilliantly, swinging the ball both ways. Now that quality is gone, the ball neither comes in nor goes out. Why has this happened? Did he ever go to a senior like Wasim Akram and ask, “My bowling has dropped so much, what should I do?” Take Waqar Younis as an example: when he had pace, his inswing was deadly. But when his pace dropped, he learned to swing the new ball away. That’s why Waqar and Wasim are still remembered as greats—they kept learning and adapting. We are not learning. Shaheen is a tremendous bowler, but right now, to improve his performances, he needs to go back to first-class cricket, play there, and learn from Wasim and Waqar.”

“Similarly, Babar is a fantastic player. But why is it that now he struggles even against part-time spinners? A little swing, and he opens his chest up. I’ve been saying for a long time that his technique has deteriorated. He needs to improve it, play first-class cricket, and spend time at academies. Unfortunately, the people around him lifted him too high, and in doing so, they spoiled him.”

About Shadab Khan’s comments:

“We want them to win more, not just rely on that one victory. The more they play well, the happier we’ll be, because Pakistan’s name will shine. I’ve already said these three (Shadab Khan, Shaheen Shah Afridi and Babar Azam) were outstanding players, but there has been a decline, and we are explaining why. That one win in 2021 seems to have made them believe they are the best, and they stopped learning. Babar, at his level, after 10–11 years of cricket, should have been asked by management: “In which phase of the innings are you most comfortable? In the first six overs, can you score 60–65 runs? Between overs 7–14, can you maintain 8+ runs per over? In the death overs, can you deliver 10+ runs per over?” A player of his caliber should be guided like this. I want Babar to finish his career like Sachin or Kohli. But the people around him, who keep inflating him, are damaging his cricket even now. If he wants to succeed in T20 cricket, my advice is: go back to first-class cricket, fix your technique, and then return stronger.”

“Look back at the Champions Trophy, when Shadab Khan dismissed Yuvraj with a brilliant drifting delivery—there was pace, drift, everything. But now, even in the India match, he conceded an easy boundary, his bowling lacked bite, and his fielding was poor. In one over, he gave away 15–17 runs. Clearly, his bowling and fielding have declined. The biggest problem is that whenever someone becomes captain, they want to bat as opener or one-down. When Shadab captained Islamabad United, he started batting at number three or four. But his main job is bowling. He should return to domestic cricket, bat at six or seven, and focus on bowling. Pakistan desperately needs players at those lower-middle order positions, but everyone wants to open or bat one-down.”

About Saurav Ganguly’s statement that “There’s no match here anymore”:

“Yes, absolutely. In the past, even when we lost World Cup matches, India respected us, they feared us, they never said such things. But now, even when we win, they don’t acknowledge us. They don’t celebrate dismissals; they don’t even look happy after victories. They just say, “There’s no competition left.” That shows we must raise our game again. This is about Pakistan’s honor.”

“We’ll need to bring in young players, fresh legs, because another T20 World Cup is just two years away. New players must come in. Of course, we hope Pakistan wins and performs well, but moving forward is essential.”

“In my view, responding with performances is the best way. That makes everyone happy. Even when we played, criticism came our way. But we listened to what senior players said on TV, picked out the useful points, and tried to improve. If something didn’t seem right, we still respected them, knowing they wanted Pakistan to succeed. When we performed, they praised us, even called us personally. Tomorrow, these current players will also sit on TV panels and criticize others. That’s not to bring anyone down, but to help Pakistan win. So, they should take criticism positively.”

About Babar Azam’s number:

“Babar is a high-level player with over a decade of experience. Management should ask him directly: “Which phase of the innings do you prefer to play in? Our targets are clear—early overs, middle overs, death overs. Where do you fit best?” That’s the way forward.”
 
Mohammad Yousaf speaking during an interview:
“We all want him to perform the way he used to—when his name was
“Babar is a high-level player with over a decade of experience. Management should ask him directly: “Which phase of the innings do you prefer to play in? Our targets are clear—early overs, middle overs, death overs. Where do you fit best?” That’s the way forward.”

In other words

Management to Babar: “Which phase of the innings do you prefer to play in? Our targets are clear—early overs, middle overs, death overs. Where do you fit best?”

Babar Azam: Yes
 
Back
Top