What's new

"PCB has suggested for Misbah-ul-Haq to continue till 2018" : Shahryar Khan

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
LAHORE: The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has requested Test captain Misbah-ul-Haq to continue leading the side till 2018 at least.

“Though Misbah is independent to decide about his future, the PCB has suggested him to continue till 2018,” said PCB chairman Shaharyar Khan in an exclusive interview to Dawn here on Monday.

“Because of his excellent fitness, Misbah can easily play international cricket for few more years. Besides, he is calm, well-educated, calculative and balanced and enjoys a lot of respect in the team,” he added.

“We have a couple of names in our minds regarding who would lead the side after Misbah’s retirement but we need to analyse them in detail before taking any decision.

“Both Azhar and Sarfraz Ahmed are good choices but the former’s batting suffers whenever he leads the side. All-rounder Imad Wasim can also be a candidate as he has impressed the PCB with his ability of handling pressure at crucial stages of matches,” the chairman said.

Meanwhile, Shaharyar said both Salman Butt and Mohammad Asif were eligible for selection in the Pakistan team after taking part in first-class matches and it was up to selectors to decide when to test them.

When asked why the PCB had different approaches towards leg-spinner Danish Kaneria and the three tainted players — Salman, Asif and Mohammad Amir — as Danish had never mixed a match against Pakistan, the chairman said, “Kaneria was banned by the England and Wales Cricket Board. The PCB and all other cricket boards are now bound to follow it, but, I have sympathy for Kaneria and I think he should file an appeal before the ECB to get justice.”

Meanwhile, about the poor show of the Pakistan team on the New Zealand tour, Shaharyar said their bowlers bowled well but their batsmen again failed to perform on green-top pitches.

“Another factor which multiplied Pakistan’s problems was rainy weather due to which they could not play a warm-up match and hold proper practice sessions.”

He said Pakistan’s coaches were more familiar with Australian wickets and therefore they could guide their batsmen better about Australian wickets.

“Our batsmen have to adjust themselves on Australian pitches and avoid unnecessary stroke making,” he said.

To a question, he said junior team’s chief selector Basit Ali was appointed head coach of the Pakistan women team only for the ongoing tours of New Zealand and Thailand, and in future he would have to keep only one post and that would be decided by the board.

He admitted that the Pakistan U-19 team for next month’s Asia Cup in Sri Lanka was announced in the absence of Basit and added that the decision of sending him with the women team was temporary and major changes were being made in the women set-up.

Shaharyar said the Senate Standing Committee on Sports had summoned the PCB on women cricket and their meeting will be held in Islamabad on Tuesday (today).

The PCB chairman denied all such reports that he would quit the post soon.

“No, I have no such idea in my mind. I am an elected chairman till August 2017. And my health is also improving after the heart surgery,” he said.

To a question, the PCB chairman said the financial condition of the PCB was not strong at the moment but they would soon be helping organisations of other sports just like India and Bangladesh.

He also dispelled the impression that the PSL, after being run as a separate company, in future, would cause losses to the PCB.

“It is a wrong impression that the PSL will damage the PCB if run as a separate company. The PSL will work under the PCB and its profits and losses will be for the PCB,” he added.

“Last year, we provided money for the first edition of the PSL and in return we not only got back our principal investment but also the profit of US$2.5million,” he said.

http://www.dawn.com/news/1299217/pcb-requests-misbah-to-continue-as-skipper-till-2018
 
That's a very very wrong thinking.Persisting with Misbah won't solve anything.
 
Lol what,I thought some posters were joking in the match thread but :)) are they out of their minds.
 
Should focus on fast tracking a new captain (Azhar/ Shafiq/ Sarfaraz) and grooming him under Misbah. Asking a 42 and half year old Misbah to continue as captain is a very very wrong approach.
 
Pakistan has a terrible strategy.

Sure we will lose less if Misbah leads the team in 2017 also, but there is life after Misbah.

You can't spoon feed 10 cricketers Misbah forever, and hope that we will be fine forever.
 
This guy is one of the main reason for our downfall. First he persisted with Azhar Ali as ODI captain and now with Misbah as test captain. Good luck to rank 9.
 
This guy is one of the main reason for our downfall. First he persisted with Azhar Ali as ODI captain and now with Misbah as test captain. Good luck to rank 9.

Misbah is the major reason why we went to number one in the first place. He has overachieved with this mediocre team.
 
I'm not Pakistani but I'm a Pakistan fan.

And I see Misbah as a problem, not the solution.

Shaharyar Khan makes clear that he is the preferred skipper more for his education than anything else.

But you need a younger, more aggressive skipper.
 
PCB should stop wasting money and stop all U-19 or A tour as they can keep recycling these players for next 10 years
 
What a joke this chairman is , always come with nonsense ideas.

What a joke this chairman is , always come with nonsense ideas.
 
Misbah misbah misbah......
Need to move forwrad & look for replacment .for example sangkara going with great form end his carrer on high note & scb never request to continue because they want move forward to create a culture for new talent .
And here pcb chairman still living in his age and continue to damage pak cricket .
 
Last edited:
Keeping Misbah the players going as long as hes performing is fine. However the long term planning of the team has to better and Azhar has already shown in his brief stints as ODI and Test captaincy and domestically hes not up to scratch and its time to look at better options in terms of test captaincy.
 
The WI tour after Australia is the best place to start a captaincy stint.

A unique approach could be to appoint a new skipper but keep Misbah in the XI as a batsman (if he wants). This will help with the adjustment since Misbah isn't a problem in the dressing room nor does he have an ego.
 
This guy is one of the main reason for our downfall. First he persisted with Azhar Ali as ODI captain and now with Misbah as test captain. Good luck to rank 9.

Pathetic post. Misbah is one of the main reasons the team has been a sucess. Keep on weeping ungreatful 'fan'.
 
The Chairman is 83 soon, Misbah is 43 soon. Both should go after a few weeks/months. It's time to move one.
 
This is a joke! Let him go for God's sake. Australia series should be his last. Hand over the Test captaincy to Yasir Shah, as he is only permanent member in the starting XI.
 
This is a joke! Let him go for God's sake. Australia series should be his last. Hand over the Test captaincy to Yasir Shah, as he is only permanent member in the starting XI.

The same Shah who was dropped for the 2nd test?
 
The same Shah who was dropped for the 2nd test?

He wasn't dropped on performance basis, but on conditions basis, and we all know it turned out to be a blunder. So, don't think he will ever be dropped like this in the future, so this makes his spot a permanent one.
 
Pathetic post. Misbah is one of the main reasons the team has been a sucess. Keep on weeping ungreatful 'fan'.

Do you even understand what I meant? Misbah did great job until 2015 and 2016 but its stupidity to persist or force him to stay until 2018.
 
I think misbah and younis should retire after australia series , our next test after the australia one will be against west indies and though we havent won a series in west indies but i dont want to see these two play against west indies especially after we missed chances to play some young ones against west indies in UAE.


Misbahs future should also depend upon how the team performs in Australian, if its the same old story then we dont need him for teams like west indies , srilanka , zimbabwe and bangladesh next year.
 
Persisting with misbah and younis don't make sense at all after the australia series , our three test series after the australia series are against west indies , bangladesh and sri lanka. It will be a good time to younis's and misbah's replacements to settle and be prepapred we play against the top ranked teams again.

Please do not make azhar ali our captain , he can speak english but apart from that he is totally clueless as a captain.
 
I think Misbah will retire after the Australian tour regardless of PCB wanting him to stay. He wanted to retire in 2015, don't think he will want to be forced to stay on further.
 
@PCB

Do you believe in life after Misbah?

I can feel something inside me say,
I really don't think you're strong enough.
 
Misbah is the major reason why we went to number one in the first place. He has overachieved with this mediocre team.

he built this mediocre team. He had six freakin years. He kicked out all the players that could play with positive approach and he continued with a set of players that played like him tuk tukking against fast bowlers and getting most of their runs against spinners.

The no.1 tag for Pakistan is very very misleading.. I say this because Pakistan has never looked like a genuine no.1 to me with lots of flaws. Our fast bowling never contributed enough even abroad. We have always relied on one man show from Yasir Shah and pre Yasir we had Ajmal the one man bowling attack. We never had a batting to dominate fast bowlers even on graveyards of batting. Our batsmen always enjoyed playing their spells out and look to take charge against spinners.

Misbah is definitely responsible because he has lead this team for 6 years. You can see huge difference in our ODI performances after he was booted out and hopefully we can see same change in approach after we get rid of him in tests.
 
@PCB

Do you believe in life after Misbah?

I can feel something inside me say,
I really don't think you're strong enough.

What exactly is he applauded for in tests? for whitewashing teams like ENg and Aus at home? Even a mediocre team like Sri Lanka had Aus for lunch in their backyard. There is no magic science required for home series wins against teams like England and Australia. Their current batting is just not good enough to last against decent spinners on these tracks and if you have good ftbs they do the rest. but a good captain builds a good team that can be effective everywhere and for every situation not just get happy by whitewashing poor teams of spin at spinning pitches.
 
What Misbah gave us in ODIs? A team that was beaten 3-0 by BD at their home. PCB can continue with Misbah as long as they want but that will change nothing.
 
What Misbah gave us in ODIs? A team that was beaten 3-0 by BD at their home. PCB can continue with Misbah as long as they want but that will change nothing.

I think they are talking about test captaincy. Misbah is not in ODIs
 
I'm not Pakistani but I'm a Pakistan fan.

And I see Misbah as a problem, not the solution.

Shaharyar Khan makes clear that he is the preferred skipper more for his education than anything else.

But you need a younger, more aggressive skipper.

The only thing Misbah had for a good captain his good management skills but he did misuse his powers when he knew no one can touch him but most importantly he was never a good tactician in the game or a good planner. He always waited for things to happen. He is such a wrong example for youngsters to follow. I just can't wait before his days are done. We will see how his captaincy make us beat Australia at their home without Yasir coming into play. Unlike English batsmen the Aussies won't gift their wickets to Yasir shah's straight ones.
 
Misbah the great is sensible enough to know that he can't continue till then. He will most likely retire after the Australian series. He isn't greedy for fame or money like some players of the past and present.
 
I think they are talking about test captaincy. Misbah is not in ODIs

I'm referring to SHK statements like he is begging Misbah. Why do PCB make it look like Pakistan needs Misbah? When it should be the other way around. His performance has highly been downhill. He has been throwing his wicket away so why is PCB still begging for him to play and lead Pakistan? Is he Steven Waugh in his heydays?It's incredible how people overrate Misbah. Life will go on.

I used ODI reference because there are uncountable people here who thought Pakistan batting will struggle to cross 200 after Misbah because he was the one scoring irrespective how and what pace but the fact is Pakistan has 90% the times has scored more than 250 ever since his departure. We have not missed him at all. and we have found a batsman who has hit 3 consecutive centuries a record. We have good young batsmen in the waiting.

The time is up for old folks. Just like it was up for Sanga and Jaya. The seniors are there to perform on tough assignments if they fail on that and they are in their late 30s that should be the right time to sideline them and look for future players.
 
Just goes to show the lack of solid planning by the PCB. They obviously think Misbah/YK retiring will hit the side hard. But they really need to form younger blood in the side too and either giving Azhar Ali or Sarfraz the captaincy is the best way of moving forward.

Keeping hold of Misbah is a desperation move and something he should decline and move on with the next chapter of his life.

Typical PCB, they bring undue pressure on a player and hope the clamour from fans & media alike will help convince the said player to change his mind.
 
Misbah the great is sensible enough to know that he can't continue till then. He will most likely retire after the Australian series. He isn't greedy for fame or money like some players of the past and present.

He was finished as a ODI player back in 2014 but he did continue to captain and took PCB's assurity of not removing him until he plays 2015 world cup...and lol greedy..do you remember the knock he played against India in the Semi final?must have weak memory.
 
Honestly, it took me a while to convince myself this isn't a satirical post. Misbah playing till 2018!! It would leave a huge vaccuum with Misbah, Younis, Asad, Azhar and Wahab retiring together :p
 
He was finished as a ODI player back in 2014 but he did continue to captain and took PCB's assurity of not removing him until he plays 2015 world cup...and lol greedy..do you remember the knock he played against India in the Semi final?must have weak memory.

You have had arguements with a lot of people over this topic for years and I'll be telling you the same thing they have. So I'd rather not argue with you, because you're never gonna have a positive view of Misbah no matter what someone says or proves.
 
People like [MENTION=57576]MRSN[/MENTION] were hiding when Misbah led the team to success. They were waiting for this moment so that they can blame everything on Misbah.
 
I'm not Pakistani but I'm a Pakistan fan.

And I see Misbah as a problem, not the solution.

Shaharyar Khan makes clear that he is the preferred skipper more for his education than anything else.

But you need a younger, more aggressive skipper.

Sarfraz??
 
The only thing Misbah had for a good captain his good management skills but he did misuse his powers when he knew no one can touch him but most importantly he was never a good tactician in the game or a good planner. He always waited for things to happen. He is such a wrong example for youngsters to follow. I just can't wait before his days are done. We will see how his captaincy make us beat Australia at their home without Yasir coming into play. Unlike English batsmen the Aussies won't gift their wickets to Yasir shah's straight ones.

Aussie batsmen are much worse at playing spin than English batsmen.
 
Would be a ludicrous move. Let the man go out in peace. Keeping him on will only harm the team and himself.
 
Sarfraz??

No, too old.

Babar Azam is the same age that Graeme Smith was: give him the captaincy and make it clear that this is a new team.

Avoid the 25-34 generation completely for the captaincy, or before you know it you will end up having to give it back to Salman Butt.
 
No, too old.

Babar Azam is the same age that Graeme Smith was: give him the captaincy and make it clear that this is a new team.

Avoid the 25-34 generation completely for the captaincy, or before you know it you will end up having to give it back to Salman Butt.

Sarfraz has exactly the kind of aggressiveness we might need and he has had a successful captaincy stint in U-19 and recently T20Is.

I wouldn't mind Sami Aslam either. He too has captained U-19 team in 2014 world cup where we were runner-ups.

I don't think we should put Babar under captaincy pressure so early. Don't you think it might affect his batting?
 
Sarfraz??

Sarfraz has exactly the kind of aggressiveness we might need and he has had a successful captaincy stint in U-19 and recently T20Is.

I wouldn't mind Sami Aslam either. He too has captained U-19 team in 2014 world cup where we were runner-ups.

I don't think we should put Babar under captaincy pressure so early. Don't you think it might affect his batting?
You're right, it might affect his batting. But I think it will also make Umar Akmal perform for obvious reasons.

And if Babar Azam fails, I'd try Sami Aslam next, after giving him around 18 months.
 
Although, I disagree with the notion of having Misbah carry on . . PCB has once again failed in grooming a captain, but the time is now (after the Australia series) to let Misbah go and bring in a new captain . .

But some of the criticism of Misbah on the thread is absolutely shambolic . . For everyone outside Pakistan, Misbah is viewed as the superman . . as the savior of Pakistan cricket . . as the one person responsible for instilling calm in the team . . as the one person who stabilized the team . . as the one person who inherited a team that lost its 3 most critical performers and turned it around . . as the one person who took mediocre talent and took the team to heights no one imagined . . as the person who as captain didn't play a single game at home and yet achieved all what he did . . Misbah is viewed with incredible respect around the world . . and has created an image of the Pakistan team where the Pakistan team is respected across the world . . that is and will remain the biggest legacy of Misbah ul Haq . . One day! This nation will realize that this man is/was much much more than star men and show men and the likes . . Misbah ul Haq, for all his tactical shortcomings, is a legend and will go down in history as one of the most influential Pakistan cricketers of all time
 
Last edited:
Very poor thinking by the PCB, continuing with Younus is also a big mistake. Misbah should ideally retire after Australia tour. PCB would do well to give the captaincy to Sarfraz, surely not Azhar Ali.
 
If Waqar was not coach than YK, Afridi, Sami will still playing in ODI. Inzamam is such a timid & spineless selector.
 
Misbah is the major reason why we went to number one in the first place. He has overachieved with this mediocre team.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't you say that Pakistani fans over emphasize the importance of the coach and captain. When Waqar and Misbah were blamed for our poor ODI ranking you said that they weren't the problem. So in this case why give all the credit to Misbah for achieving the #1 ranking?
 
PCB is obviously scared that the team will fall apart after Misbah leaves and they want to hang on to him as long as possible rather than actually do anything constructive.

As long as Misbah still wants to retire (surely he does), he should call it a day after the Australia series. If we can't test a new captain in the series after that then we may as well give up on Test cricket altogether.
 
Pakistan has to move on from Misbah after the Australian tour. I like and respect Misbah but he really can't play forever. If PCB really want Misbah to hold this team together, then appoint him team director. He can still travel with the team and mentor players.

Australian tour should be the end of both Misbah and Younis.
 
Inchallah misbah will play until 2028 so his son will be ready to take over.
 
Maaf kardo Misbah ko bhai... You want him to play till the official government retirement age of 65?

Ideally Misbah should have hung his boots after the English series. The Windies series would have been an ideal series to blood a new captain (and I don't mean Misbah 2.0)
 
I'd rather have Misbah retire and take his position than see him play until 2018... seriously let it go we have to move on and have faith in our system. If we fail that is due to our system producing bad cricketers, we have to find a way to fix that and that is where you, Mr. Khan come in.
 
What's happened is that once again the powers that be at the PCB have failed.

Instead of grooming a competent replacement for Misbah, they put all their eggs in Azhar Ali's basket and they have now realised that he probably hasn't got what it takes to be Misbah's replacement.

Now they are panicking. Misbah isn't sure if he wants to continue after the series against Australia, Azhar doesn't look captaincy material and YK looks like he's got his mind on fishing and not cricket.
 
Maaf kardo Misbah ko bhai... You want him to play till the official government retirement age of 65?

Ideally Misbah should have hung his boots after the English series. The Windies series would have been an ideal series to blood a new captain (and I don't mean Misbah 2.0)


Than who can be made captain? Don't want to burden Sarfraz too much. You want Asad dropped. Babar needs to concentrate on his batting. Don't think people would accept Amir as captain. Younis is too old to take over now.

So Azhar is the only realistic option. Yasir could be an option
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't you say that Pakistani fans over emphasize the importance of the coach and captain. When Waqar and Misbah were blamed for our poor ODI ranking you said that they weren't the problem. So in this case why give all the credit to Misbah for achieving the #1 ranking?

No one player/individual deserves 'all the credit', that is why I said Misbah is the 'major' reason and not the 'only' reason.

Misbah has made the biggest contribution because the Test team is basically his brainchild and have adopted his attritional cricket tactics, which has allowed this mediocre team to reach the pinnacle.
 
Misbah representing the negative mindset destroying Pakistan cricket. The worst culprit is the chairman himself who is in no health and age group to do any active work, should have retired sometimes ago. Same mentally think Misbah is getting younger every day. The worst case is of Younis khan. The guy according to some is in mid 40s, has scored in only one inning out of last 10 innings overseas and he is still a part of team in Australia. Don;t know what to call all this , corruption, insensitivity, extreme selfishness or lack of patriotism-------shocking indeed.
 
he built this mediocre team. He had six freakin years. He kicked out all the players that could play with positive approach and he continued with a set of players that played like him tuk tukking against fast bowlers and getting most of their runs against spinners.

The no.1 tag for Pakistan is very very misleading.. I say this because Pakistan has never looked like a genuine no.1 to me with lots of flaws. Our fast bowling never contributed enough even abroad. We have always relied on one man show from Yasir Shah and pre Yasir we had Ajmal the one man bowling attack. We never had a batting to dominate fast bowlers even on graveyards of batting. Our batsmen always enjoyed playing their spells out and look to take charge against spinners.

Misbah is definitely responsible because he has lead this team for 6 years. You can see huge difference in our ODI performances after he was booted out and hopefully we can see same change in approach after we get rid of him in tests.

Quality players don't grow on trees. Misbah worked with what he had, and he overachieved.

These so-called positive players are nowhere near the quality of players of the other teams so the end result would have been the same.

Umar Akmal could have played every Test since 2010, but he would still not be able to be in the league of Kohli, Root, Smith or Williamson. That's the reality.

As I said already, the ranking was misleading but the point system is same for everyone, so Misbah deserves credit for taking this mediocre team to number one even if it was for 5 minutes.
 
Than who can be made captain? Don't want to burden Sarfraz too much. You want Asad dropped. Babar needs to concentrate on his batting. Don't think people would accept Amir as captain. Younis is too old to take over now.

So Azhar is the only realistic option. Yasir could be an option

There is nothing wrong with making Sarfaraz the captain. He is mentally strong, always plays with a positive attitude and possesses a huge experience of captaincy, from his under 19 days. For God sake, let Misbah go and keep his legacy intact.
 
As much as I respect Misbah for what he has done with the Test team, it's time to move forward...The man is nearly 43..
 
There is nothing wrong with making Sarfaraz the captain. He is mentally strong, always plays with a positive attitude and possesses a huge experience of captaincy, from his under 19 days. For God sake, let Misbah go and keep his legacy intact.


But being a keeper and captain in 2/3 formats isn't easy. Also [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] has explained why a keeper captain in tests isn't always a good idea.

I think Misbah should retire after the Australian tour so I am willing to let him go, it's pcb who aren't.
 
For God's sake at the least allow Misbah to retire with grace while he is still very useful. I hope Misbah is wise enough and quits after the Aus or WI series.

He got us through the Eng, NZ and Aus tours. There is nothing more we can ask of him.
 
Misbah should retire post the Australia series, he'll probably be retiring after a whitewash but it's time to build for the future, whatever future pakistan cricket has.

YK/Misbah should both retire
Shafiq/Azhar should be shown the door if they do fail, they have been in the side for so long, yet bat like they just arrived in international cricket, especially Shafiq.

Sami/Babar, both just arrived, they deserve a chance, they obviously wont get the same amount of chances like Azhar/Shafiq as they were getting backed by someone.

If Misbah wants to carry on, let him.
But if he wants to retire, the chairman should let him retire.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Misbah should carry on but only as a batsman as he is still our most consistent batsman. We have already seen just how useful Azhar and especially Asad are, the so called replacements of Misbah. But Misbah should quit as captain after the Australia series and play just as a batsman for another year. That will help the next captain as he would have Misbah to guide him.
 
What's happened is that once again the powers that be at the PCB have failed.

Instead of grooming a competent replacement for Misbah, they put all their eggs in Azhar Ali's basket and they have now realised that he probably hasn't got what it takes to be Misbah's replacement.

Now they are panicking. Misbah isn't sure if he wants to continue after the series against Australia, Azhar doesn't look captaincy material and YK looks like he's got his mind on fishing and not cricket.

SHK himself is a big failure and incompetent in his second coming so there is nothing you can hope from a clueless man other than begging Misbah. That wisdom you are talking about is not there. That guy should himself not be leading an organization at this age. It's very tough to expect from him to groom replacement of Misbah. He would want Misbah to keep leading until he found some replacement through his magic wand.
 
No need to stay because our series till 2018 are not so difficult and not daunting task, and it will be achieved through younger lot:
pakistan tour to westindies march 2017 4 tests
pakistan tour to bangladesh august 2017 2 tests
pakistan vs srilanka in uae october 3 tests
pakistan tour to eng may 2018 2 tests
pakistan tour to zimbabwe august 2018 2 tests
pakistan vs australia in uae 2018 september 4 tests
pakistan vs nz in uae november 2018 3 tests
pakistan tour to rsa december 2018 3 tests
 
Back
Top