Sohaib Maqsood, while speaking on his YouTube channel, criticized the selection criteria of Pakistan's squad for the ICC Champions Trophy 2025:
"Pakistan's squad announcement for the Champions Trophy left me confused. I had almost forgotten that Pakistan was even playing in it. Other teams have already settled their lineups, but Pakistan has been busy with stadium preparations and briefing the ICC, forgetting to announce their squad earlier. This squad is a bigger mystery than Abrar Ahmed being in the Pakistani team."
"Up until now, I have backed the decisions made by the PCB and its management because I believed they were heading in the right direction. However, this squad selection raises more questions than answers. I spent almost half an hour trying to figure it out, but I couldn't understand who will open the batting, who will play at number 3, and how the bowling combination will work. Will we play with three fast bowlers or include Faheem Ashraf?"
"In ICC events, the teams that dominate are the ones whose top three batters are either stable, in form, or solid performers. If we look back at Pakistan's recent successes, even though we haven't won much in white-ball cricket, our top three players, like Fakhar Zaman, Imam-ul-Haq, and Babar Azam, have contributed significantly. Similarly, in other top teams, players like Rohit Sharma, Shikhar Dhawan, and Virat Kohli have been dominant. But with this squad, it seems we've compromised our top order."
"We should have used tours like those to Zimbabwe, South Africa, and Australia as preparation for the Champions Trophy, but here we are, shifting focus from long-term goals to short-term wins. This approach is damaging, and our top three is now uncertain, which could cause major issues."
"Fakhar Zaman’s spot is in question, with rumors suggesting Babar Azam might open the batting. But in my opinion, Babar should not open. He’s a top-order batter, and forcing him to open would be a big mistake. The mindset for an opener is completely different from that of a number three batter. Even though we have some backup players like Usman Khan, the lack of clarity is concerning."
"Mohammad Rizwan should have adjusted his batting position months ago. If he had moved to number 4 or 5, we could have better prepared players like Saud Shakeel for the 50-over format. But now, with this unclear squad, we still don’t know who will open with Fakhar Zaman. There are too many combinations, and the planning is unclear."
"You cannot have this level of uncertainty in your lineup just weeks before an ICC event. Every other top team knows their strategy months ahead of time, but we are still scrambling. It’s crucial to have a clear plan for your top three, and I’m afraid this squad will only lead to more confusion."