The reason why people hate Babar is because of Rizwan and Misbah.
Unlike these 2 Babar is a gun talent. Yes he was always overrated as hes nowhere near the likes of Kohli, but he could have easily been in the same league as Joe root in both odi and test cricket.
By root I'm referring to classic Root and not current. Root after 2021 had a test resurgence and became an atg. His whole career he only mustered 17 test centuries at a below 50 avg, but in the last 4 years he's been avg 53-55 with 19 centuries, more then any other test batter in 4 years including Steve Smith
However classic root is still solid in test cricket.
Even if people accused him as a minnow basher, not every tom dick and Harry can just score 3 back to back centuries on 2 seprate occasions.
Sides have freqently held 3 match series against the likes of zimb, Ireland, Bangladesh, Wi in the past including SA and everyone's favourite ab de villers. Yet none of them achieved it on 2 seprate occasions.
Scoring 19 odi centuries is still a solid feat in this era. His nz 100 while I have critiqued it, is a solid reminder that Babar could have been a good test cricketer as no one can deny his insane temperament that he displayed in that innings.
Logically Babar should have gotten 22-25 centuries by now as he has played against weak teams in the past 2 years. Theirs no reason why he couldnt have scored a century vs Sri lanka and NED in the world cup and atleast scored one vs Australia, Nz and SA in the odi series previously CT 2025.
Rizwan, Ramiz and Misbah 110% ruined Babar both physically and Mentally however Misbah fans just aren't willing to accept this fact.
They believe its all conspiracy, and that Rizwan + Misbah have been the greatest influence on Babar Azam. If they were the greatest influence on Babar, then our t20 and odi team wouldnt have tanked.
It got so bad, that pcb had no choice but to kick Misbah and hire temporary foreign coaches for 2021 as it would have a clown show. But then they hired Ramiz

.