What's new

Questions remain after US cop kills Muslim man who 'threw rocks'

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,993
The Muslim community in the US state of Georgia is searching for answers after a sheriff's deputy shot and killed a Sudanese-American man earlier this month.

Yassin Mohamed, 47, was killed on May 9 by an Evans County sheriff's deputy near the rural town of Claxton, which sits roughly 200 miles (320km) southeast of Atlanta, the state capital.

According to police reports, Mohamed was throwing rocks at the deputies during the incident that led to his death. He had several encounters with law enforcement agencies in the 24 hours prior to that incident.

During one of those encounters, Mohamed was taken to hospital, leading the Georgia chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR-Georgia) to question whether Mohamed was suffering from some kind of mental health issues.

"We're unclear as to the mental state of Mr Mohamed and until the culmination of the investigation we won't know for sure," said Murtaza Khwaja, the legal and policy director of CAIR-Georgia, a Muslim civil rights and advocacy organisation.

"What we do know is that law enforcement is treating this a mental health crisis," Khawaja claimed. The Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI) would not comment on the mental health of Mohamed and the Evan's County Sheriff's department did not immediately respond to Al Jazeera's request for comment.

In the May 9 incident, GBI said deputies were called after midnight found Mohamed walking on the road. An altercation ensued after the deputies attempted to make contact, GBI said in a statement.

Mohamed began throwing rocks at law enforcement, hitting one of the deputies once and "charging" him with a "larger rock", causing the deputy to fire his weapon, GBI said.

Mohamed died before being taken to hospital. The deputy was not seriously injured.

Prior to the deadly encounter with the Evans County deputy, Mohamed had "six or seven" interactions with law enforcement and emergency services over the night, according to CAIR.

These included run-ins with the Glennville police department, the Claxton police department, emergency medical services (EMS). Mohamed was detained by law enforcement and taken to hospital, where he refused treatment, GBI confirmed to Al Jazeera.

During another instance, Mohamed attacked a police officer and ambulance with a plastic pipe. A video taken by law enforcement and obtained by local news outlet All On Georgia shows the incident.

In the video, Mohamed, who was walking on the road at night, immediately approaches the police car which stopped to approach him, wielding a large, plastic pipe. An officer steps out of his vehicle after warning Mohamed, draws his firearm and appears to drop it, the video shows. Another officer assists in the encounter and Mohamed is held on the ground. EMS later takes him away.

According to the incident report, obtained by All On Georgia, the police officer, identified as Officer Skipper, "attempted to place the male subject into custody, but had to be assisted by EMS personnel. The male subject was handcuffed behind his back ... at that time Officer Skipper noticed that the male subject had urinated on himself."

GBI confirmed to Al Jazeera that Mohamed was taken into custody, but never charged. This prompts questions about why the later incident involving rocks led to his death occurred, CAIR said.

"If Mr Mohamed was indeed in the midst of a mental health crisis", Khwaja said, referencing law enforcement sending Mohamed to the hospital for an evaluation during one encounter, "it's unconscionable that law enforcement did not place him ... under a wellness hold until they were able to transfer him for treatment.

"I'd like to stress that Mr Mohamed was subdued by law enforcement without the use of lethal force," Khwaja continued, referring to the video and incident with the pipe.

The fact that this encounter did not result in the office resorting to using his weapon "illustrates the very point that far too often goes ignored, police officers choose to resort to lethal force when there are many other alternatives at their disposal".

Spate of shootings

According to GBI, the investigation will be turned over to the district attorney for review once completed. The prosecutor will then decide whether to file charges. It remains unclear whether the officer is still on active duty.

It is the 38th officer-involved shooting that GBI has been asked to investigate so far this year, according to a tweet from GBI Public Affairs Director Nelly Miles.

The Evans County Sheriff's department has not issued a statement on the killing.

News of the killing came in the shadow of a different Georgia case that caught nationwide attention.

GBI is also investigating the high-profile killing of Ahmaud Arbery, a 25-year-old African American, who was shot by two white men while jogging in the predominately white neighbourhood of Satilla on February 23.

It took two months for the men, father and son duo Gregory and Travis McMichael, to be arrested.

The arrests were made only after a video of the killing was released, roughly 10 weeks after the incident happened.

The pair was charged with murder and aggravated assault on May 7. The man who filmed the death, William "Roddie" Bryan Jr, 50, was arrested by GBI on charges of felony murder and criminal attempt to commit false imprisonment on May 21.

Bryan claims he filmed the video from his front lawn. All three men maintain their innocence. The McMichaels say they suspected Arbery was involved in a string of burglaries in the area. Arbery's mother says she believes her son was just on a job in the neighbourhood.

Khwaja, along with CAIR, has decried the killings of Arbery and Mohamed.

"Mr Mohamed's death sounds disturbingly similar to the police shootings of black men and women that regularly occur across our nation," CAIR said in a statement.

"A mental health crisis should never be a death sentence. Rocks should never be met with bullets," Khwaja said.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020...s-muslim-man-threw-rocks-200522162544188.html
 
That's irresponsible - the man seemed to have mental health problems and was not in control of his actions. What is strange is why was he allowed to leave the hospital in the first place?
 
Last edited:
Seems Police in the USA have a very loose definition of reasonable force.
 
FBI to investigate death of black man in Minnesota after arrest

The FBI will investigate the death of a black man in the US state of Minnesota after a video emerged showing a police officer kneeling on his neck.

In the footage, the man believed to be in his 40s is heard groaning and repeatedly saying "I can't breathe" to the officer, who is white.

The Minneapolis Police Department said the officers had responded to a report of a forgery in progress.

It said the man died after a "medical incident" in a "police interaction".

It is the latest accusation of US police brutality against African Americans. Recent high-profile cases include an officer in Maryland who fatally shot a man inside a patrol car.

The incident in Minneapolis on Monday evening began after officers located the man in his car, police said in a statement. They were told the man, who has not been identified, was "sitting on top of a blue car and appeared to be under the influence".

After being ordered to step away from the vehicle, the man physically resisted officers, according to police. "Officers were able to get the suspect into handcuffs and noted he appeared to be suffering medical distress," the statement added.

In the 10-minute video filmed by a witness, the man is kept on the ground by the officer and, at one point, says: "Don't kill me".

Witnesses urged the officer to take his knee off the man's neck, noting that he was not moving. One says, "His nose is bleeding", while another pleads, "Get off his neck."

The man then appears motionless before he is put on a stretcher and into an ambulance.

Police said no weapons were used during the incident and that body camera footage had been handed to the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, which is investigating the case. Two of the officers involved have been put on paid administrative leave.

After the video emerged, police said in a statement: "As additional information has been made available, it has been determined that the Federal Bureau of Investigations will be a part of this investigation."

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52806572
 
Yet another police brutality incident on a minority. If you can't see a pattern then frankly you're turning a purposeful blind eye.
 
Yet another police brutality incident on a minority. If you can't see a pattern then frankly you're turning a purposeful blind eye.

Police force is just a group of insecure men who get a big boy tool to take their frustrations out.
 
Firstly Am I the only person whose first instinct is to find out why was the guy throwing rocks?

Secondly, what is the point of reporting this incident as “Muslim” man or “black” man throwing rocks?

If he was a mentally unstable guy then does it really matter what his religion or race was?

Obviously police should not be trigger happy but this article opens a lot more questions than it answers.
 
Firstly Am I the only person whose first instinct is to find out why was the guy throwing rocks?

Secondly, what is the point of reporting this incident as “Muslim” man or “black” man throwing rocks?

If he was a mentally unstable guy then does it really matter what his religion or race was?

Obviously police should not be trigger happy but this article opens a lot more questions than it answers.

Two words: yellow journalism.
 
A Black man who yelled "I cannot breathe" as a white Minneapolis police officer pinned him down with his knee in the US state of Minnesota died late on Monday, police confirmed, drawing outrage from community members and leaders.

Video of the incident shows the police officer pinning down George Floyd, believed to be in his 40s, to the pavement with his knee on the man's neck for several minutes. Floyd was identified by prominent civil rights lawyer Ben Crump, who said he had been retained by the Floyd family.

Floyd can be heard saying in the video: "Please, please, I cannot breathe."

The officer tells Floyd to "relax".

Floyd responds: "I can't breathe. Please, the knee in my neck."

The officer continues to hold down Floyd with his knee for several minutes, with Floyd pleading and asking for water.

"My stomach hurts. My neck hurts. Please, please. I can't breathe," Floyd cries out, while moaning and trying to cough.

Floyd eventually appears motionless under the officer's knee.

Those who were watching the incident unfold can be heard begging police to move off Floyd.

"He's not f****** moving," an onlooker can be heard saying. "Get off of his f****** neck."

It is unclear what happened before and after the video was taken.

FBI to investigate

In a statement on Tuesday, the Minneapolis Police Department said its officers were responding to a "report of a forgery in progress".

"After [the suspect] got out [of his car], he physically resisted officers," the statement said. "Officers were able to get the suspect into handcuffs and note he appeared to be suffering medical distress."

He was then transported to a nearby medical centre where he died a short time later, the department said.

The Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehensive (BCA) said it was "investigating the circumstances surrounding an incident".

It added that it was sharing information with the FBI, which "is conducting a separate federal civil rights investigation at the request of the Minneapolis Police Department."

Minneapolis Police Chief Medaria Arradondo said on Tuesday that he requested the FBI involvement after receiving additional information "from a community source". He did not elaborate.

The police officers involved in the incident were wearing body cameras, the Minneapolis police department said. The footage has not been made publicly available. Arradondo said the officers involved have been "relieved of duty status", but are still being paid.

'Trauma on trauma'

The incident has drawn outrage in the city and online, with many drawing comparisons to Eric Garner, an unarmed Black man who died in 2014 after being placed in a chokehold by New York City police and pleading: "I can't breathe." That incident sparked nationwide protests.

"We all watched the horrific death of George Floyd on video as witnesses begged the police officer to take him to the police car and get off his neck," Crump, the Floyd's lawyer, said in a statement on Tuesday.

"This abusive, excessive and inhumane use of force cost the life of a man who was being detained by the police for questioning about a non-violent charge," he added. "How many 'while Black' deaths will it take until the racial profiling and undervaluing of black lives by police finally ends?"

Nekima Levy Armstrong, a local lawyer and prominent activist, wrote on Facebook that this "is trauma on trauma on trauma".

"We can't escape police violence even in a global pandemic," she added.

Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey called the incident "wrong on every level".

"Being black in America should not be a death sentence," he said in a Facebook post.

"This officer failed in the most basic, human sense," he added. All I keep coming back to is this: this man should not have died … To our Black community, to the family: I'm so sorry."

A protest is scheduled in Minneapolis on Tuesday, with organisers urging participants to wear masks and adhere to social distancing guidelines due to the coronavirus pandemic.

String of police killings
Monday night's incident comes on the heels of several cases of Black men and women being killed by police or former law enforcement across the US.

The FBI is investigating the police shooting death of Breonna Taylor in Louisville, Kentucky. Taylor, a Louisville emergency medical technician, was killed by police in the early hours of March 13 as she laid in her bed. Police said they were serving a warrant as part of a drug investigation when they returned fire from the apartment. Taylor's boyfriend said he was firing in self-defence, believing his home was being broken into. No drugs were found in the apartment. One officer was injured.

The US Department of Justice is weighing possible hate crime charges in the US state of Georgia over the shooting death of Ahmaud Arbery, an unarmed Black man, and the police handling of the case.

Arbery was killed in February as he ran through a predominantly white neighbourhood in Glynn County, Georgia. The arrests of Gregory McMichael, a retired investigator for the local prosecutor's office, and his son, both of whom are white, came more than two months after the incident and only after a video of the shooting went viral, raising questions about the handling of the case. Police have also since arrested the man who filmed the incident.

The Georgia Bureau of Investigation is also investigating the shooting death of Yassin Mohamed, a Sudanese American man, who was killed by police on May 9 after having "several altercations" with law enforcement in the 24 hours before his death. Police say they fired on Mohamed after he charged officers with a large rock. The Council on American-Islamic Relations in Georgia has condemned the incident and called for answers, including whether Mohamed was suffering from mental health issues.

According to the Washington Post Fatal Force database, more than 1,000 people have been shot and killed by police in the last year. According to the database, Black Americans are killed by police at a disproportionate rate.

African American adults are nearly six times as likely to be imprisoned or jailed than white adults, according to the Sentencing Project watchdog group.

These racial disparities have given rise to Black Lives Matter, which was founded in 2013 and seeks to end police violence and build local power to intervene in violence inflicted on Black communities.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/05/breathe-black-man-dies-officer-pins-200526165502331.html
 
A Kentucky grand juror has said the jury was not given the opportunity to consider homicide charges in the killing of Breonna Taylor by police.

Ms Taylor, a 26-year-old black hospital worker, was shot six times when police forced their way into her apartment in Louisville, Kentucky, on 13 March.

Last month the jury recommended no homicide charges against the officers.

The anonymous juror was permitted to release the statement by a judge who ruled it was in the public interest.

In the statement, they said the state's attorney general only presented to the jury wanton endangerment charges, to be considered against one officer.
 
Back
Top