It's a minor improvement at best.
It should have been elevated to a much higher level.
The 6 team structure is not sufficient, it increases competition to an unreasonable extent where those deserving of chances can easily be neglected.
The new system is better, no doubt, but they should have invested more.
If we just take into account the 6 teams we can argue that it isn’t enough however, in that argument we will be neglecting the 6 2nd XIs.
Role which 2nd XI have played in highlighting the players we have recent examples of:
Abdullah Shafique; Was outstanding in 2019 QAE 2nd XI trophy, got promoted to the main CP squad in the same season and scored a 100 on FC debut. Have been with Pak team in recent times and it all started with his impact in 2nd XI cricket before which he wasn’t even radar in much of domestic teams in old structure as he was ignored for almost the whole previous season.
Zeeshan Ashraf; was outstanding in T20s he played for SP 2nd XI in 2019 and got the limelight through that and got selected by MS in PSL in the 2020 season. He was kind of an unknown commodity before that 2nd XI season but, no in the radar of national selectors as well a permanent member of his main regional side.
Imran Randhawa: Another one who got recognized through the 2nd XI performances, got selected by the main region and then PZ in PSL and is again someone who came into prominence while playing for 2nd XI.
Abdul Bangalzai: A teenager who played for Balochistan in the last season in whiteball cricket and was recognized through the 2nd XI
Abrar Ahmed: Was exceptional in QAE 2nd XI trophy and got picked in the main Sindh team, got another opportunity in PSL with PZ this time.
Yes one can argue that if the main teams can be increased by maybe a couple but, even in the current one we cant say that people are not being recognized. Yes 2nd XI performances are not part of FC stats but, they do highlight the players who perform more often than not.
However, yes the ones who are in the transition where they are in the main squad but, arent selected in the XI and cant play for 2nd XI as well during that time maybe they do miss out on some opportunities on occasions. Though that’s gonna happen in any structure irrespective of 6 or 8 teams as someone is going to be on that bench.
If and when we are overloaded with talent and whoever is the new chairman puts forward a decent argument a slight change might be possible. However, I am personally impressed with how well the new structure has worked. People are too much focused on the results of the national team after just two years of new structure but, if we look at the enhancement in the overall talent pool (Yes development is necessary) it has improved substantially from where things stood in 2018.