Rank and rate these middle-order ODI batsmen out of 10

[Ted123]

Andrew Symonds
AB de Villiers
Yuvraj Singh
Javed Miandad
Aravinda de Silva
Kevin Pieterson
Joe Root

Views?

 

[Ab Fan]

In order of ranking:

ABD- 9
Aravinda- 8.5
Yuvraj- 8.5
Symonds- 8.5
Miandad- 8
KP- 8
Root- 8

 

[Bilal7]

ABD: 9.5
Aravinda: 7
Yuvraj: 7.5
Symonds: 7.5
Miandad: 8 (great for his time)
KP: 7 (massive underachiever in ODIs)
Root: 6.5 (thus far, has a long career ahead of him)

 

[Justcrazy]

Andrew Symonds
AB de Villiers
Yuvraj Singh
Javed Miandad
Aravinda de Silva
Kevin Pieterson
Joe Root

Views?

7
8.5
6.5
7.5
5.5
6
6

 

[Hasan123]

Symonds 8
ABD 9
Yuvraj 7.5
Miandad 8.5
De Silva 7
KP 7
Root 7 ( can get better )

 

[finalfantasy7]

Andrew Symonds- 8/10
AB de Villiers - 9/10
Yuvraj Singh - 8/10
Javed Miandad - 8.5/10
Aravinda de Silva - 7/10
Kevin Pieterson - 8/10
Joe Root - 7.5/10

Views?

my ratings, with root his has many years ahead, he should have not been added, some one like dravid/inzi/mo.yousuf- should have been added

 

[Arham_PakFan]

Andrew Symonds 8/10
AB de Villiers:9/10
Yuvraj Singh:7.5/10
Javed Miandad:8/10
Aravinda de Silva:7.5/10
Kevin Pieterson 7.5/10
Joe Root:7/10

Views?

Yuvraj and Pietersen both underachieved,the same case can be made for Symonds.Root has long way to go.

 

[Last Monetarist]

Andrew Symonds 7/10
AB de Villiers 9/10
Yuvraj Singh 8/10
Javed Miandad 8/10
Aravinda de Silva 8/10
Kevin Pieterson 6/10
Joe Root 6/10

 

[The_Odd_One]

Andrew Symonds 8.5
AB de Villiers 9
Yuvraj Singh 8
Javed Miandad 8.5
Aravinda de Silva 8
Kevin Pietersen 7
Joe Root 6

 

[QalandarFan]

Symonds - 8
AB - 9.5
Yuvraj - 8
Javed - 8
Aravinda - 8
KP - 7
Root - atm 6.5

 

[big_gamer007]

Without Yuvi we could never have won the 2007 or 2011 WC.. The guy played when it mattered doesn't need numbers to rate him...

 

[austerlitz]

De villiers best.
Followed by yuvraj,de silva and miandad roughly equal.
Rest behind.