Should Pakistaniboy be allowed to get back his released free players??

[Ibad17]

It is a simple question.

Pakistaniboy picked two players as free picks during the transfer window and after a day he released them both (don't know the reason behind releasing them).
Now he wants them back. Should he be allowed to get them back or not. Decision is up to you. Just vote yes or no. If your answer is No then tell us the next step on what should be done with the picks and pakiboy.

 

[Bhaijaan]

Yes.


#1. He got both the players earlier in free picks beating Monsters in a very amazing manner.

#2. I don't think many took this joke seriously, i didn't go for any of Shaqiri and Eriksen tonight only because i never thought this was serious and hence i did not bother to update the OP.

#3. If at all the two players are made available then i demand the free pick to occur again tomorrow as i would like to participate in it, other managers would also be interested in both the players.
__________________

 

[iZeeshan]

My only issue is - he deliberately released them. What proves that is that he released a 2nd player.

It wasn't done out of a joke or mistake.

 

[Afrid1]

Yes.


#1. He got both the players earlier in free picks beating Monsters in a very amazing manner.

#2. I don't think many took this joke seriously, i didn't go for any of Shaqiri and Eriksen tonight only because i never thought this was serious and hence i did not bother to update the OP.

#3. If at all the two players are made available then i demand the free pick to occur again tomorrow as i would like to participate in it, other managers would also be interested in both the players.
__________________

My sentiments exactly

 

[cricketjoshila]

A manager is allowed to release his players anytime.If tommorow Ibad releases a certain player and i have made my 6 picks i cant ask for more picks.So this picks to happen again thing is immaterial.

Pboy should only be allowed to get those picks back if majority of managers agree.This is not a joking place.Managers put in their time and brains for this league.

 

[murphyslaw79]

I want to hear from pboy as to why he thought it would be funny or was he serious.

Until then I will reserve judegment

 

[iZeeshan]

A manager is allowed to release his players anytime.If tommorow Ibad releases a certain player and i have made my 6 picks i cant ask for more picks.So this picks to happen again thing is immaterial.

Pboy should only be allowed to get those picks back if majority of managers agree.This is not a joking place.Managers put in their time and brains for this league.

That's what we are arguing here. You need to take a stand. You are one of the managers. Base your opinion on what you think is right.

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

I voted NO

To me it was quite obvious the comments saying P'boy cheated were jokes

Why did he release them? Don't know since he didn't offer an explanation and him releasing the players didn't appear to be a joke unlike many other deals/trades in the thread (see Space Cat giving away Xavi/Lahm for Gourcuff )

P'boy picked Shaqiri again today therefore he should get him and Eriksen should go to iZeeshan since he picked him

 

[Pakistaniboy]

Saying that I have a big heart and putting Afridi smileys after releasing the players...

I should have just edited my posts right after.

Im gonna respect whatever decision you guys take.

 

[cricketjoshila]

I voted NO

To me it was quite obvious the comments saying P'boy cheated were jokes

Why did he release them? Don't know since he didn't offer an explanation and him releasing the players didn't appear to be a joke unlike many other deals/trades in the thread (see Space Cat giving away Xavi/Lahm for Gourcuff )

P'boy picked Shaqiri again today therefore he should get him and Eriksen should go to iZeeshan since he picked him

Are you allowed to release and pick the same players again in same window?

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

Saying that I have a big heart and putting Afridi smileys after releasing the players...

I should have just edited my posts right after.

Im gonna respect whatever decision you guys take.

Actually when you released Eriksen there was no smiley, you bolded it and then asked Ibad to add it to the OP

To me and obviously to others it wasn't clear that you was joking and once you noticed that you should have mentioned it was a joke, all it did was add unnecessary confusion and drama and here we are

 

[cricketjoshila]

Izeeshan have you voted?

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

Are you allowed to release and pick the same players again in same window?

I don't see why not, as long as you fulfill the rest of the criteria (correct timing)

 

[cricketjoshila]

Actually when you released Eriksen there was no smiley, you bolded it and then asked Ibad to add it to the OP

To me and obviously to others it wasn't clear that you was joking and once you noticed that you should have mentioned it was a joke, all it did was add unnecessary confusion and drama and here we are

 

[cricketjoshila]

i voted in the other thread now it seems i cant vote here so seems like my vote is gone.

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

For what it is worth, I don't like seeing such matters because it causes bad vibes and it festers under the surface

I think we need to take people's word for it, if P'boy says he was genuinely joking about Eriksen and Shaqiri then he should get them back and we can move on BUT we should let this be a lesson that if you want to joke around make it a bit clearer otherwise we have situations like this

I already voted NO so I kinda should have posted this first, ooops Still I am sure if P'boy responds then others will vote accordingly

 

[cricketjoshila]

For what it is worth, I don't like seeing such matters because it causes bad vibes and it festers under the surface

I think we need to take people's word for it, if P'boy says he was genuinely joking about Eriksen and Shaqiri then he should get them back and we can move on BUT we should let this be a lesson that if you want to joke around make it a bit clearer otherwise we have situations like this

I already voted NO so I kinda should have posted this first, ooops Still I am sure if P'boy responds then others will vote accordingly

You are being

 

[iZeeshan]

Actually when you released Eriksen there was no smiley, you bolded it and then asked Ibad to add it to the OP

To me and obviously to others it wasn't clear that you was joking and once you noticed that you should have mentioned it was a joke, all it did was add unnecessary confusion and drama and here we are

Precisely and that's why I even asked Ibad if it would be okay to pick this players up. It's quite clear he wasn't joking considering he asked for it to be added to the OP. That's what is bothering me about this whole thing and that's why I've taken it so seriously.

 

[Pakistaniboy]

Well,

My fault then let it be.

Just finish this and give him the player.

 

[kingusama92]

Firstly, I hate jokes like these.

A lot of the managers are quite competitive and will take everything seriously. Plus, it puts a lot of undue stress on Ibad and that's truly unfair.

Having said that, we are all good friends here. Let Pakistaniboy have his player(s) back and change the rules to ensure jokes (such as releasing players) will not be tolerated.

 

[leatherface58]

If he was genuinely kidding, then let him have the players. Maybe a fine or something could be deducted from his money, so nobody will pull this cowboy stunt again?

 

[iZeeshan]

^If he was genuinely kidding, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

 

[Mohsin]

I dont care/mind either way tbh (I don't know the story behind the releasing of the players either)

 

[iZeeshan]

I dont care/mind either way tbh (I don't know the story behind the releasing of the players either)

The story is in the first post bro.

 

[leatherface58]

Okay if that's the case then a fine should be given so he doesnt repeat this stunt. Of course I am with what's the final decision.

 

[iZeeshan]

lol how are you gonna fine anyone, money's worthless. but whatever.

 

[Mohsin]

OK, did anyone pick the players after he released them?

If yes then it'll be unfair on the managers who picked the 2 (then) released players afterwards

If no then may as well let him have them back if he wants them...I'm very competitive but no need to deny him getting back his players if he wants them

Edit: However we could deduct him 3 points if he wants the players back as a 'lesson/punishment'?

 

[murphyslaw79]

I have voted yes as I could see that the posts were a joke. Zee don't get me wrong, I think u are right to some extent. I took the cricket league too seriously in season 1 and don't want to repeat that. I want all to have fun and just enjoy each others jokes and be part of this wonderful online community.


Ohh, and win all cups and league this year )

 

[iZeeshan]

OK, did anyone pick the players after he released them?

If yes then it'll be unfair on the managers who picked the 2 (then) released players afterwards

If no then may as well let him have them back if he wants them...I'm very competitive but no need to deny him getting back his players if he wants them

Edit: However we could deduct him 3 points if he wants the players back as a 'lesson/punishment'?

I picked up Eriksen at my time today, and Pboy repicked Shaqiri.

I have voted yes as I could see that the posts were a joke. Zee don't get me wrong, I think u are right to some extent. I took the cricket league too seriously in season 1 and don't want to repeat that. I want all to have fun and just enjoy each others jokes and be part of this wonderful online community.


Ohh, and win all cups and league this year )

Yaar, if it was a joke, I swear I wouldn't care. He dropped Eriksen and then asked Ibad to add it to OP. From there, I asked Ibad if I could pick up Eriksen/Shaqiri tomorrow, and he said yes, and Pboy did nothing to acknowledge this despite being a part of the thread.

 

[Mohsin]

Then IMO he should be allowed Shaqiri and Zeeshan should be allowed to keep Erikson

Seems the fairest

 

[Mohsin]

Double post

 

[iZeeshan]

I think it'll help if Pboy just answers this.

Were the releases done as a joke or not?

I will take your word for it.

 

[murphyslaw79]

I picked up Eriksen at my time today, and Pboy repicked Shaqiri.



Yaar, if it was a joke, I swear I wouldn't care. He dropped Eriksen and then asked Ibad to add it to OP. From there, I asked Ibad if I could pick up Eriksen/Shaqiri tomorrow, and he said yes, and Pboy did nothing to acknowledge this despite being a part of the thread.

I know u did, and u went about it the right way. Pboy should have been more careful or should have mentioned that it was a joke then.

Yaar in the end, it's just fantasy football (of which I have no clue)

Leave it buddy, be the bigger person here.

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

I know u did, and u went about it the right way. Pboy should have been more careful or should have mentioned that it was a joke then.

Yaar in the end, it's just fantasy football (of which I have no clue)

Leave it buddy, be the bigger person here.

For what it's worth I think iZee is being quite reasonable, if P'boy confirms it was a joke then I think he will take his word for it and then the matter will be done and we can get on with hopefully watching The Entertainers win the league

 

[iZeeshan]

Thanks guys, I love knowing that I'm not crazy

As for the entertainers winning? I don't know about that buddy, I made it to 9th without knowing anything. Now I have full-fledge expeeeeerience.

 

[cricketjoshila]

6 point fine and 30million deducted.

 

[Afrid1]

Thanks guys, I love knowing that I'm not crazy

As for the entertainers winning? I don't know about that buddy, I made it to 9th without knowing anything. Now I have full-fledge expeeeeerience.

Yep I am mad

 

[Bhaijaan]

Why is this arguement just about Pboy-Zeeshan?

I would have gone for Shaqiri if #1) I ever believed it was serious and wanted to rip Pboy off and #2) The OP was updated and the two players were officially made available.



I am sorry, this is not just about giving Shaqiri to Pboy and Eriksen to Zeeshan, its more complicated and i for one actually deserve to have both of them.

 

[Bhaijaan]

To be honest, yesterday's free picks were flawed at so many level. This whole 'Shaqiri-Eriksen joke' and the OP not being updated adding to even more confusion. I mean a few managers yesterday picked players which were already picked day before that, but the OP was never updated and they thought players were available.

Also those who didn't read those 8-10 comments in the middle of thread, for them Eriksen and Shaqiri were 'taken' and they could never participate in their bidding as only a selected few actually knew what had happened and out of them only 1 manager actually wanted to cash in. lol

Myself and Ibad of course will accept the blame for the second issue for not doing our duty as far as updating the OP is concerned which by the way in this matter is a very crucial thing.




I say just clear all matters and let this be a lesson. Let Pboy have both the players as they are just too good and he should never have released them.

 

[I Believe in the Teesra]

Guys I voted too > : ( Lets teach PBoy a lesson@!!!@!@!

 

[Sixhitter]

Don't know if my post will have any affect on the decision, if Pakistaniboy was seriously joking then he should be allowed to retain his free players, but that is only if iZeeshan agrees (and gets another free pick).

Anyhow, I think Pakistaniboy should get Shaqiri.

 

[Canistani Hero]

This is ridiculous. I'm not having any of this madness.

 

[iZeeshan]

Well this may just get messier than I thought.

 

[Afrid1]

Well this may just get messier than I thought.

You are currently being outvoted that's why? or...? Does this mean I am not mad after all?

 

[iZeeshan]

Can you calm the f*** down? I don't see why you're after me in every single thread. I never said you were mad, but you made it to look like I was being ridiculous and the only one who felt this way. Clearly other managers have felt similarly, that's why there are 4 votes.

I don't care that I'm being outvoted, but if you actually look at the votes and who voted for what - I'd say Murphyslaw is actually a NO because he has agree with my opinion.

 

[Canistani Hero]

Zeeshan and Afrid1 - for the love of God - stop it.

 

[Afrid1]

Can you calm the f*** down? I don't see why you're after me in every single thread. I never said you were mad, but you made it to look like I was being ridiculous and the only one who felt this way. Clearly other managers have felt similarly, that's why there are 4 votes.

I don't care that I'm being outvoted, but if you actually look at the votes and who voted for what - I'd say Murphyslaw is actually a NO because he has agree with my opinion.

I am very calm lol... may not seem like it but that's up to your discretion... I'm not going after you I just didn't like how you replied to the argument beforehand... and yes you may not have used those words but you certainly implied it.

 

[Afrid1]

Zeeshan and Afrid1 - for the love of God - stop it.

Sorry bro

 

[Canistani Hero]

I could've made an issue out of multiple things in this window but I haven't. I would've picked Eboue but I thought was already picked because somebody cleverly decided to change their pick after taking Santos - then CJ takes him after me. Space Cat gets Handanovic as a compensation pick - just because Ibad apparently messed up Luis Marin's stats - in the same round as when I was gonna pick him. How is that fair? I didn't make a scene of it, I didn't whine and I urge all of you to stop this because it is not only ruining the fun but also delaying the start of the season

 

[iZeeshan]

I am very calm lol... may not seem like it but that's up to your discretion... I'm not going after you I just didn't like how you replied to the argument beforehand... and yes you may not have used those words but you certainly implied it.

No I didn't at all. I'd get my 'implications' in check if I were you - I was concerned about whether I was making any sense at all and it was relieving to see GA and KU's posts.

You were there lambasting me after every single post and in all honesty, it made me feel stupid and dumb. That post had nothing to do with you, only me.

 

[Canistani Hero]

Give Pboy his picks back and no more joking around like this in the future. Zeeshan, remember what you said to me when I was trying to set a precedence? Trying to make it equal for all? ..

 

[iZeeshan]

I could've made an issue out of multiple things in this window but I haven't. I would've picked Eboue but I thought was already picked because somebody cleverly decided to change their pick after taking Santos - then CJ takes him after me. Space Cat gets Handanovic as a compensation pick - just because Ibad apparently messed up Luis Marin's stats - in the same round as when I was gonna pick him. How is that fair? I didn't make a scene of it, I didn't whine and I urge all of you to stop this because it is not only ruining the fun but also delaying the start of the season

Says the guy who almost caused a major scene at the whole Edinson Cavani scandal.

I think you should've - I was even supporting you, idk if you noticed in the thread.

 

[iZeeshan]

Give Pboy his picks back and no more joking around like this in the future. Zeeshan, remember what you said to me when I was trying to set a precedence? Trying to make it equal for all? ..

Yeah what's your point? I thought of that trust me - I don't see how that relates.

 

[iZeeshan]

I'm posting this as a reference for anyone who thinks that I took advantage of a sneaky situation, or whatever any of the misconceptions are.

Ibad, please let me know about Eriksen and Shaqiri.

Also the entire opening post is gone lol

you can get released players as free picks. Patxi Punal and Luis Marin cannot be picked.

Ok so Eriksen and Shaqiri are up for grabs?

yes they are. I don't know why Pakiboy picked them if he wanted to release them..

You know what,

I want them back.

I`ll just not play them and sell them for cheap later.

Put them in my team Ibad.

What are you doing. Is it fun for you. You people are wasting my time as well. I can give them back to you if other managers are ok with it.

 

[Bhaijaan]

Cool down dosto. Geeez

 

[Bhaijaan]

I could've made an issue out of multiple things in this window but I haven't. I would've picked Eboue but I thought was already picked because somebody cleverly decided to change their pick after taking Santos - then CJ takes him after me. Space Cat gets Handanovic as a compensation pick - just because Ibad apparently messed up Luis Marin's stats - in the same round as when I was gonna pick him. How is that fair? I didn't make a scene of it, I didn't whine and I urge all of you to stop this because it is not only ruining the fun but also delaying the start of the season

#respect

Fully agreed. Lets take this as a lesson bhaiyo and move on.

 

[Afrid1]

#respect

Fully agreed. Lets take this as a lesson bhaiyo and move on.

That's what should have been done... after Ibad made his decision there shouldn't be any need for this thread. But oh well at least we have ironed out a few flaws and can learn from our mistakes

 

[Bhaijaan]

says the guy who almost caused a major scene at the whole edinson cavani scandal.

I think you should've - i was even supporting you, idk if you noticed in the thread.

omg. ) )

 

[Bhaijaan]

Fair play there Zeeshan. ) )

 

[iZeeshan]

 

[Pakistaniboy]

Get people here and finish this quickly,

im not voting myself.

 

[iZeeshan]

Get people here and finish this quickly,

im not voting myself.

Pboy - were you joking or not when you released those players?

 

[Pakistaniboy]

Pboy - were you joking or not when you released those players?

My only fault was that I had to wake up 6 AM for college and posted from my mob and went to sleep right after.

 

[Pakistaniboy]

But Like I said,

I have nothing against you and if the majority votes in favour of you then its perfectly fine for me.

 

[Canistani Hero]

Bhai yaar - seedha jawab de do - just say I was joking. End of.

 

[iZeeshan]

My only fault was that I had to wake up 6 AM for college and posted from my mob and went to sleep right after.

Huh? What does that have to do with anything?

But Like I said,

I have nothing against you and if the majority votes in favour of you then its perfectly fine for me.

Yaar, I just want to know your answers. Most managers are under the misconception that you were "joking". If you say that you were right now, we can drop the whole thing and there's no need to finish the vote.

 

[Canistani Hero]

Says the guy who almost caused a major scene at the whole Edinson Cavani scandal.

oh wow..

 

[Bhaijaan]

I will rephrase the question, don't like the way its been put. If you dont mind Pboy bhai, please answer to the following -


*What made you release those two future stars?
Was it because you got annoyed with the cheating allegations (said in jest)? If such is the case then we should never have accepted this and have guided you to have them back in the squad and forget about the comments passed by us. We were only kidding and didn't mean to hurt you and rip you off.

 

[Bhaijaan]

bhai yaar - seedha jawab de do - just say i was joking. End of.

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

oh wow..

Please, you two don't start now especially as it looks like a conclusion to the matter is nearing

 

[Canistani Hero]

Please, you two don't start now especially as it looks like a conclusion to the matter is nearing

Haha fortunately I'm in -6 weather right now so now chance of losing my cool

 

[iZeeshan]

)

 

[Pakistaniboy]

Huh? What does that have to do with anything?



Yaar, I just want to know your answers. Most managers are under the misconception that you were "joking". If you say that you were right now, we can drop the whole thing and there's no need to finish the vote.

Thats exactly what I said,

Though not directly lol.

 

[Pakistaniboy]

haha fortunately i'm in -6 weather right now so now chance of losing my cool

-13

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

Thats exactly what I said,

Though not directly lol.

We are not politicians here, so let's give some straight answers please

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

-13

About 10 here, which we complain about

Do you watch much Norwegian football? Heard of a player called Forren? If so what is he like? We were linked with him

 

[Pakistaniboy]

We are not politicians here, so let's give some straight answers please

I was kidding.

 

[Canistani Hero]

About 10 here, which we complain about

Do you watch much Norwegian football? Heard of a player called Forren? If so what is he like? We were linked with him

Everton and Manchester United are also linked with him, will probably get him ahead of "a wee club from the northeast"

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

I was kidding.

and this imo should conclude the matter

 

[Pakistaniboy]

About 10 here, which we complain about

Do you watch much Norwegian football? Heard of a player called Forren? If so what is he like? We were linked with him

Yep,

A Lyn fan, but unfortunately they went bankrupt and are in 4th division now

And Vegard Forren is one of our top talents,

Tall, Fast CB whos positioning is very good aswell.

I rate him on par with Brede Hangeland(Fulham CB), but obviously Brede is experienced, but Vegard is young and only getting better and better.

He plays for Molde - The team lead by the one and only Ole Gunnar Solskjær.