What's new

"Sindh will always be a part of India": Rajnath Singh

Ball Blazer

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 13, 2025
Runs
6,874
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh on Sunday said that although Sindh is not part of India today, the region remains deeply connected to India’s civilisational heritage. Speaking at an event, Singh said that Sindh, which was part of undivided India before 1947 and went to Pakistan after that, may return to India again.

His comments come at a time when relations between the two countries are tense following Operation Sindoor in May.

Addressing the Sindhi Samaj Sammelan event in New Delhi on Sunday, Singh said that "civilisationally, Sindh will always be a part of India," adding that geopolitical boundaries are not permanent.

Today, the land of Sindh may not be a part of India, but civilisationally, Sindh will always be a part of India. And as far as land is concerned, borders can change. Who knows, tomorrow Sindh may return to India again," he remarked while speaking at the programme.

The Sindh state of present-day Pakistan is the native place of members of the Sindhi community, who constitute a large portion of India's population. Sindh is also the place of origin for the Indus Valley Civilisation.

The Defence Minister invoked veteran BJP leader Lal Krishna Advani while discussing the emotional and cultural connection that Sindhi Hindus share with the region even decades after Partition.

I'd also like to mention the Lal Krishna Advani here. He wrote in one of his books that Sindhi Hindus, especially those of his generation, still haven't accepted the separation of Sindh from India. Not just in Sindh, but throughout India, Hindus considered the Indus River sacred. Many Muslims in Sindh also believed that the water of the Indus was no less sacred than the Aab-e-Zamzam of Mecca. This is Advani's quote," he added.

Reiterating the cultural bond, Singh said that the people of Sindh—regardless of where they live today—will “always be our own.”

The remarks have drawn attention due to their timing and the broader geopolitical context, setting the stage for strong diplomatic responses from Pakistan in the coming days.

 
LOL. India itself may get balkanized because they are getting isolated regionally and globally. :inti

Also, they seem to have lots of domestic issues.
 
200w_d.gif
 
There is a lot of revisionism of history in India.

But one part we can agree, borders can change
:akhtar
 
The next India–Pakistan escalation is likely to see India securing some Pakistani territory.

The groundwork has been laid over the last decade through frequent cross-border strikes which called Pakistan’s nuclear bluff also.

The precedent is set and a message has been delivered about the extent of damages India can cause to Pakistan in a very short time.

1971 like binary fission of Pakistan might not repeat but there’s a good chance Pakistan loses 10-20% of its territory to India. People need to realize 1971 was unprecedented and it’s not realistic to expect a repeat of it from India. You don’t just hold one nation and tear it down to two pieces every other decade. In history it’s very rare.
 
I still think something is cooking. Maybe they are waiting for billionaire marriage to end in Udaipur, Rajasthan. :kp
 
The next India–Pakistan escalation is likely to see India securing some Pakistani territory.

The groundwork has been laid over the last decade through frequent cross-border strikes which called Pakistan’s nuclear bluff also.

The precedent is set and a message has been delivered about the extent of damages India can cause to Pakistan in a very short time.

1971 like binary fission of Pakistan might not repeat but there’s a good chance Pakistan loses 10-20% of its territory to India. People need to realize 1971 was unprecedented and it’s not realistic to expect a repeat of it from India. You don’t just hold one nation and tear it down to two pieces every other decade. In history it’s very rare.
I do not support the Idea of capturing someone legal land , yea POK is disputed territory so talking about taking it back is fine. :kp
 
I do not support the Idea of capturing someone legal land , yea POK is disputed territory so talking about taking it back is fine. :kp

Military doctrines are driven by opportunism also. Nations generally maintain peaceful posturing but at the peak of their powers, every nation ever has wanted to expand. It will be no different for India.

As the economy and military power grows, some of the smaller nations around us which have been bargaining hard and trying to blackmail us into giving them more than they offer, will certainly feel the heat. International borders aren’t drawn by God. They change over time as per power dynamics.
 
They want to cancel all pre-1947 deals and own Pakistan?


I wonder what is stopping them? Are they scared of Pak military? That seems absurd considering India's military prowess should dwarf Pakistan's.

Also why singe out Sindh? What about Punjab, Kashmir and the other half of Bengal? :unsure:
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti
They have been certainly heading that way.

They know that they can't compete with China for having much lower IQ. These dumb @$$3$ only realized it after losing thousands of kilometers of land.

They messed up relationship with USA - the only force which could save & protect them against China. US has learned now that these Uber idiots can only be milked for large size of economy, but can't even bully Pak militarily - a country multiple times smaller than them and China. They wanted to isolate Pak, but ended up stranding themselves. These idiots will calve Pak :D
 
I think this is all ba propaganda but creates the baseline for India invading the plains of Paksitan if it tries new shenanigans in Kashmir. But I think it's moot as Pak army lacks the capability of full on. War...their modus operandi is terror attacks. I though think occupyign territory is not smart...we should only focus on two things
Destruction of Pak military capability as Sindoor showed

And creating space for Sindhi Baloch and Pathans to be independent like Bangladesh.
 
They have been certainly heading that way.

They know that they can't compete with China for having much lower IQ. These dumb @$$3$ only realized it after losing thousands of kilometers of land.

They messed up relationship with USA - the only force which could save & protect them against China. US has learned now that these Uber idiots can only be milked for large size of economy, but can't even bully Pak militarily - a country multiple times smaller than them and China. They wanted to isolate Pak, but ended up stranding themselves. These idiots will calve Pak :D

Agree.

India pretty much became isolated regionally and globally.

They thought they were an economic and military superpower and thought they could get away with anything. They had some reality checks in recent times.

This is what happens when a country gets run by an illiterate, idiotic, and shortsighted chaiwala. Country goes to dump. :inti
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti


Hindu Bengalis fought to be with india and not to live in a Muslim majority east Pakistan, read bengali hindu homeland movement, so no question of west. Bengal going to Bangladesh

Tamilnadu to sri Lanka? On what basis?
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti

I forgot to add Arunachal Pradesh and Himachal Pradesh. Both should go to China. :inti

#Zangnan
 
Agree.

India pretty much became isolated regionally and globally.

They thought they were an economic and military superpower and thought they could get away with anything. They had some reality checks in recent times.

This is what happens when a country gets run by an illiterate, idiotic, and shortsighted chaiwala. Country goes to dump. :inti
You realise that Bangladeshi opinion matters little regionally or globally

The worlds 4 largest economy doesn't need Bangladeshi approval to be considered an economic power, 4 trillion plus economy speaks for itself

So does 170 plus nukes

Modi has more global standing than entire Bangladesh put together
 
Hindu Bengalis fought to be with india and not to live in a Muslim majority east Pakistan, read bengali hindu homeland movement, so no question of west. Bengal going to Bangladesh

Tamilnadu to sri Lanka? On what basis?
On the basis of his fantasies.
 
If this guy and that non halal Punjabi chicken shop owner in UK join forces who knows what’s possible…?
 
Sindhis are the closest to Indian people in Pakistan. My circle has many Sindhi people. They all have stories how their grandparents had to run from Sindh during partition. Very likable people and follow Hinduism deeply. They said many Sindhis who chose to live in Pakistan have converted to Islam and lost contact with them.
 
Sindhis are the closest to Indian people in Pakistan. My circle has many Sindhi people. They all have stories how their grandparents had to run from Sindh during partition. Very likable people and follow Hinduism deeply. They said many Sindhis who chose to live in Pakistan have converted to Islam and lost contact with them.

There are still 5 million hindus in sindh
 
You realise that Bangladeshi opinion matters little regionally or globally

The worlds 4 largest economy doesn't need Bangladeshi approval to be considered an economic power, 4 trillion plus economy speaks for itself

So does 170 plus nukes

Modi has more global standing than entire Bangladesh put together

6th largest economy.
 
The Congress on Wednesday accused Defence Minister Rajnath Singh of giving a “shameful clean chit” to Pakistan during his remarks at a Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting in Bishkek, calling his statements “anti-national.”

Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh also alleged that the minister’s comments reflected Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s foreign policy approach of “appeasement” towards the United States and “calibrated capitulation” to China.

Sharing a video clip of Singh’s address, Ramesh quoted him saying, “We must not forget that terrorism has no nationality and no theology. No grievance, real or supposed, can become an excuse for terrorism and humanitarian loss.”

In a post on X, Ramesh said, “Yesterday, the Defence Minister, obviously with the approval of and at the instance of the Prime Minister, gave a shameful clean chit to Pakistan while speaking in Bishkek.”

He further questioned Pakistan’s role in cross-border terrorism, asking, “Is Pakistan not the epicentre of terrorism?”

“Are there no terrorist camps in Pakistan with India as their target? Is there no ideological anti-India indoctrination in Pakistan? Were not the Mumbai and Pahalgam terror attacks masterminded and executed by terrorists from Pakistan?” Ramesh asked.

He added, “Clearly this new stance in relation to Pakistan is all part of the PM's policy of appeasement of the US and calibrated capitulation to China.”

Ramesh also said, “The Defence Minister's shocking statements are as anti-national as the PM's bizarre clean chit to China on June 19, 2020.”

Earlier, speaking at the SCO conclave in Bishkek, Rajnath Singh had said Operation Sindoor reflected India’s resolve that “terror epicentres” are no longer immune to “justifiable punishment.”

He also urged member nations to remain vigilant against “state-sponsored” cross-border terrorism and warned against any “double standards” in tackling the threat.

 
I think india is afraid after a good beating they had in may 2025

Went from pakistan is a terrorist state straight to terrorism has no nationality

Weldone pak army 🫡
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think india is afraid after a good beating they had in may 2025

Went from pakistan is a terrorist state straight to terrorism has no nationality

Weldone pak army 🫡
it was evident when Indian Govt did nt Name Pakistan for Delhi Attacks while Sanghi Journalists like Aditya Raj Kaul Sat in Podcast and talked about *** for tat attack on Pak in Isb Courthouse very next day of Delhi blast.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
100%

Sindoor myth was popped once again after Delhi attack
Pakistan think twice to sending Pakistan terrorist to india after operation Sindoor.. tange kanpti hai nind main bhi ki kab bramose strike ho jaye Pakistan main terrorist camps pe. ...

:klopp :kp
 
On topic , these silly remake are not needed. Are Jo hai usko hi ache se develop karo .

I'm not even intrested to talking about taking POK back . Make loc as an permanent border and happy with it.

:kp
 
We know that. Sane Indians like me like to live in the real and practical word.
If this gets them votes then why not? There are lot of people in India who'll fall for these comments.
 
If this gets them votes then why not? There are lot of people in India who'll fall for these comments.
God help those Indians who believe any part of current day Pakistan will one day be a part of India. But who can blame those Indians when a lot of Pakistanis themselves believe in pot crack theories like Ghazwa-E-Hind.​
 
God help those Indians who believe any part of current day Pakistan will one day be a part of India. But who can blame those Indians when a lot of Pakistanis themselves believe in pot crack theories like Ghazwa-E-Hind.​
True. This is just the fig leaf of politicians on both sides of the border to lure their followers.

Lets all honour the LAC and concentrate on more pressing issues plaguing our countries.
 
On topic , these silly remake are not needed. Are Jo hai usko hi ache se develop karo .

I'm not even intrested to talking about taking POK back . Make loc as an permanent border and happy with it.

:kp
devdas tere interested honay ya na honay se desh apni policies ni change krte. Yeh Dkh tera leader kia bola tha

 
devdas tere interested honay ya na honay se desh apni policies ni change krte. Yeh Dkh tera leader kia bola tha

Don't you think India would have actually done something if they really wanted PoK back instead of politicans giving faltu statements before elections?​
 
What are these stupid, propaganda-based comments of conquering one's country, First Donald Trump as Canada's 51st State and Venezuela now this crap
 
Statements reflect their Wish. Their inaction Reflects ability
Not going to lie, most Indians would wish for PoK to be a part of India. Just like most Pakistanis would wish Ghazwa-E-Hind to happen. It's ability that matters. Almost every Muslim on the planet wishes Israel to disappear from the world map. Does it matter?​
 
Not going to lie, most Indians would wish for PoK to be a part of India. Just like most Pakistanis would wish Ghazwa-E-Hind to happen. It's ability that matters. Almost every Muslim on the planet wishes Israel to disappear from the world map. Does it matter?​
I told you India Unable to take This side of Kashmir is more to do with ability. If India could take it with kinetic action , This would have happened like time ago.

Problem is that after abboragation of Article 370 , India has declared whole of Kashmir Part of Union which Makes Pakistan an occupier according to Constiution , Giving lip service in public Rallys is one thing , Making it Constitutional Liability another.

PS Whole world does nt wish Israel to Disappear. the usual wish is Rightful recognition of Palestinian State including de occupation of West bank .
 
I told you India Unable to take This side of Kashmir is more to do with ability. If India could take it with kinetic action , This would have happened like time ago.

Problem is that after abboragation of Article 370 , India has declared whole of Kashmir Part of Union which Makes Pakistan an occupier according to Constiution , Giving lip service in public Rallys is one thing , Making it Constitutional Liability another.

PS Whole world does nt wish Israel to Disappear. the usual wish is Rightful recognition of Palestinian State including de occupation of West bank .
Don't you think Pakistan would have taken our side of Kashmir if they had the capability? Despite BJP's lip service of taking back PoK, we have never started any war to take it back unlike you have.​
 
Don't you think Pakistan would have taken our side of Kashmir of they has the capability?

That would be shameful for India being a bigger country economically and militarily. No Pak does nt posess capbility to take back your Side Of Kashmir through Kinetic Action. Its Natural. Pak is much Smaller country in every aspect. But Same cant be said about India when it comes to our Side. There is no co relation
 
That would be shameful for India being a bigger country economically and militarily. No Pak does nt posess capbility to take back your Side Of Kashmir through Kinetic Action. Its Natural. Pak is much Smaller country in every aspect. But Same cant be said about India when it comes to our Side. There is no co relation
Nukes matlab no such misadventure from either side ever again.
 
You're kidding, right?
No Im not

The comments of Indians on posts related to Nukes of Pak gives you real Insight

1. Pak Does nt have nukes ( Denial )
2. Pak Nukes are actually USA owned ( Cope )
3. We have called nuclear Bluff of Pak in Sindoor ( Fantasy )
 
Rajnath Singh - You are a good boy.

We appreciate your submissive tone at the SCO. A sign of India's softening stance and admission of defeat.
 
On topic , these silly remake are not needed. Are Jo hai usko hi ache se develop karo .

I'm not even intrested to talking about taking POK back . Make loc as an permanent border and happy with it.

:kp
This.

India does not need any Pak land. Partition happened and all Indians will be thankful for that. The way it was done can be debated.
LOC should be permanent boundary and that should be the end of the story. I shudder to think a united India with 80 crore muslim population and 80 crore Hindus living side by side. There will be massacres everyday. But Ganduji and Nehruji wanted that.
 
This.

India does not need any Pak land. Partition happened and all Indians will be thankful for that. The way it was done can be debated.
LOC should be permanent boundary and that should be the end of the story. I shudder to think a united India with 80 crore muslim population and 80 crore Hindus living side by side. There will be massacres everyday. But Ganduji and Nehruji wanted that.


I think if Kashmir went to Pakistan then partition might have made sense. Until then no LOC can be made permanent. Otherwise partition itself becomes meaningless.
 
Don't be an idiot like Abdul :inti who Only spread Fake Propaganda।


:klopp :kp

yes the first video was fake its was rajnath's duplicate planted by Pakistan and made him gave the first statement.

dhurandher have killed the Pakistanis and this is the real defence minister and now giving the real statement.

nothing to do with the backlash from the saffron's and forcing rajnath to change his statement

:klopp :kp
 
yes the first video was fake its was rajnath's duplicate planted by Pakistan and made him gave the first statement.

dhurandher have killed the Pakistanis and this is the real defence minister and now giving the real statement.

nothing to do with the backlash from the saffron's and forcing rajnath to change his statement

:klopp :kp
Andhbhakts are something else, even ostriches will get ashamed seeing them.
 
I think if Kashmir went to Pakistan then partition might have made sense. Until then no LOC can be made permanent. Otherwise partition itself becomes meaningless.
Kashmir is half and half and it should remain that way. Pak got nothing. But they attacked and took their share. If it was Israel or Arabs or any Western power, they would not have let Pakistan take half of Kashmir. But India was run by a bunch of whimps and nincompoops. They did nothing and let Pakistan have their way. It did not stop at that. Pakistan was emboldened and tried to take the rest of Kashmir in 80’s through the same insurgency route. Hindus were driven out and made it a disputed land in front of the world. Then Pakistan cries victim in all these.

There is a reason why the likes of Miandad used to call Hindus Darpoke and buzdills. He was right and history shows that.
Finally a rightwing government comes to power 75 yrs after independence and takes no nonsense from Pakistan. BJP is called all sorts of names by secularists. BJP does what any proud Muslim does. Defend and claim what they believe belongs to them.

It’s funny Pakistanis cannot handle a decade of rightwing government in India while their entire history is full of rightwing and far right elements.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Kashmir is half and half and it should remain that way. Pak got nothing. But they attacked and took their share. If it was Israel or Arabs or any Western power, they would not have let Pakistan take half of Kashmir. But India was run by a bunch of whimps and nincompoops. They did nothing and let Pakistan have their way. It did not stop at that. Pakistan was emboldened and tried to take the rest of Kashmir in 80’s through the same insurgency route. Hindus were driven out and made it a disputed land in front of the world. Then Pakistan cries victim in all these.
There is a reason why the likes of Miandad used to call Hindus Darpoke and buzdills. He was right and history shows that.
Finally a rightwing government comes to power 75 yrs after independence and takes no nonsense from Pakistan. BJP is called all sorts of names by secularists. BJP does what any proud Muslim does. Defend and claim what they believe belongs to them.
It’s funny Pakistanis cannot handle a decade of rightwing government in India while their entire history is full of rightwing and far right elements.


Kashmir should be part of Pakistan because it was Muslim majority at time of partition, and the people of Kashmir wanted to join Pakistan. That is how the rest of the country was divided up.

If that was denied then partition made no sense anyway.
 
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh on Thursday (May 14, 2026) warned Pakistan against terrorism and said India would strike back decisively if provoked again.

Addressing a public gathering at Merta town in Nagaur after unveiling a statue of Rajput ruler Rao Duda, Mr. Singh said Operation Sindoor had sent a strong message to Pakistan.

"Perhaps Pakistan will not dare to look at India with hostility again. But I want to say that if it does, what has not happened till now will happen," he said.

"From the beginning, our policy was not to provoke anyone. But if anyone provokes us, we do not spare them either," Mr. Singh said.

Referring to the Pahalgam terror attack on April 22 last year, he said the terrorists had killed people after asking about their religion.

"Indian culture says there should be no division based on caste or religion. We believe in justice and humanity. But terrorists from Pakistan were shooting people after asking their religion," he said.

"The entire country was angry. We gave such a strong reply that the enemy was stunned. We proved that India is no longer a country that silently suffers. If anyone attacks our citizens, we will enter their homes and respond. No border can stop us," Mr. Singh added.

The Defence Minister said India has adopted a "zero tolerance" policy against terrorism, citing the 2016 surgical strikes and the 2019 Balakot airstrikes as examples of India's changing response strategy.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Link: https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...es-us-again-rajnath-singh/article70978098.ece
 
I don’t think it quite works like that…

India has defence/security lapses internally and then does a lot of hoo haa for its media and awaam…

They then take steps which they go on to regret afterwards.

Pakistan plays the waiting game patiently and perfectly. The DG ISPR was right…

“When Pakistan attacks, woh hamla Nazr bhi aaye ga…Aur uski Goonj bhi sunai de ghy”.

Aa jao!
 
Back
Top