What's new

"Sindh will always be a part of India": Rajnath Singh

Ball Blazer

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 13, 2025
Runs
3,708
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh on Sunday said that although Sindh is not part of India today, the region remains deeply connected to India’s civilisational heritage. Speaking at an event, Singh said that Sindh, which was part of undivided India before 1947 and went to Pakistan after that, may return to India again.

His comments come at a time when relations between the two countries are tense following Operation Sindoor in May.

Addressing the Sindhi Samaj Sammelan event in New Delhi on Sunday, Singh said that "civilisationally, Sindh will always be a part of India," adding that geopolitical boundaries are not permanent.

Today, the land of Sindh may not be a part of India, but civilisationally, Sindh will always be a part of India. And as far as land is concerned, borders can change. Who knows, tomorrow Sindh may return to India again," he remarked while speaking at the programme.

The Sindh state of present-day Pakistan is the native place of members of the Sindhi community, who constitute a large portion of India's population. Sindh is also the place of origin for the Indus Valley Civilisation.

The Defence Minister invoked veteran BJP leader Lal Krishna Advani while discussing the emotional and cultural connection that Sindhi Hindus share with the region even decades after Partition.

I'd also like to mention the Lal Krishna Advani here. He wrote in one of his books that Sindhi Hindus, especially those of his generation, still haven't accepted the separation of Sindh from India. Not just in Sindh, but throughout India, Hindus considered the Indus River sacred. Many Muslims in Sindh also believed that the water of the Indus was no less sacred than the Aab-e-Zamzam of Mecca. This is Advani's quote," he added.

Reiterating the cultural bond, Singh said that the people of Sindh—regardless of where they live today—will “always be our own.”

The remarks have drawn attention due to their timing and the broader geopolitical context, setting the stage for strong diplomatic responses from Pakistan in the coming days.

 
LOL. India itself may get balkanized because they are getting isolated regionally and globally. :inti

Also, they seem to have lots of domestic issues.
 
200w_d.gif
 
The next India–Pakistan escalation is likely to see India securing some Pakistani territory.

The groundwork has been laid over the last decade through frequent cross-border strikes which called Pakistan’s nuclear bluff also.

The precedent is set and a message has been delivered about the extent of damages India can cause to Pakistan in a very short time.

1971 like binary fission of Pakistan might not repeat but there’s a good chance Pakistan loses 10-20% of its territory to India. People need to realize 1971 was unprecedented and it’s not realistic to expect a repeat of it from India. You don’t just hold one nation and tear it down to two pieces every other decade. In history it’s very rare.
 
The next India–Pakistan escalation is likely to see India securing some Pakistani territory.

The groundwork has been laid over the last decade through frequent cross-border strikes which called Pakistan’s nuclear bluff also.

The precedent is set and a message has been delivered about the extent of damages India can cause to Pakistan in a very short time.

1971 like binary fission of Pakistan might not repeat but there’s a good chance Pakistan loses 10-20% of its territory to India. People need to realize 1971 was unprecedented and it’s not realistic to expect a repeat of it from India. You don’t just hold one nation and tear it down to two pieces every other decade. In history it’s very rare.
I do not support the Idea of capturing someone legal land , yea POK is disputed territory so talking about taking it back is fine. :kp
 
I do not support the Idea of capturing someone legal land , yea POK is disputed territory so talking about taking it back is fine. :kp

Military doctrines are driven by opportunism also. Nations generally maintain peaceful posturing but at the peak of their powers, every nation ever has wanted to expand. It will be no different for India.

As the economy and military power grows, some of the smaller nations around us which have been bargaining hard and trying to blackmail us into giving them more than they offer, will certainly feel the heat. International borders aren’t drawn by God. They change over time as per power dynamics.
 
They want to cancel all pre-1947 deals and own Pakistan?


I wonder what is stopping them? Are they scared of Pak military? That seems absurd considering India's military prowess should dwarf Pakistan's.

Also why singe out Sindh? What about Punjab, Kashmir and the other half of Bengal? :unsure:
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti
 
India should surrender these:

West Bengal and northeast India to Bangladesh
Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka
Kashmir to Pakistan
Punjab to Khalistan
Goa to Portugal

If India do that, there can be more regional peace. :inti
They have been certainly heading that way.

They know that they can't compete with China for having much lower IQ. These dumb @$$3$ only realized it after losing thousands of kilometers of land.

They messed up relationship with USA - the only force which could save & protect them against China. US has learned now that these Uber idiots can only be milked for large size of economy, but can't even bully Pak militarily - a country multiple times smaller than them and China. They wanted to isolate Pak, but ended up stranding themselves. These idiots will calve Pak :D
 
I think this is all ba propaganda but creates the baseline for India invading the plains of Paksitan if it tries new shenanigans in Kashmir. But I think it's moot as Pak army lacks the capability of full on. War...their modus operandi is terror attacks. I though think occupyign territory is not smart...we should only focus on two things
Destruction of Pak military capability as Sindoor showed

And creating space for Sindhi Baloch and Pathans to be independent like Bangladesh.
 
They have been certainly heading that way.

They know that they can't compete with China for having much lower IQ. These dumb @$$3$ only realized it after losing thousands of kilometers of land.

They messed up relationship with USA - the only force which could save & protect them against China. US has learned now that these Uber idiots can only be milked for large size of economy, but can't even bully Pak militarily - a country multiple times smaller than them and China. They wanted to isolate Pak, but ended up stranding themselves. These idiots will calve Pak :D

Agree.

India pretty much became isolated regionally and globally.

They thought they were an economic and military superpower and thought they could get away with anything. They had some reality checks in recent times.

This is what happens when a country gets run by an illiterate, idiotic, and shortsighted chaiwala. Country goes to dump. :inti
 
Back
Top