What's new

South Africa vs West Indies | 2nd ODI | Johannesburg | January 18, 2015 |

Status
Not open for further replies.
ABD has completely overshadowed Amla's innings.

Poor amla, seems like dravid at the moment.
 
Flat pitch small ground whateva it is :) Ab is just a beast no1 cant come close the the class of this man
 
LO's is becoming kind of a joke, need to get the bowlers back into the contest.
 
He needs to win SA a WC and he'll for mine become the greatest modern batsmen of all time.

SRT is regarded as the best Test bat but has never won a series in Australia and SA which is tougher than a world cup.
In fact never had a winning hand in a game won here in SA.
Why is he a test great as per your anology?
 
Checked the screcard and did a cartoon double take. This is unreal.

And as for the West Indies - just give them Associate status already, total disgrace.
 
SRT is regarded as the best Test bat but has never won a series in Australia and SA which is tougher than a world cup.
In fact never had a winning hand in a game won here in SA.
Why is he a test great as per your anology?
Because SRT has actually performed in those countries, when has AB performed in a crunch situation for SA in a WC?
 
Checked the screcard and did a cartoon double take. This is unreal.

And as for the West Indies - just give them Associate status already, total disgrace.
Just wait for Gayle, if he gets going, who knows... ODI cricket is bit of a joke these days.
 
If the West Indies were a horse they'd have been put down by now.
 
Because SRT has actually performed in those countries, when has AB performed in a crunch situation for SA in a WC?
How many "crunch" games did he win in SA tough never mind a series?
He had so many opportunities?

Not sure how many knock out games we've played in WC with AB, two?
He was run out in one of them. Hardly a sample.
But he has a good record in WC's by the way.
 
How many "crunch" games did he win in SA tough never mind a series?
He had so many opportunities?

Not sure how many knock out games we've played in WC with AB, two?
He was run out in one of them. Hardly a sample.
But he has a good record in WC's by the way.
Yes, but all he needs is the one performance to rid the tag of a choker.

Not too difficult for a batsmen of AB's quality.
 
Yes, but all he needs is the one performance to rid the tag of a choker.

Not too difficult for a batsmen of AB's quality.

You still have not addressed my points though. And all I want is consistency, let's apply the same parameters for everyone.
 
You still have not addressed my points though. And all I want is consistency, let's apply the same parameters for everyone.
AB is in the bracket as the best ever, crunch knocks in big matches count as massive points when comparing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top